Finding great pizza in Coral Gables is almost a sport. There’s something about the blend of classic charm and contemporary flair in this city that makes every slice a little more memorable. I’ve wandered down Miracle Mile on a warm afternoon, trying everything from classic Margheritas to bold, inventive pies topped with fresh basil that tasted like it was grown behind the shop. The search for the best crust and the most perfect cheese pull isn’t just about the food—it’s about discovering the neighborhood’s character one bite at a time.
If you’re wondering where to start, you’re in seasoned hands. I’ve tasted my way through Coral Gables’ pizza scene, focusing only on spots that bring serious flavor and keep things above board. Whether you prefer something artisanal or crave a simple classic, you’ll find the choices here both tempting and reliable. Ready to glimpse the city through its best slices? Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best pizza in Coral Gables, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Coral Gables, FL:
- CRAFT Coral Gables
- Pummarola Coral Gables
- P.Pole Pizza Coral Gables
- Terre Del Sapore
- Piccola Italia
- Miami’s Best Pizza
- Pauloluigi Italian Restaurant
- Don Favio’s Pizza Gourmet
- Mona Lisa Pizza & Subs
- Pizza Deli & Company
1. CRAFT Coral Gables
CRAFT Coral Gables does pizza the right way—fresh, Neapolitan-style, and with a crisp, wood-fired touch. The moment you step onto Giralda Avenue, the aroma alone pulls you in. On my first visit, the buzz of families and friends gathered around their rustic tables set a welcoming mood. This is a place where the crust is slightly charred, chewy inside, and never overwhelmed by toppings.
Their Margherita pizza shines with robust tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, both classic and unforgettable. For something a little punchier, try the Truffle Mushroom, which packs earthy flavors without feeling heavy. CRAFT impresses not just with authenticity, but also with its range of vegetarian and gluten-free pies, so there’s something for everyone. Quality and comfort meet here—a rare treat in Coral Gables.
2. Pummarola Coral Gables
Pummarola Coral Gables takes pride in its authentic Neapolitan roots. Step inside and you’ll spot the custom-built, Italian-imported oven that’s the real star. My first bite of their pizza brought back memories of a summer trip to Naples—crisp edges, delicate char, and a soft, stretchy center. Anyone with a love of Italian food will appreciate the focus on simple, high-quality ingredients.
The Diavola pizza is one to try. It melds savory sauce with a hit of spice, all balanced by creamy mozzarella. The Bufalina offers a gentler but no less memorable flavor for those who prefer subtlety over heat. With vegan and vegetarian choices, Pummarola caters to nearly every palate. This spot is a must for anyone seeking genuine pizza artistry in Coral Gables.
3. P.Pole Pizza Coral Gables
P.Pole Pizza Coral Gables is the place for anyone who prefers pizza their way. Walk in, and the energy is always high, with people swapping ideas for wild topping combinations. My favorite visit involved a group of friends, each creating their own pie—no arguments over toppings, just pure satisfaction.
Customization is king here. Pick a dough, load on the sauces, and choose from a generous range of vegetables and cheeses. The beauty lies in endless options with a single flat price, making even adventurous tries feel worry-free. I’d suggest starting with their classic tomato sauce base and adding a mix of fresh veggies. That way, you capture P.Pole’s spirit: inventive, fun, and always flavorful.
4. Terre Del Sapore
At Terre Del Sapore, the love for real Italian fare is unmistakable. Set right on Giralda Avenue, this charming spot delivers the kind of old-world dining experience that’s tough to find even in Miami. My first meal here lingered in my memory—a testament to fresh ingredients and honest flavors.
The highlight is their wood-fired pizza, cooked to the perfect texture with just the right amount of char on a tender crust. Their Funghi pizza—layered with earthy mushrooms and subtle cheese—is a standout. You’ll also sense care in every part of the meal, from the dough to the sauce. For anyone chasing true Italian taste in Coral Gables, Terre Del Sapore remains unmatched.
5. Piccola Italia
Piccola Italia is all about warmth and authenticity. Nestled on Coral Way, this cozy spot feels like stepping into an Italian family’s dining room. During my visits, the scent of baking dough and fresh herbs made it hard to think about anything but the next bite. It’s a gathering place where regulars greet each other and newcomers feel right at home.
The star here is their Vegetarian Pizza—topped with a medley of fresh vegetables, a crisp base, and cheese that’s rich without being overwhelming. For those who love classics, the Margherita balances tangy tomato and lush mozzarella. Piccola Italia shines in the way each pizza is crafted to order, ensuring every crust is golden and each ingredient at its peak.
