The search for seriously good pizza in Destin, FL is hardly a laid-back affair—especially if you crave more than the basic chain pie. I know this hunger well. After too many attempts with soggy crusts on beach towels, I finally found the local joints and crowd-pleasers that deliver flavor and fun, bite after bite. Destin balances classic family-run Italian kitchens, bold coastal twists, and the unfussy slice counters that locals hit after work.
With a platter of options along the Emerald Coast, picking the best pizza in Destin can feel almost impossible. Here’s where it gets easy: I’ve sorted through the hype and the hangouts, rounding up the top pizza spots that serve pies worth your cravings. Get ready to meet the places where wood-fired ovens, thick Sicilian crusts, and creative toppings actually matter. If you’re hungry for a slice of Destin worth returning for, your search ends here.
Where to find the best pizza in Destin, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Destin, FL:
- Buffalo Jack’s Legendary Wings & Pizza
- Merlin’s Pizza
- Fat Clemenza’s
- Vinny McGuire’s Pizza
- Pazzo Italiano
- Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano
- Roberto’s Pizzeria
- Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
- Pascalli Kitchen
- Marco’s Pizza
1. Buffalo Jack’s Legendary Wings & Pizza
+1 850-424-6288
See Menu
Buffalo Jack’s Legendary Wings & Pizza feels like a lively slice of New Orleans tucked right into Miramar Beach. The vibe is relaxed but energetic, and the menu brings out a creative, hearty side of pizza you don’t often find in Destin. Stopping in after a sun-soaked afternoon, I was struck by how the crust manages to be both crispy and chewy—a trick few pull off.
Their Buffalo Chicken Pizza stands out, blending nicely spiced chicken with tangy sauce and lots of oozy cheese. Another local favorite is the Supreme; it’s layered with fresh toppings and never skimps on flavor. If you like bold flavors, you’ll fit right in. Buffalo Jack’s shows that good pizza should be fun, generous, and full of local color.
2. Merlin’s Pizza
Merlin’s Pizza is the place you stumble into thinking you’ll grab a quick bite—and end up staying for a second slice. Locals have called it their top pick since 1999, and it’s easy to see why: everything feels homemade, from the hand-tossed crust to the thoughtfully seasoned sauces. I remember ordering a late-night pie with friends; every bite of that veggie-loaded pizza was a reminder that fresh matters.
The White Chicken Pizza is their signature—think tender chicken, garlic, and a perfectly creamy mozzarella blend. Gluten-free and vegan choices mean nobody has to miss out. When you crave a local spot that isn’t shy about bold flavors and generous portions, Merlin’s is Destin’s sure bet.
3. Fat Clemenza’s
Walking into Fat Clemenza’s, you get that classic old-world aroma of brick ovens and toasted dough—comforting and inviting all at once. This place has mastered the art of Italian pizza, and it’s always brimming with hungry regulars. My first bite here was a Margherita pizza: thin crust, just blistered, and brimming with fresh basil. Pure simplicity, but a clear standout.
Their Quattro Formaggi is for cheese lovers, balancing gooey mozzarella, sharp gorgonzola, nutty parmesan, and creamy ricotta. The crust is light but never flimsy, the toppings are as fresh as it gets, and there’s always a warm welcome from the staff. Fat Clemenza’s offers a slice of Italy on the Emerald Coast, making it worth seeking out when pizza cravings hit.
4. Vinny McGuire’s Pizza
Vinny McGuire’s Pizza sits on Harbor Boulevard, where the casual energy makes you feel right at home. The restaurant is cozy, lively, and set apart by a playful sense of creativity. I remember building my own pizza here—choosing each topping and watching the kitchen work their magic. The crust came out with that just-right balance: crispy on the outside, tender inside.
Customize your own pizza or try their classic Margherita, which always delivers with bright tomato and silky mozzarella. They use fresh, quality ingredients and never shy away from generous toppings. What makes Vinny McGuire’s shine is the sheer variety and the fun of crafting your perfect pie, bite by bite. If you like options and a laid-back setting, this spot is not to be missed in Destin.
5. Pazzo Italiano
Pazzo Italiano brings a bit of urban charm to Destin with its stylish, welcoming vibe and focus on classic Italian favorites. The first time I walked in, the scent of wood-fired dough alone was reason enough to settle in for a meal. You’ll notice the spacious dining room has a buzz—a mix of families, friends, and locals lingering over hot pies and laughter.
