Arlington’s pizza scene is a lot like a good pizza—warm, inviting, diverse, and never short of surprises. From family-owned Italian spots tucked in cozy corners to buzzing joints packed with energy, the options here cut across every style and mood. What’s the result? An ongoing local debate, a parade of pizza boxes, and a neighborhood that takes its crusts, sauces, and cheese blends a bit more seriously than most.
On my own pizza adventures across Arlington, I’ve braved deep-dish dreams, classic New York slices, and wood-fired Neapolitan pies that vanish all too quickly. It only sharpened my appetite for details—dough that’s never doughy, cheese that stretches just right, and toppings that mean business. If you’re hungry for the real lowdown—not just hype—read on. This guide sifts through the popular spots, the hidden gems, and even a slice or two you’ll want to keep on speed dial.
Where to find the best pizza in Arlington, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Arlington, VA:
- Fire Works Pizza
- The Italian Store
- Pupatella Neapolitan Pizzeria and Friggitoria
- The Commentary
- We, The Pizza
- Extreme Pizza
- Lost Dog Cafe
- Wiseguy Pizza
- Bozzelli’s Italian Deli
- California Pizza Kitchen Pentagon Centre
1. Fire Works Pizza
Fire Works Pizza never feels generic. Every visit starts with the aroma of their wood-fired ovens, setting the scene for a memorable meal. The bustling vibe in the Courthouse neighborhood only adds to the anticipation, and the heated patio is perfect for lingering over dinner.
What sets Fire Works apart is the crust: thin, crisp, and kissed by smoke, with toppings that show restraint and balance. On my last trip, the signature Fire Works Pizza delivered oven-charred edges and savory sauce.
Try the Margherita for cheese and tomato simplicity, or the Smokey Blue if you’re feeling adventurous. Each pie hints at old-school technique, but with modern flavor. This spot champions classic pizza with a local twist, no fanfare needed.
2. The Italian Store
The Italian Store brings old-world charm and New York-style slices right into the heart of Arlington. Browsing the aisles feels like stepping into a neighborhood market in Rome, with shoppers buzzing around and families debating their favorite pies. The bustle is all part of the experience.
This spot is famous for its generously sized pizzas and classic toppings done right. On my last visit, the crust hit the sweet spot between chewy and crisp—perfect for folding, just like in the city that inspired it.
Order the Neapolitan for a tasty blank canvas or go bold with the Napoli, loaded with green peppers and olives. The Italian Store excels at honest, satisfying pizza with an undeniable East Coast flair.
3. Pupatella Neapolitan Pizzeria and Friggitoria
See Menu
Pupatella Neapolitan Pizzeria and Friggitoria brings genuine Neapolitan pizza to Arlington, complete with soft, pillowy crust and a blistered, smoky finish. Each pizza is cooked in a wood-fired oven shipped straight from Naples, which makes every bite taste like a quick trip to Italy.
The real magic is in the dough—light, airy, and just chewy enough. When I last visited, the friendly staff and bright blue décor set a laid-back, lively mood, making the whole experience feel extra special.
Go for the Eggplant Parm pizza if you’re searching for something different, or stick with the classic Margherita—fresh basil, bubbling cheese, and a perfect char. Pupatella is pizza with true Italian flair and Arlington attitude.
4. The Commentary
The Commentary, tucked inside The Westin in Ballston, is proof that hotel dining can surprise you. The space buzzes with conversations between locals, business travelers, and regulars who’ve found their new go-to gathering place. I found myself hanging back for an extra slice, drawn in by the easygoing vibe and great playlist.
The pizza here balances East Coast heartiness with a hint of West Coast freshness. The dough is soft but never soggy, standing up well to bright tomato sauce and top-notch cheeses.
The Veggie Flatbread Pizza is a standout—loaded with ripe tomatoes, artichokes, and basil, each bite is fresh without being fussy. This spot redefines All-American pizza without losing the comfort you crave after a long day.
5. We, The Pizza
We, The Pizza brings big-city energy to Arlington, with counter service that keeps things lively and slices that never skimp on toppings. The wall of classic pizza photos nudges you to try something new, even if you usually stick to your favorites. On my last visit, I caved and added a second slice, no regrets.
What sets this spot apart is variety and boldness, from thick Sicilian-style squares to thinner, crispy pies. The freshness is obvious before the first bite, and slices stay hot and gooey all the way home.
Try the White Pie for rich, creamy flavor or go for the Roasted Veggie, packed with roasted peppers and spinach. Either way, this is pizza that never feels like a compromise.
