Finding the best pizza in Albany, GA, isn’t just about grabbing a slice; it’s about exploring a variety of flavors crafted with care. Over the years, I’ve tasted pizzas from classic pizzerias to hidden gems. Each spot brings its own unique twist—whether it’s a perfectly crisp crust, flavorful toppings, or a secret sauce that keeps patrons coming back. The city offers a surprising diversity of pizzerias that cater to every craving, from traditional Italian recipes to inventive styles.
Having visited several establishments in Albany, I’ve learned that the best pizza combines quality ingredients with genuine passion. Whether you’re craving a cozy family dinner or a quick lunch on the go, this guide will point you toward eateries where pizza isn’t just food—it’s an experience. Prepare to discover the places that turn pizza into an art form, making your search for the perfect slice much easier.
Where to find the best pizza in Albany, GA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Albany, GA:
- Mellow Mushroom Albany
- Marco’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Villa Gargano Italian Restaurant
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- CiCi’s Pizza
- My Pie Pizza
1. Mellow Mushroom Albany
Nestled at 2825 Nottingham Way, Mellow Mushroom Albany offers a unique twist on classic pizza. From my visits, I’ve found their creative, stone-baked pies to be a standout in the area. The atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for both casual outings and special gatherings.
What sets Mellow Mushroom apart is its bold, inventive menu featuring diverse toppings and fresh salads. A must-try is their signature Mushroom Pepperoni Pizza, which showcases their expert craftsmanship. Pair it with a craft beer to experience the full flavor. For a lighter option, their Veggie Delight pizza highlights fresh, wholesome ingredients. Each dish reflects their commitment to quality and creativity.
2. Marco’s Pizza
Located at 2818 Old Dawson Road, Marco’s Pizza stands out for its commitment to authentic Italian craftsmanship. During my visits, I’ve appreciated their fresh dough, made daily, and a carefully crafted three-cheese blend that creates a rich, flavorful crust. The sauce recipe, unchanged since 1978, speaks to their dedication to tradition.
What makes Marco’s special is its focus on quality ingredients and a family-friendly atmosphere. The Special Veggie Pizza showcases their simple yet flavorful approach, while their Meat Eater’s Delite offers hearty toppings for meat lovers. Both highlight their authentic style and attention to detail, ensuring every bite feels fresh and satisfying.
3. Pizza Hut
Situated at 2108 East Oglethorpe Boulevard, Pizza Hut is a familiar name for satisfying, family-style pizza in Albany. From my visits, I’ve found their classic, hand-tossed crust reliably tasty, offering comfort in every slice. The convenience of carryout and delivery makes it easy to enjoy their offerings at home.
What sets Pizza Hut apart is its consistent quality and wide variety of options. I recommend trying their Super Supreme Pizza for a loaded experience or the Hand-Tossed Pepperoni for a straightforward classic. Their menu reflects a balance of tradition and innovation, making it a dependable choice for any pizza craving.
4. Villa Gargano Italian Restaurant
Located at the corner of 9th and North Slappey, Villa Gargano Italian Restaurant captures the feel of a true neighborhood favorite. The setting is intimate, and from my experience, it feels like dining in someone’s well-loved kitchen. Their pizzas carry the flavor and depth of a family recipe passed down with care.
What makes Villa Gargano stand out is their no-fuss commitment to quality. Their crust is thin yet satisfying, allowing the sauce and cheese to shine. I recommend the Vegetarian Pizza for its fresh toppings that taste garden-picked, and the Classic Margherita for its straightforward balance of flavor and simplicity. Both are perfect examples of Villa Gargano’s warm, homestyle cooking.
With dine-in, carry-out, and delivery available, this spot makes comfort food feel personal and reliably good.
5. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Located in New Slappy Foods at 405 South Slappey Boulevard, Hunt Brothers Pizza offers a convenient, customizable pizza experience. During my visits, I’ve appreciated their commitment to fresh ingredients and the flexibility of the All Toppings No Extra Charge policy, letting you build your perfect pie with favorite toppings.
What sets Hunt Brothers apart is its focus on personalized options delivered quickly. I recommend trying their Classic Cheese Pizza for a simple, satisfying choice or creating your own masterpiece with various toppings. Their crust options—original or thin—cater to different tastes while staying flavorful and crisp.
Whether you’re after a quick lunch or a casual dinner, Hunt Brothers offers quality and variety that reflect their dedication to customer preferences.
6. Papa Johns Pizza
Tucked into the North Pointe neighborhood, Papa Johns Pizza at 711 N Westover Blvd delivers a consistent, satisfying slice that’s hard to beat. The location is clean, the staff is efficient, and the pizza? Always hot and fresh.
