Finding the best pizza in Charlottesville, VA, isn’t just a matter of choosing toppings or crust styles—it’s about discovering spots that turn a simple slice into a memorable experience. Over the years, I’ve sampled a variety of local pizzerias, from classic Neapolitan favorites to inventive modern twists. Each place offers its unique charm, making it clear that Charlottesville’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious. Whether you prefer a thin, crispy crust or a thick, chewy base, there’s something here for every pizza enthusiast.
What truly sets Charlottesville apart is the passion artisans pour into their craft. From wood-fired ovens to inventive artisanal toppings, the city’s pizzerias aim for excellence in every pie they produce. I’ve found that exploring these establishments often reveals more than just great food—it’s about experiencing a sense of community and tradition in each bite. If you’re on a quest for exceptional pizza, this guide will lead you to some of the town’s most beloved and critically acclaimed spots.
Where to find the best pizza in Charlottesville, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Charlottesville, VA:
- Mellow Mushroom Charlottesville
- Christian’s Pizza
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria
- Sal’s Caffe Italia
- Fabio’s NY Pizza
- Benny Deluca’s
- Vita Nova New York Style Pizza & Restaurant
- Vinny’s Italian Grill
- Anna’s Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza
1. Mellow Mushroom Charlottesville
Nestled on West Main Street, Mellow Mushroom Charlottesville offers a vibrant twist on classic pizza dining. I’ve enjoyed their creatively inspired stone-baked pies, which stand out for their bold flavors and perfect, crispy crusts. The lively atmosphere, whether inside or on the patio, makes every visit feel special.
What sets Mellow Mushroom apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients and diverse options, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices. I recommend their signature House Special Pizza, loaded with fresh toppings and flavor-packed sauce—it’s a great reflection of their innovative style. Pair it with a local craft beer or a refreshing salad for a truly satisfying experience. For a relaxed yet flavorful pizza outing, this spot is hard to beat.
2. Christian’s Pizza
Nestled in the heart of Charlottesville, Christian’s Pizza at 118 W Main St offers a delightful haven for pizza lovers. Their menu is vegetarian-friendly, making it an inclusive spot for everyone seeking a satisfying meal. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch, dinner, or a late-night slice, their commitment to quality is evident in every bite.
What truly sets Christian’s Pizza apart is their adventurous array of flavors and toppings. I fondly remember indulging in their signature White Pizza, a perfect blend of ricotta and mozzarella, infused with fresh garlic. It’s a must-try for anyone visiting Charlottesville.
For a unique taste experience, opt for Christian’s Artichoke and Spinach Pizza. It’s a delicious testament to their creativity and flair. Enjoy the convenience of fast takeout and savor each slice.
3. Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria
Located at 205 Monticello Rd, Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria is renowned for crafting authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. My visit there was memorable; the crust’s perfect thinness combined with fresh toppings made each bite exceptional. The warm, inviting atmosphere complements their dedication to traditional pizza making.
What makes Lampo stand out is their focus on authentic ingredients and a menu that’s both vegetarian and vegan friendly. I highly recommend trying their Margherita Pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella and basil—simple yet bursting with flavor, showcasing their mastery in Neapolitan tradition. They accept various credit cards, making it convenient for every guest.
For a taste of Italy right in Charlottesville, Lampo offers a slice of genuine artistry, where quality and tradition meet in every pizza.
4. Sal’s Caffe Italia
Sal’s Caffe Italia is a family-owned gem located in the heart of Charlottesville’s vibrant pedestrian mall. Offering both indoor and outdoor seating, including a cozy outdoor bar, it’s the perfect spot to savor authentic Italian flavors in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
What sets Sal’s apart is their commitment to tradition and quality. Their menu caters to all, offering vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, ensuring everyone can enjoy their handcrafted dishes. The friendly service and relaxed ambiance make it ideal for both casual lunches and special dinners.
When it comes to pizza, Sal’s delivers unmatched authenticity. The Margherita Pizza, with its fresh basil, mozzarella, and perfectly crisp crust, is a must-try. Pair it with a side of their house-made garlic knots for a truly memorable meal.
5. Fabio’s NY Pizza
Since opening in 2008, Fabio’s NY Pizza has become a favorite spot for those craving authentic New York-style pizza in Charlottesville. I recall their generous, thin-crust slices that are just the right balance of crispy and chewy. The lively, inviting atmosphere makes every visit enjoyable.
Their commitment to fresh ingredients and excellent service shines through with every dish. I recommend trying the Classic Pepperoni Pizza—it captures the true essence of NY pizza with its flavorful toppings and perfect crust. Whether dining in or taking out, Fabio’s consistently delivers a taste of Manhattan in Virginia.
For a hearty, satisfying bite that transports you straight to New York, Fabio’s NY Pizza is hard to beat.
6. Benny Deluca’s
Located at 913 W Main St, Benny Deluca’s is a beloved local pizzeria known for its friendly atmosphere and satisfying slices. I’ve enjoyed their inviting environment and the consistently good quality of their pizza, which makes it a go-to spot for both lunch and dinner.
What makes Benny Deluca’s stand out is their focus on fresh ingredients and classic flavors. I recommend trying their Margherita Pizza—light, flavorful, and topped with fresh basil and mozzarella, perfectly reflecting their commitment to quality. With convenient takeout options, it’s easy to enjoy a slice of authentic Italian-American comfort food right at home.
