Cape Girardeau, MO, is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts. This charming city offers a delightful variety of pizzerias that cater to every taste. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something innovative, Cape Girardeau has options that will spark your appetite. With each bite, you’ll discover local flavors and culinary creativity that set these establishments apart.
In my quest for the best pizza, I’ve had the pleasure of sampling the offerings from several local joints. Each place has its own unique vibe and specialties that keep you wanting more. This guide will navigate you through the top contenders, helping you find your perfect slice. From traditional recipes to modern interpretations, you’re in for a treat as we explore Cape Girardeau’s pizza scene.
Where to find the best pizza in Cape Girardeau, MO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Cape Girardeau, MO:
- Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta
- Speck Pizza + Street Food
- Minglewood Brewery
- Rosati’s Pizza
- Imo’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Little Caesars
- Pizza Hut
- Godfather’s Pizza Express
1. Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta
Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit in Cape Girardeau. Located at 1129 Broadway St, this eatery captures the essence of classic Italian cuisine with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Their commitment to quality is evident in every slice, making it a local favorite for pizza lovers.
One standout feature is their extensive menu, which includes vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. This inclusive approach ensures everyone can enjoy a meal here. After trying their sausage and mushroom pizza, I was hooked—the flavors meld beautifully, with fresh ingredients and a perfectly baked crust.
Don’t miss their homemade garlic bread on the side, which complements the meal perfectly. Pagliai’s delivers not just pizza, but an authentic culinary experience. Visit their site for more: pagliaispizzacape.com.
2. Speck Pizza + Street Food
Speck Pizza + Street Food offers a unique twist on the classic pizza experience right in the heart of Cape Girardeau at 430 Broadway St. This vibrant spot combines casual dining with a street food flair, creating a lively and inviting atmosphere. Their commitment to flavor and creativity sets them apart.
On my visit, I was captivated by their smoked brisket pizza. Topped with house-made barbecue sauce and fresh cilantro, it’s a bold choice that pays off with every bite. They also offer excellent vegetarian options that don’t skimp on taste.
Don’t forget to try their truffle fries as a side—they’re the perfect complement to any pizza. Check out more at speckpizza.com.
3. Minglewood Brewery
Minglewood Brewery is a vibrant brewpub located at 121 Broadway St, where local craft beer meets artisan pizza. As a veteran-owned establishment, it embodies a warm, welcoming vibe that makes you feel right at home. The historic downtown setting adds to its charm, making it a perfect spot to unwind.
During my visit, the standout was their BBQ chicken pizza. Topped with house-smoked chicken, jalapeños, and a tangy barbecue sauce, it showcased their commitment to quality and flavor. The crust was perfectly cooked, adding a delightful crunch.
Pair your pizza with one of their freshly brewed beers for a truly enjoyable experience. For more information, visit minglewoodbrewery.com.
4. Rosati’s Pizza
Rosati’s Pizza, located at 2136 William Street Ste 120, offers a taste of Chicago right here in Cape Girardeau. With a legacy spanning five generations, this family-owned pizzeria excels in crafting authentic Chicago-style pizzas that have won hearts across the nation. The passion for quality and flavor is evident in every dish.
On my visit, I opted for their deep-dish pizza, and it did not disappoint. The rich, flaky crust cradled layers of gooey cheese and savory toppings, creating a hearty meal that fills you right up. Their generous portions ensure you’re getting great value.
Pair it with a side of garlic bread for an added treat. To learn more about their menu, explore myrosatis.com/capegirardeau.
5. Imo’s Pizza
Imo’s Pizza, located at 1008 North Kingshighway Street, is a beloved local institution known for its unique St. Louis-style pizza. This pizzeria stands out with its ultra-thin crust, generous toppings, and, of course, a special blend of Provel cheese that gives it a distinct flavor. The inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for a casual meal.
On my recent visit, I indulged in their signature pepperoni pizza. The combination of the crispy crust and tangy sauce topped with ample pepperoni captivated my taste buds. It’s a simple dish that perfectly showcases Imo’s dedication to quality.
Don’t forget to try their breadsticks as a tasty side. For more information, head to imospizza.com.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at 1410 N Kingshighway St offers dependable pizza options for those craving a quick and satisfying meal in Cape Girardeau. Known for their efficient delivery service and diverse menu, they cater to any pizza preference, from thin crust to their famous Handmade Pan pizza.
