Columbus, OH thrives on personality, and so does its pizza. Dig into the city’s pie scene, and you’ll discover more than simple cheese and sauce. Each slice tells a story—tangy sauces, chewy crusts, and toppings that never take themselves too seriously. Whether I’ve snuck away for pepperoni at midnight or argued the merits of thin versus deep dish with friends at a local haunt, I’ve tasted a lot—and learned what earns true loyalty.
If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Columbus, you’ve landed in the right place. From family-run icons that value tradition to creative spots spinning out bold new flavors, this list curates the pies you’ll want to brag about later. Pizza here is a ritual, not just a meal, and I’m about to let you in on the favorites locals keep coming back to. Hungry? Let’s chart your course through the heart of Columbus, one slice at a time.
Where to find the best pizza in Columbus, OH
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Columbus, OH:
- Forno Kitchen + Bar
- Rubino’s Pizza
- Adriatico’s New York Style
- Harvest Kitchen and Bar
- Villa Nova Ristorante
- Figlio
- Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza
- Dewey’s Pizza – Grandview
- Mikey’s Late Night Slice
- Pies & Pints
1. Forno Kitchen + Bar
Forno Kitchen + Bar feels like the Columbus spot you discover once and return to again and again. The modern, candle-lit setting sets the mood, but it’s the stone-fired pizzas that keep memories simmering.
My last visit, the crackle of the oven delivered a Margherita pizza that walked the line between rustic and refined—bubbling mozzarella, sweet tomato, and a crust that’s crisp yet tender. Those who crave adventure should order the Prosciutto & Arugula pizza; the peppery greens and silky meat elevate every bite.
Vegetarian or gluten-free? Forno’s flexible menu offers outstanding options. Order with confidence, knowing this kitchen prizes fresh flavor and easygoing charm, no matter your diet. This is where style and substance finally share a table.
2. Rubino’s Pizza
Step inside Rubino’s Pizza, and you’re stepping into Columbus history. This is classic, old-school pizza, where the formica tables and checkerboard floors have seen more families than most living rooms. I still remember sharing a giant square-cut cheese pizza here, the crust thin as a cracker and the cheese perfectly golden.
Their pizza stands out for its balance—soft, sweet sauce, not-too-thick cheese, and a crisp crust that never gets soggy. Simplicity truly wins at Rubino’s. Order the cheese or veggie pizza for a nostalgic experience, or try a mushroom pie if you love earthy flavor in every bite.
With table service and a welcoming atmosphere, Rubino’s is the spot where lifelong pizza memories are made—one square slice at a time.
3. Adriatico’s New York Style
Adriatico’s New York Style is where Columbus meets the spirit of the Big Apple. Slices here are substantial—thin enough to fold, yet loaded with cheesy pull and a firm crust. Late nights on campus have ended with a hot, giant slice in one hand and a story worth retelling in the other.
What sets Adriatico’s apart? Generous toppings, hearty portions, and a sauce that balances sweet and savory. The signature Buckeye Pie is a local favorite, stacked with fresh veggies and gooey cheese, perfect for sharing with friends (or not, if you’re hungry).
Vegetarian-friendly and always lively, this spot delivers real New York flavor with true Columbus heart. Don’t skip their garlic bread—it’s in a league of its own.
4. Harvest Kitchen and Bar
Harvest Kitchen and Bar is where you go when you want to taste something fresh, local, and a little bit daring. Here, every pizza starts with thoughtfully sourced ingredients and ends up as a flavor-packed work of art. I once sat near their open kitchen and could smell the basil even before my order hit the table.
The Spicy Yuma pizza is not to be missed. It brings together roasted peppers and house-made crust in a way that skips the ordinary and hits all the right notes. Vegetarians and vegans will also feel at home here, with plenty of creative options tailored just for them.
With gluten-free crusts and a relaxed vibe, Harvest is proof that great pizza can taste as wholesome as it feels.
5. Villa Nova Ristorante
Villa Nova Ristorante is one of those places where tradition rules, but the food never feels stuck in the past. This is the classic red sauce Italian spot where pizza feels like family. The first time I visited, the warm welcome rivaled the aroma of baking crust and melting cheese.
The pizza here comes in hearty, comforting squares loaded with sweet tomato sauce and stretchy mozzarella. The veggie pizza is a highlight—generous with fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions, all layered on a golden, sturdy crust.
