Amarillo, TX, is a hidden gem for pizza lovers, offering a diverse array of pizzerias that cater to every taste. From classic pepperoni to gourmet toppings, the city’s pizza scene is as vibrant as its culture. Having explored many of these establishments, I can confidently say that each spot has its unique charm and flavor profile. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, finding the best pizza in Amarillo is an adventure worth embarking on.
As you dive into this guide, you’ll discover a selection of pizzerias that stand out for their quality, creativity, and atmosphere. Each entry is backed by personal experiences and local favorites, ensuring you have the most accurate and engaging information at your fingertips. Get ready to tantalize your taste buds and uncover the top pizza destinations in Amarillo, where every slice tells a story and every bite is a delight.
Where to find the best pizza in Amarillo, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Amarillo, TX:
- Fire Slice Pizzeria
- 575° Pizzeria – Hillside
- 575 Pizzeria
- Eddie’s Napoli’s Italian Restaurant
- Palio’s Pizza Cafe
- Pizza Planet
- Domino’s Pizza
- Big Jim’s Pizza Co.
- Pizza Planet
- Mudd Rack
1. Fire Slice Pizzeria
+1 806-331-2232
See Menu
Tucked behind the Summit Shopping Center, Fire Slice Pizzeria is one of Amarillo’s true finds. The alleyway entrance only adds to its charm—like stumbling on a locals-only secret. I first visited after a friend wouldn’t stop raving about their crust, and now I understand the obsession.
Stone deck baked with an east coast flair, their pizzas bring a satisfying balance of crisp and chew. The Margherita is a reliable favorite, but the White Pie with spinach and garlic butter stands out for its simple, bold flavors. It’s a spot where attention to quality speaks louder than hype.
Beyond the pies, their community involvement and local ownership give the place soul. Whether you eat in or grab a box to-go, Fire Slice delivers thoughtful, flavorful pizza every time.
2. 575° Pizzeria – Hillside
Bright, casual, and always buzzing, 575° Pizzeria – Hillside brings bold creativity to the Amarillo pizza scene. From the moment I walked in, the energy felt contagious—the kind of place where date nights and post-game hangouts feel equally at home. Service is quick, and the menu? Surprisingly varied.
What makes this spot shine is its attention to balance. Every pie is built with precision, avoiding overloading while still packing flavor. The 575° Special combines savory mushrooms, roasted garlic, and red sauce on a light, crispy crust—each slice is a reminder that well-executed basics still win hearts.
Vegan and gluten-free options are available without fuss, and the setting makes it easy to linger. 575° Pizzeria – Hillside stands out because it doesn’t try too hard—it just does pizza right.
3. 575 Pizzeria
Located conveniently at Civic Circle, 575 Pizzeria offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for both lunch and dinner. From my first visit, I appreciated their friendly service and attention to detail, making every dining experience pleasant. Their focus on fresh ingredients and creative flavors truly sets them apart.
Among their offerings, the Margherita pizza is a standout—simple, flavorful, and expertly baked. Their customizable options, including vegan and vegetarian choices, reflect a commitment to catering to diverse tastes. The crispy crust and quality toppings demonstrate the restaurant’s dedication to excellence in every slice.
Whether dining in or taking out, 575 Pizzeria consistently delivers high-quality, satisfying pizza that captures the true essence of Amarillo’s vibrant food scene.
4. Eddie’s Napoli’s Italian Restaurant
Located in the heart of downtown Amarillo, Eddie’s Napoli’s Italian Restaurant offers a delightful escape into authentic Italian cuisine. My first visit was a treat, as I enjoyed the cozy ambiance complete with a fireplace and live music. The outdoor courtyard is a perfect spot to unwind, shielded from the Amarillo wind.
What sets Eddie’s apart is their New York style pizza, which boasts a perfectly thin crust and generous toppings. The Margherita pizza, with its fresh basil and mozzarella, is a must-try, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes.
With options for both dining in and takeout, Eddie’s Napoli’s is a fantastic choice for anyone craving delicious Italian fare in a welcoming atmosphere.
5. Palio’s Pizza Cafe
At Palio’s Pizza Cafe in Amarillo, quality comes in layers—starting with hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, and a menu built for flavor without fuss. Tucked along S Soncy Road, it’s the kind of place where locals bring family and visitors get that “you’re one of us” feeling from the start.
What sets Palio’s apart is its clean, cozy space and commitment to crowd-pleasing classics with subtle flair. Whether you’re grabbing takeout or settling in for table service, the kitchen keeps things consistent, and the pizzas arrive piping hot without any compromise on toppings.
Try the Nutty Chicken Pizza, where roasted cashews mingle with grilled chicken over a creamy base—it’s not your standard slice. For a veggie-friendly option, the Mediterranean balances feta, olives, and artichokes like it was designed by a flavor architect. This spot keeps it simple but never boring.