On a particularly busy night, I ordered their Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza, which truly exceeded my expectations. The extra burst of flavor in each bite made it a standout choice. Their variety extends beyond pizza, with tasty options like mac and cheese and chicken wings that round out the meal.
The value and convenience are hard to beat, making Domino’s a reliable favorite for many. For more details, check out dominos.com.
7. Little Caesars Pizza
Located at 310 N Kingshighway St, Little Caesars Pizza is a go-to spot for quick and budget-friendly pizza options in Cape Girardeau. Known for its simple setup and efficient service, it takes the hassle out of pizza night. Their motto, “Hot-N-Ready,” truly delivers when you’re in a rush.
During one of my hectic evenings, I grabbed a Pepperoni Pizza on the go. The zesty pepperoni perfectly complemented the cheesy goodness, making for a satisfying meal that didn’t break the bank. The crust was just the right amount of crispy.
For a different twist, consider their Crazy Bread as a side. It’s the perfect addition and a crowd-pleaser. For more info, visit littlecaesars.com.
8. Little Caesars
Little Caesars, located at 310 N Kingshighway St, offers a seamless pizza experience that’s perfect for anyone looking for a quick bite. Known for its efficiency, this chain excels at serving up fresh, tasty pizzas without the long wait times. Their famous “Hot-N-Ready” concept ensures you’ll always walk out with a pizza in hand.
During a recent visit, I decided to try their iconic Crazy Bread along with a classic pepperoni pizza. The breadsticks, warm and garlicky, were the perfect companion to the cheesy, pepperoni-topped pie. It was a great value and incredibly satisfying after a long day.
Little Caesars stands out with its reliable quality and budget-friendly options. For more details, check out littlecaesars.com.
9. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut, conveniently located at 202 Siemers Dr, is a classic choice for pizza enthusiasts in Cape Girardeau. Known for its extensive menu and robust flavors, this establishment caters to all kinds of pizza cravings. The inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for family gatherings or casual dinners with friends.
On my last visit, I indulged in their Stuffed Crust Pizza, which never fails to impress with its gooey cheese-filled edges. The combination of their rich tomato sauce and fresh toppings creates a satisfying and hearty meal.
Pair it with their breadsticks and marinara for a complete dining experience. For more details, visit their Facebook page at facebook.com/692264787632240.
10. Godfather’s Pizza Express
Godfather’s Pizza Express, situated at 353 S Kingshighway St, brings a unique pizza experience to Cape Girardeau. Known for its fresh ingredients and robust flavors, this pizzeria offers a delightful take on classic pizza styles. The casual atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a quick meal or takeout.
During my recent visit, I tried their meat lovers pizza, loaded with generous portions of sausage, pepperoni, and ham. Each bite was a satisfying blend of flavors that left me wanting more.
Their thin crust option deserves a mention, too, as it allows the vibrant toppings to shine through. For more information, check out godfathers.com.
More Things to Try in Cape Girardeau, MO
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Cape Girardeau, MO?
Some of the top contenders include Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta, Speck Pizza + Street Food, Minglewood Brewery, and Imo’s Pizza. Each offers unique styles and flavors, ensuring a great pizza experience.
2. What type of pizza is popular in Cape Girardeau?
Cape Girardeau features a mix of styles, but many locals enjoy St. Louis-style pizza, known for its thin crust and Provel cheese. You can also find traditional Chicago-style deep-dish pizza for a heartier option.
3. Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options available in Cape Girardeau?
Yes, many pizzerias, including Pagliai’s Pizza and Minglewood Brewery, offer vegetarian and vegan options. Always check with the restaurant for specific menu items.
4. Can I order pizza online in Cape Girardeau?
Absolutely! Most popular pizza places like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars offer online ordering for both delivery and takeout. Check their websites for easy ordering options.
5. What are some unique pizza toppings available in Cape Girardeau?
Local pizzerias often get creative with toppings. You might find interesting options such as smoked brisket, jalapeños, and various unique blends of cheeses, especially at places like Minglewood Brewery and Speck Pizza.
6. Do any pizza places in Cape Girardeau deliver?
Yes, several pizza restaurants provide delivery services, including Domino’s and Pizza Hut. Check their websites for delivery areas and options.
7. What are good pizza side items to order in Cape Girardeau?
Many pizzerias offer delicious sides like breadsticks, garlic knots, and salads. For a standout side, try the Crazy Bread from Little Caesars or the garlic bread from Pagliai’s for a tasty complement to your pizza.