When it comes to food, few things evoke as much passion as pizza. In Columbia, MO, a thriving college town, the quest for the perfect slice is serious business. With a diverse range of pizzerias, each boasting unique flavors and styles, pizza lovers are in for a treat. Whether you crave classic cheese, innovative toppings, or a satisfying crust, the options are endless.
Many nights spent with friends, sharing laughter over a hot pie, have made me appreciate the local scene. From cozy family spots to bustling places packed with college students, every slice tells its own story. This guide explores the best spots for pizza in Columbia, ensuring you can find your next favorite pizza place. Let’s dive into the savory world of dough, cheese, and delicious toppings.
Where to find the best pizza in Columbia, MO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Columbia, MO:
- Shakespeare’s Pizza
- G & D Pizzaria
- Shakespeare’s Pizza South
- Tony’s Pizza Palace
- Shakespeare’s Pizza West
- Gumby’s Pizza
- Your Pie
- Pizza Tree
- Arris’ Pizza
- MOD Pizza
1. Shakespeare’s Pizza
Shakespeare’s Pizza in Columbia, MO, is a local favorite known for its vibrant atmosphere and delicious, handcrafted pizzas. Located at 225 S 9th St, this iconic spot draws both locals and visitors with its promise of perfectly cooked, round pizzas and friendly service. The pizzeria’s playful charm is encapsulated in its motto: “where the pizzas are round, the pepperonis are all right-side-up.”
My visit to Shakespeare’s Pizza was unforgettable. The lively chatter, the clinking of pint glasses in harmonious C-sharp, and the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza created an inviting ambiance. Their commitment to quality and freshness is evident in every bite.
For a true taste of Columbia, try their Vegetarian Pizza, loaded with fresh, colorful veggies. For gluten-free diners, there are excellent options that maintain the same great taste.
2. G & D Pizzaria
G & D Pizzaria is a hidden gem located at 2101 W Broadway in Columbia’s Crossroads West Shopping Center. Known for its warm atmosphere and delicious pizzas, this spot has become a local favorite. The friendly staff and welcoming vibe make you feel right at home as soon as you walk in.
During my visit, I was immediately struck by the incredible aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. G & D Pizzaria stands out for its commitment to quality, using fresh ingredients that elevate every dish.
For an outstanding experience, the G & D Special is a must-try. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and a blend of fresh veggies, it showcases their dedication to flavor and quality.
3. Shakespeare’s Pizza South
Shakespeare’s Pizza South is an extension of the beloved original, providing the same great taste in a cozy setting at 3911 Peachtree Dr. This location has become a gathering spot for locals, offering a relaxed environment perfect for enjoying a slice with friends or family.
My experience there was delightful. The restaurant buzzed with energy, and the friendly staff made sure every guest felt welcome. What sets Shakespeare’s Pizza South apart is its commitment to quality and innovation in every pie.
A standout order is the Spinach and Artichoke Pizza. It’s loaded with fresh ingredients, creamy cheese, and a flavorful crust that delivers a unique twist on traditional pizza that truly reflects their culinary creativity.
4. Tony’s Pizza Palace
Tony’s Pizza Palace is a beloved local pizzeria located at 17 N 5th St, known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious offerings. This spot has a charm that draws in pizza lovers seeking comfort food in a friendly setting. With vegetarian-friendly options, it caters to a variety of tastes.
During my visit, I felt right at home as I savored a slice at one of their inviting tables. What makes Tony’s special is the dedication to flavor and freshness, reflected in every dish they serve.
The Ultimate Meat Pizza is a must-try, overflowing with pepperoni, sausage, and ham. Each bite captures the essence of a classic pizzeria experience, showcasing why Tony’s Pizza Palace is a standout in Columbia’s culinary scene.
5. Shakespeare’s Pizza West
Shakespeare’s Pizza West, located at 3304 W Broadway Business Park Ct, continues the legacy of its renowned predecessors with a distinct flair. Known for its inviting atmosphere, this location provides a perfect setting for casual dining, whether you’re grabbing lunch or unwinding with dinner.
My experience at Shakespeare’s Pizza West was marked by friendly service and a vibrant crowd. The staff’s enthusiasm for their menu translates into an enjoyable dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
For a standout menu item, try the Barbecue Chicken Pizza, which showcases tender chicken paired with tangy sauce and fresh toppings. This unique twist on a classic pizza reflects Shakespeare’s commitment to quality, making it a must-try for anyone in Columbia.
