Finding great pizza in Centereach, NY, isn’t just a quest—it’s a delicious ritual. I still remember the first slice I grabbed here, piping hot, with that just-right stretch of cheese. It quickly became clear that Centereach is home to a surprisingly broad lineup, from classic neighborhood spots to chains you know by heart. Every local seems to have their personal favorite, and after more than a few friendly debates (and even more slices), I’ve come to appreciate each shop’s quirks and specialties.
Centereach’s pizzerias don’t settle for “good enough.” Whether you crave a crisp, thin crust with bold tomato sauce, or a decadent deep-dish that holds up to heavy toppings, you’ll find plenty of options—along with a sprinkle of local personality. I’ve tasted my way through the area and compared notes with fellow pizza obsessives to create a guide that spotlights the top slices around. If you’re ready to discover your own favorite, or just searching for tonight’s perfect pie, read on. The best pizza in Centereach is truly a slice above.
Where to find the best pizza in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Centereach, NY:
- Mozza Fiato
- Mama’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Domino’s Pizza
- Villa Grazia
- Michael Anthony’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Benny’s Pizzeria Inc
- Little Nicky’s Pizza Pasta & Catering Inc
- Colosseo
- Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
1. Mozza Fiato
Mozza Fiato delivers a slice of Naples right in Centereach. The first time I tried their Margherita pizza, I noticed the dough—soft yet crisp, airy in the right places, cooked in a way only true Neapolitans seem to master. What sets Mozza Fiato apart is their commitment to tradition. Ingredients come together with the kind of careful touch you rarely find outside Italy.
The menu leans Italian, but the pizza is the star. Don’t miss their Neapolitan pies, especially the Margherita or Truffle Mushroom. Both showcase the pizzeria’s knack for fresh, balanced toppings and that essential chewy crust. Here, every bite feels thoughtfully crafted.
If you’re searching for authentic flavors and quality without shortcuts, Mozza Fiato is the name locals trust.
2. Mama’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Mama’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant evokes the charm of classic pizzerias—a spot where everyone seems to know your name. My first visit came after a recommendation from a local, and the warm welcome matched the inviting aroma drifting from the kitchen. What makes Mama’s special is their devotion to homemade recipes and cozy, family-style service.
Their Sicilian slice is a must-try: thick, airy, and generously topped with savory sauce and perfectly melted cheese. If you’re a fan of a more traditional pie, the plain cheese pizza lets the high-quality dough and sauce shine. Their menu extends beyond pizza, but it’s the hearty, classic pies that keep me returning.
At Mama’s, you’ll taste tradition, consistency, and pride in every slice.
3. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Middle Country Road delivers reliability, speed, and customizable options—a combination that never goes out of style. I’ve counted on their pizza for study nights and casual gatherings, where the comfort of a classic cheese or pepperoni slice earns unanimous approval every time. Consistency and quick service define Domino’s in Centereach, making it a local go-to for delivery or carry-out.
Thin crust New York Style and their signature Handmade Pan stand out here. Order the thin crust if you want something light and foldable, while the pan version delivers that thick, golden edge. The Parmesan Stuffed Crust, with its melty, cheesy border, is a crowd-pleaser.
For straightforward, satisfying pizza with a wide range of toppings, Domino’s keeps it simple, tasty, and fast.
4. Villa Grazia
Villa Grazia radiates a friendly, neighborhood vibe from the moment you step through the door. One evening after work, I stopped in and watched as regulars greeted the staff by name—a clear sign of a local favorite. The pizzeria’s charm lies in its classic recipes and fresh approach to toppings; every slice feels carefully crafted without fanfare.
The Grandma slice is a standout, layered with a vibrant tomato sauce, olive oil, and perfect cheese coverage. If you’re after something with a bit more bite, try the white pizza, where creamy ricotta and garlic make a memorable pair. Thin crust lovers will appreciate the crisp base that never scrimps on flavor.
At Villa Grazia, traditional methods meet everyday comfort, one slice at a time.
5. Michael Anthony’s Pizza
Michael Anthony’s Pizza brings a hometown sensibility to Centereach’s pizza scene. My first pie from here was a last-minute pickup, but the quality surprised me. What sets Michael Anthony’s apart is their commitment to both classic and contemporary flavors. The welcoming staff only adds to the neighborhood feel.
Their Sicilian is impressively light and airy—each bite offers a blend of crunchy edges and a tender center. The classic cheese pie is no slouch either, featuring a bright, zesty sauce over a thin, flavorful crust. Looking for something a little different? The veggie pizza piles on fresh toppings without skimping on taste or quality.
