Milwaukee’s pizza scene is rich and diverse, boasting a wide range of flavors that cater to every palate. Picture this: a cozy pizzeria with the scent of fresh dough filling the air, a sprinkle of cheese melting perfectly, and the sound of laughter vibrating from the tables. Each slice tells a story, whether it’s a family recipe or a modern twist on a classic favorite. The city offers an impressive lineup of pizzerias, each with its own unique take, ensuring that you’ll discover something that resonates with your taste buds.
As someone who has navigated through the vibrant pizza landscape of Milwaukee, I can confidently guide you through the best spots to tantalize your senses. From traditional Italian delis to innovative eateries that push the pizza envelope, this list covers it all. By the end of this journey, you’ll be craving a slice—or maybe two—of what Milwaukee has to offer. Let’s dive into the delicious world of pizza and find your new favorite spot.
Where to find the best pizza in Milwaukee, WI
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Milwaukee, WI:
- Santino’s Little Italy
- Transfer Pizzeria Café
- Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante
- Calderone Club
- San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
- Zaffiro’s
- Ned’s Pizza
- Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant
- National Pizza Pub & Grille
- Organ Piper Music Palace
1. Santino’s Little Italy
Santino’s Little Italy is a gem nestled in a historic neighborhood of Milwaukee, radiating a cozy old-school Brooklyn vibe. The ambiance is inviting, perfect for sharing laughter and stories over a delicious meal. The moment you step in, you’re captivated by the blend of nostalgia and modern charm.
What truly makes Santino’s stand out is their Neapolitan-style pizza, crafted with the freshest ingredients and cooked to perfection in a massive wood-fired oven. I remember enjoying their Margherita pizza, where each bite offered a symphony of flavors—from tangy tomato to creamy mozzarella.
For a twist, don’t skip their pesto chicken pizza that highlights their artisanal approach, making it a delightful choice. Santino’s is more than just food; it’s about creating cherished memories while indulging in exceptional Italian cuisine.
2. Transfer Pizzeria Café
Transfer Pizzeria Café captures the essence of Milwaukee’s culinary history as it operates in the charming setting of a former pharmacy. With a vibrant atmosphere and a welcoming patio, it’s the perfect spot for enjoying pizza with friends. The stone-baked crust and fresh ingredients elevate every pie.
What sets Transfer apart is its dedication to hand-pressed pizzas, creating a unique taste that’s both hearty and satisfying. I recall savoring their pepperoni and roasted red pepper pizza, where the smoky flavors merged seamlessly with the robust tomato sauce.
For a special treat, try the house-made margherita pizza, showcasing their commitment to quality. With options for everyone, including vegans and those seeking gluten-free choices, Transfer is an essential stop in Milwaukee’s pizza scene.
3. Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante
Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante is a beloved local gem known for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu. This family-owned establishment is celebrated for its commitment to offering vegetarian-friendly, vegan, and gluten-free options, ensuring every guest finds something delightful.
During my visit, the highlight was their signature pizzas, which truly reflect the essence of Milwaukee’s pizza scene. The crust was perfectly crispy, topped with a rich tomato sauce and an abundance of fresh ingredients. I highly recommend their Sicilian-style pizza, a harmonious blend of robust flavors that exemplifies their dedication to quality.
Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, Balistreri’s promises a memorable experience with its authentic Italian-American cuisine and friendly service.
4. Calderone Club
Located in the heart of Milwaukee, Calderone Club on 842 N Old World 3rd St is a culinary gem that combines Italian charm with modern flair. The menu is rich with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, ensuring every guest finds something delightful to savor.
What truly sets Calderone Club apart is its legendary pizza. Their classic Margherita showcases a perfect balance of fresh basil, mozzarella, and a robust tomato sauce on a crispy crust. For those seeking a richer experience, the Sicilian Pizza is a must-try, offering a hearty blend of meats and cheeses.
Dining here is always a memorable experience, with a warm ambiance and welcoming service that invites you to linger over a delicious meal.
5. San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
Located at 838 N Old World 3rd St, San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is a haven for pizza lovers in Milwaukee. The restaurant is known for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, crafted meticulously to reflect the true essence of Italian cuisine. With options for vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free diners, there’s something for everyone.
During my visit, I was captivated by the Diavola pizza, topped with spicy salami, mozzarella, and a drizzle of olive oil. Each ingredient was fresh and vibrant, creating a delightful harmony of flavors. Their crust is a standout—light and airy with a perfect char, thanks to their wood-fired oven.
San Giorgio combines quality ingredients with a relaxed atmosphere, making it the ideal spot for a delicious meal.
6. Zaffiro’s
Zaffiro’s, located at 1724 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI, is a beloved local gem known for its vegan options and vegetarian-friendly menu. This cozy spot offers a range of dining experiences, from lunch and dinner to late-night bites, with the convenience of delivery, table service, and takeout.
My visit to Zaffiro’s was a delightful journey into the heart of Milwaukee’s pizza scene. The warm, welcoming atmosphere combined with the rich, savory aroma of fresh pizza made for an unforgettable experience.
What sets Zaffiro’s apart is their commitment to quality and flavor. The thin-crust pizza is a must-try, perfectly crispy and loaded with fresh ingredients. The Vegetarian Special is particularly noteworthy, showcasing a delightful blend of toppings that highlight the restaurant’s dedication to catering to diverse dietary preferences.
