Finding great pizza in Brookville, NY isn’t about luck—it’s about knowing where to look. Tucked among tree-lined streets and quiet corners, Brookville serves up more than the college town calm; it surprises you with its pizza options, from classic slices that taste like New York nostalgia to bubbling gourmet pies you’ll want to savor slowly. Years ago, I stumbled across an unassuming spot on a rainy Tuesday, tempted by nothing but the aroma drifting down the block. That single slice—thin, crisp, and flecked with basil—changed my opinion and proved that fantastic pizza can hide in plain sight.
Curiosity drives the best pizza searches, and each stop on this list brings its own flavor. With so many choices, from old-school counter spots to wood-fired upstarts, it can feel overwhelming to pick. This guide isn’t just a list; it’s a roadmap built on real taste-testing, lively local feedback, and a dash of obsession with dough and sauce. For anyone looking to unlock Brookville’s pizza potential, get ready—there’s more to each pizzeria here than just cheese and crust.
Where to find the best pizza in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Brookville, NY:
- Pizza Hut
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Raimos Pizza
- Locust Valley Pizza Cafe
- Mario’s Pizzeria
- Two Bros Pizzeria
- Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn
- Forest Avenue Pizza
- II Villaggio Pizzeria Restaurant
1. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Old Country Road is a familiar classic that delivers reliability with every box. There’s a comfort in knowing exactly what kind of slice awaits you, whether you drop in after work or gather the crew for a weekend movie night. The first time I walked through their doors, the scent of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese was all it took—I was hooked.
The signature pan pizza is sturdy yet soft, and the crust edges have their own loyal fan club. That unique buttery crispness sets it apart. Try the classic Pepperoni Lover’s or Veggie Lover’s if you want balanced toppings and a satisfying bite.
While some pizzerias chase trends, Pizza Hut sticks to what it does best: familiar flavors and that iconic stuffed crust. It’s the spot for easy carryout or casual group dinners—quick, satisfying, and always right where you need it.
2. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Hicksville takes pride in quality ingredients, and you can taste it with every bite. The crust is perfectly golden, always fresh, and the signature sauce packs in a tangy punch. I remember my first order after moving nearby—a late-night craving turned into a new go-to spot, thanks to their consistent flavor and friendly service.
If you’re after a classic taste, the Original Cheese pizza delivers melty mozzarella atop a balanced red sauce. The Garden Fresh pizza is another winner, featuring crisp vegetables without skimping on flavor or texture.
Side options like breadsticks pair nicely for a complete meal. Papa Johns brings both comfort and quality to the table, earning its loyal following near Brookville. Their pizza is straightforward, never fussy, and always satisfying.
3. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Westbury Ave isn’t just about convenience; it’s about delivering a reliable slice at any hour. Their efficient service and late-night hours have saved me more than once after a long study session or when hosting an impromptu movie night.
The Handmade Pan pizza offers a thick, golden crust that stands up to generous toppings. If you’re after that classic Domino’s experience, try the Pepperoni or Pacific Veggie options. Each bite showcases their signature blend of melty cheese and robust sauce.
Domino’s shines with customization—thin crust, gluten-free, or extra cheese to suit any craving. Their creative sauces, like the garlic parmesan white sauce, keep regulars—and the adventurous—coming back for new combos. Alongside salads and pasta, this spot is a dependable choice for Brookville pizza fans.
4. Raimos Pizza
Raimos Pizza on Woodbury Road is that neighborhood gem you hope to stumble upon. The cozy atmosphere pairs with the familiar tang of a well-made sauce and soft, chewy crust. I remember ducking inside on a rainy night, drawn mostly by the inviting glow, but it was the Margherita pizza that won me over with its simple, fresh flavors.
This spot stands out for attention to detail—slices here never taste rushed or mass-produced. Their classic cheese pizza showcases a perfectly balanced blend of mozzarella and tomato. If you’re feeling a bit adventurous, try the White Pizza. Creamy, garlicky, free of unnecessary toppings, it’s Italian comfort straight from the oven.
Raimos keeps it straightforward but never boring, making it a staple for families and college students alike near Brookville.
5. Locust Valley Pizza Cafe
Locust Valley Pizza Cafe is the kind of place where regulars are on a first-name basis with the staff. The laid-back vibe and quick, friendly service make it just as comfortable for grabbing a solo slice as it is for group dinners.
Their Neapolitan-style pies show a real commitment to quality—with crisp edges and a slight char that brings out the dough’s flavor. I still remember my first bite of their Margherita pizza: bright sauce, fresh basil, and melty mozzarella working together in harmony.
