Best Pizza in Cape Coral, FL

Alright, let me tell you about Cape Coral, FL. It’s a place where pizza is, honestly, just amazing. This city is packed with so many good spots, it’s hard to pick just one. But, trust me, I’ve got you covered. Whether you’re into thin crust, deep dish, or something in-between, there’s a slice here with your name on it.

So, what’s the best pizza in Cape Coral? That’s a tough one because it really depends on what you love. Nice Guys Pizza is edgy and fun, with creative toppings. Paradise Pizza sticks to the classics. And if you’re after a thick, cheesy deep-dish, Chicago Pizza is your spot. No matter your choice, you’ll leave happy and full.

But wait, there’s more to uncover. This guide dives into the best pizza joints in town. From their unique vibes to their must-try slices, I’ll share it all. By the end, you’ll know exactly where your next pizza night should be. Let’s dig in!

Top 10 Pizza in Cape Coral, FL

1. Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails
2. Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral
3. Papa Joe’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4. Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
5. Chicago Pizza
6. Grado’s Pizza
7. Long Island Brothers New York Pizza
8. Luciano’s Pizza
9. Lelulo’s Pizza Life
10. Matthew’s Pizza Kitchen

1. Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails

Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails is a cool spot in Cape Coral. It has a warm vibe that feels just right. The seating is comfy, whether you’re inside or on the patio. And yes, they even have curbside pickup, which is super handy when I’m in a rush.

I love grabbing a slice here. The pizza always hits the spot. They’ve got unique toppings that make each bite exciting. Plus, the craft beer selection is fantastic. I usually go on trivia night, and the place is buzzing with energy. It’s a fun way to hang out with friends.

If you visit, definitely try the Taco Pizza. It’s a fun twist that I can’t get enough of. Their classic Margherita Pizza is also a must-try. It’s fresh and simple, just like pizza should be. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

2. Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral

Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral is like a slice of NYC in Florida. It’s super relaxed and perfect for chilling out. They’ve got comfy indoor and outdoor seating. Plus, the place is wheelchair-accessible, which is great. And if you’re in a hurry, curbside pickup is really convenient.

I had a great time there last weekend. The pizza was just amazing. Fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. What really sets them apart is their attention to quality. Each pie feels like it’s made with love.

You’ve got to try the Paradise Special. It’s loaded with all the best toppings and tastes incredible. The Spaghetti and Meatballs are also really good and comforting. I always leave Paradise Pizza feeling happy and full. It’s a must-visit!

3. Papa Joe’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Papa Joe’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is so charming. The moment you walk in, you feel at home. The cozy vibe is perfect for a relaxed meal. You can sit inside or enjoy the fresh air outside. Oh, and it’s wheelchair-accessible too, which is always a plus!

I remember the first time I visited. It was such a treat! The pizza came out hot and fresh. The flavors were just right. Every slice was a joy to eat. The staff? Super friendly and welcoming.

The Margherita Pizza is a must-try. It’s simple, but wow, so tasty. The fresh basil and melted mozzarella are dreamy. Also, the Fettuccine Alfredo is to die for. It’s creamy, rich, and full of flavor. You’ll love it!

4. Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is my happy place. It’s this cozy, family-run spot. And oh, those Venice murals! They just transport you. You can sit inside or chill outside. They even do curbside pickup!

I went there last month. It was fantastic! The atmosphere was super cozy. The staff? So friendly. Freshly made pizza, and it was divine. You can feel the love in every bite.

Their made-to-order pizzas are a must. Try the Chicken Alfredo Pizza. It’s a delightful twist. And the Lasagna? Pure comfort food. You just feel at home here, and every meal is a treat!

5. Chicago Pizza

Chicago Pizza is such a fun spot. It feels like a big family hangout. The atmosphere is lively with sports on TV. I love the option of indoor or outdoor seating. They also make ordering easy with curbside pickup.

I remember the last time I went. My friends and I were craving something hearty. We ordered a giant Supreme Pizza, and wow, it did not disappoint! Each slice was loaded with toppings. The crispy crust was just perfect.

What makes this place special is the friendly vibe. The staff is always welcoming. You really feel at home here. Be sure to try the Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza. It’s so rich and filling. And don’t miss their tasty sandwiches! You’ll leave happy every time!

6. Grado’s Pizza

Grado’s Pizza is a fantastic find in Cape Coral. It’s such a cozy place with options for indoor and outdoor seating. I love how welcoming it feels. They also do delivery and takeout, which is super convenient.

Last week, I decided to stop by. The smell of fresh pizza hit me right away. I ordered their famous Margherita Pizza, and it was amazing! The crust was perfectly crispy, and the cheese was so gooey. Every bite was full of flavor.

