There’s something about the way Boise does pizza that makes it hard to settle for just one favorite. I’ve wandered down 8th Street with friends on a brisk afternoon, ducking into local spots where the aroma of charred crust and bubbling cheese feels like a warm handshake. One slice at a time, I’ve come to appreciate the variety—thick dough with punchy tomato sauce, thin crust folded just right, rustic pies kissed by wood-fired ovens. Each stop is a new story, a different spin on what Boise calls its best.
This guide doesn’t just name names—it uncovers the top pizza places in Boise, ID, with sharp insight and honest praise. If you’re searching for a slice worth crossing town for, or maybe a cozy booth to linger over dinner, you’re in the right place. Whether you crave Neapolitan precision or New York foldability, Boise serves it all with no frills and no shortcuts. What follows isn’t hype—it’s clarity, choice, and craveable detail.
Where to find the best pizza in Boise, ID
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Boise, ID:
- The Wylder
- Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza Downtown
- Hilltop Station
- The Front Door Taphouse
- Flatbread Neapolitan Pizzeria
- Flying Pie Pizzaria
- Smoky Mountain Pizzeria Grill
- Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza Chinden
- Red Bench Pizza
- Wiseguy Pizza Pie
1. The Wylder
Located at 501 W Broad St, The Wylder offers a fresh take on Boise’s pizza scene. From the moment I stepped inside, I appreciated its inviting atmosphere and the diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences. The restaurant’s focus on vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options makes it a standout choice for health-conscious diners.
What truly sets The Wylder apart is its commitment to quality and creativity. Their wood-fired pizzas feature crisp, flavorful crusts topped with locally inspired ingredients. I recommend trying their Margherita pizza—simple yet packed with fresh flavor—or the Veggie Delight for a vibrant, satisfying experience that reflects The Wylder’s dedication to flavor and inclusivity.
2. Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza Downtown
Situated at 235 N 5th St, Guido’s is a true taste of New York right in Boise. I recall biting into their classic slices, where the thin, foldable crust perfectly balances crispness and chew. The lively atmosphere and the aroma of baking cheese make it a favorite stop for both locals and visitors.
Guido’s stands out with its authentic New York style pizza—large, shareable slices loaded with fresh toppings. I highly recommend the Sicilian Square for its hearty, thick crust or the Margherita for a simple, flavorful experience. It embodies quality, tradition, and a genuine New York pizza spirit that’s hard to beat in Boise.
3. Hilltop Station
Perched in the scenic foothills of Boise, Hilltop Station feels like a welcoming retreat from the busy city. I discovered this gem during a roadside trip, and its cozy, rustic vibe instantly made me feel at home. Beyond its warm atmosphere, the restaurant offers a diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.
What makes Hilltop Station truly special is its long-standing history and commitment to quality. Their wood-fired pizza boasts a perfectly charred crust and fresh toppings that highlight Idaho’s local ingredients. I recommend trying the Veggie Delight or the classic Pineapple & Ham pizza—both reflecting the restaurant’s dedication to flavorful, high-quality comfort food in a friendly setting.
4. The Front Door Taphouse
Right in the heart of downtown Boise, The Front Door Taphouse brings together two essentials—great pizza and carefully curated local brews. I found it during a casual evening walk and was pulled in by the scent of melting cheese and fresh dough. Inside, the relaxed, family-friendly vibe makes it easy to stay awhile.
What makes this place shine is the pairing of house-made pizzas with a rotating selection of local microbrews. The crust here has just the right chew, and the toppings are layered with intention. I recommend the Veggie Supreme for its balance of flavor and texture or the Classic Margherita, which lets the fresh ingredients speak for themselves. It’s simple, satisfying, and unmistakably Boise.
5. Flatbread Neapolitan Pizzeria
Located at 3139 S Bown Way, Flatbread Neapolitan Pizzeria offers an authentic taste of Italy right in Boise. I enjoyed visiting for a relaxed evening, where the aroma of wood-fired pizzas filled the air. The vibrant, lively atmosphere makes it a great spot for families or friends seeking quality and fun.
What sets Flatbread apart is its certified Neapolitan pizzas, baked at 900 degrees in their traditional wood oven. Their Margherita and Prosciutto & Arugula pizzas showcase fresh, high-quality ingredients and artisanal craftsmanship. Whether dining in or sharing a pie from their full bar selection, you experience a blend of tradition and modern urban flair that’s truly memorable.
6. Flying Pie Pizzaria
Located at 6508 W Fairview Ave, Flying Pie Pizzaria is a Boise staple known for its welcoming atmosphere and creative pizza options. I recall visiting on a relaxed evening, trying their signature Flying Pie Supreme, which had just the right balance of toppings and a crisp, flavorful crust. The lively vibe makes it perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.
