Dyer, Indiana, has amazing pizza. Trust me, you’ll find everything here. From crispy thin crusts to gooey, deep-dish pies, this town knows its pizza.
So, what’s the best pizza in Dyer, IN? Honestly, it’s hard to pick just one. Dyer is packed with pizzerias offering fresh, tasty, and crowd-pleasing slices. Each has its own special charm, making pizza lovers really happy.
Get ready for an insider’s guide to Dyer’s top pizza spots. From hidden gems to local favorites, I’ll cover them all. Stick around to discover your next favorite pizzeria!
Top 10 Pizza in Dyer, IN
- Doreen’s Pizzeria
- John’s Pizzeria
- State Line Pizza Dyer
- Little Italy
- Windy City Pizza Kitchen Dyer
- Beggar’s Pizza
- Rosati’s Pizza Dyer
- Giordano’s
- Pizza Kitchen
- Tony’s Italian Deli
1. Doreen’s Pizzeria
Phone: (219) 865-9988
Menu: www.doreenspizzeria.com
Directions: Open on Map
Doreen’s Pizzeria feels like home. It’s welcoming, warm, and smells amazing. You can sit inside, outside, or just take your pizza to go. Plus, it’s easy on the wallet, making it a perfect pick for any night.
The first time I went, I couldn’t stop smiling. The staff was so kind, and the pizzas? Oh, they were heavenly. I tried their margherita pizza, and wow—it was fresh, crisp, and packed with flavor.
What makes Doreen’s shine is its quality. You can tell they care. Every bite tastes fresh, from the crunchy crust to the gooey cheese. If you’re going, try Doreen’s Special. It’s loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and veggies. It’s a slice of pure joy and definitely a must-try!
2. John’s Pizzeria
Phone: (219) 322-8400
Menu: www.johnspizzerias.net
Directions: Open on Map
John’s Pizzeria is a real treat. It feels friendly and fun inside. You can sit in or enjoy the fresh air outside. It’s also super affordable, which is great for everyone.
The first time I visited, I was impressed. The staff made me feel welcome right away. I went for their classic cheese pizza. Wow! It was simple, but so tasty. The cheese was melted perfectly, and the crust had a nice crunch.
What I love about John’s is the relaxed vibe. It’s perfect for a casual meal with friends. If you’re there, try the Meat Lovers Pizza. It’s loaded with flavors and toppings. You can really taste the quality in every bite!
3. State Line Pizza Dyer
Phone: (219) 865-2922
Menu: statelinepizza.net
Directions: Open on Map
State Line Pizza Dyer is such a fun place. It has a chill vibe and cozy seating. You can eat inside or outside, which is super nice. The prices are just right, making it easy to enjoy a great meal.
When I visited, I felt right at home. The staff greeted me with smiles. I ordered their BBQ Chicken Pizza, and wow, it was amazing! The flavor was sweet and smoky. It hit the spot.
What makes State Line stand out is their creative toppings. They really know how to mix things up. If you go there, definitely try the Veggie Deluxe Pizza. It’s fresh and packed with colorful veggies. Trust me, you’ll love it!
4. Little Italy
Phone: (219) 865-3040
Menu: www.dyerlittleitaly.com
Directions: Open on Map
Little Italy is such a delightful place. It has a warm, romantic vibe. You can sit inside or enjoy the outdoor seating. The prices are moderate, making it a nice spot for special moments.
When I walked in, I instantly felt cozy. The staff was super friendly, which made me feel welcome. I ordered their gourmet pizza. Oh wow, each slice was so tasty! The flavors really stood out.
What I love about Little Italy is how they elevate classic dishes. They take familiar favorites and make them special. If you visit, definitely try the Signature Lasagna. It’s cheesy, flavorful, and just amazing. Trust me, you’ll be coming back for more!
5. Windy City Pizza Kitchen Dyer
Windy City Pizza Kitchen Dyer is a great find. It has a cozy atmosphere. You can sit inside or enjoy the sunshine outside. It’s such a chill place to grab a bite.
When I stopped by, I felt right at home. The staff greeted me with smiles. I couldn’t resist trying their deep-dish pizza. Let me tell you, it was fantastic! The crust was thick and delicious.
What really sets Windy City apart is their Chicago-style pizza. They do it with pride. If you go, you have to try the Classic Pepperoni Deep-Dish. It’s packed with flavor and so cheesy. Trust me, you’ll love every bite!
6. Beggar’s Pizza
Phone: (219) 322-4448
Menu: www.beggarspizza.com
Directions: Open on Map
Beggar’s Pizza is such a great place to visit. They have a wide range of pizzas, from thin-crust to deep-dish. The vibe is casual and fun, and you can choose to eat inside or outside. It’s perfect for a meal with friends or family.
When I went there, I felt very welcome. The staff was super nice and eager to help. I tried their stuffed pizza, and wow! It was seriously good. The crust was thick and filled with all my favorite toppings.