6. Pizza Planet
Looking for the best pizza in Amarillo, TX? Whether you’re a thin crust purist or a deep-dish devotee, Amarillo has a slice for every kind of pizza lover. From locally-owned gems to national chains, this guide walks you through the top spots to grab a pie in the Yellow Rose of Texas. No fluff, no filler—just straight-up pizza talk.
-
Fire Slice Pizzeria
Tucked away in a strip mall, Fire Slice is a local favorite for a reason. Their hand-tossed crust hits the sweet spot between chewy and crisp. Try the “Texas Heat” if you like your pizza with a kick. Bonus: they’re serious about fresh ingredients and friendly service. -
575° Pizzeria – Hillside
This location of 575° Pizzeria keeps the bar high. Their wood-fired pies are known for bold flavors and creative toppings. The “Napoli” with roasted garlic and basil is a standout. It’s casual, but the quality is anything but. -
575 Pizzeria
The original 575 location still holds its own. Expect the same high standards: scratch-made dough, house sauces, and a rotating list of specials that keep regulars coming back. It’s a solid pick for dine-in or takeout. -
Eddie’s Napoli’s Italian Restaurant
More than just pizza, but their pies deserve attention. The crust leans soft and chewy, with a slightly sweet sauce that balances well. It’s a good pick if you want pizza with a side of pasta or a proper Italian entrée. -
Palio’s Pizza Cafe
Palio’s offers a family-friendly vibe with a menu that caters to all tastes. Their “Nutty Chicken” pizza is a local curiosity—don’t knock it till you try it. They also offer gluten-free crusts, which is a plus. -
Pizza Planet
A local chain with multiple locations, Pizza Planet is known for its thick crust and generous toppings. It’s not fancy, but it’s reliable. Great for a casual night in or a quick lunch stop. -
Domino’s Pizza
You know what you’re getting here. Domino’s has improved its crust game in recent years, and the Amarillo locations are consistent. It’s a go-to for late-night cravings or quick delivery. -
Big Jim’s Pizza Co.
Big Jim’s leans into the classic pizzeria vibe. The portions are hefty, and the crust has a nice crunch. Their “Meat Monster” is unapologetically loaded. It’s not subtle, but it satisfies. -
Pizza Planet
Yes, again. With several locations across Amarillo, Pizza Planet earns repeat mentions. Each spot has its quirks, but the core menu stays the same: hearty, satisfying pies with a local touch. -
Mudd Rack
More bar than pizzeria, but don’t overlook the pizza. It’s a solid option if you want a cold drink with your slice. The crust is thin, the toppings are fresh, and the vibe is relaxed. -
Pizza Planet
Another location, same dependable formula. If you’re near this one, it’s worth a stop. -
Pizza Hut
A national staple. Amarillo’s Pizza Hut locations offer the familiar pan crust and stuffed crust options. It’s comfort food, plain and simple. -
Chuck E. Cheese
Geared toward kids, but the pizza has improved over the years. If you’re here for the games, the pizza won’t disappoint. Just don’t expect gourmet. -
Cicis Pizza
All-you-can-eat pizza buffet. It’s not fancy, but it’s fast and affordable. Great for families or anyone who wants to try a bit of everything. -
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘n’ Bake Pizza
A different model: you take it home and bake it yourself. Surprisingly good quality, especially if you like your pizza hot out of the oven. Their “Cowboy” pizza is a crowd-pleaser. -
La Bella Pizza Hillside
A local spot with a loyal following. The crust is thick, the cheese is generous, and the sauce has a nice tang. It’s not trying to be trendy—just good. -
Mr Gatti’s Pizza
Buffet-style with a retro feel. The pizza is simple and satisfying. It’s a nostalgic pick for many Amarillo locals. -
Godfather’s Pizza
Known for its thick, chewy crust and bold flavors. The “All-Meat Combo” is a beast. It’s a heavier pie, so come hungry. -
Pizza Hut
Another location, same dependable pies. If you’re nearby, it’s a safe bet. -
Pizza Hut-Wing Street
This hybrid location offers wings alongside the usual Pizza Hut fare. If you want a side of spicy wings with your pepperoni, this is your spot. -
Papa Johns Pizza
Better ingredients, better pizza? That’s the claim. Amarillo’s Papa Johns delivers consistent quality and a slightly sweeter sauce than most chains. -
Pizza Hut
Yes, again. Amarillo has plenty of them, and they’re all about consistency. -
Little Caesars
Fast, cheap, and hot. The “Hot-N-Ready” model works when you’re in a rush. Not gourmet, but it gets the job done. -
Georgia Street Taphouse
Not a pizza joint per se, but their flatbreads are worth a mention. Thin, crispy, and topped with creative combos. Great with a pint. -
Charlee’s Chicken
You’re here for the chicken, but the pizza is a sleeper hit. It’s a wildcard pick, but surprisingly solid. -
Pizza Hut
Another one. If you’re counting, Amarillo really likes Pizza Hut. -
Pizza Hut
Yes, again. You won’t have trouble finding one. -
Burger King
Not a pizza place, but some locations have pizza-style items. Not recommended unless you’re truly curious. -
Dairy Queen
Same story. Stick to the Blizzards. -
House Divided Restaurant & Sports Grill
More of a sports bar, but their pizza is a solid option. Good crust, generous toppings, and a lively atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s the best local pizza in Amarillo?
