Finding great pizza in Arlington, NY can feel a bit like searching for treasure. There’s something oddly satisfying about that first bite—a delicate crunch, just enough gooey cheese, and a sauce that tastes like someone’s nonna whipped it up in her own kitchen. Over my late-night study sessions and spontaneous slices with friends, I’ve ventured through nearly every pizzeria dotting the Arlington map. The search is both an adventure and a comfort.
What started as a simple curiosity turned into an unofficial quest. Each shop has its crowd, its legends, and those menu quirks you discover only by talking to locals. If you want a classic foldable New York slice, or prefer a pillowy, modern twist, this guide covers it all. Prepare to discover your new favorite pizza spot, whether you’re craving a quick lunch or plotting out a late-night craving fix.
Where to find the best pizza in Arlington, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Arlington, NY:
- Emiliano’s Pizza
- Pizza Mia
- Marco’s Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe
- Pavese’s Pizza
- D D’s Pizza
- Bella Amici Pizza
- Big Guy Pizza
- Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant
1. Emiliano’s Pizza
Step into Emiliano’s Pizza and you’ll feel at home before the first slice even reaches your plate. Family-owned for over 20 years, this spot draws regulars with its welcoming vibe and reliably crisp pies. My first visit turned into a weeknight ritual thanks to their soft, perfectly chewy crusts and just-right tangy sauce. It’s easy to see why locals claim this pizzeria as their own.
What makes Emiliano’s stand out is their commitment to generous portions and genuine flavor. Their classic cheese pizza lets the handmade dough and sauce take the spotlight, but if you’re up for boldness, try the sausage topping; it speaks to old-school quality. For groups, their calzones and fresh-baked breads are perfect for sharing. This is where tradition meets taste, all at a price that doesn’t leave your wallet hungry.
2. Pizza Mia
Pizza Mia thrives on the art of simplicity—great ingredients, friendly prices, and slices that hit the spot every time. Tucked into Bridgeview Plaza, this place makes you feel like you’ve uncovered a neighborhood secret. My go-to order has always been their cheese pizza, which balances a thin, crackling crust with a mellow, stretchy cheese layer that never overpowers.
What really sets Pizza Mia apart is its no-nonsense approach. You get reliable pies made fresh and fast, so it’s a favorite for a quick lunch or takeout. Their veggie slice is an unsung hero—bright, loaded with fresh toppings, and never weighed down. For those with a bigger appetite, the Sicilian slice offers a fluffier, thick crust experience with just enough crunch.
Stop by for the quality, stay for the comfort food vibe. Pizza Mia keeps it classic and lets the flavor do the talking.
3. Marco’s Pizza
(845) 204-9880Call
At Marco’s Pizza on Raymond Ave, every visit feels a little like coming home—especially if home means being tempted by the aroma of bubbling cheese and warm dough. This spot has long been a personal favorite for group dinners that don’t break the bank. The menu is extensive, but pizza is the clear star.
Marco’s stands out thanks to its slightly charred, chewy crust and the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. Order the Margherita for its fresh basil and vibrant tomato flavor. If you’re after something heartier, their veggie pizza stacks on generous helpings of mushrooms, peppers, and olives without making the crust soggy.
This is the place for classic comfort and reliable, well-executed pies. It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back.
4. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza runs on the promise of speed and value, making it a lifesaver during hungry afternoons or group study sessions. There’s a certain joy in walking in, grabbing a hot pizza within minutes, and knowing your wallet can handle it. I’ve dashed in myself more times than I care to admit—always greeted by the scent of fresh dough and the unmistakable “Pizza!Pizza!” energy.
What sets Little Caesars apart in Arlington is consistency. You know what you’re getting every single time: a sturdy crust, a good stretch of cheese, and a sauce that’s just tangy enough. The classic Hot-N-Ready cheese or veggie pizza is a no-fuss pick. If you want something more filling, their deep dish is a satisfying, doughy treat.
Come here when you want fast, reliable pizza that won’t disappoint.
5. Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe
Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe is where a casual meal turns into a small celebration. Set at the corner of Spackenkill Road, this local favorite has an inviting, busy atmosphere—think families sharing big pies, friends huddled over cheesy slices. I wandered in on a rainy day and was instantly won over by the aroma from their open kitchen.
The draw at Giacomo’s is their thin, crackly crust and rich homemade sauce. The Margherita pizza is a standout, each bite balancing savory cheese and fresh basil. Their veggie pie loads on crisp peppers and tender mushrooms, never skimping on flavor. Slices here strike a happy medium between nostalgic and modern.
For a taste that feels both special and familiar, Giacomo’s is an easy pick. You leave full and already plotting your return.
