Best Pizza in Eagle River, WI

Eagle River, WI, is full of surprises. This little town might be famous for its scenic beauty and friendly folks, but let me tell you, it’s also a hidden gem for pizza lovers. You’re about to find out where to get the best slice (or two) in town.

So, where’s the best pizza in Eagle River, WI? Here’s the short answer. You’ll find it at a handful of local spots, each offering something special. Some are great for thin crust. Others are all about loaded toppings. Either way, you won’t leave disappointed.

Curious to know more? Stick around. I’ll take you through the top pizzerias. You’ll get all the details you need—flavors, vibes, and why each spot is worth a visit. Let’s dig in!

Top 6 Pizza in Eagle River, WI

1. LP’s Pizza + Pasta
2. Club Denoyer
3. Aiello’s On Wall Street
4. Bortolotti’s Cin Cin
5. Butch’s Pizza North
6. Alexander’s Family Pizza Parlor

1. LP’s Pizza + Pasta

LP’s Pizza + Pasta is a charming spot on East Wall Street. It has indoor and outdoor seating. The place is wheelchair-accessible too.

I had a great time there. The moment I walked in, the warm vibe hit me. The staff was super friendly and the smell of fresh pizza was amazing.

LP’s stands out because of its quality. They use fresh ingredients and the flavors are bold. It’s a must-visit.

Try the LP’s Special Pizza. It’s loaded with toppings and cheese. Their homemade pasta is also a treat. It’s a meal you won’t forget.

2. Club Denoyer

Club Denoyer is a cozy gem on Highway 70. It has indoor and outdoor seating. The place is wheelchair-accessible too.

I loved my time there. The moment I stepped in, I felt at home. The staff greeted me with smiles and the whole place had a warm vibe.

Club Denoyer stands out for its affordable prices and tasty pizzas. I highly recommend their Pepperoni Pizza. It’s simple, yet so flavorful. The crispy crust and generous cheese are a delight. Also, try their garlic breadsticks. They are the perfect side to your pizza and absolutely delicious!

3. Aiello’s On Wall Street

Aiello’s On Wall Street is super cool. It’s on East Wall Street. They have indoor and outdoor seating. You can even take your food to go.

I remember my visit there. The vibe was great. Lots of happy people. The staff was really nice. And the service was so fast.

Their fresh ingredients are amazing. The flavors just pop. Try the Margherita Pizza. It’s so fresh and tasty. And don’t miss the cheesy garlic bread. It’s a perfect starter.

Aiello’s is a must-visit. You’ll love it!

4. Bortolotti’s Cin Cin

Bortolotti’s Cin Cin is such a gem. Tucked away on Bluebird Road, it feels like a cozy escape. You can sit inside or enjoy the breeze outside. They even take reservations, which makes things so easy.

When I walked in, it just felt right. The vibe was warm and cheerful. The staff smiled a lot, which was nice. It wasn’t too loud, so I could relax and enjoy myself.

The pizza there? Oh, it’s a must-try. Their Cin Cin Pizza blew me away. The crust was crispy, and the toppings tasted super fresh. I also loved their garlic knots. They were soft, buttery, and just perfect.

Everything about this place stands out. It’s friendly, tasty, and truly unforgettable. I can’t wait to go back.

5. Butch’s Pizza North

Butch’s Pizza North is a fantastic place. It’s right on Wall Street in Eagle River. I love that they deliver and offer takeout. They even have a wheelchair-accessible entrance.

When I walked in, the warm vibe hit me. The staff was super friendly and helpful. The smell of fresh pizza just made my mouth water. It felt like a great spot to hang out.

What really stands out is their specialty pizzas. I tried the sausage and pepperoni. Wow, it was so good! The crust was perfect—crispy yet chewy. And don’t forget the cheesy garlic bread. It’s a must-have! Butch’s Pizza North is all about good vibes and even better food. Can’t wait to go back!

6. Alexander’s Family Pizza Parlor

Alexander’s Family Pizza Parlor is a gem on Railroad Street. I love their cozy vibes. You can sit inside or outside. It’s great for any day. They have such friendly staff. I felt welcomed as soon as I walked in. The aroma of pizza made my mouth water instantly.

I had a blast dining here. The staff is super nice. It felt like visiting old friends. Their Supreme Pizza is amazing. It’s loaded with yummy toppings. The crust is crispy and perfect. I also recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. It’s spicy and packed with flavor.

What makes Alexander’s stand out? It’s their warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Everyone feels at home here. The food is top-notch, and the service is fantastic. If you love pizza, you must visit Alexander’s.

Map of Pizza in Eagle River, WI

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 6 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best pizza spots in Eagle River, WI?
I’d say LP’s Pizza + Pasta and Aiello’s On Wall Street are must-tries. Each place has its own unique taste and vibe. You really can’t go wrong with either!

2. Do any pizza places in Eagle River do delivery?
Yes, Butch’s Pizza North offers delivery! It’s super handy if you want to enjoy pizza at home. Many others have takeout too.

3. Can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza options?
Definitely! Most places have great vegetarian choices with fresh veggies. Some even offer vegan cheese, so just ask!

4. Can I make reservations at pizza restaurants?
For sure! Bortolotti’s Cin Cin takes reservations. It’s always smart to call ahead during busy times, so you get a seat.

5. How much does a pizza cost in Eagle River?
Most pizzas range from about $10 to $20. The price depends on the size and toppings you choose. Plus, there are usually good deals on sides.

6. Is there outdoor seating at pizza spots?
Absolutely! Places like Club Denoyer and Alexander’s have outdoor seating. It’s lovely to enjoy your meal outside when the weather is nice.