Looking for the best pizza in Coralville, IA? You’re in good company. I still remember my first slice in this town—thin crust, cheese that stretched with every bite, and a sauce with that little hint of mystery. It was nothing fancy, just perfect. Since then, I’ve sampled my way across Coralville, and let’s just say I know where to go when the craving strikes.
This guide is built from real taste tests, honest opinions, and a genuine love for good pizza. Whether you lean classic, get creative with toppings, or need your slice with a side of nostalgia, you’ll find something here to tempt you. Each spot on this list offers its own reason to drop by. Now, let’s discover which kitchens are tossing up the true favorites in Coralville.
1. Backpocket Brewery
Tucked along Quarry Road, Backpocket Brewery offers a lively spot for lunch or dinner, especially if you love pairing pizza with craft drinks. The outdoor seating is a nice touch, letting you enjoy Coralville’s summer evenings with a slice in hand.
One visit left me keen on their wood-fired pizza. The crust had the right blend of crisp and chew, and the flavors were balanced—never too many toppings to distract from the essentials.
Try the Margherita or the Brewer’s Special. Each pie feels tuned to complement their brewed-in-house drinks, balancing freshness with richness. Whether you come with friends or simply for a quick takeout, you’ll find the quality and vibe are tough to match.
2. Marquee Pizzeria
Marquee Pizzeria sits in the Iowa River Landing, but it could be the star of any food scene. When I walked in for dinner, I was greeted by the cozy, bustling energy you expect at a true neighborhood spot. Friends gather here, sharing laughter over wood-fired slices and a chat with the folks behind the bar.
The pizzas are the main event, crisped to perfection in a roaring oven that brings just the right char. Each bite has that balanced chew, with toppings that honor the classics but never shy away from the bold.
The Marquee Margherita is a testament to simplicity, while the Funghi balances earthiness and fresh basil beautifully. Every pie reflects their dedication to quality and their love for creating a welcoming gathering place.
3. Happy Joe’s Pizza and Ice Cream
Happy Joe’s Pizza and Ice Cream combines the comfort of a family pizzeria with a nostalgic dash of dessert-shop fun. My last visit was sparked by a craving for something simple—a place to enjoy pizza that reminds you of good times, birthdays, and celebrations.
The menu is centered on old-school pies topped generously, built for sharing. Their Taco Joe pizza gets top marks, loaded with plenty of fresh veggies and a playful scattering of crushed chips for texture.
If you want a break from the usual routine, their lineup of creative, hearty pizzas rarely disappoints. Round out your meal with a quick scoop of ice cream for a sweet finish and you’re set for an easygoing night.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on 2nd Street keeps things reliable, no matter the craving. Sometimes you want comfort—something familiar and satisfying, which is exactly why I stopped in last time. There’s something about that unmistakable red roof and the scent of baking dough that evokes classic pizza night memories.
The Original Stuffed Crust is hard to beat if you’re the type who saves the edges for last. There’s a doughy, golden ring with just enough cheesy pull. Or go for the Veggie Lover’s Pizza for classic flavors and plenty of crunch.
Perfect for carryout or delivery when plans change, Pizza Hut still delivers the pizzas you remember, made for sharing with family or friends around a busy table.
5. Tavern Blue
Tavern Blue has found a clever way to blend breezy lake house vibes with serious pizza-making. Each visit feels relaxed yet upbeat. Last time, I spent an easy afternoon here with friends, squeezed into a booth, sampling slices over a game of shuffleboard.
What separates them is the brick oven, which turns out pizza with a crisp crust and smoky undertone that lingers in all the right ways. Their classic cheese offers purity done well, while the veggie pizza piles on roasted peppers, onions, and mushrooms for extra flavor.
Order the Wood-Fired Veggie if you want the best of that oven’s charm. Tavern Blue is built for lingering, making it perfect for those who like their pizza with fun and games on the side.
6. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza has built its name around delivering consistency. My last order arrived piping hot, dough still soft and sauce packed with a burst of tomato flavor. It’s the familiar taste you can count on, no matter how hectic the day gets.
The focus here is on fresh ingredients and a crust with just the right chew. Every pie is built to satisfy cravings without overcomplicating things. The slices stay firm and the flavors never clash.
Go for the Garden Fresh if you like your pizza with heaps of vegetables and that signature blend of cheese. It’s an easy favorite for group orders, keeping every bite simple, fresh, and reliable.
7. Iowa Athletic Club
Iowa Athletic Club brings together the spirit of game day with food that goes well beyond typical bar fare. On my last visit, the buzz of fans and sight of scratch-made pizzas being shuttled around added to the sense of energy.
Each pizza starts with dough made daily and toppings that hit the sweet spot between hearty and fresh. The crust is soft yet holds up well, perfect for grabbing another slice mid-game.
The Veggie Supreme is a must if you enjoy your pizza loaded with flavor and color. Their pies have a welcoming, crowd-pleasing charm that makes every visit feel like a celebration, whether you’re in for a big match or a low-key dinner with friends.
8. Barrel House
+1 319-626-2550
Barrel House makes a strong case for your next Coralville hangout, offering not just great pizza but also a lively, easy-going atmosphere. My last visit coincided with a game night, which meant big screens and even bigger flavors.
What catches the eye here is their wide-ranging pizza menu, each one thin, nicely browned, and loaded with toppings. The Garden Pizza hits all the right notes for anyone looking for a veggie-forward option, boasting fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms atop a golden crust.
Barrel House manages to treat every dish like it’s game day food, but with a twist—fresh, made-to-order, and crowd-friendly. This is a place that invites you to linger, snack, and make the most of every meal.
9. Pizza Hut Express
See Menu
Pizza Hut Express at Coral Ridge Avenue inside Target is convenience in pizza form. On a recent shopping trip, I grabbed a quick slice—proof that quality and speed can go hand in hand. This spot is all about getting classic flavors into your hands fast.
Don’t expect a full menu, but what’s here hits the mark for traditional cravings. The Cheese Personal Pan Pizza always comes out hot, with that signature golden crust and plenty of gooey cheese.
Perfect for an on-the-go lunch or a snack break between errands, Pizza Hut Express keeps things simple. It’s a reliable stop when you want your pizza fix without missing a beat in your day.
10. Sbarro
See Menu
Sbarro brings a hint of New York to Coralville, thanks to its classic slices and no-fuss approach. Whenever I stop at the mall for a bite, the sight of those massive pizzas behind the glass always wins me over. There’s an instant comfort in knowing a fresh, hot slice is just a quick line away.
What stands out is the generous portion size and soft, chewy crust. Every Cheese Slice is baked to golden perfection, offering that classic foldable experience you expect from a New York-style pizza.
For a little more flavor, try the Veggie Pizza. It’s loaded with fresh toppings and makes for a quick, satisfying lunch between shopping or errands. Sbarro keeps pizza lovers fueled and ready for whatever comes next.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in Coralville offer vegetarian options?
Most local spots, including Backpocket Brewery, Marquee Pizzeria, and Barrel House, offer hearty vegetarian pizzas topped with a variety of fresh veggies.
Are there any pizzerias in Coralville with outdoor seating?
Yes, you’ll find outdoor seating at places like Backpocket Brewery and Tavern Blue—perfect for enjoying pizza with a fresh breeze.
Which Coralville pizza restaurants provide takeout or delivery?
Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, and Sbarro all provide takeout and delivery. Many local spots also offer these services as a convenience.
Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Coralville?
Marquee Pizzeria and Tavern Blue both specialize in wood-fired, brick oven pizzas that offer crisp, flavorful crusts.