Best Pizza in Batavia, IL

Batavia, Illinois, is a pizza lover’s dream. I’ve checked out all the spots. Trust me, this town knows its pies.

So, where’s the best pizza in Batavia? You’ve got a ton of great choices. From gooey cheese to perfect crusts, every place brings something special.

Stick around. I’ll share the must-visit pizzerias and what makes them stand out. You won’t want to miss it!

Top 10 Pizza in Batavia, IL

1. Riverside Pizza & Pub – Batavia
2. WindMill Grille & Pizzeria
3. Louie Angelo’s Pizza & Italian
4. Rosati’s Pizza batavia
5. Pal Joey’s
6. Charlie Fox’s Pizzeria
7. Papa Johns Pizza
8. Main Street Pizza Company
9. Domino’s Pizza
10. Little Caesars Pizza

1. Riverside Pizza & Pub – Batavia

Riverside Pizza & Pub is a favorite of mine. It’s right in the heart of Batavia. The vibe is lively and fun. You can sit inside or enjoy the outdoor seating.

What really stands out here is the pizza. It’s delicious! The crust is crispy, and the cheese is so gooey. I love how friendly everyone is too. You always feel welcome.

When you go, you’ve got to try the Riverside Special. It’s loaded with everything good! Don’t forget to grab their garlic breadsticks. They’re warm, buttery, and the perfect side for your pizza. Trust me, you’ll love it!

2. WindMill Grille & Pizzeria

WindMill Grille & Pizzeria is one of my favorite spots in Batavia. It feels warm and welcoming. You can choose to eat inside or outside, which is nice.

This place really stands out to me. Their pizza is amazing! I tried the spicy Italian sausage pizza and loved it. The flavors are bold, and the crust is super crispy.

When you visit, don’t skip the WindMill Supreme. It’s piled high with toppings! Also, their cheesy garlic bread is a must-try. It’s warm and gooey—totally delicious. You won’t regret it!

3. Louie Angelo’s Pizza & Italian

Oh, you have to try Louie Angelo’s Pizza & Italian. It’s this cozy little spot in Batavia. It feels so warm and inviting. I love how laid-back it is. You can sit inside or outside. Both are super nice.

Their pizza? Oh wow, it’s amazing. The crust is just perfect. It’s crispy but still soft enough inside. I can’t stop thinking about their Margherita pizza. It’s loaded with fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil. Honestly, every bite is pure happiness.

You know what I noticed? Everything feels so well thought out there. The staff are so kind and quick. It makes a huge difference. Oh, and you have to order their garlic knots. They’re soft, buttery, and so addictive. You’ll leave with a big smile!

4. Rosati’s Pizza batavia

Rosati’s Pizza in Batavia is such a great spot. It’s part of a famous chain. The vibe here is super friendly. You can sit inside or enjoy the outdoor seating. I love that!

The Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is what really steals the show. It’s thick and loaded with goodness. I remember my first bite. The cheese just stretched, and the sauce was so rich. It’s honestly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

What keeps me coming back is how tasty everything is. The staff is always nice and quick. You feel right at home.

If you go, definitely get the deep-dish pizza. The sausage and pepperoni combo is a must-try! And don’t miss out on their breadsticks. They’re warm, buttery, and perfect for dipping in the sauce!

5. Pal Joey’s

Oh, Pal Joey’s is a favorite of mine. It’s cozy and welcoming. The kind of place that feels like home. Whether you’re inside or out, it’s just lovely.

Their pizza is something else. Thin-crust? Super crunchy, just how I like it. Pan pizza? Soft, cheesy, and absolutely mouthwatering. Both are so good.

And guess what? There’s live music. It makes the place come alive. It’s perfect for an evening out with friends.

You have to try the Margherita pizza. The flavors are fresh and bright. The garlic bread? It’s buttery, warm, and simply irresistible. Trust me, you’ll want to order extras. Pal Joey’s truly knows how to make food that sticks with you. You’ll be planning your next visit right away.

6. Charlie Fox’s Pizzeria

Charlie Fox’s Pizzeria is one of my go-to spots in Batavia. It has that cozy, friendly feel. I love grabbing a slice after work. They offer different crusts, which is super fun.

