Looking for the best pizza in Washington, NC isn’t just a craving—it’s a quiet hunt that turns into a ritual. I remember driving along Highway 264 with a rumbling stomach and no fixed destination, ending up at a tiny shop with mismatched chairs and warm lighting. What I found on the plate was unexpected: a crust with character, sauce that didn’t overpower, and toppings that didn’t play it safe. That was my first encounter with local pizza that didn’t pretend to be New York or Naples—it was unapologetically Washington.
This guide brings that same clarity. Whether you’re after classic thin-crust, a slice with local flair, or a place that still believes dough should be made in-house, Washington has more to offer than chain options. Each spot listed here has been chosen for its own merit—from family-run favorites to reliable pizzerias that deliver more than just speed. If you’re looking for great pizza without compromising your taste or values, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Washington, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Washington, NC:
- Frank’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Marabella’s Pizza and Grill
- Haven’s Mill Pizza Co.
- Pizza Hut
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Pizza Inn
- Domino’s Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Labella Pizza Inc
1. Frank’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Founded in 1986, Frank’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant has become a neighborhood staple in Washington, NC. I recall visiting on a busy weekend, where the rich aroma of baked dough and seasoned toppings greeted everyone at the door. The staff’s warmth and friendliness felt just like dining with family, which is what Frank’s strives for.
What truly sets Frank’s apart is their authentic New York style pizza made in various sizes, perfect for any appetite. Their calzones and strombolis offer a delicious twist on classic favorites. I recommend trying their pizza or pasta dinners—each dish showcases quality ingredients and a dedication to flavor. Whether for dine-in or takeout, Frank’s consistently delivers satisfying meals with a welcoming touch.
2. Marabella’s Pizza and Grill
During a visit to Washington, NC, I discovered Marabella’s Pizza and Grill, a spot that combines casual comfort with quality ingredients. Their welcoming atmosphere makes it ideal for a laid-back lunch or dinner with friends or family. I was impressed by the variety and how they cater to dietary preferences, including vegetarian and vegan options.
What makes Marabella’s stand out is their attention to both taste and inclusivity. I recommend trying their signature pizza, which features fresh toppings and a perfectly crisp crust that reflects their dedication to quality. Their grilled dishes and specialty pizzas showcase a blend of flavors that keep customers coming back. For a satisfying, flavor-packed meal, Marabella’s offers some of the best pizza in Washington, NC.
3. Haven’s Mill Pizza Co.
See Menu
During a quick stop in Washington, NC, I stumbled upon Haven’s Mill Pizza Co., a cozy spot that instantly felt inviting. Their focus on pizza means every bite is crafted with care, using fresh ingredients that highlight pure, honest flavors. The rustic vibe adds to the charm of dining here.
What truly sets Haven’s Mill apart is their straightforward but flavorful pizza selection. I recommend the classic Margherita or their signature specialty with a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Each slice exemplifies the place’s commitment to quality and simplicity. If you’re seeking authentic pizza with a local touch, Haven’s Mill Pizza Co. delivers just that in Washington, NC.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Washington, NC, offers a familiar experience with its consistent quality and variety. It’s the kind of place where you know what you’re getting, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a box to go. I remember ordering their Original Stuffed Crust on a rainy evening—the warm, cheesy edges hit the spot without trying too hard.
What keeps Pizza Hut relevant is their range. Their Meat Lovers® pizza is a bold choice for hearty appetites, while the Original Stuffed Crust® remains a fan favorite for its indulgent texture. If you’re in a hurry or need a dependable bite, Pizza Hut delivers flavor and familiarity every time. For classic, comfort-style pizza, it remains a solid pick in Washington, NC.
5. Papa Johns Pizza
During a busy day in Washington, NC, I turned to Papa Johns Pizza for a reliable meal. Their focus on Better Ingredients really shows in the quality of their toppings and crust. I recall ordering their classic pepperoni pizza, which arrived hot and flavorful, perfectly crispy on the edges.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their dedication to freshness and consistency. Their signature sauce pairs perfectly with various toppings, and their freshly baked breadsticks complement the pizza wonderfully. For a satisfying, dependable pizza experience, Papa Johns offers a taste that consistently meets expectations in Washington, NC.
