Finding great pizza in Emerald Isle, NC, is a lot like hunting for the perfect seashell—everyone’s got an opinion and the search is part of the fun. Whether you’re a visitor with sand still clinging to your feet, or a local who can taste the difference between a classic hand-tossed crust and a thin, bubbly pie, Emerald Isle manages to serve up slices that surprise and satisfy. I’ve eaten my way across the island, where a casual spot hidden in a plaza might rival a beachside pizzeria for best sauce, crust, and cheese pull.
This guide skips the hype and zeroes in on real experiences, honest flavors, and the places that locals trust. If you crave a simple cheese pizza as the sun sets over Bogue Sound or a unique specialty pie layered with unexpected toppings, you’re in the right place. Each spot on this list brings something distinct to the table—from old-school pizzerias serving family recipes to new favorites slinging creative, oven-fired wonders. As you read on, you’ll find everything you need to settle that next pizza craving—without any guesswork.
1. Lazzara’s Pizza & Subs
Lazzara’s Pizza & Subs has the cozy, friendly energy that turns a pizza night into a ritual. Hidden off Coast Guard Road, it’s the spot locals mention when you ask where to grab a real slice. On my last visit, I went for their classic cheese pizza, and the balance of tangy sauce and golden crust was spot-on.
The menu bursts with options, but their signature pies and hand-crafted subs keep regulars coming back. If you like trying different toppings, the Deluxe Pizza is a winner—each bite is loaded but never soggy.
For those who want a taste of Italy in Emerald Isle, the Italian Special brings out the best in their kitchen. Whether you’re ordering takeout or dining in, Lazzara’s feels like a reliable friend in pizza form.
2. Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs
Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs sits at the center of Emerald Isle’s pizza scene, tucked inside the busy Emerald Plantation Shopping Center. Whenever I’m in the neighborhood, I stop for their extra-large New York-style pizza—crisp at the bottom, generous with cheese, and always cut into wide, foldable slices.
This spot draws a blend of families and surfers, all eager for quick service and hearty portions. The Veggie Pizza is a standout with a colorful mix of peppers, onions, and mushrooms—fresh and never greasy.
If you crave something more indulgent, their Meat Lovers is a slice of pure comfort. Michaelangelo’s manages to nail those simple flavors with just the right balance, making it a favorite for both lunch and laid-back dinners.
3. Pizza Inn
Pizza Inn is the kind of place where you find both variety and comfort, a perfect combination if you’re not sure what you’re in the mood for. My last meal there left me genuinely impressed by their classic thin-crust pizza—light, crisp, and not shy with the toppings.
What sets Pizza Inn apart is its buffet, where you can mix and match slices, pastas, and salads. It’s easy to see why families flock here during vacation season.
The Pepperoni Max pizza is a crowd-pleaser, stacked to the edge with zesty pepperoni and melty cheese. Pair it with fresh breadsticks for the full Pizza Inn experience. Service is quick and the vibe is relaxed, making it a reliable stop for classic pizza cravings.
4. Stoney’s Fired Pizza
Stoney’s Fired Pizza brings the unmistakable crunch of wood-fired crust to Emerald Isle right from a pizza truck. There’s something fun about stumbling across their mobile kitchen and watching flames kiss your dinner to life. The aroma alone pulls you in fast.
The Margherita Pizza hits the sweet spot for classic flavor—fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil mingle on a crisp, smoky crust. Each pie is crafted to order, making the experience feel personal and the flavors pop with freshness.
Try the White Pizza for something a little more adventurous, with creamy ricotta and a hint of garlic. Stoney’s stands out by keeping things simple but never boring, and the owner’s passion shows with every slice that comes out piping hot.
5. No Name Pizza
(252) 764-0004Call
No Name Pizza is the kind of spot you hear about through locals—one of those “if you know, you know” places at the corner of Islander Drive. There’s a laid-back charm in the name itself, hinting that the focus here is all about the food, not the flash.
Their hand-tossed dough stands out—pillowy and fresh, with just the right hint of chew. I always lean toward their veggie-loaded pizza, which lets the bright flavor of fresh toppings and tangy sauce shine through.
If you’re in the mood for something more hearty, the Supreme is a safe bet, packed edge-to-edge with quality toppings. No Name Pizza keeps things unpretentious and flavorful, winning regulars one slice at a time.
6. Circle Pizza & Subs
Circle Pizza & Subs sits right off Emerald Drive, making it an easy stop for anyone craving pizza after a day at the beach. The atmosphere is casual, with friendly staff who make you feel part of the local crowd. From my visits, I’ve noticed regulars coming back for both the pizza and the subs—a good sign of consistency.
