Imagine sinking your teeth into a slice of pizza that hits every note—crisp crust, gooey cheese, and rich toppings—crafted with care and local flavor. In Columbia, SC, the pizza scene is as diverse as the city itself, offering everything from classic Neapolitan pies to innovative creations that push the boundaries of taste. Whether you’re after a casual slice to fuel your day or a gourmet pie for a special occasion, the options are abundant and thoughtfully curated.
Having explored many establishments in Columbia, I’ve discovered that finding the best pizza is about more than just toppings; it’s about the perfect harmony of quality ingredients, authentic techniques, and a welcoming atmosphere. This guide is rooted in firsthand experience and thorough research, aimed at helping you navigate Columbia’s pizza landscape with confidence. From longstanding favorites to hidden gems, these spots promise to satisfy your craving and elevate your pizza expectations.
Where to find the best pizza in Columbia, SC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Columbia, SC:
- Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria and Pub
- Mellow Mushroom
- Blaze Pizza
- Il Giorgione
- Old Chicago
- Za’s
- Dano’s Pizza
- Schiano’s
- Very’s Great Philly Food
- Hungry Howie’s Pizza
1. Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria and Pub
Located near the University of South Carolina, Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria and Pub offers a relaxed, friendly environment just steps from campus. The casual atmosphere, with a dining room and covered deck, makes it a perfect spot for students and locals alike. Open six days a week, it’s a great place to unwind after a game or concert, enjoying good food with a laid-back vibe.
What sets Thirsty Fellow apart is its commitment to vegetarian-friendly and vegan options, ensuring everyone finds something satisfying. Their signature pizzas, especially the classic Margherita or the veggie-packed special, showcase fresh ingredients and bold flavors typical of Columbia’s vibrant food scene. I recommend trying their house-made crust and flavorful toppings—each bite reflects their dedication to quality and community spirit.
2. Mellow Mushroom
Located on Gervais Street, Mellow Mushroom is known for its uniquely inspired, stone-baked pizzas. The vibrant atmosphere, whether dining indoors or relaxing on the patio, creates an inviting space for friends and families. Their diverse menu also includes wings, fresh salads, burgers, and crafted cocktails, making it a well-rounded spot for any occasion.
What makes Mellow Mushroom stand out is its commitment to vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, catering to a variety of dietary preferences. My personal favorite is their classic Margherita pizza—light, flavorful, and topped with fresh ingredients that highlight their creative approach. Each bite embodies their promise of a higher order of pizza, crafted with quality and a touch of artisanal flair.
3. Blaze Pizza
Located at Park Terrace Drive, Blaze Pizza is known for delivering exceptional quality pizza at lightning speed. Their assembly-line style allows you to choose from over 30 toppings, creating a customized pie that suits your taste. The blazing hot oven and dedicated pizzasmith ensure your pizza is perfectly crisp and ready in just 180 seconds.
What makes Blaze stand out is its focus on artisanal ingredients and rapid service. My personal favorite is their signature Margherita—simple, fresh, and expertly cooked. Whether for lunch or dinner, Blaze is a reliable choice for a quick, flavorful, and customizable pizza experience in Columbia.
4. Il Giorgione
Nestled on Devine Street, Il Giorgione offers a refined take on Italian cuisine with a focus on authentic, wood-fired pizzas. Its cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for both casual lunches and intimate dinners. The menu features a variety of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, showcasing their commitment to accommodating diverse dietary needs.
What sets Il Giorgione apart is its dedication to quality ingredients and traditional techniques. I recommend their Margherita pizza, with fresh basil and high-quality mozzarella, which perfectly reflects their authentic style. Every pizza is crafted with care, embodying the flavors of Italy while capturing the character of Columbia’s local scene.
5. Old Chicago
Located on Gervais Street, Old Chicago offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual dining. The restaurant is appreciated for its diverse menu that includes vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re visiting for lunch or dinner, the table service makes for a comfortable experience.