6. Extreme Pizza
Extreme Pizza takes adventurous eating to a tasty new level. With a menu full of inventive combos, this spot turns pizza into a playground for your taste buds. I first wandered in on a rainy afternoon and left with a new respect for bold, unconventional toppings.
Here, innovation drives every pie, and variety isn’t just a buzzword—it’s the norm. Crisp, flavorful crust forms the base, and every slice feels like its own experiment in style.
Try the Pandora’s Box for a mix of artichokes, spinach, and fresh tomatoes, or opt for the Baja 1000 if you like a little spice. Extreme Pizza wins over the curious, the creative, and anyone who believes pizza should never be predictable.
7. Lost Dog Cafe
Lost Dog Cafe is a neighborhood favorite where pizza comes hand-in-hand with quirky charm and a laid-back vibe. Inside, walls are adorned with canine art and shelves lined with an impressive drink selection. Spending an evening here feels more like visiting a friend than dining out.
Diversity is their trademark—gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan pies are all on deck. My recent visit ended with a group sampling three pizzas, each one distinct, yet every crust landed just right: chewy, golden, and flavorful.
The Veggie Works pizza is a must-try, piled high with fresh veggies, or order the Mediterranean for a tangy twist with feta and olives. For creative, comfort-driven pizza, Lost Dog Cafe is always a good call.
8. Wiseguy Pizza
Wiseguy Pizza channels the city spirit with giant, foldable slices that practically demand two hands. The energy inside always hums—busy lunch lines, laughter around communal tables, and the irresistible smell of baking dough. On a brisk afternoon, grabbing a slice here instantly brought back echoes of old-school Manhattan pizza counters.
The secret is in how they treat the classics: huge 18-inch pies, with a bright red sauce and a snap to the crust. Every slice lands hot, thin, and never greasy, with quality you can taste in every bite.
Order the Grandma slice for a square, slightly thicker base topped with fresh tomatoes and basil, or stick with their signature Cheese for pure, simple satisfaction.
9. Bozzelli’s Italian Deli
Bozzelli’s Italian Deli brings a slice of family history and comfort to every order. Walking in, the aroma gives away their secret—hand-tossed dough and sauce that’s made in-house daily. It’s easy to feel like a regular after just one visit, thanks to their warm, no-fuss style.
Their pies are soulful and loaded with fresh, classic ingredients, never sacrificing quality for speed. I once tucked into their Veggie Pizza on a whim and was taken aback by the sheer freshness—from still-crisp peppers to satisfyingly stretchy cheese.
Order the Classic Cheese Pizza to sample the basics, or get the Spinach and Feta if you’re after something lighter but still indulgent. Bozzelli’s always delivers comfort in a box.
10. California Pizza Kitchen Pentagon Centre
California Pizza Kitchen Pentagon Centre takes a fresh, California-inspired approach to pizza in Arlington. The open, welcoming dining room buzzes with families and friends who come for something a little out of the ordinary. My last visit felt like a sunny escape, complete with a friendly waitstaff who knew their way around the menu.
What sets this place apart is its creative flavor combinations and accommodating menu options—think vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free. The crust is never an afterthought; it’s crisp, light, and packed with flavor.
Go for the California Veggie if you want color and crunch, or sample the Margherita on cauliflower crust for a lighter but still satisfying option. This spot nails the balance between casual comfort and culinary flair.
More Things to Try in Arlington, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza spots in Arlington, VA?
Some of the top picks include Fire Works Pizza, The Italian Store, Pupatella, Wiseguy Pizza, and Lost Dog Cafe. Each offers a unique style, from Neapolitan to classic New York slices.
Are there vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Arlington?
Definitely. Many places like Lost Dog Cafe, Extreme Pizza, California Pizza Kitchen, and Pupatella have vegan and vegetarian-friendly pizzas with fresh, tasty ingredients.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Arlington, VA?
Yes. Spots such as Fire Works Pizza, Extreme Pizza, and California Pizza Kitchen offer gluten-free crusts, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
Which Arlington pizzerias deliver?
Delivery is available from most places, including Wiseguy Pizza, Bozzelli’s Italian Deli, Lost Dog Cafe, and We, The Pizza. Delivery areas and times may vary.
What kinds of pizza styles are available in Arlington?
You’ll find everything from traditional Neapolitan and Sicilian-style to New York thin crust and innovative California-inspired pies. There’s truly a slice for every preference.