Hunting for truly great pizza in East Hills, NY is its own kind of local adventure. Picture strolling down a quiet lane, the aroma of baking dough pulling you closer to an unassuming shopfront, and suddenly, every bite feels like the pizza makers designed it just for this neighborhood. I remember my first slice here: the crust had just the right snap, the sauce danced between sweet and savory, and the cheese had that ideal, golden stretch. If you know East Hills, you know that steady debate about the best spot. It’s not just food—it’s a quest.
What sets East Hills apart is a blend of family-run treasures and modern twists. The options might surprise you. There’s always a place nearby serving a pie worth your next meal, whether you’re a classic Margherita fan, prefer loaded veggie options, or seek out a thin, crisp base. With so many pizzerias vying for the top spot, navigating them can feel like a full-time job. Luckily, you’re in the right place—consider this your shortcut to the pizzaiolo highlights of East Hills.
Where to find the best pizza in East Hills, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in East Hills, NY:
- Abeetza Pizza
- Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
- Village Pizza
- Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn
- Attilio’s Pizza
- Delicacies
- Domino’s Pizza
- Skinny Pizza
1. Abeetza Pizza
(516) 484-3123Call
Abeetza Pizza in Roslyn Heights is the reliable crowd-pleaser for anyone who calls East Hills home. The first time I stepped through the door, I was met by the inviting scent of their classic pies baking in the oven—enough to put any tired appetite on notice.
What makes Abeetza really stand out is their balance of old-school tradition with just the right touch of creativity. Their pizza crust is consistently crispy outside and light inside—a tall order, but they hit it every time.
If you haven’t tried the Margarita slice, start there. The mozzarella is fresh, the basil bright, and the sauce is just tangy enough. For something bolder, their Grandma pie has a devoted following, and once you try it, you’ll understand why.
2. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza on Northern Blvd gives you a taste of classic tradition with a smoky twist. The first visit hooked me with that signature aroma—the kind you only get from a coal oven cranked up to full force. It’s a spot where crisp means crisp, and the toppings always feel thoughtfully chosen.
The main draw here is the distinctive charred crust, which manages to be both sturdy enough for a loaded slice and light enough that you never feel weighed down. The sauce bursts with flavor, thanks to a well-guarded family recipe.
Start with the Traditional Pie. The fresh mozzarella melts into the tangy sauce, while basil rounds out every bite. The Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza is a standout for anyone looking for an authentic local favorite—robust, zesty, and unmistakably East Hills.
3. Village Pizza
Village Pizza on Warner Ave feels like the classic neighborhood spot everyone wishes they had down the block. My last visit was a rainy evening; a slice of their piping hot pie made the walk home worth every step. There’s something comforting about how they keep things simple but never boring.
What sets Village Pizza apart is their dedication to quality ingredients and a perfectly balanced crust. Each bite achieves that golden balance of chewy and crispy, with flavors that are familiar but always fresh.
If you want to understand what the fuss is about, go straight for their classic cheese slice—it’s the kind of pizza you can eat any time, any day. Their white pizza, with creamy ricotta and just the right hit of garlic, is also a solid recommendation if you’re looking for something different.
4. Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn
Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn sits on Northern Blvd and has become a local favorite for those who love a bit of flair with their pie. My own visit was a revelation—the place buzzes with regulars grabbing their favorite slices, and you get a real sense of neighborhood pride in every detail.
What gives Joanne’s its edge is a menu stacked with inventive options and a crust that manages both a gentle crisp and a lasting chew. There’s always a touch of extra care in the toppings, from fresh vegetables to perfectly seasoned sauces.
The Pesto Pie is a standout and shows how Joanne’s handles bold flavors—nutty, fresh, and vibrant. For something classic, their Margherita pizza highlights the balance of quality mozzarella, basil, and a bright tomato sauce. It’s comfort done with style.
5. Attilio’s Pizza
Attilio’s Pizza on Mineola Ave is the sort of place where you’ll spot families crowding around fresh pies and locals dashing in for a quick lunch. On my last visit, the friendly staff made sure I felt right at home—there’s a warmth here that adds to every meal.
The defining feature at Attilio’s is a reliable, classic approach to pizza. Each pie comes out with a golden crust that can stand up to a mountain of toppings, and a sauce that’s rich yet never overpowering.
If you’re wondering what to order, their Vegetable Pizza is packed with flavor, showing off their knack for fresh, bright toppings. The Sicilian slice hits that perfect note for anyone who loves a thick, airy base with a little crunch at the edges.
6. Delicacies
Delicacies on Old Northern Blvd feels like a hidden gem, tucked between familiar shops and busy streets. During my last visit, I found the variety tempting and the staff attentive—there’s an unmistakable local vibe that sets the tone for a great meal.
What’s unique about Delicacies is their fusion of deli classics and pizza favorites. You’ll find options that range from traditional to unexpected, all made with a clear focus on freshness and flavor. The crust holds its own, never overshadowing the well-crafted toppings.
The Vegetable Pizza here is a standout, loaded with seasonal veggies that actually taste vibrant. If you love a straightforward favorite, the plain cheese slice is always solid, showing off the balanced sauce and pillowy dough.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Mineola Ave serves up consistency for those times when you crave a familiar slice. My last order was on a busy weeknight—delivery was fast, and the pizza was just as expected: hot, cheesy, and satisfying.
Domino’s stands out for their customization and speedy service. Whether you love a classic hand-tossed crust or prefer a crispy thin crust, there’s a style to match your mood. Plus, their app makes ordering almost too easy.
If you want the house specialty, go with the Handmade Pan Pizza. It’s thick, buttery, and holds up well to plenty of toppings. For something lighter, the Thin Crust Veggie Pizza really lets the cheese and fresh veggies balance each bite.
8. Skinny Pizza
Skinny Pizza on Mineola Ave is perfect for those who want flavor without the heaviness. I first tried it after hearing that you could get a guilt-free slice without missing out on taste. The experience surprised me—thin, crisp crust and fresh toppings that felt lighter, but still satisfying.
What’s different about Skinny Pizza is their focus on wholesome, all-natural ingredients and creative combinations. The selection covers both classics and inventive pies, all with a nod toward lighter eating and mindful choices.
The Skinny Margherita is a reliable favorite: tomatoes and mozzarella on a cracker-thin base, finished with fresh basil. Their Veggie Lovers Pizza piles colorful, crisp vegetables on a surprisingly sturdy crust for a pie that feels fresh and vibrant. Good pizza, pared down to the essentials.
More Things to Try in East Hills, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are most popular in East Hills, NY?
You’ll find a mix of classic New York-style slices, gourmet pies, thin-crust options, and thick Sicilian slices at local spots. Vegetarian-friendly pizzas are widely available too.
Are there any pizza places in East Hills that offer vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes, several pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts and vegan-friendly pizzas. It’s best to check menus or call ahead to see what’s available on the day you order.
Is delivery available from pizza restaurants in East Hills, NY?
Nearly every major pizza spot in East Hills offers delivery, either directly or through food delivery apps. Some even have their own apps for quick ordering and tracking.
Can I find traditional Italian-style pizza or contemporary flavors in East Hills?
You’ll get the best of both worlds. Old-school Italian recipes sit right alongside newer, creative takes. Many places experiment with fresh produce and unique toppings for those seeking something different.
Are there any late-night pizza options in East Hills?
Some restaurants and national chains stay open late, especially on weekends. For a late-night craving, it’s smart to check hours or order ahead before heading out.