What makes Flying Pie unique is its variety of specialty pizzas and commitment to quality. Their Veggie Lover’s Pizza is a standout for vegetarians, while the Meat Lover’s satisfies fans of hearty toppings. Pair your slice with a local brew for a true Boise experience focused on great food, good company, and excellent beer.
7. Smoky Mountain Pizzeria Grill
Located at 415 E Parkcenter Blvd, Smoky Mountain Pizzeria Grill has been a local favorite in East Boise for over 20 years. I visited during a family night out and appreciated its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu. The option for Kids to make their own pizza made it a hit with my children, adding a fun twist to dining.
What sets Smoky Mountain apart is its commitment to from-scratch cooking and a variety of dietary options, including gluten-free, vegan, and keto choices. For pizza, I recommend the BBQ Chicken Pizza for its smoky flavor or the Veggie Delight to enjoy fresh, vibrant toppings. The combination of quality, variety, and family-friendly ambiance makes it a standout.
8. Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza Chinden
Tucked along W Chinden Blvd, Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza Chinden brings the Bronx to Boise without the jet lag. The moment I stepped inside, the scent of crisped dough and oregano hit like a warm memory. Service was fast, and slices were ready to fold, just like they should be.
This spot stands out for its authenticity. The crust is thin but not floppy, with the perfect balance of crunch and chew. The atmosphere? No-frills, just straightforward comfort. Vegetarian-friendly options also make it welcoming for everyone.
If it’s your first visit, try the White Pizza or the classic Pepperoni Slice. Both highlight Guido’s devotion to bold flavor and well-balanced toppings—proof that simplicity done right still reigns supreme.
9. Red Bench Pizza
Located at 1200 South Vista Avenue, Red Bench Pizza offers a welcoming, modern twist on classic pizza. I visited on a chilly evening and was immediately drawn by the warm atmosphere and vibrant menu. The restaurant’s focus on vegetarian and vegan options makes it a top choice for diverse dietary needs.
What makes Red Bench special is their commitment to quality ingredients and creative toppings. I highly recommend trying the Margherita Pizza for fresh simplicity or the Veggie Delight loaded with seasonal produce. Their pies reflect a balance of flavor and freshness, making every bite satisfying without sacrificing dietary inclusivity.
10. Wiseguy Pizza Pie
Located at 570 W Main St, Wiseguy Pizza Pie offers a casual yet vibrant pizza experience in Boise. I visited on a busy weekend and was impressed by the lively vibe and quick service. The place’s focus on vegetarian options and generous slices makes it perfect for a relaxed meal.
What sets Wiseguy apart is its style of hearty, flavorful pizza with a creative twist. I recommend ordering the Supreme Pizza for a mix of meats and veggies or the Veggie Special to enjoy fresh, colorful toppings. Their pizzas reflect a commitment to quality, big flavors, and a fun, approachable atmosphere.
More Things to Try in Boise, ID
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Boise, ID?
Some of the top-rated pizza spots in Boise include The Wylder, Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza, Flatbread Neapolitan Pizzeria, Wiseguy Pizza Pie, and Flying Pie Pizzaria. Each offers a unique style, from New York thin crusts to artisan wood-fired pies.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Boise?
Yes, many places like Wiseguy Pizza Pie, Flatbread Neapolitan, and Red Bench Pizza offer dedicated vegetarian pizzas with fresh and flavorful toppings.
Who serves authentic New York-style pizza in Boise?
Check out Guido’s Original New York Style Pizza, both Downtown and Chinden locations. They’re known for their thin crust, large slices, and a no-frills approach that New Yorkers would appreciate.
Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Boise?
Head to Flatbread Neapolitan Pizzeria or The Wylder. Both restaurants are popular for their wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pies that balance charred crusts with bold flavors.
Is there a late-night pizza spot in Boise?
Yes, Pie Hole Pizza is a local favorite for late-night slices, especially among students and night owls looking for quick, casual bites.
Which Boise pizzerias are family-friendly?
Smoky Mountain Pizzeria Grill and Idaho Pizza Company are known for their family-friendly atmosphere, kid-friendly menus, and plenty of seating for larger groups.
Does Boise have any gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, several spots such as Extreme Pizza, North End Pizzeria, and Romios Greek and Italian Restaurant provide gluten-free crusts and can accommodate dietary preferences.
Are there dine-in and delivery options available?
Most Boise pizza places offer both dine-in and delivery, including Flying Pie Pizzaria, Idaho Pizza Company, and Westside Pizza. Always check hours and availability before placing an order.
What’s the average cost of a pizza in Boise?
A standard 12-inch pizza usually ranges from $12 to $20, depending on the location and ingredients. Specialty pizzas or gourmet toppings may cost more.
Are there halal pizza options in Boise?
Halal-specific pizza options are limited. It’s best to contact the restaurant directly to ask about ingredient sourcing or look for places that offer vegetarian-friendly menus as an alternative.