A: Fire Slice and 575° Pizzeria are top picks for locals who want quality and creativity.
Q: Are there halal or haram-free options?
A: Many places offer vegetarian pizzas, and some allow custom orders. Always check with the restaurant to confirm ingredients.
Q: Which place is best for families?
A: Palio’s, Mr Gatti’s, and Cicis are all family-friendly with plenty of space and variety.
Q: What’s the best pizza for delivery?
A: Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Planet are reliable for fast, hot delivery.
Q: Any hidden gems?
A: Mudd Rack and Charlee’s Chicken aren’t traditional pizza spots, but they surprise with solid offerings.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Ross Street in Amarillo is a go-to for pizza lovers craving convenience and flavor. Known for its quick delivery and consistent quality, it’s the perfect choice for a late-night snack or a family dinner. My personal experience with their Hand Tossed Pepperoni Pizza was delightful; the crust was perfectly chewy, and the pepperoni was generously layered.
What makes Domino’s stand out is its commitment to innovation, offering a variety of crust options and toppings to customize your pizza just the way you like it. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a must-try for those who enjoy a spicy kick, while the Veggie Deluxe caters to vegetarian preferences without compromising on taste.
8. Big Jim’s Pizza Co.
Big Jim’s Pizza Co. on Olsen Boulevard is more than a local staple—it’s where Amarillo’s pizza story took a delicious turn. The cozy interior and local crowd give it a relaxed, neighborhood feel that chain pizzerias just can’t match. Service is quick, and the staff treat first-timers like regulars.
What sets Big Jim’s apart is its deep-rooted legacy in Amarillo, evolving from its original La Bella days into a full-service pizzeria with a dining area, bar, and drive-thru. It’s ideal for lunch breaks or late-night cravings.
Try the Original Hand-Tossed Cheese or Veggie Supreme. Their crust hits that perfect sweet spot between crispy and doughy, and the sauce has a gentle tang that complements each bite. Every slice feels curated with care.
With vegetarian-friendly options and consistently warm hospitality, Big Jim’s Pizza Co. captures what local pizza should taste like in Amarillo, TX.
9. Pizza Planet
Pizza Planet in Amarillo is a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking variety and flavor. With a menu that extends beyond just pizza, it offers a range of appetizers, salads, and subs, making it a perfect spot for families and groups. My recent visit was a delightful experience; the atmosphere was lively, and the staff were incredibly welcoming.
What makes Pizza Planet stand out is its unique offerings, like the Taco Pizza, which combines classic pizza elements with zesty taco flavors. It’s a fun twist that showcases their creativity. The Planet Salad is also a refreshing complement to any meal, packed with fresh ingredients.
For a satisfying meal, I recommend the Specialty Pizzas, particularly the Meat Lovers or Veggie Delight, both of which reflect the quality and care that goes into every dish. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Pizza Planet is sure to please.
10. Mudd Rack
Tucked away on E Hastings Ave, Mudd Rack is where Amarillo locals unwind. It’s part bar, part family hangout, and all heart. The brick oven pizza here doesn’t try too hard—it just delivers bold, satisfying flavor without the fuss. Pool tables clack, crab races bring laughs, and live music breathes energy into the room.
What makes it stand out? It’s a rare mix of casual charm and neighborhood familiarity. One visit feels like you’ve been coming for years. Evenings here feel relaxed, welcoming, and a little unpredictable—in the best way.
If you’re here for pizza (and you should be), go for their brick oven cheese or veggie pie. The crust lands that sweet spot between crispy and chewy, and the toppings are generous without going overboard.
More Things to Try in Amarillo, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Amarillo, TX?
Local favorites include Fire Slice Pizzeria and 575° Pizzeria for their quality and creative toppings. Both are highly recommended for authentic, delicious pizza.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Amarillo?
Yes, many places like Palio’s Pizza Cafe and Fire Slice Pizzeria offer vegetarian-friendly and vegan options, ensuring choices for all dietary preferences.
Which pizza spots are family-friendly in Amarillo?
Palio’s Pizza Cafe, Mudd Rack, and Cicis Pizza are great options for families, offering a relaxed environment and menu options for everyone.
Do any Amarillo pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Most popular chains like Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Planet provide reliable delivery and takeout services. Many local spots also offer convenient options.
What should I try at a local Amarillo pizzeria?
Popular choices include specialty pizzas like Taco Pizza at Pizza Planet or the wood-fired Margherita at Fire Slice. Always ask for their house specials for a true taste of their style.