When hunger strikes in El Dorado, AR, pizza is more than a fallback—it’s a favorite. Tucked between historic charm and quiet streets, this southern town serves up slices that surprise, satisfy, and stick in memory. I remember biting into a piping hot Supreme at a local spot off Northwest Avenue—it wasn’t just the crispy base or rich sauce that impressed me. It was the way every bite felt thoughtful, perfectly balanced, and made with care. That moment turned into a habit, and the habit into a quest: find the very best pizza this city offers.
El Dorado’s pizza scene blends big names with neighborhood treasures, each offering their own take on the timeless pie. Whether you’re after a thin crust folded with local flair, or a deep-dish indulgence that refuses shortcuts, you’ll find options that keep it real and skip the fluff. I’ve sifted through menus, counted toppings, and gathered honest feedback—so you don’t have to. Read on, and we’ll cut through the noise and straight to the slices worth your time.
Where to find the best pizza in El Dorado, AR
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in El Dorado, AR:
- Pizza Pro
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Larry’s Pizza
- Poppy’s Pizza
- La Piazza Italian Restaurant
- Papa John’s Pizza
1. Pizza Pro
Pizza Pro in El Dorado isn’t just a quick stop—it’s a quiet staple tucked on North Jackson Ave that delivers consistently solid pizza. On my last visit, I walked in expecting something typical but left impressed by a crust that held up under serious toppings and a sauce that leaned just right between sweet and savory. It felt like the kind of pie you’d get from a kitchen that knows what it’s doing.
What sets Pizza Pro apart is its unfussy charm. You get honest pizza made for everyday cravings—nothing flashy, just reliable and tasty. It’s the kind of place locals return to when they want something that hits the spot without pretense.
If you’re ordering, try the Meat Lover’s (minus any haram toppings). It shows off their generous topping style and bold flavor layering. Their veggie combo also deserves a mention for freshness and balance, especially if you’re skipping meat.
Street parking is easy, service is fast, and they accept a wide range of payments—making Pizza Pro both accessible and dependable.
2. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in El Dorado offers a reliable and versatile pizza experience that caters to a variety of tastes. I recall ordering a large pizza with their classic thin crust topped with fresh vegetables—it arrived hot and perfectly cooked, ready to satisfy my craving for something quick and flavorful. Their commitment to quality makes every order feel consistent and dependable.
What makes Domino’s stand out is its extensive menu and unbeatable deals. Whether you prefer a foldable New York Style slice or a hearty Pan pizza, they deliver on flavor and value. Their famous Parmesan Stuffed Crust adds a cheesy twist that appeals to those seeking a little extra indulgence.
For a true taste of what’s popular in El Dorado, I recommend trying their pepperoni or sausage toppings—both showcasing their focus on bold, satisfying flavors. With quick delivery and flexible payment options, Domino’s makes it easy to enjoy pizza without fuss.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in El Dorado is known for its classic approach to pizza, offering familiar favorites with a touch of comfort. I remember ordering their Original Stuffed Crust pizza; the cheese packed inside the crust made each bite irresistibly cheesy and satisfying. The consistency and quality remind me why Pizza Hut remains a reliable choice for many.
What sets Pizza Hut apart is its focus on hearty, classic options. Their Meat Lovers® pizza showcases their generous toppings and rich flavors, reflecting their commitment to delivering filling, enjoyable pizza. It’s a go-to spot for those craving comfort food with a recognizable taste.
If you’re in El Dorado, try their signature wings or pasta to complement your pizza. Quick service and easy curbside pickup make Pizza Hut an effortless choice for a satisfying meal.
4. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars in El Dorado is known for delivering quality pizza at an affordable price, making it a popular choice for families and quick bites. I remember grabbing a Deep! Deep! Dish Pepperoni pizza, which was hot, cheesy, and satisfying—perfect for a busy weeknight. Its fast service and consistent taste keep me coming back.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is its emphasis on value and convenience. Their Hot-N-Ready options let you grab a pie without waiting, while their use of fresh ingredients, like vine-ripened tomato sauce and scratch-made dough, ensures a satisfying flavor.
If you’re in El Dorado, the Classic Pepperoni or their Pepperoni Pizza with their famous Crazy Bread make excellent choices. Both reflect their commitment to quality and budget-friendly bites that don’t compromise on taste.
5. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Stopping by Hunt Brothers Pizza on Hillsboro Street felt less like visiting a chain and more like finding a reliable neighborhood spot. Though tucked inside a local convenience store, the place delivers big on flavor and friendliness. My pepperoni pizza was piping hot, with a golden crust that held up beautifully under a generous layer of cheese.
What sets Hunt Brothers apart is their consistency and no-fuss style. You won’t find an expansive menu, but you will get hearty portions and customizable options without added cost. Their “All Toppings No Extra Charge” approach reflects their practical, customer-first mindset.
If you’re in El Dorado and craving something bold, try the Loaded Pizza. It’s packed with classic toppings and baked until the edges crisp just right. Ideal for those who like their pizza straightforward and satisfying.
Hunt Brothers is perfect for a quick, budget-friendly bite that doesn’t skimp on taste. It’s not artisanal, but it’s dependable—and sometimes that’s exactly what you need.
6. Larry’s Pizza
(870) 639-3922Call
My visit to Larry’s Pizza in El Dorado proved that good things come in sizable slices. The atmosphere is cozy, perfect for a family dinner or a casual get-together. I ordered a classic Margherita, and the fresh basil combined with a crispy crust made it stand out from the usual.
