Hunting for the best pizza in Atlantic City, NJ is an adventure worth savoring. I’ve strolled the boardwalk in the salty night air, chased the glowing casino lights, and slipped into corner pizzerias where the scent alone was enough to turn any passing plan into dinner. Sometimes, that perfect slice comes from a bustling old-school joint packed with locals and stories. Other times, it’s a new spot with flavors that make you pause with every bite.
Atlantic City’s pizza scene is a tapestry of bold sauce, bubbling cheese, and crusts that range from paper-thin to satisfyingly chewy. If you’re after tried-and-true classics or ready to chase something unexpected, this guide is your insider map. Each spot on this list has earned its place, serving up slices that’ll keep you coming back. Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best pizza in Atlantic City, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Atlantic City, NJ:
- Tony’s Baltimore Grill
- Tony Boloney’s – Atlantic City
- Famous Famiglia Pizzeria
- Gino’s Pizza
- Three Brothers Pizza
- Pizata Pizza Pasta
- Pizata at the Marketplace Eatery
- Mario’s 2 Pizzaria
- Pin-Up Pizza
- Rhythm & Spirits
1. Tony’s Baltimore Grill
Tony’s Baltimore Grill has a legendary aura that only comes with decades of late nights and secret recipes. As soon as you step inside, the red booths and jukebox set a classic tone. Few spots capture Atlantic City’s gritty charm like this one.
The pizza—simple, bold, and comforting—sets Tony’s apart. The sauce has a touch of sweetness and the cheese forms a perfectly golden top. Order a plain cheese or try their pepper-infused veggie pie for that elusive balance of flavor. Each slice carries a satisfying chew that makes you reach for another, even if you promised yourself just one more.
If you want a taste of old Atlantic City and pizza that doesn’t mess around, Tony’s is the place.
2. Tony Boloney’s – Atlantic City
Tony Boloney’s – Atlantic City is where culinary curiosity meets wild creativity. The first time I stepped through the door, I spotted pizzas you’d never find on a standard menu. The vibe here is playful, laid-back, and just a little daring.
Expect pizzas piled high with inspired toppings, from fresh veggies to spicy house-made sauces. If you’re feeling bold, order the “Sh#t Faced” pizza—just ask for it without haram ingredients for a loaded slice packed with layered, zesty flavor. Their classic “Plain Jane” is anything but ordinary, thanks to a crispy, chewy crust and impeccable balance of cheese and sauce.
For those looking for flavor with personality, Tony Boloney’s delivers an experience you won’t soon forget.
3. Famous Famiglia Pizzeria
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria sits right on the Boardwalk, drawing in everyone from casino regulars to beachgoers with its welcoming aroma. My first slice here came as a quick pit stop turned slow savor—one bite and I found myself lingering to enjoy every chew.
Their New York-style pizza shines through: a foldable crust, just enough chew, and a bright, tangy sauce that balances the melted cheese. It’s pizza that plays to the classics and does so confidently. If you’re looking for something that satisfies without any fuss, a plain cheese or veggie slice nails it every time.
Whether you’re escaping the hustle outside or fueling up before another round in the casino, Famiglia makes simplicity taste seriously good.
4. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza looks like a simple spot from the outside, but step in and you find that locals are always coming back for something more. My own first trip was on a rainy afternoon—the kind of day when comfort food makes all the difference.
The crust is what sets Gino’s apart. Crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, it holds up to plenty of toppings without getting soggy. Gino’s veggie pizza is a standout, layered with bell peppers, onions, and mushrooms, all fresh and never overdone. If you prefer to keep it classic, their cheese pie is a solid example of balance and flavor.
Whether you dine in or opt for delivery, Gino’s brings a reliable, honest slice to Atlantic City’s pizza scene.
5. Three Brothers Pizza
Three Brothers Pizza is a boardwalk staple that’s tough to miss after a day at the shore. I once grabbed a slice here after a long walk in the sun, and the timing couldn’t have been better. Their pizzas are massive—you’ll need both hands, trust me.
The big draw is their classic, oversized slices. The thin, chewy crust and generous layer of cheese guarantee satisfaction with every bite. The veggie slice stands out, piled high with fresh toppings that don’t skimp on flavor. It’s the sort of pizza you remember for its simple, no-frills goodness.
This is the place when you want a quick lunch or an indulgent late-night bite, all on Atlantic City’s buzzing boardwalk.
