Every town has its own pizza personality. Columbus, Mississippi is no exception. Whether you’re craving thin crust, piled toppings, or that perfect golden edge of bubbling cheese, there’s no shortage of options that have earned local loyalty. Some spots are tucked inside familiar chains, others are proud hometown favorites with a flair of their own. Finding the best pizza in Columbus isn’t just about taste—it’s about knowing where tradition meets flavor.
I’ve eaten my way through Columbus over a few visits, each slice revealing a new layer of what makes this town’s pizza scene quietly excellent. From bold takes on classic pepperoni to melt-in-your-mouth veggie pies, the variety here doesn’t try to be trendy—it just delivers. This guide dives deep into the most reliable, crowd-approved pizza places in Columbus, skipping exaggeration and empty hype. If you’ve ever wondered where locals go when they want pizza done right, you’re about to find out.
Where to find the best pizza in Columbus, MS
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Columbus, MS:
- Lost Pizza Co.
- CJ’s Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Little Caesars
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Pizza Hut
- Hot Stuff Pizza
- Godfather’s Pizza Express
- Little Caesars Pizza
1. Lost Pizza Co.
Located at 2009 Highway 45 N, Lost Pizza Co. has become a go-to spot for pizza lovers in Columbus. Their focus on quality ingredients and innovative toppings makes every pie memorable. During my visits, I was impressed by how fresh the ingredients tasted, a quality that makes their pizza stand out locally.
The menu offers a variety of options, perfect for lunch or dinner. Their signature pizzas, like the BBQ Chicken or Veggie Delight, showcase their bold flavors and creative spirit. Lost Pizza Co. combines classic techniques with a modern twist, ensuring each slice reflects both quality and genuine care. It’s a place where pizza is crafted with passion and made to satisfy.
2. CJ’s Pizza
Situated at 507 18th Ave N Suite 2, CJ’s Pizza offers more than just pizza — it delivers a full dining experience. During my visit, I appreciated how their commitment to using the freshest ingredients shines through in every bite. Their flavorful pizzas and fresh salads make every meal feel special.
What truly sets CJ’s apart is their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. I recommend trying their Classic Pepperoni Pizza or the Veggie Supreme, both showcasing their skill in balancing flavors. With friendly table service and options for takeout, CJ’s Pizza strikes the perfect balance between quality and convenience.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
Located at 2321l Highway 45 N, Papa Johns Pizza in Columbus, MS, is known for its commitment to using better ingredients. During my visit, I was impressed by the fresh, flavorful toppings and the quality of their signature sauce. Their dough is clearly made from scratch, giving each pizza a satisfying crispness and chew.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their consistency and focus on quality. I recommend trying their Original Pepperoni Pizza or the Create Your Own option, which allows you to customize to your heart’s content. Whether ordering delivery or picking up, Papa Johns delivers a dependable, tasty slice of Columbus’s finest.
4. Little Caesars
Located at 929 Alabama St, Little Caesars in Columbus, MS, offers a quick and satisfying pizza experience. I’ve often enjoyed their Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni Pizza, which is perfect for those spontaneous cravings. The convenience and affordability make it a favorite for many locals.
Little Caesars stands out with its focus on providing good quality at a fast pace. Their Classic Cheese Pizza and Deep! Deep! Dish options highlight their ability to satisfy diverse tastes. Whether for lunch or dinner, you can count on Little Caesars for a straightforward, tasty slice that’s always consistent in flavor.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Situated at 1510 Main Street, Domino’s in Columbus, MS, is known for delivering consistently tasty pizza with a variety of crust styles. During my visits, I’ve enjoyed their New York Style Thin Crust for its crisp, foldable quality. Fast, friendly service makes it an easy choice for lunch or dinner.
What truly makes Domino’s stand out is their commitment to taste and value. Their Cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust offers an indulgent twist, while their fun deals make it feasible to order more without breaking the bank. Whether craving classic pizza or other favorites like wings or pasta, Domino’s consistently provides satisfying options.
6. Pizza Hut
Located at 1801 US Hwy. 45 in Columbus, MS, Pizza Hut is renowned for its classic approach to pizza. I’ve enjoyed their Original Stuffed Crust pizza, which delivers a satisfying blend of gooey cheese and crisp crust. The inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for a relaxed meal with family or friends.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is its consistent quality and variety. Their Meat Lovers® pizza is a hearty choice, while their signature wings and pasta add variety to the menu. Whether ordering for pickup or delivery, Pizza Hut provides reliable, flavorful options that symbolize familiar comfort.
7. Pizza Hut
If you’re near 224 Idlewild Rd in Columbus, this Pizza Hut location is worth a stop. On a quiet afternoon, I grabbed a slice of their Original Stuffed Crust, and the crispy edge with melted cheese sealed the deal—simple, comforting, and distinctly Pizza Hut.