For anyone seeking a dependable and delicious pizza experience, Benny Deluca’s is a local treasure that never disappoints.
7. Vita Nova New York Style Pizza & Restaurant
Vita Nova New York Style Pizza & Restaurant, located at 310 E Main St in Downtown Mall, Charlottesville, is a must-visit for lovers of authentic Italian flavors. Known for its gourmet New York-style pizzas, this cozy eatery captures the essence of Italy with every bite. Their focus on fresh ingredients and traditional recipes ensures a consistently delightful dining experience.
What sets Vita Nova apart is its dedication to quality and creativity. Each pizza is crafted with care, from their perfectly baked crusts to their signature sauces and gourmet toppings. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, you’ll find a menu that satisfies both classic and adventurous palates.
For a standout choice, try the Margherita Pizza, a simple yet flavorful masterpiece topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a rich tomato sauce. The Vegetarian Deluxe Pizza, loaded with seasonal veggies, is another must-try. Every dish reflects Vita Nova’s commitment to excellence, making it a top pick for pizza in Charlottesville.
Experience the warm hospitality and irresistible flavors that make Vita Nova a local favorite. One visit, and you’ll be hooked!
8. Vinny’s Italian Grill
Located at 241 Connor Dr, Vinny’s Italian Grill offers a warm and inviting atmosphere to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine. I personally appreciated how their menu balances traditional flavors with a modern touch, making each meal memorable. Their friendly service and cozy setting make it a great spot for both lunch and dinner.
Vinny’s stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and inviting ambiance. Their Margherita Pizza is a highlight, with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a rich tomato sauce baked to perfection. For a more hearty option, the Vegetarian Pizza loaded with seasonal veggies perfectly reflects their focus on fresh, flavorful ingredients.
Whether dining in or taking out, Vinny’s Italian Grill consistently delivers a delightful pizza experience rooted in tradition and quality.
9. Anna’s Pizza
Nestled on 115 Maury Ave, Anna’s Pizza is a laid-back spot that’s quietly won over locals with its no-frills charm and well-crafted pies. I remember stopping by after a long afternoon and feeling right at home amid the humble décor and familiar smell of fresh dough rising.
What sets Anna’s apart is its commitment to simplicity done right. The crust is soft but holds its own, and the sauce leans savory without overpowering. Their Cheese Pizza might seem basic, but it’s anything but bland — layered with perfectly melted mozzarella that speaks to their kitchen’s attention to quality.
For a little more texture, the Vegetable Pizza offers a bright mix of bell peppers, onions, and mushrooms — no shortcuts, just fresh ingredients.
If you’re looking for well-made pizza in Charlottesville without the extra noise, Anna’s quietly delivers.
10. Marco’s Pizza
On Olympia Drive, Marco’s Pizza stands out as a local favorite for its authentic Italian-style pies. I recall their dough, which is made fresh daily, providing a perfect base for their vibrant sauces and cheeses. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through with every bite.
Their Three-Cheese Blend Pizza is a highlight — a rich, creamy combination that balances flavors beautifully. Besides pizza, they offer hearty subs, wings, salads, and desserts, making it a versatile spot for any craving.
As a veteran-owned business, Marco’s proudly supports the community, and their friendly service makes every visit enjoyable. For a satisfying, quality pizza experience in Charlottesville, it’s a reliable choice.
More Things to Try in Charlottesville, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Charlottesville, VA?
Charlottesville offers a variety of great pizza spots. Some top-rated choices include:
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Known for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas.
- Mellow Mushroom: Offers a creative and diverse menu with a funky vibe.
- Christian’s Pizza: Popular for its wide array of topping choices and large slices.
- Crozet Pizza: A local favorite with unique flavor offerings.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Charlottesville, VA?
Several places offer gluten-free options:
- Mellow Mushroom: Known for its gluten-free crust.
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Offers gluten-free options upon request.
- Brixx Wood Fired Pizza: Has a dedicated gluten-free menu.
Are there vegan-friendly pizza options in Charlottesville, VA?
Yes, many places cater to vegans:
- Mellow Mushroom: Offers vegan cheese and a variety of vegetable toppings.
- Christian’s Pizza: Provides several vegan topping choices.
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Can accommodate vegan requests with their fresh ingredients.
Which pizza places offer delivery in Charlottesville, VA?
Several pizza places provide delivery services:
- Domino’s and Papa John’s: Offer reliable delivery services throughout Charlottesville.
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Available through food delivery apps.
- Mellow Mushroom: Also partners with delivery apps for convenience.
Are there any pizza places in Charlottesville with outdoor seating?
Yes, enjoy pizza with a view at these spots:
- Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Offers a pleasant outdoor seating area.
- Mellow Mushroom: Features a patio for outdoor dining.
- Three Notch’d Craft Kitchen & Brewery: Offers a great outdoor space with pizza and craft brews.
What are some family-friendly pizza places in Charlottesville, VA?
Families will enjoy these locations:
- Mellow Mushroom: Known for its fun atmosphere and kid-friendly menu.
- Brixx Wood Fired Pizza: Offers a casual setting with a menu that appeals to all ages.
- Christian’s Pizza: Provides a relaxed environment and varied menu options.
Where can I find the best pizza deals in Charlottesville, VA?
Look for deals at:
- Domino’s and Papa John’s: Frequently have online specials and coupons.
- Local eateries: Such as Benny Deluca’s, often have slice specials or student discounts.