Discovering the best pizza in Pueblo, CO, feels a bit like uncovering a hidden treasure. Having explored the city’s vibrant food scene, I’ve found that each pizzeria offers its own unique spin on this beloved dish. From thin-crust classics to hearty deep-dish creations, Pueblo’s pizza places serve up flavors that satisfy every craving. Whether you’re a local seeking a new favorite or a visitor eager to taste authentic styles, the city’s diverse options won’t disappoint.
What sets Pueblo’s pizzerias apart is their commitment to quality ingredients and genuine craftsmanship. Each slice tells a story—crafted with care and a touch of local flavor. This guide aims to highlight those standout spots that consistently deliver memorable pizza experiences. If you’re in search of perfecting your pizza game in Pueblo, stay tuned—these establishments are sure to entice and satisfy your appetite.
Where to find the best pizza in Pueblo, CO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Pueblo, CO:
- Angelo’s Pizza Parlor
- Pizza Ranch
- Do Drop Inn
- Blackjack Pizza
- Ianne’s Pizzeria
- Toni & Joes Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Little Caesars
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Old Chicago
1. Angelo’s Pizza Parlor
Nestled along the riverwalk at 105 E Riverwalk Union Ave., Angelo’s Pizza Parlor offers a cozy yet lively spot to enjoy a slice. My visit revealed a place that balances tradition with a modern touch, making every bite memorable. The aroma of fresh dough and melting cheese immediately signals quality and care.
What sets Angelo’s apart is its dedication to catering to all dietary preferences. From vegetarian and vegan options to gluten-free crusts, they aim to please everyone. I recommend trying their signature Margherita pizza, which showcases fresh ingredients and authentic flavor. For a hearty choice, the Meat Lover’s pizza reflects their commitment to rich, satisfying toppings. Angelo’s blends quality ingredients with friendly service, making it a top choice for pizza in Pueblo.
2. Pizza Ranch
Just a short drive from Lake Pueblo State Park, Pizza Ranch at 1761 S Pueblo Blvd. offers more than just pizza—it delivers a full family-style experience. Walking in, I was immediately drawn to the warm, rustic décor that channels the American West. It’s casual and welcoming, perfect for relaxed gatherings or laid-back dining.
What makes Pizza Ranch different is its expansive buffet. It’s rare to find a place that balances quantity and quality so well. I found myself going back for seconds of the Texan-style Roundup™ pizza, a bold mix of cheese and zesty vegetables on a perfectly crisp crust. If you want to keep it classic, the Cheese Lover’s pizza nails the basics with a flavorful twist.
Don’t skip the fresh salad bar or their well-known Cactus Bread® for dessert. Whether you’re fueling up after a trip to the zoo or gathering with friends, Pizza Ranch hits the sweet spot between comfort and variety.
3. Do Drop Inn
Located on S Santa Fe Ave, Do Drop Inn offers a friendly neighborhood vibe with a surprising pizza menu. I found its blend of classic and creative options refreshing. The casual yet welcoming atmosphere makes it an easy spot to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family.
What sets Do Drop Inn apart is its dedication to quality and accommodating all tastes, including vegetarian choices. Their pizza crust hits the perfect balance between chewy and crisp, making each slice enjoyable. I recommend the House Special pizza, a flavorful mix of fresh veggies and cheese that highlights their commitment to fresh ingredients. For a lighter option, the Veggie Delight stands out for its freshness and balance.
Whether you come for lunch, dinner, or brunch, Do Drop Inn proves to be a reliable choice for great pizza in Pueblo.
4. Blackjack Pizza
Located at 1000 W 6th St, Blackjack Pizza has been serving Pueblo since 1983, built on a foundation of quality and passion. From my first bite, I appreciated their commitment to handcrafted ingredients—nothing frozen, only fresh. The crust was perfectly chewy, and the toppings were generous, reflecting their slogan of providing the best ingredients possible.
Blackjack’s focus on freshness sets it apart from many competitors. Their pizzas are a showcase of simplicity and craftsmanship. I recommend the Blackjack Special, loaded with premium toppings, or the Veggie Lovers for something lighter yet flavorful. Every slice speaks to their dedication to quality, and it’s clear they take pride in delivering a genuine, satisfying pizza experience in Pueblo.
5. Ianne’s Pizzeria
Situated at 515 W Northern Ave, Ianne’s Pizzeria offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with attentive service. My visit revealed a place where tradition meets casual comfort. The aroma of freshly baked pizza greeted me, hinting at the quality to come.
What makes Ianne’s stand out is their focus on delivering consistent, hearty pizzas. Their crust is thin but sturdy, perfect for holding generous toppings. I recommend the Specialty Margherita, which highlights fresh tomatoes and basil, or their Meat Lovers for a hearty, satisfying bite. Every dish reflects their dedication to quality ingredients and classic style, making Ianne’s a go-to for pizza lovers in Pueblo.