What stands out at Grado’s Pizza is the quality. You can tell they use fresh ingredients. The staff is friendly and really cares about your experience.

If you make a trip here, try the Margherita Pizza. It perfectly shows off what Grado’s Pizza is all about. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

7. Long Island Brothers New York Pizza

Long Island Brothers New York Pizza sits on Skyline Blvd. It’s cozy and welcoming. The place is wheelchair-friendly too. They also do delivery, takeout, and have both indoor and outdoor seating. Prices are fair, which is always a bonus.

I stopped by one evening. The smell hit me first—fresh pizza, yum! I ordered the pepperoni pizza. The crust was thin and crunchy. The sauce was tangy, and the pepperoni was perfect. Each bite felt like a slice of New York.

They care about their food. It tastes homemade, not rushed. The staff is super nice too. They make you feel at home.

If you go, try the pepperoni pizza. It’s their star dish. The flavor is spot-on. It’s crispy, savory, and absolutely delicious. You won’t regret it!

8. Luciano’s Pizza

Luciano’s Pizza is a great find on Pine Island Rd. It’s a cozy spot that feels welcoming. You can sit inside or outside, depending on your mood. They also offer delivery and takeout, which is super convenient. The prices are really low too, making it perfect for a quick bite.

I visited Luciano’s last week, and it was a treat. The moment I walked in, I could smell the fresh pizza. I decided to order the Margherita pizza. It was light, crispy, and topped with fresh ingredients. Each bite was super tasty!

What I love about Luciano’s is their friendly vibe. The staff is always smiling and helpful. If you go, definitely try that Margherita pizza. It’s simple yet delicious. You won’t be disappointed!

9. Lelulo’s Pizza Life

Lelulo’s Pizza Life is such a fun place! It’s located right on Chiquita Blvd. The vibe is casual and super welcoming. I love the sports memorabilia all around. It really gives the place character. You can sit inside or outside. They also offer delivery and takeout if that’s more your style.

I visited Lelulo’s last weekend, and it was awesome! The atmosphere was lively. I grabbed a seat and caught the game on TV. I ordered the BBQ Chicken Pizza, and wow, it was fantastic! The crust was nice and crispy, and the BBQ sauce was so flavorful.

What really stands out at Lelulo’s is the variety. They have lots of specialty pizzas, subs, and wings. If you go, definitely try the BBQ Chicken Pizza. It’s a perfect balance of sweet and savory. You’ll love it!

10. Matthew’s Pizza Kitchen

Matthew’s Pizza Kitchen is such a cozy spot! It’s on NE 3rd Ave, and it feels like home. The place is family-run, which I love. You can choose to sit inside or outside. If you’re in a rush, they also do curbside pickup, which is super handy.

I went to Matthew’s last week, and it was wonderful! The staff greeted me with smiles, and the vibe was really relaxed. I ordered their Pepperoni Pizza, and wow, it was amazing! The crust was soft and chewy, and the toppings were super fresh.

What really stands out at Matthew’s is the family touch. They use great ingredients and stick to traditional recipes. If you visit, definitely try the homemade pasta. It’s so flavorful and will keep you coming back for more!

Map of Pizza in Cape Coral, FL

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best pizza places in Cape Coral?
You’ve gotta try Nice Guys Pizza, Paradise Pizza, and Chicago Pizza. Each one has its own unique vibe and tasty flavors.

2. Do these places offer delivery?
Yes, most pizzerias in Cape Coral do delivery. Many also offer curbside pickup, which is super handy if you’re in a rush.

3. Where can I find New York-style pizza?
Long Island Brothers New York Pizza is the spot! Their slices are big, thin, and totally delicious. You’ll feel like you’re in NYC!

4. Are these pizzerias good for families?
Oh, definitely! Many places are family-friendly. The atmosphere is casual, and there’s something for everyone on the menu.

5. What are the popular toppings around here?
You can’t go wrong with pepperoni or sausage! But you’ll also find some fun options like BBQ chicken or taco toppings.

6. Can I make reservations at these places?
Some spots do take reservations, like Papa Joe’s. It’s a good idea to call ahead, especially if you’re going on a busy night.

7. Do they have vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes, many places offer vegan and gluten-free pizzas. Just ask the staff, and they’ll help you find something that works for you.

8. How much does pizza cost in Cape Coral?
Most pizzas range from about $10 to $25. It’s a great deal for a tasty meal that the whole family can enjoy!

9. When’s the best time to visit?
Try going on a weeknight. It’s usually quieter. But if you want a lively vibe, weekends can be a blast, especially during game nights!

10. Can I order pizza online?
Absolutely! Most pizzerias let you order online through their websites. It’s a quick way to get your favorite pizza delivered to your door!