6. Pizza Inn
Pizza Inn, located on Carolina Ave in Washington, NC, delivers a classic dine-in experience with its casual atmosphere and consistent quality. It’s one of those places where the smell of fresh dough and melted cheese hits you the moment you walk in.
I dropped in for a late lunch and went straight for the Buffet Special—a spread that showcased the variety Pizza Inn is known for. The thin-crust veggie pizza was crisp, generously topped, and not drowned in sauce, while the cheese pizza nailed the perfect gooey-to-crunch ratio.
What sets Pizza Inn apart is its commitment to freshness and variety. Their friendly table service makes it easy to settle in, and the menu caters to straightforward pizza cravings without pretense.
If you’re new here, try the Super Supreme. It’s well-balanced, flavorful, and reflects why Pizza Inn remains a local favorite in Washington, NC.
7. Domino’s Pizza
During a busy evening in Washington, NC, I ordered from Domino’s Pizza and appreciated their quick delivery and consistent quality. Whether you prefer the thin New York style crust or their thick Handmade Pan pizza, Domino’s caters to every craving with reliability and flavor.
I recommend trying their Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza for an indulgent twist or their famous cheese sticks for a perfect side. Their menu also includes pasta, salads, and wings—ensuring everyone finds something satisfying. Domino’s stands out for its value and variety, making it a go-to option for quality pizza in Washington, NC.
8. Little Caesars Pizza
On a quick call in Washington, NC, I decided to try Little Caesars Pizza for a simple yet satisfying meal. Known for their hot-N-Ready option, the convenience and speed are what make this spot stand out. The affordable prices don’t compromise flavor, making it ideal for a quick lunch or late-night snack.
I recommend grabbing their classic ExtraMostBestPizza® for a generous, cheesy experience. Their signature Deep! Deep! Dish Pizza or the Crispy Rye Sandwich are good options if you’re craving something hearty. Little Caesars’ focus on quality and quick service keeps it a popular choice in Washington.
9. Hunt Brothers Pizza
During a stop at Cratches Mini Mart in Washington, NC, I discovered Hunt Brothers Pizza, a convenient option for fresh, customizable pizza. Their approach of using all toppings no extra charge makes it easy to craft a pie exactly how you like it, whether you prefer original or thin crust.
I recommend trying their cheese pizza as a classic, or building your own with an array of toppings for a personalized treat. The pizzas are made with quality ingredients and cooked just right. Hunt Brothers stands out for offering straightforward, hearty pizza that’s perfect for a quick meal or snack when you’re on the go.
10. Labella Pizza Inc
Tucked into the heart of downtown, Labella Pizza Inc brings a touch of rustic charm to Washington, NC. The moment you step inside, the aroma of fresh dough and slow-simmered tomato sauce sets the tone. It’s a cozy, no-frills spot where the focus stays on flavor.
What sets Labella apart is its authentic approach to New York-style pizza. The crust is thin, crisped just right, and strong enough to hold generous toppings without folding under pressure. Their Margherita pizza is a standout—simple, balanced, and full of character. For something heartier, the Vegetarian Deluxe layers fresh veggies over a rich, herbed base.
Labella’s charm lies in its consistency. It’s the kind of place where locals return not out of habit, but out of loyalty to quality.
More Things to Try in Washington, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza in Washington, NC?
A: The best pizza varies based on personal taste, but spots like Frank’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Marabella’s Pizza and Grill, and Haven’s Mill Pizza Co. are highly recommended for their quality and flavor.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options available?
A: Yes, many local pizzerias like Marabella’s and Labella Pizza Inc offer vegetarian options, and some places are starting to include vegan toppings or crusts.
Q: Do local pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most restaurants in Washington, NC, including Domino’s and Papa Johns, provide delivery, takeout, and curbside pickup for added convenience.
Q: Are there gluten-free pizza options nearby?
A: Some spots like Frank’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant provide gluten-free crusts; it’s best to check with individual restaurants for availability.
Q: What are popular pizza styles in Washington, NC?
A: Popular styles include New York thin crust, hand-tossed, and deep-dish, with many restaurants offering their own unique twists.