6. Toni & Joes Pizza
Toni & Joes Pizza, tucked away at 2039 Columbia Dr, is the kind of spot where the crust crunches just right and the sauce speaks for itself. During my last visit, it was the laid-back feel and genuine hospitality that set the tone. There’s no pretension—just good, honest pizza done well.
What sets them apart? A consistent focus on flavor and portion. Their pizzas are generously topped and served hot with no frills, just satisfaction. I’d suggest the Classic Cheese or Veggie Supreme—both strike a balance between bold taste and freshness.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or winding down for dinner, Toni & Joes makes it simple: takeout is quick, seating is casual, and the pizzas hit the mark every time.
7. Pizza Hut
Tucked just off Highway 50, Pizza Hut in Pueblo delivers a familiar comfort with a local twist. The space is clean, the service is quick, and the menu hits all the right notes for pizza lovers who want consistency without sacrificing flavor.
What sets this location apart is its reliability and customization. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or feeding a crowd, the staff keeps things moving without cutting corners. The Original Stuffed Crust® remains a crowd favorite—crispy on the outside, soft and cheesy inside. Pair it with a Veggie Lover’s or Cheese Pizza for a satisfying, halal-friendly option.
If you’re unsure where to start, go for a Pan Pizza. The buttery crust and balanced toppings make it a Pueblo staple. It’s not flashy, but it’s exactly what you want when you’re craving something classic.
8. Little Caesars
Located at 4104 Outlook Blvd, Little Caesars in Pueblo offers quick, satisfying pizza at a great price. From my experience, it’s perfect for those busy days when craving pizza, but you want something convenient. The service is fast, and their signature hot-n-ready pizzas are always fresh and flavorful.
What makes Little Caesars stand out? Their commitment to affordability without sacrificing quality. I recommend their Classic Pepperoni or the Ultimate Supreme for a flavorful, satisfying slice. The crust is crispy, and the toppings generously layered, reflecting their straightforward, no-frills approach.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or dinner, Little Caesars offers reliable, halal-friendly options that deliver consistent taste every time.
9. Papa Johns Pizza
Located at 1427 West U.S. Highway 50, Papa Johns Pizza in Pueblo prioritizes quality with their promise of Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. During my visit, I noticed how their commitment to fresh, high-quality toppings and original dough makes a tangible difference in flavor and texture. The crust is crispy yet tender, showcasing their dedication to craftsmanship.
What sets Papa Johns apart? Their signature Old World Pepperoni and the classic Cheese Pizza highlight their focus on simple, flavorful ingredients. The available breadsticks and wings complement their pizza offerings perfectly, making it ideal for any occasion—dining in or taking out.
If you’re after reliably good pizza with a focus on quality, Papa Johns in Pueblo is a dependable choice for satisfying, Halal-friendly options every time.
10. Old Chicago
Located at 3204 N Elizabeth St, Old Chicago offers a lively atmosphere that’s perfect for casual dining. From my experience, their extensive selection of craft beers pairs well with their hearty, thin-crust pizzas. The setting feels vibrant yet relaxed, making it ideal for group gatherings or family dinners.
What makes Old Chicago stand out? It’s their commitment to variety and quality. Their Super Supremo Pizza packs a flavorful punch with plenty of toppings, while the Veggie Delight caters to a vegetarian palate. Both dishes reflect their dedication to crafting flavorful, satisfying pizza in Pueblo.
If you’re after a comfortable spot with diverse options, Old Chicago’s blend of good food and a friendly vibe makes it a reliable choice.
More Things to Try in Pueblo, CO
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Where is the best pizza in Pueblo, CO?
Many locals recommend Angelo’s Pizza Parlor and Blackjack Pizza for their quality ingredients and flavorful options. Both spots offer a range of styles to satisfy different tastes. -
Are there vegetarian options for pizza in Pueblo?
Yes. Places like Angelo’s and Do Drop Inn provide vegetarian-friendly pizzas and often include vegan and gluten-free options as well. -
What are popular pizza toppings in Pueblo?
Common toppings include pepperoni, sausage, vegetables like bell peppers and mushrooms, and fresh herbs. Many pizzerias also offer specialty toppings like spicy jalapeños and unique cheeses. -
Can I get halal pizza in Pueblo?
Most mainstream pizzerias offer standard ingredients, but if halal options are needed, check with local places like Papa Johns, which can accommodate dietary preferences upon request. -
Do Pueblo pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, most establishments like Pizza Hut, Domino’s, and Papa Johns offer delivery and takeout, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home or on the go.