What stands out here? It’s the choices! They have great pizzas, but also ribs and wings. It’s more than just pizza, and everything tastes amazing. The staff always makes you feel at home.

When I visit, I always get their classic cheese pizza. It’s so cheesy and delicious! If you’re in the mood for something spicy, the buffalo wings are a must-try. They’re packed with flavor!

The prices are great too. You can enjoy a tasty meal without breaking the bank. You’ll definitely leave happy and satisfied!

7. Papa Johns Pizza

Papa Johns Pizza is my go-to for a quick meal. It’s right on North Randall Road. The best part? They offer delivery and takeout, which I love.

What makes Papa Johns stand out? Their pizzas are always fresh! The crust is crispy on the outside and soft inside. Each bite is packed with flavor. Plus, they have tons of options, including wings and sides.

I often order the Pepperoni Pizza. It’s loaded with pepperoni and super cheesy. You’ll definitely want to try it! And don’t forget the cinnamon pull-aparts for dessert. They are warm and so delicious!

With great prices and tasty food, you can’t go wrong here. You’ll leave happy and satisfied every time!

8. Main Street Pizza Company

Main Street Pizza Company is such a charming spot! Located right on East Main Street, it feels like a cozy old-fashioned pizza place. Whether you sit inside or outside, the vibe is so inviting. They even offer delivery and takeout, which I find super helpful.

What I love most is their pizza. You can choose deep-dish or thin-crust, and both are fantastic. The flavors just pop! Plus, their wings and subs are delicious too. It’s a great place for a casual meal.

When I go, I always order the deep-dish pizza. It’s cheesy and oh-so-satisfying. And don’t skip the wings—hot and crispy, just how I like them! Main Street Pizza Company is definitely a must-visit!

9. Domino’s Pizza

Domino’s Pizza is my quick fix for tasty pizza. Located on North Randall Road, it’s super convenient. I really appreciate their curbside pickup and delivery options. They make ordering so easy!

What I love about Domino’s? There’s so much to choose from! You can customize your pizza and pick from lots of sides. Plus, the prices are really good.

My favorite order is definitely the pepperoni pizza. It’s cheesy, flavorful, and always fresh. I also can’t resist their breadsticks. They’re warm, cheesy, and perfect for dipping into marinara sauce. Domino’s always hits the spot!

10. Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza is one of my favorite spots in Batavia. Located on South Randall Road, it’s super easy to get to. They have great takeout and delivery. Plus, the entrance is accessible for everyone.

What I love about Little Caesars? The prices are so good! You get a lot of pizza for your money. Their pizzas are always hot and fresh. The flavors are bold and satisfying.

When I go there, I can’t resist the Classic Pepperoni pizza. It’s cheesy and tasty every time. And the Crazy Bread? Wow, it’s a must-try! It’s warm and buttery, perfect for dipping. Little Caesars never lets me down!

Map of Pizza in Batavia, IL

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

• What’s the best pizza in Batavia?
  Honestly, you can’t go wrong with Riverside Pizza or Pal Joey’s. The flavors are top-notch, and the atmosphere is cozy.

• Can I get pizza delivered in Batavia?
  Absolutely, most spots like Domino’s and Papa John’s deliver. Just check their delivery zones first.

• Do they have gluten-free options here?
  Yep! Many places, like Rosati’s Pizza, have gluten-free crusts. Just ask when ordering.

• Which places are good for families?
  Riverside Pizza & Pub and Charlie Fox’s are awesome. They’re welcoming and have big, comfy spaces.

• What’s the most popular topping here?
  Oh, definitely pepperoni or sausage. But a lot of folks love mushrooms too.

• Are vegetarian pizzas available?
  Yes, tons of choices. Veggie pizzas with olives and peppers are everywhere.

• What’s the price for a pizza?
  Usually around $10 to $20 for a medium. There are always great deals, though.

• Where can I sit and eat pizza?
  WindMill Grille and Main Street Pizza are nice for dine-in. Super chill spots.

• What about late-night pizza?
  Domino’s is your best bet for late-night cravings. They’re open pretty late.

• Can I build my own pizza?
  Oh, for sure! Most places let you pick everything. Crust, toppings, you name it.