Few quests inspire such devoted hunger as the search for the best pizza in Colorado Springs. I remember the first time I bit into a slice downtown—crisp crust, bubbling cheese, just the right balance of sauce. I knew I was in a city where pizza isn’t just dinner. It’s an experience. Exploring Colorado Springs one slice at a time quickly became my favorite excuse to disappear for a few hours and return with flour dust on my shirt and a grin on my face.
You’ll find passionate chefs here who have turned pizza into an art form—whether you crave wood-fired Neapolitan, pan-baked pies, or experimental toppings that surprise you with every bite. From family favorites to modern upstarts, the Springs’ pizza scene is surprisingly varied. As you read on, you’ll discover spots where the first bite will tell you you’ve found something special. Ready to meet the pizzerias that make locals drop what they’re doing for just one more slice? Keep reading, and bring your appetite.
Where to find the best pizza in Colorado Springs, CO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Colorado Springs, CO:
- Pizzeria Rustica
- Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria
- MOD Pizza
- Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza
- Slice 420
- Old Chicago
- Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse
- Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana
- Il Vicino University Village
- P74: The Downtown Paninos
1. Pizzeria Rustica
Step into Pizzeria Rustica and you’ll notice right away this is no ordinary spot. Antique décor and a cozy, heated patio set the scene for a truly classic pizza experience. Every pizza here is hand-stretched and cooked in a wood oven, lending that irresistible Neapolitan char and chew.
One bite of their Margherita pizza—with creamy mozzarella, bright sauce, and fragrant basil—captures the essence of tradition. The crust is soft, subtly smoky, and never overwhelmed by toppings. For something different, try the Rustica, with local veggies and top-tier olive oil, showing off their commitment to both quality and creativity.
Other highlights include vegan and gluten-free choices, plus a smart wine list. If you appreciate craftsmanship, Pizzeria Rustica always delivers.
2. Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria
Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria knows how to keep things lively. Walking in, the aroma of fresh dough and tangy sauce hits you before you even see their modern, bustling space. It’s a place where you can build your own pizza or trust the menu if decisions aren’t your strong suit.
Every pie comes out crisp and light, never greasy. I still remember my first bite of their Truffle Shuffle pizza—earthy mushrooms, creamy mozzarella, and just the right drizzle of truffle oil. It’s indulgent without being heavy.
If you’re craving something on the lighter side, their gluten-free and vegan pies are just as satisfying as the originals. Bambino’s is all about fresh, bold choices and quality you can taste in every slice.
3. MOD Pizza
You’ll know you’ve found MOD Pizza at Falcon Landing by the buzz of energy and people pointing at options. This is the place to let your pizza imagination run wild, piecing together unique combos with over 40 fresh toppings—no limits, just one set price. Watching my pizza come to life here felt a bit like a choose-your-own-adventure, only tastier.
The Mad Dog stands out for its tangy red sauce and double cheese, plus a bold punch of veggies. If you’re feeling creative, custom pies are the way to go, whether you’re testing out hearty roasted vegetables or going simple with classic mozzarella and tomatoes.
Gluten-friendly and vegan choices keep everyone happy. MOD’s fast service and genuine community vibe make it a favorite for both quick lunches and group cravings.
4. Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza
Step into Duca’s Neapolitan Pizza inside The Antlers Hotel and you’ll feel like you’ve stumbled into a corner of Naples. The open wood-fired oven steals the show, turning out blistered, chewy crusts topped with honest, straightforward ingredients. There’s an old-world charm here you can taste with every bite.
My pick? The Margherita. It’s simple, classic, and lets those high-quality tomatoes and creamy mozzarella really shine. The sauce is light, the basil fresh, and the balance spot on. For something with more pop, the Verdura is loaded with seasonal vegetables for a fresh, earthy bite.
Duca’s champions tradition—pizzas are lightly dressed, never overloaded, so every bite feels balanced and authentic. Vegan options round out the menu for everyone’s table.
5. Slice 420
If you’re on the hunt for classic New York-style pizza in Colorado Springs, Slice 420 makes you feel at home from the minute you walk in. This place prides itself on community and mission, but what really wins me over is the unmistakable aroma of fresh-baked pies warming the air.
The cheese or veggie slices are a go-to—thin, foldable, and with just enough crisp to the crust. For something extra, try a white pizza topped with ricotta and local veggies. Each bite is proof that these folks take flavor and quality seriously.
Gluten-free options also shine, proving care extends to every guest. When you crave simplicity and authenticity, Slice 420 delivers a slice of city comfort—right in the heart of Old Colorado City.
