Finding the best pizza in Durham, NC isn’t just about crust thickness or cheese ratios—it’s about discovering that perfect slice that tells a story. I still remember walking through downtown Durham on a crisp fall afternoon, drawn by the scent of wood-fired dough and bubbling mozzarella. One bite into a slice from a tucked-away garage-turned-pizzeria, and it changed my definition of what pizza could be. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or prefer the comfort of a hearty square cut, Durham has quietly evolved into one of the most underappreciated pizza cities in the Southeast.
This guide trims the excess and delivers just what you need: clear insights into Durham’s most compelling pizza spots, from long-standing local legends to new names that deserve recognition. We’ve made sure every recommendation considers quality, consistency, local buzz, and—yes—ingredient integrity. If you care about craft, flavor, and places that truly get it right (without needing a gimmick), stick around. You’re about to uncover your next favorite pizza in Durham.
Where to find the best pizza in Durham, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Durham, NC:
- Pizzeria Toro
- Mellow Mushroom Durham
- Randy’s Pizza
- Enzo’s Pizza Co.
- Hutchins Garage
- Devil’s Pizzeria
- Marco’s Pizza
- Tomato Jake’s
- Pop’s Backdoor
- Pie Pushers
1. Pizzeria Toro
Tucked in Durham’s downtown, Pizzeria Toro pairs wood-fired charm with a menu that’s both thoughtful and bold. On my first visit, I took a seat near the open kitchen and watched flames dance behind the oven—there’s a meditative rhythm to the place, and it shows in every pie.
What makes Toro stand out is its simple yet intentional approach. Every pizza starts with chewy, blistered crust and layers of seasonal ingredients. The Margherita is a reliable favorite—clean flavors, no overthinking. But if you want something memorable, try the Spicy Lamb Sausage Pizza. It’s rich, aromatic, and delivers balanced heat without overpowering the integrity of the crust.
Whether you’re after lunch, dinner, or a late-night slice, Toro nails consistency. Plus, options for vegetarians and gluten-free eaters make it easy to bring friends along.
Pizzeria Toro isn’t just about food—it’s about pacing and place. That’s rare, and it’s worth your time.
2. Mellow Mushroom Durham
Walking into Mellow Mushroom Durham feels like stepping into a vibrant slice of creativity. I remember sitting on the patio on a warm evening, sipping craft beer and sampling a slice that was as imaginative as the decor—bright colors, quirky art, and a relaxed vibe. It’s a place that elevates pizza beyond tradition, blending bold flavors with artistic presentation.
What makes Mellow Mushroom stand out is its creatively inspired stone-baked pizzas and diverse menu. If you’re craving something memorable, the Buffalo Summa pizza combines spice and richness, while the vegetarian-friendly Veg Out caters to meatless appetites. The gluten-free options ensure everyone can enjoy a slice without compromise.
Perfect for lunch, dinner, or late-night bites, Mellow Mushroom Durham offers an experience that’s both fun and flavorful—truly a higher order of pizza.
3. Randy’s Pizza
There’s something comforting about a slice from Randy’s Pizza. I first stopped by after a long day on the road, craving something familiar yet satisfying. What I got was a massive, foldable slice that tasted like it came straight from a New York corner shop—crispy edges, chewy center, and just the right amount of sauce-to-cheese ratio.
Randy’s has earned its reputation for serving the best New York-style pizza in the Triangle, and it’s not just hype. The crust is thin but sturdy, the toppings are generous, and the flavor is consistent across locations. The Cheese Slice is a classic, but the White Pizza with spinach and ricotta is where Randy’s really shows its range.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or ordering in for dinner, Randy’s delivers on quality and portion. It’s no-frills, just good pizza done right.
4. Enzo’s Pizza Co.
When I visited Enzo’s Pizza Co., I was struck by its welcoming ambiance and inviting aroma. Sitting in a cozy corner, I ordered the Margherita Pizza, which exemplifies their dedication to quality ingredients and authentic flavors. The fresh basil and ripe tomatoes balanced perfectly atop a crisp, chewy crust, showcasing Enzo’s commitment to traditional Italian techniques.