What makes Old Chicago stand out is its commitment to quality and flavor. I suggest trying their signature pizza, which features a hearty crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh ingredients. Their pizzas reflect a balance of traditional styles with creative twists, making each bite memorable. It’s a reliable choice for those seeking satisfying, well-made pizza in Columbia.
6. Za’s
Located on Devine Street, Za’s Brick Oven Pizza is a beloved neighborhood spot known for its wood-fired pizzas and Italian-inspired dishes. The relaxed atmosphere, complemented by outdoor seating and a full bar, makes it perfect for casual dinners or happy hours with friends. Their focus on fresh, house-made ingredients adds a special touch to every dish.
What makes Za’s stand out is its commitment to quality and community. I highly recommend their signature brick oven pizza—crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and expertly cooked. Pair it with a house-made sausage or organic chicken salad for a complete experience that reflects Za’s dedication to fresh, wholesome food at a great value.
7. Dano’s Pizza
Located on Rosewood Drive, Dano’s Pizza is a go-to choice for classic and satisfying pizza in Columbia. Known for its friendly service and relaxed vibe, it’s a favorite for both lunch and dinner. Their menu features a good variety of vegetarian options, ensuring everyone leaves happy.
What makes Dano’s stand out is its commitment to quality and freshness. I recommend trying their signature thin-crust pizza, topped with rich tomato sauce and generous cheese. Their casual style and dependable flavors make it an ideal spot for a laid-back meal, whether dining in or opting for delivery.
8. Schiano’s
Located on Two Notch Road, Schiano’s offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Known for its dependable menu and friendly service, it’s a go-to spot for both lunch and dinner in Columbia. They provide a variety of vegetarian options, ensuring all guests find something satisfying.
What makes Schiano’s stand out is its commitment to quality and comfort. I suggest trying their classic margherita or pepperoni pizza—both showcase their dedication to fresh ingredients and traditional flavors. Whether dining in or enjoying takeout, Schiano’s delivers consistent, well-crafted pizzas with a touch of home-cooked charm.
9. Very’s Great Philly Food
Situated on Two Notch Road, Very’s Great Philly Food is renowned for its hearty Philly cheesesteaks and casual, friendly atmosphere. While they excel in classic Philly dishes, their menu also features satisfying comfort foods that appeal to a wide range of tastes. Perfect for lunch or dinner, with the convenience of table service or takeout.
What sets Very’s apart is its focus on quality ingredients and generous portions. I recommend trying their specialty cheesesteaks, but if you’re craving pizza, their flavorful, thin-crust options are also worth exploring. Each dish reflects their dedication to fresh, hearty, and satisfying meals—ideal for a laid-back meal with friends or family in Columbia.
10. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
Located on Saint Andrews Road, Hungry Howie’s Pizza is known for its flavorful crusts and diverse toppings, making it a favorite for casual pizza lovers in Columbia. Their menu offers a variety of options for lunch and dinner, with convenient delivery and takeout services. The relaxed seating makes it a great spot for a quick bite or a relaxed meal with friends.
What makes Hungry Howie’s stand out is its unique flavor-infused crusts and high-quality ingredients. I recommend trying their classic pepperoni or the veggie-inspired options, which showcase their creative approach to traditional pizza. Each slice reflects their commitment to satisfying cravings with bold, tasty options crafted with care.
More Things to Try in Columbia, SC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Columbia, SC?
A: The best pizza spot depends on your taste, but popular options include Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria for its casual vibe, Mellow Mushroom for creative stone-baked pies, and Za’s for wood-fired authentic flavors. Exploring these can help you find your favorite.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Columbia?
A: Yes, many restaurants like Mellow Mushroom and Za’s offer vegetarian and vegan options with plenty of fresh toppings and plant-based cheeses, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious slice.
Q: Do Columbia pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most popular spots, including Hungry Howie’s and Il Giorgione, provide convenient takeout and delivery services to suit your schedule and convenience needs.
Q: Are gluten-free pizzas available in Columbia?
A: Yes, several establishments, such as Mellow Mushroom and Blaze Pizza, feature gluten-free crust options for those with dietary restrictions.