6. Old Chicago
Old Chicago brings a bit of Chicago tradition to Colorado Springs, and every trip here feels like catching up with an old friend. You get casual comfort, bustling energy, and, most importantly, deep-dish and pan pizzas that turn any meal into an event.
The star is always the Chicago-style deep-dish pizza—thick, buttery crust, layers of gooey cheese, and bold tomato sauce. One slice in, you’ll get why people keep coming back. Prefer a lighter touch? Their thin-crust veggie pizzas balance crispness and flavor without ever feeling heavy.
It’s an easy spot for groups, with tables perfect for sharing and gluten-free choices so everyone leaves happy. If you want classic, hearty pizza done right, Old Chicago is never a gamble.
7. Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse
Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse is equal parts neighborhood hangout and pizza destination. The moment I sat on the patio, soaking up mountain views, I saw why this place draws such a loyal crowd—it all feels effortless and inviting.
The menu lets you sample inventive pies, but the Veggie Deluxe is my top pick: loads of fresh, colorful veggies piled onto a golden, chewy crust. If you’re in a sharing mood, try a classic cheese or Margherita—proving simple combinations shine here. Every pizza feels crafted, not mass-produced.
Paired with one of their craft sodas and a side salad, it’s a cozy, crowd-pleasing meal. Gluten-free and vegan options make it easy to bring everyone to the table at Walter’s303.
8. Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana
+1 833-692-2745
See Menu
Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana brings a slice of Naples to Colorado Springs—no passport required. From the first moment I watched the chef hand-stretch dough and slide pies into the tiled oven, I knew this was serious pizza territory. The aroma alone was enough to win me over.
The Caprese Pizza is a beautiful showcase of quality—velvety mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and fresh basil over a crust that’s crispy at the edge yet tender inside. Their Margherita, with its simple, sunny flavors, is another crowd favorite.
With vegan and gluten-free options, everyone can join the feast. For classic Neapolitan technique and full-bodied flavors, Basil & Barley stands out in the Springs’ pizza line-up.
9. Il Vicino University Village
Il Vicino University Village is the kind of spot where you want to linger just a bit longer. With an open kitchen and welcoming aroma of baking dough, it’s the pizza place I head to when only wood-fired will do. The setting is airy and casual, making it easy to enjoy a slow lunch or relaxed dinner with friends.
The Salsiccia pizza, with roasted veggies and creamy mozzarella, sets the bar high. For something with pure, simple charm, the classic Margherita is hard to top—perfectly balanced flavors and a crust with just the right bite.
Plenty of vegan and gluten-free options keep everyone happy, but the care put into each pizza is what makes Il Vicino rise above the standard chain fare in Colorado Springs.
10. P74: The Downtown Paninos
P74: The Downtown Paninos has deep roots in Colorado Springs, and every slice or sandwich served here feels like a nod to decades of tradition. The atmosphere is lively, classic, and filled with the aroma of golden-baked dough. It’s the spot I hit when I want comfort paired with a bit of local history.
Their Pepperoni and Veggie Panino pizza stands out for its chewy crust and generous toppings. You’ll taste the quality in every bite. If you want a dose of nostalgia, try one of their famed specialty Panino sandwiches alongside a veggie pizza for the full experience.
P74 nails the balance between old-school family recipes and fresh ingredients. Whether you’re a pizza fan or in the mood to experiment, you’re bound to find something memorable on their menu.
More Things to Try in Colorado Springs, CO
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Colorado Springs?
You’ll find everything from thin, New York-style slices to traditional wood-fired Neapolitan, classic Chicago deep dish, and creative specialty pies at local spots. There’s no shortage of variety, whether you’re craving a light, crisp crust or something with serious heft.
Are there good gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Colorado Springs?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias offer gluten-free and vegan pizzas, so you don’t have to miss out. Places like Pizzeria Rustica, Bambino’s, and MOD Pizza have menus that cater to a range of dietary needs.
Can I get pizza by the slice in Colorado Springs?
Yes, several local favorites like Slice 420 serve up quality pizza by the slice. Perfect if you want a quick bite or want to try a few different flavors.
Which Colorado Springs pizza places are best for families or large groups?
Spots like Old Chicago, MOD Pizza, and Walter’s303 are great for groups. They offer big tables, shareable pies, and casual vibes that keep everyone comfortable.
What’s a must-try signature pizza in Colorado Springs?
Don’t miss the Margherita at Pizzeria Rustica for wood-fired tradition, or camp out at Old Chicago for a slice of their deep dish. Each has a local following for good reason.