Best Pizza in Barrie, ON

I’ve tasted a lot of pizza in my time. Barrie, Ontario, really surprised me. It’s a cozy spot packed with great pizza joints. Each place has its own charm. Trust me, you’re in for a treat!

So, what’s the best pizza in Barrie? Honestly, it’s hard to nail down just one. Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint, PizzaCAPO, and Paezano’s Pizza & Marketplace are among the favorites. Each offers tasty pies and a welcoming vibe. You’ll find something special at every stop.

Stick around! I’ll share my top picks and why I love them. Let’s dive into the delicious world of Barrie’s best pizza!

Top 10 Pizza in Barrie, ON

1. Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint
2. PizzaCAPO
3. Doughbox Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta Barrie
4. Jimmy Chews [ Primo – Pizza ]
5. Pizzaiolo
6. P_ZZA
7. Pizza People & Sub
8. Paezano’s Pizza & Marketplace
9. Cocelli Pizza
10. Pizza Nova

1. Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint

Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint is a real gem in Barrie. The moment I walked in, I felt at home. The warm, cozy vibe pulled me in right away. And that smell! It’s hard to resist the aroma of pizza baking in a wood-fired oven.

On my last visit, I tried the Pie-Za. Wow! It had prosciutto, fresh arugula, and just the right amount of truffle oil. Every bite was delicious! The crust was crispy but fluffy—really amazing.

What makes this place stand out is the quality. They use fresh, top-notch ingredients. The staff is friendly too, always ready to help.

If you’re planning to visit, don’t miss the Pie-Za or the classic Margherita. Both are super tasty and show off their style perfectly!

2. PizzaCAPO

PizzaCAPO is such a fun place to visit. It feels so warm and welcoming. The moment I stepped in, I could smell the freshly baked pizzas. It made my mouth water instantly.

I remember trying the Capo Classic. Oh, it was so good! Packed with pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers. Each bite was bursting with flavor. And that crispy crust? Absolute perfection.

This place stands out for all the right reasons. They use fresh ingredients that make every pizza pop with taste. Plus, the staff are super friendly and make you feel at ease.

If you’re visiting, don’t miss the Capo Classic. It’s a crowd-pleaser! And the Margherita? Simple but so fresh and full of flavor. You’ll love them both!

3. Doughbox Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta Barrie

Doughbox Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta Barrie is a real treat! It’s such a chill place. When I walked in, the smell of pizza and fresh dough hit me right away. I was ready to dig in!

On my last visit, I had the Mushroom Delight pizza. Wow, it was fantastic! The mushrooms were fresh and flavorful. The crust was crispy, and the cheese was gooey. Every bite was so yummy!

What makes Doughbox special is their care for quality. Everything is made fresh. The wood-fired oven gives each pizza a smoky taste that’s just amazing.

If you stop by, definitely try the Mushroom Delight. And don’t forget their Veggie Supreme! It’s loaded with fresh veggies and super delicious. You won’t regret it!

4. Jimmy Chews [ Primo – Pizza ]

Jimmy Chews [Primo – Pizza] is tucked away on Mulcaster Street in Barrie. It’s such a cozy spot to grab a bite. The place feels warm and inviting. You can choose to sit indoors or outdoors, which is nice. It’s perfect for hanging out with friends or family.

I loved their wood-fired pizzas. The crust has that perfect smoky crunch. The toppings are super fresh and flavorful. Their Margherita pizza? Oh, it’s a dream! Cheesy, fresh, and just enough basil. If you’re into bold flavors, try the BBQ Chicken pizza. It’s got this sweet, tangy, smoky kick. So good!

What really stands out is how friendly the staff are. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible and great for takeout too. Jimmy Chews truly has it all!

5. Pizzaiolo

Pizzaiolo on Yonge Street, Barrie, is a real find. This place serves thick-crust pizzas with fancy toppings. The vibe is super chill, ideal for a quick bite. They have housemade sauces and options for gluten-free folks.

So, I tried the Classic Margherita pizza. Wow, it was so good! The crust was thick and chewy. The fresh tomatoes and basil were perfect.

What makes Pizzaiolo special? The quality. They use fresh stuff and make each pizza with love. The staff is super friendly too.

If you go, get the Classic Margherita. It’s amazing. Also, try the BBQ Chicken pizza. Both are delicious and show off their style!

6. P_ZZA

So, there’s this cozy spot in Barrie called P_ZZA. It’s right on Dunlop Street East, super easy to find. They’ve got both indoor and outdoor seating. You can also order delivery or takeout, which is great.

