Bloomington, IL, is a hidden gem for pizza lovers. It boasts a diverse range of pizzerias, each with its own unique twist on a classic dish. Whether you’re craving a gooey, cheesy slice or a thin crust loaded with fresh toppings, this city has something to satisfy any pizza aficionado.
After countless visits to local spots, I’ve navigated the doughy landscape of Bloomington and discovered some truly standout places. From the cozy atmosphere of family-owned joints to the efficient service of popular chains, each pizzeria has its own charm and flavor profile. Let’s dive into the best pizza options in Bloomington, IL, and explore where to find your next great meal. Your taste buds will thank you for it.
Where to find the best pizza in Bloomington, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Bloomington, IL:
- Monical’s Pizza
- Rosati’s Pizza of Bloomington/Normal
- Tobin’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Cj’s Restaurant & Catering
- Giordano’s
- Pizza Hut
- Pizza Payaa
- D’agostino’s Pizza
1. Monical’s Pizza
Monical’s Pizza, established in 1959, combines tradition with taste in every slice. Located at 2103 N Veterans Pkwy, this quick-service restaurant is beloved for its casual atmosphere and extensive menu, featuring more than just pizza. Their starters and salads are just as enticing as the main attraction.
What sets Monical’s apart is their thin-crust pizza, which is a local favorite. On my last visit, I savored the delicious pepperoni and extra cheese, perfectly crisped to golden perfection. For something unique, try their Malnati salad as a side—it’s refreshing and complements the rich flavors of the pizza.
If you’re in Bloomington, Monical’s offers a pizza experience that resonates with the heart of the community. It’s not just a meal; it’s a slice of local culture.
2. Rosati’s Pizza of Bloomington/Normal
Rosati’s Pizza of Bloomington/Normal offers a rich culinary heritage dating back to 1927 when Saverio Rosati’s Chicago restaurant became a hotspot for celebrities and politicians. Today, this legacy continues in Bloomington, IL, where the Rosati family tradition thrives. The warm, inviting atmosphere and commitment to quality make it a standout dining destination.
My visit to Rosati’s was memorable due to the authentic flavors and friendly service. The deep-dish pizza, with its perfectly baked crust and generous toppings, stood out. The Classic Margherita Pizza showcased fresh ingredients and rich, tangy tomato sauce, reflecting Rosati’s dedication to quality.
For a true taste of Rosati’s, try the Signature Chicago-Style Pizza. Its hearty layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings represent the essence of Rosati’s culinary excellence. Each bite delivers a delightful blend of flavors, making it a must-try in Bloomington.
3. Tobin’s Pizza
Tobin’s Pizza has been a cornerstone of the Bloomington-Normal pizza scene for over 50 years, recognized as the #1 Pizza in McLean County. Their commitment to quality shines through in every pie, made fresh without fillers or pre-cooked ingredients. Located at 1513 N Main St, this pizzeria is all about delivering a genuine pizza experience.
On my recent visit, I was impressed by the thin crust pizza, which was perfectly baked to a crisp and topped with fresh ingredients. The Garden Vegetable Pizza is a standout, showcasing seasonal veggies and a savory blend of cheeses that captures the essence of Italian cooking.
If you’re looking for a hearty option, the deep-dish pizza is a must-try. Its gooey cheese and robust toppings create a satisfying meal that embodies the passion Tobin’s has for pizza. With friendly service and a neighborhood vibe, Tobin’s Pizza truly delivers on taste.
4. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at 2205 E Oakland Ave offers a blend of convenience and flavor that appeals to pizza lovers in Bloomington. With a strong focus on quality and customer satisfaction, Domino’s takes pride in delivering a wide range of pizzas, whether you prefer thin, foldable New York-style or their hearty Handmade Pan pizza.
On my last order, I couldn’t resist trying the Parmesan Stuffed Crust Pizza. The cheesy filling elevated the dish, making it indulgent and satisfying. Domino’s also offers fantastic value, like their Bogo deal on two medium pizzas, which is perfect for gatherings or a cozy night in.
Beyond pizza, their menu features items like mac and cheese and flavorful chicken wings, ensuring there’s something for everyone. If you’re seeking a dependable choice with diverse options, Domino’s Pizza won’t disappoint.
5. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza at 1407 N Veterans Pkwy, Bloomington, IL, is dedicated to delivering Better Ingredients, Better Pizza. With a focus on high-quality ingredients, their pizzas stand out for their fresh, original dough and signature sauce. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick carryout or opting for delivery, you can always expect delicious, freshly-made pizza.
During my visit, the friendly staff at Papa Johns ensured a seamless experience. The Pepperoni Pizza, loaded with generous toppings and melted cheese, was a highlight. The crust was perfectly crisp, and the sauce had a delightful blend of flavors.
Why Papa Johns Pizza stands out: Their commitment to quality ingredients and consistent taste sets them apart in Bloomington. For a must-try, go for their BBQ Chicken Pizza – it’s a perfect mix of tangy BBQ sauce, tender chicken, and fresh onions.
For pizza lovers in Bloomington, Papa Johns is a top choice for a satisfying meal. Their variety includes not just pizzas but also breadsticks and wings, making it a great spot for any occasion.
