Discovering the best pizza in Edwardsville, IL, is a delightful journey through varied flavors and styles. Having sampled many local favorites, I can confidently guide you to spots that truly excel. Whether it’s a wood-fired crust or a classic double-layered slice, Edwardsville offers a range of pizzerias that cater to every craving.
What makes this list special is the diversity in approach and quality. From cozy neighborhood joints to more upscale pizzerias, each place has its own story and signature dish. If you’re searching for that perfect pie, look no further—these options promise a satisfying bite with every visit. Let’s dive into what makes these establishments stand out in this charming Illinois town.
Where to find the best pizza in Edwardsville, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Edwardsville, IL:
- Peel Wood Fired Pizza
- Dewey’s Pizza – Edwardsville
- Joes Pizza And Pasta
- Pantera’s Pizza
- MOD Pizza
- Imo’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Hooker’s Reel Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Sauce On The Side
- Pizza Hut
1. Peel Wood Fired Pizza
Peel Wood Fired Pizza is a standout for pizza lovers in Edwardsville. Known for their award-winning, wood-fired pies, each pizza is cooked at a blistering 800 degrees in a Mugnaini-built oven. The result is a crust with a distinct charred bubble, giving every slice a smoky, flavorful crunch that’s hard to match.
What sets Peel apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients and seasonal menu changes. I recommend trying their signature Margherita pizza, with its perfect balance of fresh basil, mozzarella, and a crisp crust. For something unique, their wood-fired wings and house-made desserts are equally worth sampling. Every visit promises a memorable taste of authentic, quality pizza crafted with care.
2. Dewey’s Pizza – Edwardsville
Dewey’s Pizza in Edwardsville offers a refined take on gourmet pizza with a vibrant, casual atmosphere. Known for their creative combinations and focus on fresh, local ingredients, every pie is a tribute to flavor and originality. The use of a dedicated playlist and welcoming service makes each visit feel special.
During my visit, I enjoyed their Fried Egg and Arugula Salad, which pairs beautifully with a slice of their signature White Pizza with Ricotta and Mozzarella. These dishes showcase Dewey’s commitment to quality and inventive toppings. Whether dining in or taking out, Dewey’s consistently delivers an elevated pizza experience that stands apart in Edwardsville’s pizza scene.
3. Joes Pizza And Pasta
Joe’s Pizza And Pasta in Edwardsville is a family-friendly spot known for its generous portions and warm service. The restaurant features spacious dining and cozy patio seating, making it perfect for casual meals or gatherings. Their diverse menu includes pizza, pasta, salads, and subs, all crafted with fresh ingredients and attention to flavor.
In my experience, their Margherita Pizza stands out for its crisp crust and fresh toppings, embodying the restaurant’s commitment to quality. For a hearty option, the Chicken Parmesan Pasta offers a satisfying blend of tender chicken and flavorful sauce. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Joe’s consistently delivers comfort food with a smile.
4. Pantera’s Pizza
Pantera’s Pizza in Edwardsville is a local favorite known for its hearty portions and inviting atmosphere. Featuring a dinner and lunch buffet, it’s perfect for those who want to sample a variety of flavors in one visit. The restaurant emphasizes a vegetarian-friendly menu, ensuring options for every palate.
During my visit, I enjoyed their classic Meat-Lover’s Pizza with a perfectly crispy crust and generous toppings. For something lighter, their Veggie Pizza showcases fresh ingredients and balanced flavors. Pantera’s stands out for its consistent quality and community feel, making each meal satisfying and dependable.
5. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza in Edwardsville offers a truly customized dining experience with a menu designed for personal preference. Known for their unlimited toppings and set price, it’s easy to craft a pizza exactly how you like it. The vibrant atmosphere pairs well with the modern, open kitchen, where you can watch your pizza come to life.
During my visit, I enjoyed building a Cauliflower Crust Vegetarian Pizza topped with fresh vegetables and vegan dressing—highlighting the restaurant’s accommodating options. With over 40 toppings and various crust choices, MOD Pizza caters to diverse dietary needs while maintaining high-quality ingredients. It’s perfect for a quick, custom, and satisfying meal in Edwardsville.
