Finding the best pizza in Utica, NY isn’t just a matter of taste—it’s an adventure. Utica wears its pizza pride on its sleeve, boasting crusts that have a satisfying crunch and toppings that don’t skimp on flavor. I still remember my own first slice here: a square-cut, slightly charred undercarriage, and a sauce that told its own story. It’s the sort of experience that keeps you coming back, each stop offering its twist on a familiar classic.
Whether you’re seeking a no-frills cheese slice or a pie loaded with local character, Utica’s options are as diverse as its neighborhoods. From pizzerias that have kept recipes in the family for decades to new spots shaking things up, this city knows how to lay out a table. I’ve tried them all—sometimes twice, just to be sure. If you want to skip the guesswork and cut right to where the flavor lives, read on.
Where to find the best pizza in Utica, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Utica, NY:
- O’scugnizzo Pizzeria
- O’scugnizzo North Utica
- Parkway Pizza
- Nina’s Pizza
- Franco’s Pizza & Italian Deli
- Palermo Pizzeria
- Slice
- Lukins Brick Oven Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Rosario’s Pizzeria East Utica
1. O’scugnizzo Pizzeria
O’scugnizzo Pizzeria at 614 Bleecker Street is often the first name locals mention when you ask about classic Utica pizza. This place has been serving the city since 1914, making it a landmark as much as a restaurant. The atmosphere is unfussy, and there’s always a steady stream of regulars picking up orders or grabbing a booth.
What makes O’scugnizzo stand out is its upside-down pizza. Here, cheese goes straight on the crust, sauce gets ladled on top, and the result is a pie with crisp edges and a signature tang. My first slice here was a revelation—simple, honest, and packed with flavor.
If you’re new, start with the half-moon shaped sausage and pepper pizzas (sausage is made in-house). You’ll taste why Utica’s pizza reputation starts here. For a vegetarian twist, the white garlic pizza is a bright, garlicky change of pace.
2. O’scugnizzo North Utica
+1 315-266-0450
O’scugnizzo North Utica gives you the classic Utica pizza tradition in a slightly more spacious setting. Nestled on Auert Avenue, it’s an easy spot for families or groups to gather after work or on weekends. If you’ve ever had to wait for a table at the original, this location tends to move quicker but keeps the flavor every bit as bold.
What stands out here is their attention to consistency. Every pie I’ve tried comes out with that perfect upside-down layering: gooey cheese below, rich tomato sauce above, and a crust that stands up to every bite. It’s the kind of pizza that tastes like someone is still watching over the recipe after all these years.
Give their classic sausage pizza a try—the toppings are generously portioned and the crust offers just the right crunch. For something a touch different, their thick-crust veggie pie brings plenty of color and flavor.
3. Parkway Pizza
+1 315-733-8585
Parkway Pizza may look modest from the outside, but inside, the ovens are always busy. Located on Culver Avenue, this spot draws steady crowds who swear by their distinctive sauce and feather-light crust. There’s an easygoing energy here, perfect for a casual night out or a quick lunch break.
The crust is what got me hooked—soft, a touch chewy, and just sturdy enough to hold generous toppings. Their sauce has a slightly sweet finish that matches well with the gooey cheese layer. The pizza comes out piping hot, cut in easy-to-share squares or classic slices, depending on your mood.
If you want a taste of what makes Parkway popular, go for their loaded vegetable pizza or classic cheese. Each slice showcases the care put into every batch and keeps regulars coming back.
4. Nina’s Pizza
At Nina’s Pizza on Genesee Street, you’ll find a local pizzeria with a knack for getting every detail right. The vibe here is relaxed, with friendly staff who seem to remember everyone’s favorite order. The open kitchen lets you watch as dough is stretched and pies are tossed, which adds a bit of personal theater to each visit.
What drew me back was the balance they achieve between a chewy, tender crust and a lively, well-seasoned sauce. Their cheese blend has genuine character—rich, just a hint sharp, and satisfyingly melted with every slice. This isn’t pizza that tries too hard; it just lets the ingredients do the talking.
For first-timers, the margherita pizza is the move. Bright tomatoes, fresh basil, and a drizzle of olive oil highlight the basics done perfectly. If you want something heartier, their spinach and ricotta pie is a solid bet for flavor and comfort.
5. Franco’s Pizza & Italian Deli
Franco’s Pizza & Italian Deli on Trenton Avenue is where pizza lovers and comfort food seekers cross paths. It’s more than a pizza shop; you’ll smell fresh-baked bread and see a deli counter full of classic sides and salads. On my last visit, the friendly counter chat and tempting menu made it tough to walk out with just one thing.
