Finding the best pizza in Decatur, AL is like exploring a secret menu just waiting to be discovered. Some might say good pizza spots are hiding behind ordinary doors, but locals know the difference between reheated cardboard and a pie worth tracking down. I’ve spent more than a few evenings working through bubbling cheese and crisp crusts across Decatur, never passing up a fresh slice. That hands-on research—think fork in one hand, napkin ready in the other—fuels this guide.
Every pizza fan has a personal favorite—but some names stand out for a reason. Whether you crave tangy sauce, extra cheese, or a specialty topping that keeps you guessing, Decatur’s pizzerias deliver. Let’s dive into the most notable spots around town, the ones where slices disappear quickly and leftovers rarely make it home. If you’re searching for your next pizza night destination or just want to settle the great debate over thin versus thick crust, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Decatur, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Decatur, AL:
- Mellow Mushroom Decatur
- Alfonso’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Pizza Hut
- Pizza Hut
- Domino’s Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza Decatur AL
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Marcos Pizza Rnf
1. Mellow Mushroom Decatur
Mellow Mushroom Decatur brings a distinct twist to classic pizza nights. The first time I visited, the whimsical décor and aroma of baking crust set the scene. The real star, though, is their stone-baked pizza, always served bubbling hot with a crust that’s both chewy and crisp.
Signature pies like the Mighty Meaty (minus any haram toppings) or the Veg Out are proof that they lean into bold flavors. Their lineup is friendly to vegetarian and vegan pizza lovers, which isn’t always a given around town.
Mellow Mushroom stands out for its creative combinations and fresh ingredients paired with a relaxed, welcoming vibe. Try the Kosmic Karma for something a little different; its blend of feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and spinach never disappoints.
2. Alfonso’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Alfonso’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is the type of spot that makes you linger over your meal. On my first visit, the friendly staff and warm scent of baking dough made it easy to feel at home. Here, the pizza keeps things classic without losing personality.
Their Margherita pizza is a must—fresh basil and ripe tomatoes set it apart from the crowd. If you’re in the mood for something heartier, the Veggie pizza brings together crisp vegetables on a golden crust with just the right amount of cheese.
What truly makes Alfonso’s shine is the care in every bite and the menu’s devotion to Italian tradition, while still offering something for everyone. Stop in for lunch or dinner and you’ll see why locals love this place.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Point Mallard Parkway brings the classic chain experience everyone knows, but sometimes that’s exactly what you want. My visits here always end with a box of leftovers and the undeniable comfort of a familiar slice.
The Original Stuffed Crust® pizza is a nostalgic favorite. It arrives piping hot and stretches out those cheese pulls to the delight of everyone at the table. For those who crave variety, the Veggie Lovers pizza is loaded with crisp vegetables and a flavorful tomato sauce.
Pizza Hut excels at consistency and convenience. Whether you dine in, order delivery, or grab carryout, you get the same doughy goodness and prompt service every time. Sometimes, a classic just gets it right.
4. Pizza Hut
This Pizza Hut location on Beltline Road makes pizza nights easy and satisfying. After a long day, I often find myself ordering here because you know every slice will hit the spot. The familiar scent as you walk in is a comfort in itself.
Thin ‘N Crispy® pizza wins for its satisfying crunch, and the bold flavors keep you reaching for another slice. For a group, the Veggie Lovers is always a smart, crowd-friendly choice—vivid with its colorful toppings and cheese.
Service is quick and convenient, whether you plan to eat in or dash out with a piping hot box. If you crave that classic chain taste with a near-perfect crust, this spot has you covered.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Glen Street SW has a knack for satisfying those late-night cravings. After one too many study sessions, I learned the value of their quick delivery and piping-hot pies. You won’t wait long before the doorbell rings with that familiar Domino’s box.
The Handmade Pan pizza stands out for its thick, buttery crust and edge-to-edge cheese. If you prefer something lighter, their New York Style offers a foldable slice with the right balance of sauce and cheese.
Customizable options abound, so you can tailor every pizza to your taste, whether you want extra veggies or a unique blend of sauces. Domino’s brings value and quick service together—a win for busy pizza fans across Decatur.