Larry’s Pizza is known for its hearty, flavorful pies that emphasize quality ingredients. Their attention to craftsmanship shows in every slice—whether it’s a specialty or a simple cheese pizza. They prioritize freshness and satisfying portions without overcomplicating things.
If you’re looking for a reliable slice of El Dorado, try their BBQ Chicken Pizza. Its smoky flavor and tender chicken reflect Larry’s commitment to flavorful, well-made pizza. It’s the kind of place that balances tradition with great taste.
For a comforting meal, Larry’s Pizza offers dependable quality that keeps locals coming back. It’s straightforward, satisfying, and just what you need for a classic pizza experience.
7. Poppy’s Pizza
Poppy’s Pizza, located at 2664 Haynesville Hwy, El Dorado, AR, is a local favorite for delicious, handcrafted pizza and classic American dishes. With a welcoming atmosphere and a focus on quality, it’s the perfect spot for family dinners or grabbing a quick bite. The restaurant offers free parking and wheelchair accessibility, making it convenient for all visitors.
What sets Poppy’s Pizza apart is its commitment to fresh, flavorful ingredients and a menu that caters to every taste. Their pizzas are crafted with care, featuring perfectly crisp crusts and generous toppings. Whether dining in or taking out, you’re guaranteed a satisfying meal.
Must-try dishes include the signature “Poppy’s Supreme Pizza”, loaded with fresh vegetables and savory meats, and their classic cheese pizza, which showcases the simplicity of their artisan approach. Pair it with a side of their garlic bread for a complete experience.
Visit Poppy’s Pizza today to experience the best of El Dorado’s pizza scene. Their friendly service and unbeatable flavors make every visit memorable!
8. La Piazza Italian Restaurant
La Piazza Italian Restaurant on Cedar Street offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that makes every meal feel special. During my visit, I was impressed by their authentic Italian flavors, especially their thin-crust pizzas topped with fresh ingredients. It’s a spot where comfort meets quality, and you can tell they put care into every dish.
What makes La Piazza stand out is its diverse menu and emphasis on Mediterranean and Italian cuisine. Their pizzas showcase a balance of crisp, flavorful crusts and generous toppings, reflecting an authentic European flair. It’s a great choice for those wanting more than just pizza, with dishes that celebrate Mediterranean freshness.
If you visit, try their Margherita Pizza or their specialty Veggie Pie. Both highlight their commitment to simple, quality ingredients and flavorful authentic recipes. It’s a place where Italian tradition is served with a welcoming smile.
9. Papa John’s Pizza
During my visit to Papa John’s in Junction City, I appreciated the consistent quality and fresh ingredients that define their brand. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza, which arrived hot with crispy crust and flavorful toppings. It’s a dependable choice if you’re after a satisfying, no-nonsense meal.
What makes Papa John’s stand out is its focus on quality ingredients and signature sauces. Their classic pizzas, especially the Pepperoni or Veggie options, highlight their commitment to flavor and freshness. The handmade dough and generous toppings ensure each slice is satisfying.
If you’re in El Dorado, their personalized pizza options and the Zesty Jalapeño Cheddar Stuffed Crust are excellent for a quick, tasty meal. Papa John’s delivers reliability with every order, making it a go-to for pizza lovers.
More Things to Try in El Dorado, AR
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best pizza in El Dorado?
Local favorites include Main Street Pizza for its fresh ingredients and cozy atmosphere, and La Piazza Italian Restaurant for authentic Italian-style pies [[0]](https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurants-g31569-c31-El_Dorado_Arkansas.html) [[1]](https://www.restaurantji.com/ar/el-dorado/pizza/).
Which pizza places offer delivery in El Dorado?
Domino’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars all provide delivery options. You can order online or through their apps for convenience [[1]](https://www.restaurantji.com/ar/el-dorado/pizza/) [[2]](https://www.yellowpages.com/el-dorado-ar/pizza).
Are there any locally owned pizza spots worth trying?
Yes, Poppy’s Pizza is a locally owned gem known for its friendly service and Sunday buffet. Main Street Pizza also offers a community-focused vibe with solid menu variety [[1]](https://www.restaurantji.com/ar/el-dorado/pizza/).
Do any pizza places in El Dorado offer vegetarian options?
Most chains like Domino’s and Papa John’s have veggie pizzas. Larry’s Pizza features a Veggie Pizza and customizable toppings for plant-based diners [[1]](https://www.restaurantji.com/ar/el-dorado/pizza/).
Which pizza restaurants are good for dine-in?
La Piazza and Main Street Pizza offer comfortable dine-in experiences. Larry’s Pizza also has a game room and themed nights, making it a fun spot for families [[0]](https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurants-g31569-c31-El_Dorado_Arkansas.html) [[1]](https://www.restaurantji.com/ar/el-dorado/pizza/).
Are there any pizza places open late?
Chain locations like Domino’s and Pizza Hut typically stay open later than local spots. Check their hours online before heading out [[2]](https://www.yellowpages.com/el-dorado-ar/pizza).
Do any places offer gluten-free pizza?
Domino’s and Papa John’s offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability and preparation practices.
Can I find halal or haram-free pizza in El Dorado?
While specific halal options may be limited, you can request vegetarian or seafood-based pizzas at most locations to avoid haram ingredients.