6. Imo’s Pizza
Imo’s Pizza in Edwardsville is renowned for its distinctive thin-crust pie and commitment to quality. Known for their St. Louis-style pizza, each slice features a cracker-thin crust with just the right amount of crunch. The restaurant offers a cozy setting with options for lunch, dinner, or takeout.
From personal experience, the Classic Imo’s Pizza with its signature provel cheese remains a favorite. Its crisp texture and savory flavor showcase Imo’s dedication to authentic flavors. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or a sit-down meal, Imo’s delivers a fulfilling pizza experience rooted in tradition and craftsmanship.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Edwardsville is known for offering a wide variety of pizza styles to suit every craving. From thin, foldable New York Style pizzas to thick, hearty Pan pizzas, they cater to diverse preferences with consistent quality. Their focus on value and convenience makes them a favorite for quick meals or late-night bites.
During my experience, I enjoyed their Cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust Pizza, which adds an extra layer of flavor and indulgence. Their menu also features popular sides like wings and pasta, perfect for rounding out a meal. Domino’s remains a reliable choice for satisfying, delicious pizza at a moment’s notice in Edwardsville.
8. Hooker’s Reel Restaurant & Pizzeria
Hooker’s Reel Restaurant & Pizzeria in Edwardsville combines a welcoming atmosphere with a focus on hearty Italian fare. Known for their delicious house-made pizza, they emphasize fresh ingredients and traditional flavors. The restaurant’s cozy setting makes it ideal for family dinners or casual outings.
From my experience, their Classic Pepperoni Pizza features a perfectly crisp crust with high-quality toppings. Their breakfast and lunch options also add versatility, but it’s their pizza that truly stands out. Hooker’s commitment to authentic, satisfying dishes earns it a special place for those seeking a genuine Italian experience in Edwardsville.
9. Sauce On The Side
See Menu
Sauce On The Side in Edwardsville offers a vibrant take on Italian cuisine with a focus on flavorful, fresh ingredients. Their signature pizzas are crafted with inventive toppings and a perfect crust that balances textures and taste. The restaurant’s inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for lunch or dinner with friends or family.
My favorite dish is their BBQ Chicken Pizza, which combines smoky sauce with tender chicken and cheese—a true reflection of their creative approach. The menu also features a variety of Italian classics and unique twists that keep diners coming back. Sauce On The Side’s commitment to quality and innovation makes it a standout in Edwardsville’s dining scene.
10. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Edwardsville is a familiar name when it comes to delivering classic, reliable pizza. Known for their Original Stuffed Crust and Meat Lovers options, they bring comfort and consistency to every order. The inviting ambiance makes it suitable for casual dining, takeout, or delivery.
In my experience, their Personal Pan Pizza offers a warm, satisfying bite, perfect for a quick meal. Their signature wings and decadent desserts complement the pizza perfectly. Pizza Hut’s focus on quality ingredients and recognized flavors makes it a dependable choice for pizza lovers in Edwardsville.
More Things to Try in Edwardsville, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Edwardsville, IL?
A: The best pizza depends on your taste, but popular options include Peel Wood Fired Pizza for authentic wood-fired pies and Dewey’s Pizza for creative toppings and upscale flavors. Both are highly recommended.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Edwardsville?
A: Yes, many places like MOD Pizza and Sauce On The Side offer vegetarian options, with some even providing vegan and gluten-free choices to accommodate dietary preferences.
Q: Do Edwardsville pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most restaurants, including Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Joe’s Pizza And Pasta, provide both delivery and carryout services, making it easy to enjoy your favorite pizza at home.
Q: Which pizza shops in Edwardsville have gluten-free crusts?
A: Peel Wood Fired Pizza and MOD Pizza both offer gluten-free crust options, catering to guests with gluten sensitivities.
Q: Can I order pizza for lunch in Edwardsville?
A: Absolutely. Many pizzerias serve lunch specials, including modern spots like MOD Pizza and traditional places like Domino’s and Imo’s Pizza, perfect for a midday meal.