For a true taste of Milwaukee, Zaffiro’s pizza is a standout choice. Each bite reflects the passion and expertise behind the brand, making it a top recommendation for any pizza lover.
7. Ned’s Pizza
Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Ned’s Pizza has been a local favorite since 1969, serving up the city’s iconic thin crust pizza with timeless recipes that haven’t changed in over five decades. The moment you step in, there’s a warm, nostalgic feel—like walking into a cherished family tradition.
On my visit, I tried the Veggie Lover’s Delight, and the crispy, perfectly seasoned crust with fresh mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives completely won me over. The ingredients tasted fresh, and the balance of flavors made every bite memorable.
What sets Ned’s apart is its commitment to quality and consistency. Their specialty pizzas, like the Four Cheese Classic, offer a rich, comforting taste that truly reflects Milwaukee’s love for bold, hearty flavors.
Vegetarian-friendly and perfect for lunch or dinner, Ned’s is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Milwaukee-style pizza.
8. Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant
Located at 2995 S Clement Ave, Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant offers a rustic yet inviting dining experience in Milwaukee. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, it caters to various dietary preferences with options that are vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free.
During my visit, I couldn’t resist trying their Margherita pizza, and it was a delightful choice. The crust was thin and crispy, perfectly complemented by fresh basil and rich tomato sauce. Each bite felt like a tribute to the simplicity of authentic Italian cooking.
What sets Tenuta’s apart is their commitment to quality and traditional flavors. The Signature Meat Lovers Pizza is another standout, packed with a savory assortment of meats that will satisfy even the heartiest appetites.
Whether you choose to dine in or takeout, Tenuta’s promises a delicious Italian experience that will keep you coming back.
9. National Pizza Pub & Grille
Located at 5501 W National Ave, National Pizza Pub & Grille offers a welcoming neighborhood vibe that’s hard to resist. Known for its affordable prices and friendly service, this popular spot specializes in pizzas and calzones, but has an extensive menu that caters to diverse tastes.
During my visit, I indulged in their famed Italian Fries, a unique appetizer made from specialty pizza dough, deep-fried to golden perfection. They were a hit! The pepperoni pizza I ordered was just as impressive—crispy, cheesy, and generously topped, showcasing their commitment to quality.
With weekly food and drink specials, National Pizza Pub & Grille is perfect for a casual dining experience with friends or family. It’s a place where great food meets an inviting atmosphere.
10. Organ Piper Music Palace
Located at 4353 S 108th St in Greenfield, Organ Piper Music Palace isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s an entertainment destination. This unique venue combines delicious pizza with live music, featuring an impressive antique organ that plays nostalgic tunes, creating a lively atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back.
During my visit, I enjoyed their specialty sausage pizza, which boasted a delightful blend of spices and generous cheese. The crust was perfectly crisp, adding a satisfying crunch to each bite. It’s a perfect representation of why Organ Piper stands out, marrying great food with lively entertainment.
For a fun evening with family or friends, the combination of exceptional pizza and engaging live performances makes Organ Piper Music Palace a must-visit in Milwaukee.
More Things to Try in Milwaukee, WI
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best pizza places in Milwaukee, WI?
Milwaukee offers a variety of great pizza places. Some top picks include Zaffiro’s Pizza, known for its thin crust and classic toppings; Transfer Pizzeria Café, which is popular for its innovative toppings and cozy atmosphere; and Balistreri’s Italian-American Ristorante, offering a mix of Italian dishes and excellent pizza.
What types of pizza are popular in Milwaukee?
In Milwaukee, both thin crust and deep-dish pizzas are popular. The city is also known for its unique take on cracker-thin crust pizza, often topped with a generous layer of Wisconsin cheese.
Does Milwaukee have any unique styles of pizza?
Yes, Milwaukee is famous for its cracker-thin crust pizza, which is crispy and often cut into squares. This style is distinct from the traditional round slices found elsewhere.
Are there any vegan pizza options in Milwaukee?
Absolutely! Many pizza places in Milwaukee offer vegan options. Classic Slice and Ian’s Pizza are well-known for their vegan-friendly menus, providing a variety of plant-based toppings and cheese alternatives.
Where can I find the best deep-dish pizza in Milwaukee?
For deep-dish pizza lovers, Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria and Lisa’s Pizza are popular choices in Milwaukee. They both offer rich, hearty pies with plenty of cheese and toppings.
What are the typical pizza prices in Milwaukee?
Pizza prices in Milwaukee can vary, but you can expect to pay around $10 to $15 for a standard pizza at most places, with specialty or larger pizzas costing more.
Is pizza delivery available in Milwaukee?
Yes, most pizza restaurants in Milwaukee offer delivery services. Popular options like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and local favorites often provide delivery through their websites and apps, as well as through third-party services like DoorDash and Uber Eats.
Do any pizzerias in Milwaukee offer gluten-free options?
Many pizzerias in Milwaukee cater to gluten-free diets. Transfer Pizzeria Café and Pizza Shuttle are a couple of places known for their gluten-free crust options.
Are there any pizza events or festivals in Milwaukee?
Yes, Milwaukee hosts several food festivals where pizza is featured, such as the Milwaukee Pizza Fest. These events are a great way to explore different styles and flavors from various local pizzerias.