For something heartier, their Sicilian pie has a pillowy, flavorful crust and a subtle touch of garlic. Locust Valley Pizza Cafe balances tradition and comfort, making it a reliable stop for anyone serious about pizza near Brookville.
6. Mario’s Pizzeria
Mario’s Pizzeria on Old Country Road keeps things classic. Step inside and you’re greeted by the smell of dough hitting the oven and sauce simmering. I discovered Mario’s during a lunch break; the quick service and friendly atmosphere have brought me back more times than I can count.
Their cheese slice is a study in New York simplicity with a chewy crust, bright sauce, and rich mozzarella. For a heartier meal, the Grandma pie is worth the extra wait—thin, square, and packed with deep tomato flavor and a hint of fresh basil.
Mario’s delivers on that old-school pizza parlor feel, making it a must for anyone seeking true, fuss-free pizza near Brookville.
7. Two Bros Pizzeria
Two Bros Pizzeria in Levittown blends casual comfort with serious know-how in the kitchen. Walk in and you’ll usually spot a few regulars chatting at the counter, and the vibe makes you feel like you belong. My own introduction came from a friend who swore by their pies—and two slices later, I understood the hype.
Their Sicilian pizza stands out: thick, airy crust, a splash of zesty sauce, and plenty of cheese without overwhelming the slice. For something with a twist, the White Pie delivers creamy, garlicky flavor with a golden finish.
Two Bros combines reliable service and big flavors, making it a favorite stop for both classic and creative pizza near Brookville.
8. Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn
Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn puts a creative spin on classic pies while keeping things approachable. On my first visit, I was caught off guard by the sheer variety behind the counter—slices as colorful as they are aromatic. There’s an energy here that only comes from a true neighborhood favorite.
Their Spinach and Ricotta pizza is a standout, with creamy cheese and just the right hit of freshness from the spinach. If you’re in the mood for something traditional, the Margherita pie balances a crisp crust with bright tomato and wisps of basil.
From signature combos to playful toppings, Joanne’s brings both flair and satisfaction for pizza lovers in the Brookville area.
9. Forest Avenue Pizza
Forest Avenue Pizza in Glen Cove brings all the charm of a local favorite without any pretension. There’s a small-town familiarity here—friendly staff, quick service, and slices that hit the spot whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. My first visit was for a casual dinner, but the airy crust and robust sauce quickly turned me into a repeat customer.
Their plain cheese slice is a go-to for its balance of crispness and cheesy comfort. For bigger appetites, the Sicilian pie stands out with its pillowy base and satisfying portion.
Forest Avenue Pizza’s menu stays classic, with just enough variety to keep regulars coming back. This is the place for fuss-free, honest pizza that’s easy to love near Brookville.
10. II Villaggio Pizzeria Restaurant
II Villaggio Pizzeria Restaurant in Sea Cliff feels like a hidden secret tucked along the avenue. The cozy space and friendly staff quickly make new visitors feel like regulars. I popped in once on a whim and was met with that unmistakable aroma of baking dough and fresh herbs—always a good sign.
Their traditional Neapolitan pizza is a standout, with thin crust that’s equal parts chewy and crisp. Simple slices like Margherita or a classic cheese offer the essence of Italian comfort in every bite.
II Villaggio keeps the menu focused, with each pizza reflecting careful preparation and respect for traditions. For a genuine pizzeria experience near Brookville, this spot never disappoints.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are popular in Brookville, NY?
Brookville’s nearby pizzerias serve a wide range—classic New York thin crust, Sicilian square, Neapolitan, and creative gourmet pies. There’s something for fans of tradition and those looking to try new twists.
Where can I get vegetarian pizza options near Brookville?
Many pizzerias offer vegetarian pizzas, including Margherita, Vegetable Lover’s, and White Pizza. Joanne’s Gourmet Pizza-Roslyn and Papa Johns are especially known for their vegetarian-friendly menus.
Do local pizzerias in Brookville offer gluten-free options?
Several chains and independent spots provide gluten-free crusts. Domino’s and some family-owned pizzerias offer customizable gluten-free pizzas—just ask when you call or visit.
Is there a place to find authentic Italian-style pizza near Brookville?
Yes, try II Villaggio Pizzeria Restaurant or Locust Valley Pizza Cafe for Neapolitan and other Italian-inspired pies that focus on fresh, simple ingredients and classic preparation.
What’s the best value pizza in the Brookville area?
Forest Avenue Pizza, Mario’s Pizzeria, and Domino’s are go-tos for affordable prices and reliable quality. Specials and combo meals offer extra savings for families or groups.