Finding truly exceptional pizza in Abilene, TX isn’t just a matter of following local buzz—it’s about knowing which spots consistently deliver that perfect mix of crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings, all while sticking to clean and halal-friendly options. I’ve taken that journey firsthand—ducking into hole-in-the-wall joints after a long drive through the Big Country, tasting slices that punch above their size, and sitting down to meals that felt more like reunions than just dinner. Abilene’s pizza scene holds surprises: local gems that refuse to be ordinary and chains that have quietly upped their game.
In this guide, you’ll get a focused list of Abilene’s most reliable and satisfying pizza places, with each entry reviewed for flavor, freshness, and authenticity. Whether you lean toward wood-fired crusts with a smoky finish or prefer the comfort of classic pies made just right, this lineup doesn’t play favorites—it prioritizes quality. You’ll also find insights into ambiance, service, and consistency across locations. There’s no fluff here, just clear, accurate info to help you land your next favorite slice in Abilene.
Where to find the best pizza in Abilene, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Abilene, TX:
- Vagabond Pizza
- Brick Oven Pizza Co. of Abilene
- Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
- Joe’s Pizza
- Potter’s Pizza
- Dante’s Pizza
- Little Italy Pizza and Pasta
- Pizza by Design
- Cicis Pizza
- Little Caesars
1. Vagabond Pizza
Vagabond Pizza, located at 1056 N 2nd St in Abilene, TX, offers a refreshing take on the local pizza scene. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere that feels both relaxed and lively. Their wood-fired pizzas boast a perfect balance of smoky flavor and crisp crust, making each bite memorable. The place also features an eclectic selection of craft beers and wines, enhancing the dining experience.
What sets Vagabond apart is its commitment to quality and community. Vegetarian-friendly and offering vegan options, it caters to diverse tastes. I recommend trying their signature veggie pizza or the classic Margherita, both showcasing their fresh ingredients and authentic style. Vagabond Pizza truly blends craftsmanship with a welcoming vibe, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Abilene.
2. Brick Oven Pizza Co. of Abilene
Brick Oven Pizza Co. of Abilene, at 4714 S 14th St, brings a relaxed charm that feels almost like eating at a longtime friend’s kitchen—if your friend happened to perfect thin crust in a stone hearth. The aroma of their pizzas hits before you’re even seated, and the crackle of the oven promises what’s to come. Each order is prepared fresh, and the time they take shows in the texture and taste.
What makes this spot stand out is its dedication to traditional techniques and consistent flavor. The crust is thin, crisp, and just the right kind of chewy. If you go, try the veggie-loaded pizza—it’s vibrant, well-balanced, and highlights the hand-prepped toppings. Brick Oven keeps things simple, fresh, and seriously satisfying.
3. Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
Tucked away on S Treadaway Blvd in Abilene, TX, Joe’s Pizza and Pasta is a cozy local gem serving up hearty portions of Italian favorites. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh-baked dough and savory sauces lets you know you’re in for something special.
What sets Joe’s apart is its authentic, homemade style — you can taste the care in every bite. The staff is welcoming, and the service is quick, especially for takeout. It’s the kind of place where families gather and locals return again and again.
I highly recommend the New York-style cheese pizza — crisp crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of sauce. Their vegetarian options are flavorful, especially the veggie deluxe pizza packed with fresh toppings.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or dinner, Joe’s delivers flavor, comfort, and quality that stands out in Abilene’s pizza scene.
4. Joe’s Pizza
Joe’s Pizza, located on Buffalo Gap Rd in Abilene, feels like one of those neighborhood spots where the pizza speaks louder than any signage. The layout is unpretentious, and the food does all the talking. I remember grabbing a late lunch here and being pleasantly surprised by how fresh everything tasted—even the crust had just the right bite and char.
What elevates Joe’s is its consistency and simplicity. You won’t find gimmicks here—just well-made pizza with thoughtfully chosen ingredients. It’s the kind of place where locals feel at home and newcomers feel like they’ve found a keeper.