Their wood-fired Margherita is a star: thin and crisp, topped with aromatic basil, ripe tomato, and creamy mozzarella. Another local favorite is the Quattro Stagioni, loaded with artichoke, olives, and savory mushrooms. Pazzo Italiano stands out for its top-notch ingredients and a menu that welcomes everyone. If you want old-world flavor with a modern twist, this is your answer in Destin.
6. Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano
Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano brings old-school Italian warmth right to Destin’s busy Highway 98. The atmosphere is a step above the typical pizza spot, with friendly service and a cozy patio perfect for lively dinners. I remember my last visit: after making a reservation, I was greeted as if I were family, and the aroma from the oven was irresistible.
Their signature Mimmo’s Pizza always impresses, layered with mozzarella, mushrooms, artichokes, and a light touch of olive oil. The dough has a springy chew, and every topping tastes fresh. Mimmo’s combines authentic recipes with a relaxed setting, so it’s no wonder locals suggest making a reservation. If you value both tradition and genuine hospitality, this is your pizza spot in Destin.
7. Roberto’s Pizzeria
Roberto’s Pizzeria is where sports fans and pizza lovers find common ground in Sandestin. It’s a lively spot set up for both casual family meals and game day excitement, with big TVs and a menu that feels classic yet fresh. I dropped in during football season and ended up staying for the relaxed vibe and genuinely good crust.
The Works Pizza is a crowd-pleaser—plenty of mushrooms, onions, and peppers, all layered over their signature dough. It’s satisfying without being heavy, and the cheese stretch alone is enough to draw a crowd. Roberto’s balances comfort and quality effortlessly, making it a smart pick whether you’re taking out or settling in for the evening with friends.
8. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria transports you straight to Brooklyn, minus the subway hustle. Their coal-fired brick oven draws pizza fans from across Destin, and it’s easy to understand the pull. My visit was about nostalgia—freshly made mozzarella, that whisper of smokiness from the charred crust, and slices you fold in half without losing a crumb.
The classic Margherita is always a win, marrying velvety mozzarella and tangy secret-recipe sauce on a crackly crust. Their White Pizza, brushed with garlic and olive oil, is another standout. Grimaldi’s delivers heritage in every slice, whether you gather with friends or tuck into a pie solo. For those after an old-school pizza with an unmistakable New York accent, this is the place to grab a table.
9. Pascalli Kitchen
Pascalli Kitchen, tucked along Scenic Gulf Drive, is the kind of local spot you discover once and return to whenever you crave comfort. The menu leans into quality, with something for everyone morning to night. I dropped in with friends on a whim and was pulled in by the kitchen’s open, friendly energy.
Their Veggie Pizza is a winner, loaded with fresh spinach, tomatoes, bell peppers, and mushrooms. It’s light, crisp, and lets the ingredients shine. Pascalli’s makes every pie to order, so it always feels personal and satisfying. If you value a neighborhood atmosphere and a pizza that feels both wholesome and flavorful, Pascalli Kitchen is your go-to on this stretch of Miramar Beach.
10. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Poinciana Boulevard earns loyal fans with its craveable pies and reliable service. It’s a practical option when you want fresh, made-to-order pizza that doesn’t cut corners—no shortcuts here. I’ve often dropped by when the urge for a quick dinner strikes, and I’m always met with a smile and a piping hot box.
The Garden Pizza stands out, stacked with crisp veggies and a zesty sauce that holds its own. Every crust is baked to that sweet spot between soft and golden brown. Marco’s manages to hit the right balance between value and flavor. If you’re after classic comfort and a simple, honest slice, it’s hard to top Marco’s Pizza in Destin.
More Things to Try in Destin, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Destin for families?
Many locals head to Merlin’s Pizza, Fat Clemenza’s, or Pazzo Italiano for family dinners. These spots offer friendly service, relaxed dining, and pizzas everyone can enjoy.
Which pizza places in Destin offer vegan or gluten-free options?
If you have dietary preferences, try Merlin’s Pizza, Fat Clemenza’s, or Grimaldi’s Pizzeria. All these restaurants feature vegan and gluten-free menu items.
Are there any late-night pizza spots in Destin?
Merlin’s Pizza and Fat Clemenza’s keep their ovens going late into the night, perfect for post-beach cravings or late arrivals in town.
Where can I find authentic Italian-style pizza in Destin?
Authentic options include Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano, Fat Clemenza’s, and Pazzo Italiano. These restaurants are known for their classic recipes and high-quality ingredients.
Can I get pizza delivery in Destin?
Absolutely. Major chains like Marco’s Pizza, Domino’s, and Papa John’s deliver throughout Destin, while many local spots like Merlin’s Pizza and Roberto’s Pizzeria also offer delivery services.