6. Miami’s Best Pizza
Miami’s Best Pizza has a reputation that stretches beyond Coral Gables. Their classic slices have seen generations of UM students gather after late-night study sessions or big games. I first stopped in after a long walk on Ponce de Leon, and the energy felt both lively and laid-back—a neighborhood fixture reliving its legacy in every pie.
The Veggie pizza is always reliable, with a generous helping of fresh toppings and a crunchy crust. For pure comfort, the Cheese pizza is a nostalgic throwback that lets the sauce and dough shine. Every slice here is hand-made with daily-prepared ingredients, which means you get a taste of tradition in every bite. This is the go-to for reliable, honest pizza in the city.
7. Pauloluigi Italian Restaurant
Pauloluigi Italian Restaurant is tucked away on Bird Ave, but once you find it, you’ll want to come back. The atmosphere invites you to linger—think classic trattoria vibes with friendly staff who remember your favorite order. On my visit, it felt like a slice of old Coral Gables, where conversation flows as easily as the food.
Their Four Cheese Pizza is a creamy, decadent treat that showcases richness without heaviness. If you like cleaner flavors, the Margherita is crisp and aromatic, emphasizing fresh basil and tangy sauce. Each pizza comes out hot and perfectly charred, never skimpy on toppings. Pauloluigi focuses on robust flavors and a welcoming spirit, setting it apart in a city full of choices.
8. Don Favio’s Pizza Gourmet
Don Favio’s Pizza Gourmet is all about big flavors and easygoing vibes right on Miracle Mile. From my spot near the window, I watched the staff toss dough with practiced hands and could tell every pie is given real attention. Their creative take on classic recipes draws both locals and curious newcomers.
The Veggie Pizza is a fresh standout, packed with crisp vegetables on a thin, golden crust. The White Pizza, loaded with mozzarella and herbs, offers a satisfying change from tradition. Slices here are balanced and never greasy, making repeat visits tempting. At Don Favio’s, expect quality and some creative twists, all without losing the warmth of a proper pizza joint.
9. Mona Lisa Pizza & Subs
Mona Lisa Pizza & Subs feels like a neighborhood secret, just off SW 8th Street. With its low-key storefront, it’s easy to miss—but inside you’ll find loyal regulars and a comforting, old-school vibe. My first time there, I was greeted like a familiar face, with plenty of chat about the best toppings and stories from the owner’s family recipes.
The Vegetarian Pizza here is a classic: chunky bell peppers, mushrooms, olives, and a crust that manages to be both crisp and pillowy. Their Cheese Pizza is also noteworthy, leaning on a tangy sauce and the perfect cheese-to-crust balance. Mona Lisa stands out for its generous portions, commitment to quality, and a welcoming approach that feels more like joining a family meal than grabbing a typical pizza.
10. Pizza Deli & Company
+1 786-717-5848
Pizza Deli & Company has mastered the art of keeping things simple and satisfying. Located on SW 57th Ave, this spot delivers unpretentious, high-quality pies perfect for a casual lunch or a cozy dinner. My first stop was on a whim, but the fresh aromas and genuinely friendly staff convinced me it was more than just a quick pizza fix.
Their Spinach and Mushroom Pizza is a revelation—plenty of fresh greens with a hit of garlic and a perfectly crisp crust. For something classic, the Cheese Pizza is a safe bet, allowing their homemade sauce and dough to really shine. Pizza Deli & Company’s strong suit is consistency and the honest flavors that keep regulars coming back for more.
More Things to Try in Coral Gables, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Coral Gables?
Neapolitan-style pizza leads the pack here. Expect thin, soft crusts topped with high-quality ingredients and cooked in wood-fired ovens at many popular spots.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options available?
Absolutely. Most Coral Gables pizza restaurants offer vegetarian and often vegan choices, with fresh vegetables and plant-based cheeses clearly marked on the menu.
Which Coral Gables pizza shops offer gluten-free options?
Plenty do, including CRAFT and Pummarola, which both have gluten-free pizza bases alongside their regular offerings.
Can I find late-night pizza in Coral Gables?
Yes, several places such as Miami’s Best Pizza and Don Favio’s stay open late, making it easy to grab a slice well after dinner hours.
Is delivery or takeout available at Coral Gables pizza restaurants?
Most pizza spots here provide delivery and takeout for convenience. Several also offer easy online ordering or even curbside pickup.
Where can I host a pizza party or group event?
Many of the local pizzerias are great for groups and families. CRAFT and Pummarola, for example, regularly host gatherings and even pizza-making classes for a fun, hands-on experience.