6. Pavese’s Pizza
(845) 691-8446Call
There’s a cozy, unpretentious charm to Pavese’s Pizza that sets it apart the moment you walk in. Nestled on Vineyard Ave, this longstanding pizzeria has become my detour for quick, no-fuss takeout—especially when I’m in the mood for a reliable classic. Locals drop by for a reason: consistency and modest prices you can count on.
Pavese’s keeps things simple, focusing on dough that’s soft yet satisfyingly sturdy. Their cheese pizza is an easy favorite, but the veggie slice always impresses with fresh, chunky toppings. Everything is made with a clear respect for tradition and good taste. The vibe is relaxed, perfect for both rushed lunches and laid-back dinners.
For honest, classic pies and an extra-friendly staff, Pavese’s hits the mark every single time.
7. D D’s Pizza
(845) 452-1754Call
D D’s Pizza on Hooker Ave has the rare kind of local energy where everyone—from college students to long-time residents—seems to recognize each other. The unassuming storefront hides a gem for those who know their way around a classic New York slice. My own introduction was a spontaneous lunch, but I left already planning a return visit.
What sets D D’s apart is their attention to texture: a crisp bottom, chewy edge, and a sauce with just a hint of sweetness. Their plain cheese pizza shines as the ideal comfort meal, while the veggie option offers real slices of fresh tomato and bell pepper, not just the usual sprinkle. Every pie comes out with a golden touch.
D D’s is the go-to for straightforward, honest pizza done right.
8. Bella Amici Pizza
(845) 834-3222Call
Bella Amici Pizza radiates a warmth that’s more than just oven heat. You’ll find it tucked along US Highway 9W, a place I stumbled upon on a Sunday drive looking for something beyond the usual. The staff greets everyone like a regular and it’s easy to get swept up by the casual, upbeat vibe.
Bella Amici shines thanks to its crust—thin, light, and just crisp enough around the edges. Their classic cheese pizza delivers the right balance of sauce and cheese, never too greasy or heavy. If you want a little adventure, try the veggie pizza for its garden-fresh toppings and color burst on every slice.
It’s great for casual dinners or a spontaneous pizza craving, and always delivers the kind of comfort you remember.
9. Big Guy Pizza
(845) 691-2500Call
With a name like Big Guy Pizza, you expect generous portions and you’ll get just that. Tucked on Vineyard Ave, this is the pizzeria that saved my hunger after a long hike—slices bigger than my face and plenty of variety. The space is unfussy, but the pies are anything but ordinary.
Big Guy Pizza’s main draw is its classic New York-style slices: paper-thin, foldable, with just the right snap. The cheese pie is simple but delivers big flavor, while the veggie pizza comes loaded with a satisfying mix of bell peppers and mushrooms. The crust steals the show—crispy yet foldable, it holds up to any topping combination.
Craving a real slice that fills you up? Big Guy Pizza’s the local answer.
10. Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant
(845) 473-3100Call
Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant feels like that spot where every bite transports you to backstreet Italy. Nestled on Freedom Plains Road, this pizzeria became my go-to on lazy Saturdays—easy parking, friendly faces, and slices that never disappoint. The relaxed vibe and wallet-friendly prices make it a local favorite for families and solo diners alike.
Ciccio’s stands out for its hand-stretched dough and well-seasoned sauce with a hint of garlic. Their classic cheese pizza is comfort food, but try the Sicilian if you’re craving a thick, satisfying bite. The veggie pizza, too, boasts crisp peppers and fresh mushrooms on a sturdy crust that stays light, not doughy.
If you want classic, expertly prepared pizza without any pretension, Ciccio’s is a sure bet.
More Things to Try in Arlington, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are most popular in Arlington, NY?
You’ll find a mix of classic New York-style slices—thin, foldable, and crisp—along with Sicilian and a few places offering specialty pies with creative toppings. Most pizzerias serve traditional hand-tossed crusts and veggie-packed options.
Can I get vegetarian pizza in Arlington, NY?
Absolutely. Nearly every pizzeria features vegetarian choices and many offer customizable veggie-topped pizzas. The freshness and variety of toppings are a highlight at several local shops.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Arlington?
Some pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts, though selection varies. It’s a good idea to call ahead to check for availability.
Which spots are good for a quick slice or takeout?
Little Caesars, Pizza Mia, and Ciccio’s Pizza & Restaurant are popular for fast takeout. Most places let you grab a quick slice during lunch or dinner rush.
Do Arlington pizza shops offer delivery?
Yes, many offer delivery, including Emiliano’s, Marco’s Pizza, and chain favorites like Papa John’s. You can order online or by phone at most locations.
What’s the price range for pizza in Arlington, NY?
Prices generally range from $2-$4 for a slice and $12-$20 for a whole pie, depending on the size and toppings. There are plenty of affordable options for both individuals and groups.