6. Gumby’s Pizza
Gumby’s Pizza at 1201 E Broadway is a popular choice for those craving a satisfying slice in Columbia. Known for its laid-back atmosphere and fun vibe, it’s the perfect spot for college students and locals alike to gather for lunch or dinner.
During my visit, I enjoyed not only the delicious pizza but also the playful spirit of the place, complete with quirky decor and an energetic ambiance. Gumby’s stands out for its extensive menu, offering something for everyone.
The Pokey Stix are a must-try, loaded with cheese and perfect for sharing. Pair them with any of their specialty pizzas, like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which captures bold flavors and ensures a memorable meal.
7. Your Pie
Your Pie at 1413 Grindstone Plaza Drive is revolutionizing the pizza game in Columbia with its fast-casual approach. Known for its customizable personal pizzas, this spot draws inspiration from family recipes hailing from the Italian island of Ischia. The dedication to quality shines through in every hand-tossed crust.
During my visit, I appreciated the vibrant atmosphere and the opportunity to craft my own pizza using fresh ingredients. What sets Your Pie apart is the ability to personalize every aspect of your meal, making it an adventure for your taste buds.
For a standout dish, try the Margherita Pizza, featuring homemade sauce and fresh basil. Pair it with a local craft beer to enhance your meal experience.
8. Pizza Tree
Pizza Tree, located at 909 Cherry St, is a charming spot in Columbia that offers a unique twist on the traditional pizzeria experience. With a cozy setting perfect for both lunch and dinner, it’s an inviting place to enjoy a good slice of pizza.
During my visit, I was impressed by the warm atmosphere and the friendly staff, who made ordering simple and enjoyable. What sets Pizza Tree apart is its commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations.
For a standout option, try the White Pizza, topped with creamy ricotta and garlic. It’s not only delicious but a perfect reflection of Pizza Tree’s focus on quality and innovation.
9. Arris’ Pizza
Arris’ Pizza, located at 1020 E Green Meadows Rd, has become a family favorite in Columbia thanks to its rich history and welcoming atmosphere. Family-owned and operated since its founding, it brings a sense of community to every meal, making it a great spot for gatherings.
During my visit, I was struck by the warm service and the nostalgic feel of the place. Arris’ Pizza stands out for its dedication to quality and tradition, evident in every dish they serve.
The Classic Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try, featuring a perfect balance of flavors that pays homage to their roots. Its rich and inviting taste truly reflects the spirit of Arris’ Pizza.
10. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza at 21 Conley Rd is redefining the pizza experience in Columbia, making it all about personalization. With their motto of “pizza is personal,” you can create your perfect pie or salad with an incredible array of over 40 toppings and 8 sauces, all for one fixed price.
During my visit, I was impressed by the energetic atmosphere and the skillful staff known as the MOD Squad. They crafted my pizza right before my eyes, showcasing the creativity and fun that MOD Pizza encourages.
For an extraordinary meal, try their MOD Classic Pizza loaded with fresh vegetables and a zesty sauce. This customizable approach perfectly captures MOD Pizza’s commitment to quality and individuality.
More Things to Try in Columbia, MO
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Columbia, MO?
Some of the top spots include Shakespeare’s Pizza, G & D Pizzaria, and Your Pie. Each offers a unique experience, from classic pies to customizable options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
2. Do any pizza restaurants in Columbia offer gluten-free options?
Yes, several places like MOD Pizza and your local Shakespeare’s Pizza provide gluten-free crusts, making it easier for those with dietary restrictions to enjoy a delicious slice.
3. What is the typical price range for pizza in Columbia?
The price for a pizza typically ranges from $10 to $25, depending on the size and toppings. Customizable options might be priced differently based on your selection.
4. Can I find vegetarian options at pizza places in Columbia?
Absolutely! Most pizzerias, including G & D Pizzaria and MOD Pizza, offer a variety of vegetarian toppings and specialty pizzas catering to plant-based diets.
5. Where can I order pizza for delivery in Columbia?
Many local pizzerias, such as Domino’s and Gumby’s Pizza, offer delivery services. It’s always best to check their websites or apps for details on delivery options.