Best Pizza in Cinnaminson, NJ

Cinnaminson, NJ, is a pizza lover’s dream. The town has so many amazing spots to grab a slice. Whether you love thin crust or thick, you’ll find it here.

Wondering where to get the best pizza in Cinnaminson, NJ? My favorites are Nick’s Pizza and Pasta, Bellisimos, and more. They have delicious pies, fresh toppings, and great service. You’ll never leave hungry!

Stick with me. I’ll take you through my favorite pizza places in Cinnaminson. Let me show you where the perfect slice awaits!

Top 10 Pizza in Cinnaminson, NJ

1. Nick’s Pizza and Pasta
2. Brothers Pizza
3. Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria
4. Di Vincenzo’s Pizza
5. Goody’s
6. Pats Select Pizza | Grill
7. Zio’s Tuscan Grille
8. Bellisimos Pizza
9. Tony Sopranos Pizza & Ristorante
10. Milanese Pizza of Riverton, NJ

1. Nick’s Pizza and Pasta

Nick’s Pizza and Pasta is a real gem. It’s a cozy family-run spot located on US-130. The vibe is friendly and welcoming. I love that the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, too.

What makes Nick’s special? Their pizza is always fresh and cheesy. I remember visiting on a busy night. The service was quick and the staff was so nice. It felt like a big hug as soon as I walked in.

When I go, I always order the Margherita pizza. It’s simple, but it’s packed with flavor. The fresh mozzarella and basil are a must-try. If you’re in the mood for pasta, their homemade dishes are comforting and delicious. Nick’s is definitely a must-visit for pizza lovers!

2. Brothers Pizza

Brothers Pizza is a real treat. It’s right on US-130 in Cinnaminson. The place feels cozy, and I love that it’s wheelchair-accessible. It’s so nice to have a spot for everyone.

What I love most about Brothers Pizza is how consistent they are. Every time I visit, the pizza is always fresh and hot. I’ll never forget the time I went with friends. We ordered a bunch of pies and had the best time together. The staff was super friendly and made us feel right at home.

My go-to order is the Pepperoni pizza. It’s classic but so tasty. The crust is just right—crispy and chewy. If you want to try something new, their white pizza is amazing. It’s creamy and packed with flavor. Brothers Pizza is a must-try for all pizza lovers!

3. Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria

Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria feels like home. The warm vibe hits you right away. It’s cozy and perfect for everyone. And yes, they’ve got wheelchair access too. Super thoughtful, right?

The wood-fired pizzas are pure magic. I still remember that smoky smell—so good. The dough is soft yet crispy. Every bite is fresh and full of flavor. Oh, and the staff? So kind, so welcoming.

If you visit, order the Margherita pizza. Trust me, it’s a classic done right. The fresh basil, juicy tomatoes, and gooey cheese—just wow. Want something creamy? Try their white pizza. It’s dreamy, rich, and oh-so-satisfying. You really can’t go wrong. This place is a must-visit for pizza lovers!

4. Di Vincenzo’s Pizza

Di Vincenzo’s Pizza is a lovely spot on Cinnaminson Ave. It feels warm and inviting right when you walk in. I love that it’s casual and laid-back. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is really nice.

What really stands out at Di Vincenzo’s are their classic pizzas and pasta. I’ll never forget my first visit—the smell of fresh dough was incredible! The staff welcomed me like family and made me feel right at home.

When I go, I always order their traditional cheese pizza. It’s simple, but so fresh and tasty. If you’re in the mood for something different, their white pizza is amazing. It’s creamy, garlicky, and super satisfying. Di Vincenzo’s Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

5. Goody’s

Goody’s is a fun spot on US-130. The vibe is relaxed and super friendly. I really like that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is a nice touch.

What sets Goody’s apart is their amazing menu. I remember going there with friends and being excited to try different dishes. The staff was welcoming and made us feel right at home.

One of my favorites is their BBQ chicken pizza. It’s packed with flavor and so delicious. If you want something spicy, go for the buffalo chicken pizza. It’s a real treat! Goody’s is a must-try if you love pizza!

6. Pats Select Pizza | Grill

Pats Select Pizza | Grill is such a cozy spot. It’s family-friendly, and the vibe just makes you want to stay longer. I love that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s great for any kind of day. The wheelchair-accessible entrance is such a thoughtful touch too.

The menu is packed with so many options. There’s pizza, pasta, wings, and sandwiches. Everything I’ve tried has been super tasty. Oh, and the prices? Totally reasonable. Perfect for families, friends, or even just you.