When you want easy comfort and high standards, Michael Anthony’s delivers both, every time.
6. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Centereach blends familiar flavor and nostalgia. There’s something comforting about the red-roofed boxes that makes any get-together just a bit more festive. I once picked up a fresh pan pizza before a movie night and the classic, buttery crust didn’t disappoint. It’s that signature pan crust—thick, golden, and crisp—that truly distinguishes Pizza Hut from other chains.
The Personal Pan Pizza is an ideal pick if you want a quick, satisfying solo option, while the Veggie Lover’s is loaded with fresh toppings and always a hit among groups. For those who lean toward cheesy satisfaction, the cheese pizza stays true to Pizza Hut’s reliable formula.
Dependable, balanced flavors make Pizza Hut a favorite for casual cravings.
7. Benny’s Pizzeria Inc
(631) 467-6622Call
Benny’s Pizzeria Inc feels like the sort of place where regulars know exactly what they want the moment they walk in. I dropped by on a rainy afternoon, and the warm welcome made the day brighter. Benny’s stands out for its value and laid-back vibe—plenty of seating, easy parking, and a menu that gets the basics right.
The classic cheese slice is worth seeking out. The balance between the thin, just-crisp-enough crust and the tangy sauce makes it an easy favorite for traditionalists. If you’re after something with more substance, the Sicilian square offers a hearty bite with its soft, thicker base and a layer of cheese that’s just the right thickness.
Budget-friendly, reliable, and local—Benny’s is a Centereach mainstay for good reason.
8. Little Nicky’s Pizza Pasta & Catering Inc
(631) 588-6425Call
Little Nicky’s Pizza Pasta & Catering Inc is the spot where big flavor and welcoming service meet. I first popped in during a community event—locals lined up for pizza that was both aromatic and clearly made with attention. This pizzeria shines for its consistency and generous toppings, whether you’re there for a single slice or feeding a small crowd.
The Grandma slice is a local favorite: thin, square, with fresh tomato and a sprinkle of herbs that keeps it light but packed with taste. For standard fare, the cheese pizza delivers with its chewy crust and well-balanced sauce. If you’re thinking about catering, their trays are just as reliable and hearty as the slices.
Little Nicky’s mixes warmth, quality, and community spirit in every bite.
9. Colosseo
Colosseo is an institution for pizza lovers in the Port Jefferson Station area—a bit outside Centereach, but well worth the short drive. I tried it on a friend’s recommendation, and the first bite made it clear why locals rave. Colosseo is known for fresh ingredients and hand-tossed pies that strike the right balance between chewy and crisp.
Their classic cheese pizza is almost legendary: bubbling with cheese, nicely browned and anchored by a sauce with a hint of sweetness. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their white pizza—rich ricotta and fresh garlic make each slice a standout. Calzones and pinwheels here deliver the same level of quality as the pizza itself.
Generous portions, fair prices, and a reliable local buzz keep Colosseo on the map for serious pizza fans.
10. Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant offers a blend of classic Italian comfort and neighborhood charm that keeps regulars coming back. I stumbled on this spot during a birthday party; the pizzeria was buzzing with families, laughter, and the unmistakable scent of fresh-baked dough. Their welcoming atmosphere matches a menu that’s both broad and refined.
Branchinelli’s Sicilian pizza is a local talker: thick, pillowy, and topped with a blanket of cheese that hits just the right balance with their flavorful sauce. For thin-crust enthusiasts, their hand-tossed pies are crisp on the bottom but still chewy at the edge. The plain cheese pizza lets quality ingredients shine through, reflecting years of pizza-making tradition.
Whether you’re picking up a pie or sitting down for a family meal, Branchinelli’s serves generosity and flavor in equal measure.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Centereach, NY?
Some of the most popular spots include Mozza Fiato, Mama’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Villa Grazia, Benny’s Pizzeria Inc, and Michael Anthony’s Pizza. Each is known for its distinct pizza style and local following.
Are there any pizzerias in Centereach that offer gluten-free options?
Yes, several local pizzerias such as Michael Anthony’s Pizza and Domino’s Pizza offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability and preparation methods.
Which places are best for takeout or delivery?
Domino’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Pauly’s Pizza & Pasta are reliable bets for speedy takeout or delivery. Most shops also offer online ordering for added convenience.
What styles of pizza can I find in Centereach?
You’ll find a wide variety including New York-style, Sicilian, Neapolitan, and grandma pizza. Many spots put their own twist on the classics, so there’s something for every preference.
Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Centereach?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias offer cheese, veggie, and specialty pies made without meat. Ask about daily specials for even more choices.