Franco’s does pizza Utica-style: easygoing, generous, and full of flavor. Their crust has a chewy bite and the sauce tastes homemade, which is harder to find than you’d think. There’s real joy in their cheese pizzas, especially when pulled from the oven bubbling and golden.
Try the veggie supreme for a colorful, hearty meal or a plain slice with extra sauce. Both reflect the straightforward, satisfying style Franco’s does so well.
6. Palermo Pizzeria
Palermo Pizzeria on Genesee Street gives you a taste of classic Italian-American pizza right in the heart of Utica. The first thing you’ll notice when you walk in is a cheerful buzz—this is the sort of spot that families rely on for midweek dinners and game nights. My most memorable experience was grabbing a pie to go, only to dig in while it was still warm in the car. No regrets.
Palermo’s stands out for its thick, sturdy crust and a sauce that tastes like it simmered all morning. The pizzas here lean a bit rustic, with toppings spread thick and cheese that melts into every corner. Every bite is hearty and straightforward.
The classic cheese pizza is always a strong bet, but if you’re ready for something more, the veggie or white pizza showcases Palermo’s ability to layer flavors and textures.
7. Slice
Slice on Genesee Street makes its case with big, bold pizza that’s easy to love. Walk in and you’re greeted by an open counter filled with options—giant pies cut into classic foldable slices. There’s a no-nonsense charm here, and it’s a favorite late-night go-to for students or anyone chasing real flavor after a long day.
The appeal at Slice is the crust: thin, with just enough chew to feel satisfying, yet never heavy. Their sauce has a gentle kick, setting off a cheese blend that’s gooey but never greasy. Watching your slice get warmed up right in front of you adds extra comfort.
Don’t overthink it—order a plain cheese slice first, or try a vegetable-topped pie for something more colorful. Either way, you get the heart of what makes Slice stand out.
8. Lukins Brick Oven Pizza
Lukins Brick Oven Pizza on Varick Street draws you in with the aroma of wood-fired crust and the hum of a night out. This spot feels lively, and the crisp heat of the oven brings every pie to life. My most memorable meal here was shared with friends, swapping slices and debating which one had the best char.
The brick oven makes all the difference: you get crust that’s light, blistered, and smoky on the underside. Lukins doesn’t pile their pizzas high, but every ingredient feels chosen for its punch of flavor. There’s a creativity here that’s fun but never fussy.
Start with their margherita for a crash course in simplicity, or try the roasted vegetable pie for something that shows off the oven’s fire-kissed charm.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Chenango Road is the place Utica turns to when only fast, familiar pizza will do. There’s comfort in knowing exactly what you’re getting, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick delivery. My go-to order here usually arrives hot, with that signature herby crust and stretchy cheese.
What sets Domino’s apart is its sheer variety—there’s a style for every mood. Choose from thin, New York-style slices to their thick, classic pan pizza. Every option comes with that dependable, consistent flavor Domino’s is known for.
Try the hand-tossed veggie pizza for a lighter bite, or indulge in their mozzarella-laden cheese pizza if you’re after the classics. Domino’s keeps it easy and reliable, every time.
10. Rosario’s Pizzeria East Utica
Rosario’s Pizzeria East Utica on Welsh Bush Road is the kind of neighborhood spot that feels like a well-kept secret. You walk in and the air is filled with the scent of bubbling cheese and fresh dough. My most recent visit ended with a pizza box on the passenger seat and the interior fogged with steam, which honestly felt like a hallmark of a good pie.
Rosario’s stands out for its blend of authentic Italian tradition and Utica spirit. The sauce has a gentle sweetness, the cheese stretches for miles, and the crust has that golden bite you chase after. Each pie is carefully baked, so even a busy night never feels rushed.
Go for a classic margherita for a snapshot of what makes Rosario’s click, or try their veggie-loaded option for a pizza that eats like a meal.
More Things to Try in Utica, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of pizza is Utica known for?
Utica is famous for its unique “upside-down” pizza, where the sauce is layered on top of the cheese. The style features a crispy, sturdy crust and a bright, tangy tomato sauce.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Utica?
Yes, most pizza places in Utica offer vegetarian choices. Look for margherita, white garlic, and vegetable-loaded pizzas for delicious meatless options.
Can I find late-night pizza in Utica?
Absolutely. Several pizzerias, including Slice and Lukins Brick Oven Pizza, keep their ovens hot into the late hours. Perfect for a post-event craving or a night out.
Is delivery widely available in Utica?
Most pizzerias offer delivery and takeout. Chains like Domino’s and local favorites such as Franco’s, Slice, and O’scugnizzo make it easy to enjoy fresh pizza at home.
Which Utica pizzeria is best for families?
Places like Parkway Pizza and Palermo Pizzeria have a welcoming family vibe, roomy seating, and plenty of pizza choices for all ages.