What sets this spot apart is their commitment to “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.” You can taste it in the crust—soft inside, with just the right crisp on the edge. Their signature sauce has a subtle tang that complements the toppings without overpowering them.
I recommend the Garden Fresh Pizza for a flavorful, meat-free option that doesn’t skimp on taste. If you’re feeling classic, the Original Cheese or Pepperoni hits the spot. Whether you’re grabbing takeout or ordering delivery, Papa Johns in Albany keeps it simple and satisfying.
7. Little Caesars Pizza
At Little Caesars Pizza on N Slappey Blvd, speed and value come standard. This Albany location keeps things moving with a no-fuss, grab-and-go setup that’s perfect when you’re short on time but still craving something warm and satisfying.
What makes this spot stand out is the Hot-N-Ready concept. Walk in, and you’re likely walking out with a fresh Classic Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza in under a minute. The crust is thick, chewy, and holds up well under generous layers of cheese and sauce.
If you’re looking for something with a little more edge, try the Thin Crust Veggie Pizza. It’s crisp, flavorful, and doesn’t feel heavy. For a quick bite that doesn’t compromise on taste, Little Caesars delivers—literally and figuratively.
8. Domino’s Pizza
At Domino’s Pizza on Dawson Road, consistency meets convenience. Whether you’re grabbing a quick carryout or settling in for delivery, this Albany location delivers exactly what you expect—fast, hot, and satisfying pizza.
What sets this spot apart is the range of crust options. The Handmade Pan Pizza is a standout—thick, buttery, and crisp on the edges. If you prefer something lighter, the Thin Crust Veggie Pizza offers a crisp bite without the weight. And for those who like a little indulgence, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust adds a cheesy twist to your favorite toppings.
Domino’s also nails the details. Orders are accurate, the app is easy to use, and the deals—like two medium two-topping pizzas for $6.99 each—make it easy to feed a group without breaking the bank.
For a reliable pizza night in Albany, Domino’s delivers on flavor, speed, and value.
9. CiCi’s Pizza
Located at Cross Station Shopping Center, CiCi’s Pizza has been a family favorite since 1985. The variety of pizzas, pastas, and salads offers something for everyone. I’ve enjoyed their buffet style, which allows for sampling different flavors without committing to one pie.
What makes CiCi’s stand out is its focus on affordability and family-friendly atmosphere. The Cheese and Pepperoni Pizzas are reliably tasty, while their unique options like Zesty Ham and Cheddar and Chicken and Spinach Alfredo reflect their creative approach to classic dishes.
For dessert, their brownies and cinnamon rolls are a sweet ending to any meal. The catering and fundraiser programs highlight their community-oriented spirit, making CiCi’s more than just a pizza spot.
10. My Pie Pizza
Situated at the corner of Westover Blvd. and Dawson Road, My Pie Pizza prides itself on serving authentic New York-style pizza. I’ve enjoyed their custom-build approach, which allows you to choose fresh, locally sourced ingredients for a truly personalized experience.
What makes My Pie stand out is their commitment to freshness and quality. Their dough and sauces are made daily from recipes passed down from their family archives, ensuring each slice is flavorful and satisfying. The pizza is cooked quickly, delivering a hot meal in a matter of minutes.
I recommend their Build-Your-Own Pizza for maximum customization, or the Margherita for a classic taste. Each pie reflects their dedication to freshness and authentic flavor, making it a neighborhood favorite for good reason.
More Things to Try in Albany, GA
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Albany, GA?
A: It depends on your taste, but some popular options include Mellow Mushroom for creative, stone-baked pies and Marco’s Pizza for authentic Italian-style pizza. Exploring different spots can help you find your favorite.
Q: Are there any gluten-free or vegetarian pizza options in Albany?
A: Yes. Many pizzerias, such as Pizza Hut and Domino’s, offer gluten-free crusts and vegetarian toppings. It’s best to check with each restaurant for specific menu options.
Q: Do Albany pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most do. Places like Papa Johns, Domino’s, and Papa Murphy’s provide convenient delivery and takeout services, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Q: What kinds of pizza are common in Albany, GA?
A: Classic toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and cheese are popular. You’ll also find specialty pies with ingredients like spinach, chicken, or unique sauces reflecting local tastes and the diverse styles available.
Q: Are there family-friendly pizza restaurants in Albany?
A: Absolutely. Many places, including Cici’s Pizza and Little Caesars, are designed to be family-friendly, offering buffets, quick options, and kid-friendly menus.