6. Pizata Pizza Pasta
Pizata Pizza Pasta has a spot inside the Hard Rock, making it easy to grab a quality slice between casino runs or concerts. My first visit was a lucky find after a late-night craving—hot, cheesy pizza, just steps from the action.
What sets Pizata apart is its consistency and speedy service. The cheese pizza is timeless, featuring a thin, golden crust that snaps on the first bite. Their veggie pie is also worth trying, topped with crisp peppers and mushrooms that hold their own flavor.
This is a reliable stop when you need comfort food fast, without sacrificing flavor or freshness. Each slice is made to satisfy, whether you’re fueling up for the next round of fun or winding down for the night.
7. Pizata at the Marketplace Eatery
Pizata at the Marketplace Eatery draws a steady stream of hungry guests from the Borgata, and for good reason. I discovered it on a day full of back-to-back events, and it delivered one of the quickest, most satisfying slices I’ve had inside a casino.
The crust is where Pizata shines—thin, crackly, and just sturdy enough for loaded toppings. Their cheese pizza is a clear winner, while the veggie pie brings a lively mix of peppers, tomatoes, and olives. Each bite keeps the balance between crispy and cheesy—never too greasy or heavy.
Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeaway between activities, this spot is made for anyone who refuses to settle, even while on the go.
8. Mario’s 2 Pizzaria
Mario’s 2 Pizzaria is one of those places where pizza is served with a side of nostalgia. It sits right on the boardwalk, pulling in regulars and curious passersby alike. My own visit came after a long day at the beach; their warm, melty slice made that sun-soaked afternoon even better.
The hallmark here is their classic yet generous approach. The cheese pizza leans toward the traditional, but the crust is puffy and the cheese is rich, bubbling to the very edge. For something different, their veggie pizza has the right amount of bell peppers and mushrooms layered on a sturdy base.
It’s a spot where the simple pleasure of a well-made slice shines brightest, keeping both taste buds and beach memories happy.
9. Pin-Up Pizza
Pin-Up Pizza is tucked away inside Harrah’s, making it a top pick for a post-game meal or a quick fix between casino thrills. I walked in on a busy weekend, and the sight of massive slices caught my eye before anything else did. These pizzas are anything but small—or shy.
The secret here is size and taste. Their cheese slice stretches nearly the length of your forearm, and it doesn’t just rely on the wow-factor. The crust is crisp yet flexible, and the sauce leans tangy, balancing the generous cheese layer. The veggie option is fresh and loaded, perfect if you enjoy some crunch and color with your slice.
Grab a slice, take in the atmosphere, and find out why Pin-Up is a favorite with both regulars and newcomers at Harrah’s.
10. Rhythm & Spirits
Rhythm & Spirits gives classic Italian pizza a fresh, modern flavor right off Tennessee Avenue. I first stopped in after dark, drawn by the buzz of conversation and the promise of something far above your average boardwalk slice. The ambiance leans intimate but never pretentious, with both indoor and inviting outdoor seating.
Pizzas here feature perfectly blistered crusts and bold, imaginative toppings. The margherita is a must—simple, with rich tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and basil that’s always fresh. For a twist, their veggie pizza layers roasted peppers and artichokes, adding real depth to each bite. Each pie is crafted with a chef’s precision, striking the right balance between rustic and inventive.
If you want Atlantic City energy with some culinary flair, this spot will easily win you over.
More Things to Try in Atlantic City, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Atlantic City?
Atlantic City leans heavily toward classic New York-style pizza—thin, foldable slices with a satisfying balance of sauce and cheese. You’ll also find inventive options, but the big slices tend to steal the spotlight.
Are there halal or vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Atlantic City?
Yes, many pizzerias offer vegetarian pies, and you can always customize. For halal options, it’s best to call ahead as menus and preparation can vary—some places are happy to make accommodations if you ask.
Can I get pizza delivered to my hotel or casino?
Absolutely. Most Atlantic City pizza spots offer delivery or partner with delivery apps. Whether you’re staying on the boardwalk or at a casino, you can get a hot pie sent right to your room.
Where can I find the biggest pizza slices in Atlantic City?
Pin-Up Pizza and Three Brothers Pizza are famous for their oversized slices. If you want a slice that hangs over your plate (or doesn’t quite fit on it), those are your go-to spots.
Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
While not every pizzeria offers gluten-free crusts, a few, like Tony Boloney’s, regularly provide gluten-free options. Calling ahead is a good way to make sure your favorite spot can accommodate.