Whether you’re dining in their cozy dining room or grabbing takeout for a quiet night at home, Villa Nova’s pies remind you that sometimes the old ways are still the best.
6. Figlio
Walking into Figlio always feels like an invitation to slow down and savor. This spot puts real care into every pie, blending creative touches with classic roots. On my last visit, I watched the kitchen turn ordinary toppings into something quietly memorable.
The Thai Chicken pizza is a local legend for good reason. It combines house-made peanut sauce, fresh cilantro, and just the right balance of sweet and savory. Prefer something simple? The Margherita never disappoints, offering bright tomato and fresh basil on a chewy, golden crust.
With gluten-free options and a laid-back atmosphere, Figlio is perfect for relaxed dinners where you want your pizza to spark a conversation.
7. Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza
Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza is a late-night favorite in Columbus for a reason. This is the place where crust becomes an obsession. You get three choices—Thin, Smokin’ Joe’s, or Garlic Butter Crust. I still remember the first time I tried their garlic butter crust; it could make any topping shine.
The specialty is building your own pizza from scratch, but don’t overlook their classics like the Veggie Lovers. Packed with colorful, fresh vegetables, it’s hearty and satisfying at any hour.
The vibe is laid-back and a little quirky, making it ideal for kicking back after a long day or livening up a casual dinner with friends. Don’t be surprised if you start craving that crust out of the blue.
8. Dewey’s Pizza – Grandview
Dewey’s Pizza – Grandview is where gourmet never feels fussy and every meal turns into a celebration. From the colorful, open kitchen to the custom playlists, the vibe is as lively as the pizzas. My best meal there was a family gathering, where the staff’s warmth matched the bubbly cheese on each pie.
Try the Green Lantern pizza if you want bold flavor. Loaded with fresh spinach, bell peppers, and tangy goat cheese, every bite is a bright surprise. The Southwest BBQ Chicken pizza wins for those craving a bit of heat and smoke.
Vegetarian options and creative salads round out the menu, making Dewey’s a crowd-pleaser for groups with mixed tastes. Grab a local craft beer and enjoy the show.
9. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Mikey’s Late Night Slice is where cravings and nightlife meet in the heart of Columbus. The place is legendary for giant slices served until the early hours, perfect for refueling after concerts or comedy shows. My favorite memory? Grabbing a greasy, delicious cheese slice with friends, laughing under neon lights while the city hummed outside.
Their pizza is classic, with a chewy crust and a bold, herby sauce. If you like heat, don’t miss their signature spicy sauce on the side—it packs a real punch. Veggie options are always on hand, and the size means you never leave hungry.
Casual, quick, and impossible to forget, Mikey’s proves that some of Columbus’s best pizza is served by the slice.
10. Pies & Pints
Pies & Pints makes pizza an adventure, pairing inventive pies with a rotating cast of craft beers. It’s one of those places where the menu rewards curiosity; a single lunch there turned my friends and me into instant fans. The staff is never shy with recommendations, helping you find something out of the ordinary.
Try the Mushroom Garlic pizza for a savory, earthy kick or go for the seasonal specials, which always push the boundaries of flavor. Gluten-free and vegan options are expertly built, so no one misses out.
Pies & Pints stands out for making pizza the main attraction, whether you’re winding down after shopping or fueling up for a game. Come thirsty—and arrive hungry.
More Things to Try in Columbus, OH
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What style of pizza is Columbus known for?
Columbus boasts its own signature style—round, thin-crust pies cut into square slices. It’s crisp, loaded with toppings, and easy to share with friends.
Q: Are there good options for vegetarians or vegans?
Absolutely. Many Columbus pizzerias offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas, with places like Harvest and Pies & Pints excelling in plant-based creativity.
Q: Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Columbus?
You’ll find gluten-free crusts at spots like Figlio, Dewey’s, and Pies & Pints, so no one has to skip pizza night.
Q: Which pizzeria delivers late in Columbus?
Mikey’s Late Night Slice and Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza are local favorites for a late-night slice delivered right to your door.
Q: What’s the best pizza place for families?
Rubino’s Pizza and Villa Nova Ristorante offer classic pies and welcoming spaces perfect for kids and parents alike.
Q: Can I find New York or Chicago style pizza in Columbus?
Yes. For New York style, check out Adriatico’s. For deep-dish, Giordano’s is the go-to spot.