Locating the best pizza in McAllen, TX, can feel like a delightful quest. Over the years, I’ve explored many places, each offering its unique spin on this beloved dish. My personal favorite is the balance between crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. There’s nothing quite like biting into a slice that combines these elements just right—a feeling that keeps me coming back for more. Whether you prefer classic toppings or inventive combinations, McAllen has a pizzeria to satisfy your cravings.
What sets this city apart is its diverse range of options, from cozy neighborhood spots to larger chains. The range ensures that everyone, whether a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, finds their ideal slice. This guide aims to highlight the most notable places, backed by real experience and a passion for quality pizza. If you’re eager to discover where to find the most satisfying slice in McAllen, you’re in the right place. Prepare to uncover some hidden gems and well-loved favorites for your next pizza night.
Where to find the best pizza in McAllen, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in McAllen, TX:
- Mama Mia Pizzeria
- Mama’s Pizzeria
- Cicis Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Extreme Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Pizza Hut
- Little Caesars
- Peter Piper Pizza
- Malfitany Pasta Company
1. Mama Mia Pizzeria
Nestled at 100 E US Highway 83, Mama Mia Pizzeria is a favorite among locals for its authentic and flavorful pizza. I remember my first visit, enchanted by the inviting aromas and warm atmosphere. The staff’s friendly service makes every meal feel personal, whether you dine in or opt for takeout.
What sets Mama Mia apart is its commitment to quality and variety. The menu features vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring every guest feels accommodated. Their signature Margherita and BBQ chicken pizzas are must-tries, showcasing a perfect balance of fresh ingredients and crisp crust. For a true taste of McAllen, Mama Mia Pizzeria delivers a slice of comfort with every bite.
2. Mama’s Pizzeria
Mama’s Pizzeria, tucked away on N 10th Street, is one of those places that feels like it’s been part of the neighborhood forever. I stopped in on a quiet afternoon and was greeted with the kind of warmth that’s hard to find. The space is cozy, and the aroma of fresh dough and herbs sets the tone for a satisfying meal.
Their pizzas lean into tradition, with a focus on simple, bold flavors. The veggie pizza stands out—loaded with fresh toppings and a crust that’s crisp without being dry. If you’re after something hearty, the cheese-stuffed crust options are worth exploring. Mama’s Pizzeria doesn’t try to impress with gimmicks; it wins you over with consistency and care.
3. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza, located on Trenton Road, is where variety meets value. I first visited with a group of friends, and the all-you-can-eat buffet made it easy for everyone to find something they liked. The casual setup and game room add a playful touch, making it ideal for families and relaxed outings.
What makes Cicis stand out is its endless selection. From classic cheese to zesty veggie, the buffet is constantly refreshed. If you don’t see your favorite, they’ll make it fresh on request. Their Spinach Alfredo Pizza is a personal favorite—creamy, savory, and surprisingly light. The Mac & Cheese Pizza is another standout, offering a fun twist that’s both nostalgic and satisfying.
For those seeking variety without compromising on flavor, Cicis Pizza delivers a buffet experience that’s hard to beat.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 739 W. Dove is a reliable spot for classic pizza. I remember ordering a Pepperoni Lover’s Pizza here, and the crust was perfectly baked, with a generous amount of toppings. The familiar flavors and warm atmosphere make it a go-to whenever I crave familiar comfort food.
What makes Pizza Hut memorable is its Original Stuffed Crust—a slice of cheesy indulgence. For variety, their Meat Lovers® pizza offers a hearty option loaded with savory toppings. Pair it with their signature wings or a side of pasta for a complete meal that highlights their commitment to quality and flavor.
Pizza Hut’s consistency and signature style make it a top choice for dependable, satisfying pizza in McAllen.
5. Extreme Pizza
Extreme Pizza, located on W Nolana Ave, lives up to its name with innovative flavor combinations. I tried their BBQ Chicken Pizza, and the smoky sauce combined with tender chicken and fresh toppings made it a standout. It’s clear they focus on quality ingredients and creative pairing.
What sets Extreme Pizza apart is its “not mainstream” approach. Their unique options, like the Hawaiian Cheeseburger, show a playful yet sophisticated take on pizza that appeals to adventurous eaters. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, the bold flavors are always consistent.
If you’re looking for a pizza experience that breaks the mold, Extreme Pizza offers inventive dishes that reflect their extreme philosophy and dedication to quality.
6. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 2000 S McColl is a familiar favorite for classic, dependable pizza. I ordered their Meat Lovers® pizza once, and the generous toppings and perfect crust reminded me why so many choose Pizza Hut for comforting, consistent flavors. The friendly staff made the experience even more enjoyable.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is its Original Stuffed Crust—a signature feature that adds extra indulgence. Their wings and pasta dishes complement the pizza perfectly, creating a well-rounded meal. Whether you’re dining in or ordering for takeout, the quality and familiar taste never disappoint.
For those craving a reliable slice, Pizza Hut’s fusion of tradition and flavor keeps it at the top of the list in McAllen.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 404 S 10th St has a way of making simple comfort feel like a culinary win. On my last visit, I opted for the Veggie Lover’s pizza with their signature Original Stuffed Crust. The crust carried just the right amount of cheese—rich but not overwhelming—and the vegetables were fresh and well-balanced across each slice.
What truly sets this location apart is its consistency. Every visit delivers on the basics: timely service, warm pizza, and a clean dining space. It’s easy to appreciate that kind of reliability when hunger meets high expectations.
If you’re ordering in McAllen, try their Cheese Pizza with Thin ‘N Crispy crust. It’s light, flavorful, and doesn’t need extra toppings to shine. That’s Pizza Hut’s quiet strength—doing the essentials well, every time.
8. Little Caesars
Little Caesars at 6101 N 23rd St offers quick, satisfying pizza that’s perfect for a busy day. I once grabbed a Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni pizza on my way home, and it was ready in minutes. The crust was crispy, and the toppings were satisfying, making it a reliable choice for a hungry family.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is its commitment to affordability and convenience. Their Deep! Deep! Dish Pizza delivers rich, thick layers of cheese and toppings for those craving something more filling. The Extra Most Bestest Pepperoni is a favorite—generously loaded, ensuring every slice packs a punch.
For a quick and tasty meal in McAllen, Little Caesars offers great value and consistent quality, making it a go-to for many pizza lovers.
9. Peter Piper Pizza
Peter Piper Pizza at 1620 N 10th St is more than just a pizza place; it’s a family-friendly entertainment hub. I visited with my children, and the arcade games kept them engaged while I enjoyed a slice of their handcrafted BBQ Chicken Pizza. The dough is made fresh daily, and the toppings are always vibrant and flavorful.
What makes Peter Piper unique is its combination of quality pizza and fun atmosphere. Their Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza is a tried-and-true favorite that appeals to all ages. The spacious layout and large TVs make it a perfect spot to relax or catch a game.
For a family outing that combines great food with entertainment, Peter Piper delivers a memorable experience rooted in freshness and fun.
10. Malfitany Pasta Company
Malfitany Pasta Company at 2013 W Nolana Ave is a hidden gem for authentic Italian and pizza dishes. I recently enjoyed their Homemade Margherita Pizza, featuring fresh dough, rich tomato sauce, and fragrant basil. It’s a perfect reflection of their dedication to scratch-made ingredients.
What makes Malfitany stand out is their commitment to quality. Every element, from pasta to dough, is made daily with care. Their Homemade Noodles and flavorful sauces elevate traditional Italian favorites and create a truly satisfying meal.
Whether dining family-style or grabbing takeout, Malfitany Pasta Company offers authentic flavors that capture the essence of Italy.
More Things to Try in McAllen, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best traditional pizza in McAllen, TX?
A: For classic pizza flavors, places like Mama Mia Pizzeria and Pizza Hut are popular choices. They offer well-loved options like Margherita and Meat Lovers’ pizza, both reflecting authentic styles.
Q: Are there gluten-free or vegetarian pizza options in McAllen?
A: Yes. Many pizzerias, including Mama’s Pizzeria and Mama Mia Pizzeria, feature vegetarian and gluten-free options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a tasty slice.
Q: Which pizza places offer quick service or takeout in McAllen?
A: Chains like Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, and Domino’s are known for speedy takeout and delivery. They’re perfect if you want hot pizza served fast.
Q: Are there family-friendly pizza spots in McAllen?
A: Absolutely. Places like Peter Piper Pizza offer arcade games and a playful atmosphere, making them ideal for family outings.
Q: What are some unique or innovative pizza options in McAllen?
A: Extreme Pizza offers inventive combinations, such as the BBQ Chicken or Hawaiian Cheeseburger pizzas, for those looking to try something new.