You have to try their Margherita pizza. The basil is so fresh. The cheese? Melted perfectly. And the tomato sauce has this tangy kick. Pair it with their garlic Parmesan wings. Trust me, it’s amazing! Pats Select Pizza | Grill really knows how to make a meal feel special.

7. Zio’s Tuscan Grille

Zio’s Tuscan Grille feels like home. The moment you walk in, it’s cozy. Booths invite you to sit and relax. If the weather’s good, the outdoor seating is lovely. It’s perfect for grabbing a bite, no fuss.

Their menu is a crowd-pleaser. The brick-oven pizzas are the real deal. You can taste the fresh ingredients. The crust is just right—crispy, yet soft. It’s simple but so good. My favorite? The Margherita pizza. It’s fresh basil, melty mozzarella, and a hint of magic.

What I really love is the flexibility. Got kids in tow? Takeout is a lifesaver. In a hurry? Curbside pickup is so easy. They just make dining stress-free. Honestly, what’s not to like?

8. Bellisimos Pizza

Bellisimos Pizza is such a cozy little spot. Located on Branch Pike, it feels warm and welcoming. I love that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner. Plus, it’s really easy to get takeout or delivery if you’re in a rush. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is great for everyone.

The pizza here is always a hit. Their crust is thin and crispy, just like I like it. I can’t get enough of their Margherita pizza. The fresh tomato, basil, and mozzarella come together perfectly. If you want something heartier, their meat lovers’ pizza is amazing too. It’s loaded with toppings and super cheesy.

What really stands out is how affordable it is. The service is quick, and the staff is always friendly. Bellisimos Pizza is definitely my go-to for delicious and easy pizza nights!

9. Tony Sopranos Pizza & Ristorante

Tony Sopranos Pizza & Ristorante is at 1426 Route 130 N in Cinnaminson, NJ. They do curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout. Plus, they have indoor and outdoor seating. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible too. The prices are moderate. You can even make a reservation.

The moment you walk in, you’re hit with the smell of fresh pizza. The place feels cozy, and the staff are so friendly. It’s great for family dinners or just a relaxed meal.

When I went, I had the Chicken Parmigiana Pizza. It was amazing. The chicken was tender, and the sauce was perfect. The cheese was super gooey. If you love pasta, get the Fettuccine Alfredo. It’s so creamy and tasty.

So, Tony Sopranos stands out because of its quality and friendly vibe. I just love going there.

10. Milanese Pizza of Riverton, NJ

So, Milanese Pizza in Riverton, NJ is this super cozy place on Broad Street. They’ve got both indoor and outdoor seating. Perfect for any weather. And hey, it’s wheelchair accessible too. That’s always a win.

The first thing I noticed was their thin-crust pizza. Wow, it’s crispy and full of flavor. On my first visit, the warm, friendly vibe made me feel right at home. The staff were so welcoming and kind.

I must say, their classic cheese pizza is my go-to. It’s perfectly balanced. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try the stromboli. It’s packed and super satisfying. Milanese Pizza is definitely a gem you shouldn’t miss!

Map of Pizza in Cinnaminson, NJ

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best pizza places in Cinnaminson, NJ?
  If you’re asking, definitely check out Nick’s Pizza and Pasta and Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria. They both have amazing flavors and great vibes!

• Do these pizza places offer delivery?
  Yes, most of them do! Places like Bellisimos Pizza and Domino’s deliver right to your door.

• Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
  Absolutely! Many places, including Nick’s, offer gluten-free crusts. Just double-check when you order!

• Which pizza place is best for families?
  I’d say Italian Brick Oven Pizzeria is fantastic for families. It’s spacious and super welcoming, perfect for kids!

• What are the must-try pizzas in Cinnaminson?
  You’ve got to try the classic cheese pizza at Nick’s. And don’t miss the brick oven specialties at Italian Brick Oven!

• Do these places have vegetarian options?
  Yes! Most pizza spots have delicious vegetarian pizzas. You can even customize your order to fit your needs.

• Are there dine-in options available?
  For sure! Places like Bellisimos Pizza and Zio’s Tuscan Grille have cozy dining areas to enjoy your meal.

• What are the price ranges for pizzas in Cinnaminson?
  Prices usually fall between $10 and $20 for a medium pizza. Specialty pies might cost a little more.

• Do these pizzerias offer catering services?
  Yes, some like Nick’s Pizza and Pasta do cater. It’s a great choice for parties and events!

• Are there any late-night pizza spots in Cinnaminson?
  Yes! Domino’s is usually open late. It’s perfect for those late-night cravings!