What really sets Enzo’s apart is its focus on accommodating various dietary needs without sacrificing flavor. The gluten-free options and vegetarian selections are thoughtfully prepared, making it easy for everyone to enjoy a quality slice. Their lunch and dinner menus are versatile, ensuring convenience and freshness with every order.
For those seeking a pizza that combines authenticity with a contemporary touch, Enzo’s delivers a memorable experience rooted in quality and care.
5. Hutchins Garage
Hutchins Garage is the kind of place that makes you rethink what pizza can be. Set in a converted auto shop on Geer Street, it blends Durham charm with wood-fired flavor. The vibe is industrial but warm, the kind of laid-back spot that locals swear by.
What stands out at Hutchins is their dedication to quality. Their crust is chewy, blistered, and kissed by flame, delivering that perfect balance of structure and tenderness. You can tell the dough gets the attention it deserves.
If it’s your first visit, go for the Margherita or the roasted mushroom pizza. Both showcase the kitchen’s minimalist precision—fresh ingredients, bold flavors, no shortcuts. It’s pizza that speaks clearly, with no gimmicks.
This isn’t a chain, and it shows. Hutchins Garage keeps things honest, focused, and seriously good.
6. Devil’s Pizzeria
Tucked into Durham’s Ninth Street scene, Devil’s Pizzeria has the kind of neighborhood charm that feels both familiar and fresh. It’s not trying to be trendy—it just delivers solid, satisfying pizza that locals keep coming back for. The space is casual, the service is quick, and the slices? Dependably good.
What sets Devil’s apart is its New York-style pizza: thin, foldable, and generously topped. The crust has that perfect balance of chew and crisp, and the sauce leans savory with just a hint of sweetness. It’s the kind of slice that doesn’t need a gimmick.
If you’re ordering for the first time, go for the classic cheese or the veggie-loaded Garden Pizza. Both showcase the kitchen’s attention to balance and flavor. And if you’re in a hurry, their takeout and delivery options are fast and reliable.
Devil’s Pizzeria doesn’t overpromise—it just gets the fundamentals right. That’s what makes it a quiet staple in Durham’s pizza lineup.
7. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza in Durham keeps things straightforward: no pretense, just solid pizza. On a quiet weekday evening, I grabbed a seat and a slice of their original cheese pizza—it was impressively crisp on the edges, with a soft interior and a balanced tomato sauce that didn’t overpower the bite. That first slice felt familiar in the best way.
What makes Marco’s stand out is its focus on consistency. The crust is always reliable, never soggy, and their blend of cheeses gives each pie a subtle richness. It’s a dependable spot whether you’re dining in or ordering out.
If you’re choosing, start with the Deluxe Pizza. It’s layered with fresh vegetables and hearty toppings, all without tipping into excess. Their vegetarian-friendly options make it easy to share without compromise.
Marco’s Pizza isn’t chasing trends. It’s simply serving up well-made, satisfying pies that suit Durham’s no-fuss crowd.
8. Tomato Jake’s
Tomato Jake’s feels less like a chain and more like your neighborhood spot that actually gets pizza right. I popped in after a late shift and was met with warm service and a pie that didn’t feel rushed. The crust was perfectly crisp without being dry, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio leaned flavorful without drowning the slice.
What makes Jake’s stand out is how it balances bold flavors without overcomplicating the experience. It’s a place where the pizza does the talking, especially their Big Jake’s Pepperoni—thick-cut slices, rich tomato base, and enough bite to keep it interesting. Their veggie combo is also worth noting: fresh, bright toppings, all perfectly roasted.
Ideal for quick lunch stops or casual dinners, Tomato Jake’s offers takeout and delivery too, without compromising quality. It’s pizza built for Durham’s everyday crowd—reliable, satisfying, and unpretentious.