Now, let me tell you about their pizza. It’s all about fresh ingredients. Seriously, the crust is crispy, the sauce is smooth, and the toppings are super tasty. You can tell they put a lot of thought into each pizza.

One thing you must try is their “Truffle Deluxe.” It’s got truffle oil, mushrooms, and mozzarella. It’s so rich and yummy. Don’t forget to get some garlic knots too. They’re a nice extra treat.

P_ZZA is more than just a place to eat. It’s where you enjoy good food and have a great time. Whether you eat there or order in, it’s always a good choice in Barrie.

7. Pizza People & Sub

Pizza People & Sub is such a great spot in Barrie! It’s located on Duckworth Street, so it’s super easy to get to. The place has a nice, casual vibe. I love that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s really welcoming and cozy.

What I love most is the prices. They’re very affordable, which is awesome. Even with the low prices, their food is super fresh and tasty. I’ve always had a good experience, whether dining in or getting takeout.

You have to try their “Meat Lovers Special.” It’s loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. It’s so flavorful and satisfying! Their subs are also fantastic. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

8. Paezano’s Pizza & Marketplace

Paezano’s Pizza & Marketplace is at 35 Cedar Pointe Dr, Barrie. It has curbside pickup, delivery, and seating. Prices are low. The place is wheelchair accessible.

My first visit was great! The staff were so nice. The smell of pizza was amazing. I sat down and couldn’t wait to eat.

Paezano’s stands out. They use fresh ingredients. The pizza tastes great. Try the Margherita pizza. The tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil are perfect.

Also, try the garlic knots. They are soft and buttery. They taste so good with the pizza. Paezano’s is a must-visit for good, cheap pizza in Barrie.

9. Cocelli Pizza

Cocelli Pizza is such a cool spot in Barrie! It’s located at 241 Essa Rd #8. They keep it simple, offering pizza, pasta, wings, and poutine. It’s a no-frills place, but that’s why I love it. You can eat in or get it delivered. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair accessible, which is great.

When I first went there, I felt right at home. The staff were super friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere was cozy, and I was excited to try their food.

What really stands out at Cocelli is the freshness. Their pepperoni pizza is a must-try. It’s classic and so tasty! Also, the wings are fantastic. They’re crispy and packed with flavor. You won’t be disappointed!

10. Pizza Nova

Pizza Nova is located on Dunlop Street West in Barrie. It’s a great place for a casual meal. The vibe is relaxed, and you can dine inside or outside. Plus, the prices are super affordable!

When I walked in, the smell of pizza made my mouth water. The staff were really friendly and helped me out right away. I love that you can build your own pizza. It’s fun to choose your favorite toppings!

I definitely recommend the ‘Pepperoni Duo.’ It’s packed with flavor and always hits the spot. If you’re in the mood for something quick and tasty, Pizza Nova is the place to go! You won’t be disappointed.

Map of Pizza in Barrie, ON

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Restaurant	Price	Seating	Takeout	Delivery	Wheelchair	Reservation
Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
PizzaCAPO	–	No	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Doughbox Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta Barrie	–	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Jimmy Chews [ Primo – Pizza ]	–	Yes	Yes	–	Accessible	–
Pizzaiolo	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
P_ZZA	–	Yes	Yes	Yes	–	No
Pizza People & Sub	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Paezano’s Pizza & Marketplace	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Cocelli Pizza	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Pizza Nova	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best pizza places in Barrie, ON?
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Barrie, I recommend checking out Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint and PizzaCAPO. They both have amazing flavors and awesome vibes.

2. Do any pizzerias in Barrie offer gluten-free options?
Yes! Many places, like Doughbox and Pizza Nova, have gluten-free crusts. Just ask when you order, and they’ll take care of you.

3. Can I order pizza for delivery in Barrie?
Absolutely! Most pizza spots, like Cocelli Pizza and P_ZZA, deliver right to your door. It’s super easy and convenient.

4. Are there vegetarian pizza options available in Barrie?
For sure! Most pizzerias offer great vegetarian options. You can find lots of veggie toppings to enjoy.

5. What are some popular pizza toppings in Barrie?
In Barrie, people love classic toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives. You can also find fun options like barbecue chicken or truffle oil!

6. Is it possible to customize my pizza?
Definitely! Places like Pizza Nova and P_ZZA let you build your own pizza. You can choose everything from the crust to the toppings!

7. Are there any family-friendly pizza restaurants in Barrie?
Yes! Many spots, like Jimmy Chews and Paezano’s, are great for families. Kids love pizza, so everyone has a good time!

8. How do I find pizza deals or discounts in Barrie?
Check the websites of local pizzerias for deals. You can also follow them on social media for tasty discounts!