6. Cj’s Restaurant & Catering
(309) 663-4444Call
CJ’s Restaurant & Catering at 2901 E Empire St is a versatile dining destination in Bloomington, IL, offering a diverse menu that caters to every craving. With spacious seating and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s perfect for family gatherings or casual outings.
During my visit, I was impressed by the variety of options available, especially the pizza menu. Their Classic Cheese Pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and showcases a delightful crust that pairs perfectly with their rich tomato sauce.
CJ’s stands out not only for its extensive menu, which includes breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, but also for the family-friendly vibe. If you’re in the mood for something unique, I recommend trying the Pizza with a Twist, featuring a blend of unexpected toppings that highlights their creative approach to classic dishes.
For a casual yet satisfying meal, CJ’s offers an inviting atmosphere combined with quality food that keeps locals coming back.
7. Giordano’s
Giordano’s, located at 1505 N Veterans Pkwy, is a haven for lovers of Chicago-style deep dish pizza in Bloomington, IL. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, Giordano’s is the perfect place to gather for a hearty meal or to order for a cozy night in.
On my last visit, the aroma of fresh baked pizza was inviting. The signature Stuffed Deep Dish Pizza truly exceeded expectations. It’s generously filled with layers of cheese and rich toppings, all enveloped by a flaky crust that holds it all together.
What makes Giordano’s stand out is their commitment to authentic flavors and quality ingredients. For a must-try, order the Italian Sausage Deep Dish—it perfectly blends savory sausage with gooey cheese, embodying the best of what Giordano’s has to offer. This is a pizza experience not to be missed.
8. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 103 E Hamilton Rd is a go-to spot for anyone craving satisfying and classic pizza in Bloomington, IL. Known for their versatile menu and commitment to quality, they’ve been a staple in the community for years, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
During my last visit, I ordered the Original Stuffed Crust Pizza, and it delivered a delightful combination of rich flavors and a comforting, cheesy experience. The stuffed crust adds an irresistible twist that sets it apart from other pizza options.
Pizza Hut truly stands out with its variety, featuring classics like the Meat Lovers® Pizza and flavorful signature wings. If you’re in the mood for something different, their pasta options are worth exploring too. For a convenient meal that satisfies, Pizza Hut is an excellent choice.
9. Pizza Payaa
Pizza Payaa at 4 Currency Dr is a delightful spot for pizza enthusiasts in Bloomington, IL. Focused on crafting the best pizza, they take pride in their dough-making process, emphasizing time, effort, and love to create a perfect base that forms the heart of their pies.
During a recent visit, I was struck by the crispy, airy perfection of their crust, which set the stage for generous toppings and fresh ingredients. The Margherita Pizza was a standout, showcasing bright tomato sauce, fresh basil, and gooey mozzarella that highlighted the quality of their offerings.
What makes Pizza Payaa unique is their commitment to daily improvement in dough and flavor. For a delightful experience, order their Pizza Payaa Special, featuring a mix of savory toppings that exemplify their passion for pizza. It’s a local gem worth exploring.
10. D’agostino’s Pizza
D’Agostino’s Pizza, located at 608 N Main St, brings authentic thin crust and Chicago-style pizza to Bloomington, IL. Established in 1968, this family-owned pizzeria is renowned for its commitment to quality and has made a name for itself since its early days near Wrigley Field in Chicago.
My experience there was delightful; the inviting atmosphere made it feel like a true neighborhood gem. I ordered the Classic Thin Crust Pizza, and it did not disappoint. The thin, crispy base perfectly supported generous toppings, complemented by a rich sauce that danced on the palate.
D’Agostino’s stands out due to its rich heritage and authentic recipes. For a special treat, I recommend trying their Italian Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza. It showcases the perfect balance of savory flavors that highlight their dedication to crafting quality pizza.
More Things to Try in Bloomington, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Bloomington, IL?
Some top spots include Monical’s Pizza, Rosati’s Pizza, and Giordano’s for their delicious offerings and unique crust styles. Each place has its own specialty, making them favorites among locals.
2. Does Bloomington offer any pizza delivery options?
Yes, many pizzerias in Bloomington provide delivery, including popular chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut, as well as local favorites like Tobin’s Pizza and D’Agostino’s Pizza. Check their websites or call for delivery details.
3. Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Bloomington?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, including Pizza Payaa and Giordano’s, offer a variety of vegetarian toppings, allowing you to customize your pizza according to your preferences.
4. What type of pizza is Bloomington known for?
Bloomington is known for a mix of styles, including Chicago-style deep-dish and thin crust pizzas. Each restaurant often serves its interpretation of traditional recipes, providing a taste of the local pizza culture.
5. Are there gluten-free pizza options available in Bloomington?
Yes, several pizzerias, such as Papa John’s and Pizza Hut, offer gluten-free crust options. It’s best to check with individual restaurants to confirm availability.
6. Is pizza in Bloomington suitable for kids?
Definitely. Most pizzerias, like CJ’s Restaurant & Catering and Pizza Hut, have kid-friendly menus featuring smaller portions and simple toppings that appeal to younger diners.
7. Can I host a pizza party in Bloomington?
Yes, many pizzerias offer catering services, perfect for pizza parties or events. Places like D’Agostino’s Pizza provide options for larger orders to satisfy your guests.