What I really love about Beggar’s Pizza is their variety. They have something for everyone. If you’re there, you have to order the Meat Lover’s Stuffed Pizza. It’s so hearty and flavorful. You’ll enjoy every single bite!
7. Rosati’s Pizza Dyer
Rosati’s Pizza Dyer is just awesome. Their Chicago-style deep-dish pizza? A total dream. The crust is buttery and oh-so-thick. Every bite bursts with flavor. It’s cozy inside with friendly vibes. The outdoor seating is great, too.
When I went, I felt super welcome. The staff smiled and chatted with me. I grabbed a table and ordered. It didn’t take long. I got their classic deep-dish, and wow. The cheese was gooey, the toppings fresh. It was amazing.
What makes them special? It’s the taste. The deep-dish feels truly authentic. If you visit, try the Sausage Deep-Dish. It’s so hearty. The flavors just hit right. Honestly, every slice is pure happiness. Trust me on this one.
8. Giordano’s
Phone: (219) 215-0333
Menu: giordanos.com
Directions: Open on Map
Giordano’s is a must-visit for pizza fans. They’re known for their deep-dish pizza, and trust me, it’s amazing. The vibe is casual and relaxed. You can sit inside or enjoy the weather outside.
When I went to Giordano’s, I felt super excited. The team was friendly and helpful. I ordered the stuffed deep-dish pizza, and wow! It was loaded with cheese and toppings. Each slice was thick and satisfying.
What really sets Giordano’s apart is their flavor. It’s rich and delicious. If you try it, definitely go for the Spinach and Cheese Stuffed Pizza. It’s fresh and oh-so-good. You won’t regret it, I promise!
9. Pizza Kitchen
Pizza Kitchen is such a great spot in Dyer. The vibe is cozy and inviting. You can choose to sit inside or outside, which is nice. It’s perfect for a casual meal or a quick takeout.
When I visited, I was really hungry. I decided to try their thin-crust pizza. Each slice was fantastic! The cheese was melty, and the toppings tasted super fresh. And the crust? Just right—crispy yet light.
What makes Pizza Kitchen stand out is their quality. Everything tastes homemade and delicious. If you go, you really have to try the Margherita pizza. The simple mix of tomatoes and fresh basil is amazing. You’ll enjoy every single bite!
10. Tony’s Italian Deli
Phone: (219) 515-2012
Menu: www.mytonysdeli.com
Directions: Open on Map
Tony’s Italian Deli feels like home. It’s small, cozy, and inviting. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Perfect for any mood or weather.
The first thing I noticed was the smell. Freshly baked bread and spices filled the air. The staff greeted me like an old friend. They were warm and helpful, making me feel welcome.
Their Italian combo sandwich is a must-try. It was full of fresh, flavorful meat and crisp veggies. The bread had the perfect crunch. But honestly, the star was their homemade pizza. Thin, crispy crust topped with rich, gooey cheese. It was love at first bite.
Tony’s stands out for its quality. Every bite tastes fresh and homemade. You’ll leave with a happy stomach and a big smile!
Map of Pizza in Dyer, IN
Choosing the Right Restaurant for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Restaurant | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doreen’s Pizzeria | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | No |
| John’s Pizzeria | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| State Line Pizza Dyer | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Little Italy | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Windy City Pizza Kitchen Dyer | – | Yes | Yes | Yes | – | – |
| Beggar’s Pizza | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Rosati’s Pizza Dyer | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Giordano’s | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | No |
| Pizza Kitchen | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | No | – | – |
| Tony’s Italian Deli | – | Yes | Yes | No | Accessible | No |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Dyer, IN?
Oh, there are so many great spots! Doreen’s Pizzeria and Giordano’s are top picks. Each one has its own tasty style.
2. Does Dyer have any pizza delivery options?
Definitely! Lots of places in Dyer deliver. You can enjoy your pizza at home, all warm and fresh.
3. Can I eat pizza outdoors in Dyer?
For sure! Many pizzerias have outdoor seating. It’s a nice way to enjoy your meal outside.
4. What types of pizza can I find in Dyer?
You’ll find everything in Dyer! From deep-dish to thin crust, there’s something for everyone. Toppings vary, too, so you can mix and match.
5. Are there vegetarian pizza options available?
Yes, they do! Many spots offer veggie pizzas. You can load them with fresh toppings and cheese.
6. How much does a pizza cost in Dyer?
Pizza prices are pretty reasonable. Most places range from about $10 to $30, depending on the size. It’s a good deal for a tasty meal!
7. Are there gluten-free pizza options in Dyer?
Absolutely! Many restaurants have gluten-free crusts. Just ask when you order, and they’ll help you out.
8. Can I make reservations for pizza restaurants in Dyer?
Some spots take reservations. It’s smart to call ahead, especially if you’re going with a group. It’s best to ensure you get a table!