6. Marco’s Pizza Decatur AL
+1 256-822-1300
See Menu
Marco’s Pizza Decatur AL feels like a slice of Italy at the edge of town. My first visit set the bar high—fresh dough, a balanced sauce, and service that made everything easy. The shop’s pickup window is perfect when you want something quick but aren’t willing to compromise on flavor.
Their signature White Cheezy pizza is a standout, blending a creamy, garlicky base with a satisfying golden crust. If you love classic combinations, the Garden pizza comes loaded with colorful vegetables on a crust that tastes homemade.
Marco’s makes authenticity a daily practice, with dough and sauce crafted in-house. Whether you opt for carryout, drive-thru, or delivery, this spot brings you true Italian comfort, slice after slice.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on 6th Ave has always been my top choice for a dependable slice. There’s something about the first bite—the crust is fresh, and the sauce delivers a bright, tangy flavor every time. Pickup is always quick, making it perfect when dinner needs no extra fuss.
Their Garden Fresh pizza stands out for its mix of crisp peppers, onions, and mushrooms over a soft, chewy base. It’s proof that simple ingredients can create a fantastic pie. If you want a crowd-pleaser, their thin crust option pairs well with a range of fresh veggies.
Papa Johns sets itself apart by focusing on quality. You taste it in every slice, right down to the signature garlic dipping sauce that completes the experience.
8. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on Danville Road is the go-to for anyone craving fast, no-nonsense pizza. I’ve relied on their Hot-N-Ready options more times than I can count—walk in, grab a fresh pie, and you’re out the door in minutes. It’s about as convenient as it gets without sacrificing taste.
The ExtraMostBestest cheese pizza is the standout, loaded with gooey mozzarella and a buttery, golden crust. It’s a crowd favorite and holds up well for group meals or a quick solo dinner.
Little Caesars separates itself with value and consistency. Their prices are tough to beat, but they always use real cheese and make dough daily. It’s pizza that’s accessible any day of the week without missing the mark on quality.
9. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza on 6th Ave is proof that you don’t need a fancy storefront to serve up satisfying pizza. Many of my favorite slices have come from their oven, often as a quick stop during a busy day. It’s the kind of spot where you know what you’re getting every time—hot, solid pizza that doesn’t overcomplicate things.
Their Build-Your-Own pizza is the way to go. You pick the toppings and they pile them on a crisp crust, giving you control without the fuss. For something classic, their Veggie pizza brings together fresh peppers, onions, and tomatoes in the right balance.
Hunt Brothers stands out for its convenience and flexibility. Grab a slice or a whole pie on the go—perfect for those who value speed but still want a filling, tasty meal.
10. Marcos Pizza Rnf
Marcos Pizza Rnf on Beltline Road feels like one of Decatur’s best-kept secrets. When I first stumbled into this location, I was surprised by how quickly they turn around a flavorful, piping-hot pie. It has become a trusted spot for days when my cravings for a fresh slice hit hard.
The Deluxe pizza is always a winner here, with a generous layer of vibrant vegetables that don’t skimp on taste or freshness. If you’re after a lighter option, their veggie pizza comes packed with crisp toppings and just the right amount of cheese.
What sets Marcos Pizza Rnf apart is consistency and friendly service. Every order feels made-to-order and their dough boasts that airy, homemade feel. It’s an easy pick if you want solid pizza without the wait.
More Things to Try in Decatur, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in Decatur, AL, offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Many top spots such as Mellow Mushroom, Alfonso’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, and Marco’s Pizza have dedicated vegetarian pizzas and vegan-friendly choices. It’s always best to check menus for the latest options.
Who delivers pizza late at night in Decatur?
Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut usually offer late-night delivery, with hours varying by location. Ordering via their app or website is quick and reliable.
Where can I get good takeout or curbside pickup?
Almost all major chains in Decatur, including Little Caesars, Marco’s Pizza, and Hunt Brothers, provide carryout and curbside pickup. Mellow Mushroom even has online ordering for added convenience.
Which pizza places have gluten-free crusts?
Mellow Mushroom and Papa Murphy’s are great picks for gluten-free crusts. Always double-check for preparation practices if you have concerns about cross-contamination.
What’s the most popular pizza style in Decatur?
Classic hand-tossed and pan pizzas are favorites across town. But you’ll also find New York style, thin crust, and stuffed crust featured at many locations―enough variety to suit every preference.