Try the classic veggie pizza or opt for a custom build with their fresh toppings. The crust is thin but sturdy, delivering a proper base that never overwhelms the sauce-to-cheese balance. Portions are generous without being over-the-top.
If you’re after a satisfying, no-fuss pizza in Abilene, Joe’s Pizza quietly delivers every time.
5. Potter’s Pizza
Potter’s Pizza, located at 3802 Buffalo Gap Road in Abilene, has become a go-to spot for casual and satisfying pizza. Since 2011, they’ve built a reputation for serving fresh, high-quality ingredients in a family-friendly atmosphere. I recall visiting after a busy day and being greeted with genuine warmth, which made the meal even more enjoyable.
What makes Potter’s stand out is their commitment to quality ingredients and excellent service. Whether dining in, ordering carry-out, or opting for delivery, you can always expect a flavorful pizza paired with friendly customer care.
I recommend the meat lover’s pizza or the vegetarian option—both showcase their dedication to flavor and freshness. The crust is well-balanced, and toppings are generously applied, making every slice a delight.
Potter’s Pizza offers consistent quality and a genuine, community-focused vibe, making it a reliable choice for pizza in Abilene.
6. Dante’s Pizza
Nestled in Abilene, Dante’s Pizza is a local favorite for those seeking delicious, authentic pizza. Located at 4310 Buffalo Gap Rd, this cozy spot is perfect for lunch or dinner, offering both delivery and takeout options. Their Facebook page is the go-to for updates and specials.
What makes Dante’s Pizza stand out is their commitment to quality and flavor. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients, reflecting the passion and dedication of the staff. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a great place to enjoy a meal.
I highly recommend the Margherita Pizza. Its perfect balance of fresh basil, mozzarella, and ripe tomatoes truly captures the essence of Italian cuisine. This dish highlights Dante’s dedication to authentic flavors and quality.
7. Little Italy Pizza and Pasta
Located at 620 Ambler Ave in Abilene, Little Italy Pizza and Pasta offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of Texas. I discovered this spot during a family lunch, and it quickly became a favorite for its warm atmosphere and authentic flavors. Their pizzas are crafted with care, using fresh ingredients that shine through every bite.
What makes Little Italy stand out is their dedication to quality and variety. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese or a more adventurous veggie or meat-loaded pie, their menu has you covered. The restaurant also offers excellent vegetarian-friendly options and reliable delivery or takeout services.
For a true flavor experience, try the Margherita pizza. Its crispy crust, fresh basil, and tangy sauce embody the restaurant’s commitment to authentic Italian tradition and high-quality ingredients.
8. Pizza by Design
Located at 3753 Catclaw Dr in Abilene, Pizza by Design offers a customizable pizza experience that stands out from the ordinary. I visited during a casual dinner, impressed by how easy it was to build a pizza just the way I wanted. Their fresh ingredients and creative options make each pie special.
What sets Pizza by Design apart is its focus on personalization, allowing you to choose your crust, sauce, toppings, and cheese. This flexibility ensures a satisfying, tailored meal. The quality ingredients and efficient service make it a top choice for lunch or dinner.
Highly recommended is their signature Margherita—a perfect blend of fresh basil, mozzarella, and a crispy crust that highlights their dedication to quality. It’s a simple yet flavorful example of their craftsmanship.
9. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza in Abilene, TX offers a fun and casual dining experience with an all-you-can-eat buffet that includes freshly made pizza, pasta, salad, and desserts. Located at 3366 Turner Plz, it’s a local favorite for families and groups looking for great value and variety.
During my visit, I was impressed by the freshness and speed of the buffet. The staff quickly refilled popular pizzas, and the atmosphere was welcoming. It felt like a place where community and comfort meet.
What makes Cicis stand out is its creative pizza options—from classic cheese to unique flavors like BBQ Chicken and Alfredo Spinach, all made without haram ingredients. Don’t miss the stuffed crust pepperoni—crispy edges and gooey cheese make it unforgettable!
Whether you’re craving something savory or sweet, Cicis delivers variety and value in every bite.