9. Pop’s Backdoor
My visit to Pop’s Backdoor was a charming surprise. Hidden away on Shannon Road, it offers a cozy, pub-like atmosphere that perfectly matches its creative pizza offerings. I ordered the Sausage and Roasted Pepper Pizza, which impressed with its thin, crispy crust and layers of smoky, flavorful toppings. Each bite reflected the care and quality that Pop’s brings to its craft.
What makes Pop’s stand out is its commitment to fresh, local ingredients and its inventive toppings. Their pizza isn’t just standard—it’s thoughtfully assembled with a flavor profile that’s both familiar and exciting. Vegetarian options are available, adding to its accessibility.
Whether for lunch or dinner, Pop’s Backdoor offers reliable quality, making it a go-to spot for satisfying pizza in Durham.
10. Pie Pushers
Tucked above Main Street in downtown Durham, Pie Pushers delivers more than just slices—it serves up a local favorite with personality. The vibe is casual but confident, much like their menu. It’s the kind of place where regulars know the staff by name and newcomers feel like they’ve stumbled onto something special.
What sets Pie Pushers apart is its bold, scratch-made approach. The crust is thin but sturdy, with just enough chew to hold up to generous toppings. I tried the “Green Monster”, a standout with fresh spinach, roasted garlic, and a tangy pesto drizzle. It’s a perfect example of how they balance flavor and texture without overcomplicating things.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie, Pie Pushers delivers quality with a local twist.
More Things to Try in Durham, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the most popular pizza places in Durham, NC?
Some of the most visited spots include Pizzeria Toro, Randy’s Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Pie Pushers. Each offers a distinct style, from wood-fired to New York-style slices.
2. Where can I find halal or vegetarian pizza options in Durham?
While halal options are limited, several places offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas, including Devil’s Pizzeria, Enzo’s Pizza Co., and Emmy Squared. Always check with the restaurant for ingredient details.
3. Which pizza place is best for families with kids?
Chuck E. Cheese and Pizza Inn are popular with families due to their kid-friendly menus and casual atmosphere. Papa Johns and Domino’s also offer reliable delivery for family nights.
4. Are there any local pizza spots near Duke University?
Yes, Devil’s Pizzeria and Pie Pushers are close to campus and cater to students with quick service and affordable slices.
5. What’s the best place for wood-fired pizza in Durham?
Pizzeria Toro and Cugino Forno are known for their authentic wood-fired pies, offering crisp crusts and fresh toppings.
6. Where can I get gluten-free pizza in Durham?
Blaze Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Domino’s offer gluten-free crust options. Be sure to confirm cross-contamination policies if you have dietary restrictions.
7. Which pizza places offer delivery in Durham?
Most chains like Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut provide fast delivery. Local favorites such as Randy’s Pizza and Marco’s Pizza also offer delivery through third-party apps.
8. What’s the best pizza for a date night in Durham?
Pizzeria Toro and Hutchins Garage offer a more intimate setting with elevated flavors, ideal for a relaxed evening out.
9. Are there any pizza buffets in Durham?
Pizza Inn is one of the few places offering a classic pizza buffet, perfect for those who want variety at a good value.
10. What’s the most affordable pizza in Durham?
For budget-friendly slices, check out Pie Pushers, Tomato Jake’s, and Marco’s Pizza. They balance price with quality.
11. Do any Durham pizza places offer unique or creative toppings?
Devil’s Pizzeria stands out with options like taco pizza and chicken parmesan pizza, while Hutchins Garage experiments with seasonal ingredients and bold combinations.
12. Is there Detroit-style pizza in Durham?
Yes, Emmy Squared specializes in Detroit-style square pizzas, known for their thick crust and caramelized edges.
13. Which pizza places are open late in Durham?
Randy’s Pizza, Domino’s, and Papa Johns typically stay open later than most, making them reliable for late-night cravings.
14. Are there any pizza places with outdoor seating in Durham?
Hutchins Garage, Cugino Forno, and Pizzeria Toro offer outdoor dining, ideal for enjoying Durham’s mild evenings.
15. What’s the best pizza for large groups or parties?
Chains like Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Domino’s are equipped for bulk orders, while Randy’s Pizza is a local favorite for feeding crowds.