Their hand-tossed pizzas are impressively flavorful, with a crust that’s golden and just a bit chewy. The cheese blend stretches with each slice, never skimping and always comforting.
The Mediterranean Pizza stands out here—loaded with spinach, tomatoes, and feta for fresh coastal flavor. If you want something classic, the cheese or pepperoni never disappoints. Circle Pizza & Subs is a safe bet for a laid-back meal with reliable quality.
7. Ruckerjohn’s Restaurant & More
Ruckerjohn’s Restaurant & More has roots in Emerald Isle that go back decades. Walk in and you’ll notice the cozy dining room stocked with families, regulars, and friends unwinding after a day out. I’ve always been drawn to their casual charm—it’s a spot where no one feels rushed and the menu caters to nearly every craving.
Their pizzas are crafted with care, using a dough that hits a sweet spot between crispy and soft. My top pick is the Cheese Pizza, stretching from slice to slice with gooey richness and just the right sauce to cheese ratio.
Try their Veggie Pizza for a colorful spin, topped with fresh vegetables that don’t get lost in the shuffle. Ruckerjohn’s brings consistency and comfort to every order, making it as reliable for pizza as for anything else.
8. Frank’s Pizza & Subs
Frank’s Pizza & Subs is worth the short drive to Newport if you’re seeking a hearty, no-fuss pie with a neighborhood feel. The first time I visited, it was the bustling lunch crowd and the aroma of baking dough that won me over. It’s a place you can count on for both consistency and generous portions.
Their hand-tossed pizza comes hot from the oven with a slightly chewy crust and well-seasoned sauce. Each pizza I’ve tried came loaded with fresh toppings, never shying away from flavor.
Their Classic Cheese Pizza is simple but perfectly balanced, while the Veggie Supreme stands out for those craving lots of color and crunch. Frank’s keeps things authentic and approachable, making it a go-to for old-school pizza cravings.
9. Trattoria Gourmet Pizza
(910) 326-5001Call
Trattoria Gourmet Pizza in nearby Swansboro leans into classic Italian charm. Walking in, you’re greeted by the welcoming scent of herbs and bubbling cheese. This spot feels almost hidden, but regulars know it’s worth tracking down for a slow-paced, relaxing meal.
Their gourmet pizzas arrive with an airy crust and balanced toppings that don’t overpower the base. I’ve had the pleasure of tasting their Margherita—fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and mozzarella that melts in layers.
For those who prefer a heartier bite, the White Pizza is both creamy and light, with ricotta and garlic joining the lineup. Trattoria is about more than pizza; it’s about savoring good food in good company, bite after bite.
10. Luigi’s Pizza
(252) 240-3125Call
Luigi’s Pizza in Morehead City brings a taste of classic Italian tradition to the coast. The atmosphere is unpretentious, and the kitchen stays busy tossing dough and sliding pies into the oven. On my first visit, the service was warm and the attention to detail on every pizza was clear.
Their hand-crafted pies are noted for a light, crisp crust and sauce that walks the line between tangy and savory. The regulars rave about the Supreme Pizza, piled high with a colorful array of fresh vegetables and classic toppings—each bite balanced and satisfying.
If you’re after classic simplicity, the Cheese Pizza is done just right here. Luigi’s manages to strike that sweet spot between friendly neighborhood joint and true pizzeria flavor, keeping diners coming back again and again.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best local pizza spots in Emerald Isle, NC?
You’ll find plenty of great choices, including Lazzara’s Pizza & Subs for classic pies, Michaelangelo’s for New York-style slices, and Stoney’s Fired Pizza if you crave wood-fired flavor. Each offers its own twist and local following.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Emerald Isle?
Yes, several pizzerias like Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs and Pizza Inn typically offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability, as options may change with the season.
Can I order pizza for delivery in Emerald Isle?
Absolutely. Chains like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and Pizza Hut provide delivery, but many local spots also offer takeout and delivery during the summer and busy weekends.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizzas?
Most Emerald Isle pizza shops offer a veggie pizza or customizable options without cheese. Stoney’s Fired Pizza and Circle Pizza & Subs are popular for fresh veggie toppings.
What’s the price range for pizza in Emerald Isle?
You’ll see prices ranging from about $10 for small pies at takeout spots to $25 or more for specialty or gourmet pizzas. Portions are generous, and most places offer family deals.