10. Little Caesars
Located at 4102 Buffalo Gap Rd in Abilene, Little Caesars offers quick and reliable pizza options perfect for busy days. I stopped by during a hectic evening, and their hot-n-ready pizzas made dinner effortless without sacrificing flavor. The experience was straightforward—fast, fresh, and satisfying.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their affordable prices and convenience. Their signature Cremesicle Pizza and classic pepperoni are always popular choices, delivering consistent quality. The crust is crispy, and toppings are fresh, reflecting their commitment to quick-service excellence.
If you’re after a dependable and tasty pizza in Abilene, Little Caesars’ hot and ready options are a smart choice for satisfying your cravings fast.
More Things to Try in Abilene, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Abilene, TX?
Abilene offers a variety of pizza options, from local favorites to popular chains. Some highly-rated spots include:
– Brick Oven Pizza Co. for wood-fired, artisanal pizzas.
– Little Italy Pizza & Pasta for authentic Italian-style pizza.
– Pizza by Design for customizable pizzas made fresh.
2. Are there any halal pizza options in Abilene, TX?
While specific halal-certified pizza places may be limited, you can inquire with local restaurants about their ingredients and preparation methods. Some vegetarian or seafood pizza options might meet halal requirements.
3. Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Abilene, TX?
Many pizzerias in Abilene now offer gluten-free options. Check out:
– MOD Pizza for customizable gluten-free crusts.
– Pizza Hut for a gluten-free menu option.
4. Do pizza places in Abilene deliver late at night?
Yes, several pizza places offer late-night delivery, including:
– Domino’s Pizza (open until midnight or later).
– Papa John’s Pizza (open late on weekends).
5. Are there any pizza buffets in Abilene, TX?
Yes, pizza buffets are a popular choice in Abilene! Try:
– Cicis Pizza for an affordable all-you-can-eat experience.
– Mr. Gatti’s Pizza for family-friendly buffet options.
6. What’s the most popular pizza topping in Abilene, TX?
Pepperoni is a crowd favorite, but locals also enjoy unique toppings like jalapeños and barbecue chicken.
7. Are there vegan pizza options in Abilene, TX?
Yes, some pizza places offer vegan-friendly choices. Look for:
– MOD Pizza for dairy-free cheese and plant-based toppings.
– Pizza Hut for their vegan crust and veggie toppings (ask to skip the cheese).
8. What’s the average price of pizza in Abilene, TX?
Prices range from $10 to $20 for a medium pizza, depending on the restaurant and toppings. Buffets and deals from chains may be more affordable.
9. Can I find New York or Chicago-style pizza in Abilene, TX?
Yes, a few restaurants specialize in regional styles:
– Little Italy Pizza & Pasta for New York-style pizza.
– Brick Oven Pizza Co. for a unique take on Chicago-style deep dish.
10. Are there family-friendly pizza spots in Abilene, TX?
Definitely! Popular choices include:
– Mr. Gatti’s Pizza with games and a buffet.
– Cicis Pizza for budget-friendly meals and space for kids.
11. Do local pizza places in Abilene offer catering services?
Yes, many pizzerias offer catering for parties or events. Check with:
– Pizza by Design for large orders and customizable options.
– Papa John’s Pizza for catering packages.
12. Can I order pizza online in Abilene, TX?
Absolutely! Most pizzerias in Abilene, including Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and local spots like Brick Oven Pizza Co., offer online ordering through their websites or apps.
13. What are some unique pizza flavors available in Abilene, TX?
Some interesting flavors to try include:
– BBQ Chicken Pizza at Brick Oven Pizza Co.
– White Pizza at Little Italy Pizza & Pasta.
– Buffalo Chicken Pizza at Domino’s.
14. Are there any deals or discounts on pizza in Abilene, TX?
Yes, many chains like Pizza Hut, Domino’s, and Papa John’s regularly offer deals (e.g., buy-one-get-one or discounted combos). Local restaurants may also have daily specials, so check their websites or social media pages.
15. What’s the best way to reheat leftover pizza?
To keep your pizza fresh and crispy, reheat it in an oven at 375°F for 8-10 minutes or use a skillet on medium heat for a few minutes with the lid on. Avoid microwaving, as it can make the crust soggy.