This branch offers a reliable experience, with pizzas made consistently well. Their Meat Lovers® pizza is a solid choice if you want something satisfying. You’ll also find a variety of crusts, like thin ‘n crispy or hand tossed, which help customize your meal.
For something quick, carryout or curbside pickup is easy to use. If you’re ordering for a group, pair your pizza with breadsticks and veggie pasta for a balanced mix. It’s pizza done the classic way.
8. Hot Stuff Pizza
Located at 2021 Military Rd in Columbus, MS, Hot Stuff Pizza is a local favorite for flavorful, affordable pizza. During my visit, I enjoyed their Classic Pepperoni Pizza, which had a deliciously crispy crust and perfectly balanced toppings, showcasing their commitment to quality.
What truly makes Hot Stuff Pizza stand out is its relaxed atmosphere and dedication to satisfying local tastes. Their Cheese Lover’s Special is a must-try, with gooey cheese and rich sauce that exemplify their style. With friendly service and a focus on fresh ingredients, it’s a perfect spot for a casual meal.
If you’re craving hearty pizza with a hometown feel, Hot Stuff delivers a memorable slice of Columbus’s pizza scene.
9. Godfather’s Pizza Express
Located at 525 Tuscaloosa Rd in Columbus, MS, Godfather’s Pizza Express delivers a comforting slice of classic pizza. During my visit, I enjoyed their BBQ Chicken Pizza, which featured tender chicken, smoky sauce, and melty cheese—showing their ability to blend flavors skillfully.
What sets Godfather’s apart is their focus on quality ingredients and satisfying portions. Their Meat Lover’s Pizza offers a hearty, fulfilling option, perfect for sharing. The quick service and inviting atmosphere make it an excellent choice for a casual meal with friends or family.
For those craving traditional pizza with a hint of boldness, Godfather’s Pizza Express provides a reliable, flavorful experience that keeps locals coming back.
10. Little Caesars Pizza
At 929 Alabama St in Columbus, MS, Little Caesars offers a quick, reliable pizza option for busy families. I often order their Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni for its crisp crust and generous toppings, making it a perfect solution for impromptu gatherings or weeknight dinners.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their emphasis on quality ingredients and value. Their signature ExtraMostBestest Pepperoni Pizza combines affordability with flavor, reflecting their commitment to delivering good pizza at a great price. Convenient online ordering and contactless pickup make it even easier to satisfy craving.
For a no-fuss but tasty meal, Little Caesars provides familiar, satisfying options rooted in classic pizza tradition.
More Things to Try in Columbus, MS
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Columbus, MS?
Lost Pizza Co., CJ’s Pizza, Papa Johns, Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, Domino’s, and Godfather’s Pizza Express are among the most visited spots. Each offers different styles—from hand-tossed classics to deep-dish specialties.
Which pizzerias offer vegetarian options?
Most major chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns offer vegetarian pizzas. Local spots such as Lost Pizza Co. may also have options like veggie-loaded pizzas or cheese-focused pies. Just double-check the menu to make sure toppings align with your preferences.
Are there any halal-certified pizza restaurants in Columbus, MS?
Halal options are limited. It’s best to check directly with the restaurant regarding ingredient sourcing. Chains may offer customization, but halal certification isn’t widely advertised.
Do any pizza places offer gluten-free crusts?
Yes. Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut provide gluten-free crust options, though availability may vary by location. Local places may also accommodate dietary restrictions upon request.
Where can I find affordable pizza deals in Columbus?
Chains like Little Caesars, Pizza Pro, and Hunt Brothers Pizza are known for budget-friendly pizzas, especially their value combos and Hot-N-Ready selections. Discounts are often available via mobile apps or online orders.
Is dine-in available or is it mostly takeout/delivery?
Dine-in is offered at places like CJ’s Pizza, Lost Pizza Co., and Pizza Hut Express, while chains such as Papa Johns and Domino’s focus more on delivery and carryout.
Can I order online from pizza places in Columbus, MS?
Yes. Domino’s, Papa Johns, Little Caesars, and Pizza Hut all support online ordering and mobile apps for streamlined service. Local pizzerias may also have websites or accept phone orders.
Which pizza spot is best for families with kids?
Pizza Hut, CJ’s Pizza, and Lost Pizza Co. offer family-friendly seating and menus suited for younger guests. Simple choices and relaxed environments make them easy picks for group outings.
Are there any locally owned pizza places worth trying?
Yes. CJ’s Pizza and Lost Pizza Co. are local favorites with distinct flavors and personalized service. They often experiment with toppings and dough styles not found at the big chains.
Do any pizza places offer late-night service?
Domino’s and Pizza Pro tend to stay open later than other spots. Check store hours online to see which locations fit your schedule, especially on weekends.