Long Island has long been celebrated as a haven for pizza lovers, with each neighborhood boasting its own local favorites. Over the years, I’ve explored countless eateries—from cozy corner spots to bustling pizzerias—that serve slices worthy of a daily rotation. What sets this area apart is its rich pizza culture; each place offers a unique spin on classic recipes, often blending traditional methods with creative twists. My personal visits have led me to discover flavors that linger long after the last bite, making every trip feel like a delicious adventure.
This guide aims to shine a spotlight on the best pizza in Long Island, NY—places that stand out through quality, authenticity, and a genuine passion for pizza craftsmanship. Whether you’re craving a thin and crispy crust, a generously topped Sicilian slice, or something innovative, each of these spots has something special to offer. Trust me, when it comes to finding the perfect slice, this list is your map to a slice of pizza paradise. Prepare your taste buds; the journey starts here.
Where to find the best pizza in Long Island, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Long Island, NY:
- Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Gino’s Pizza
- Buona Fortuna Pizza
- Mario’s Pizza
- La Capannina
- Pita & Pizza
- Mama Angelina’s Restaurant
- Sal’s Pizzeria
- LoPiccolo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
- Francesco’s
1. Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
Located in Hauppauge, Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant has been a staple in the Smithtown community for over 30 years. I remember stopping by on a Saturday and being greeted by the inviting aromas of freshly baked pizza and rich Italian herbs. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual comfort and authentic charm, making it ideal for family dinners or a quick bite.
What sets Branchinelli’s apart is their hand-tossed pizza, crafted with quality ingredients and a knack for consistency. I highly recommend their classic Margherita pizza, with fresh basil and a crisp crust, embodying true Italian simplicity. For a heartier option, their submarine sandwiches and calzones showcase the same dedication to flavor and craftsmanship. Whether dining in or taking out, it’s clear this place delivers a slice of Italy with every bite.
2. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza in Ronkonkoma has earned a reputation for serving classic, flavorful pizza made with fresh ingredients. I visited on a quiet weekday and was struck by how friendly the staff was, making my experience feel welcoming and genuine. The cozy atmosphere complements their traditional approach to Italian-American favorites.
What makes Gino’s Pizza stand out is their balanced crust and rich toppings, especially in their beloved cheese pizza. Their menu also features tasty submarine sandwiches and calzones, perfect for sharing or a quick meal. With affordable prices and quick service, Gino’s delivers a reliable slice of Long Island pizza culture in every bite.
3. Buona Fortuna Pizza
Buona Fortuna Pizza in Bohemia offers a taste of authentic Italian flavors with a local twist. I once ordered their large spinach and mushroom pie for a quick dinner, and the freshness of the ingredients truly impressed me. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for casual meals or takeout.
What sets Buona Fortuna apart is their generous specials and reliable quality. The large pizza paired with garlic knots or their classic cheese pie reflects their dedication to traditional techniques. Their weekly pasta night features hearty dishes like spaghetti & meatballs, perfect for satisfying a craving while enjoying great value. This place consistently delivers satisfying pizza with a genuine Italian touch.
4. Mario’s Pizza
(631) 244-0764Call
Mario’s Pizza in Bohemia is a reliable choice for quality, affordable pizza. I once ordered their classic pepperoni slice during a busy weeknight, and the crispy crust combined with savory toppings made it an instant favorite. The friendly staff and quick service add to its appeal for takeout or casual dining.
What makes Mario’s Pizza stand out is its consistent performance and welcoming atmosphere. Their cheese pizza is a simple, satisfying option, but I also recommend trying their veggie pizza loaded with fresh toppings. With prices that are easy on the wallet, Mario’s offers a tasty slice of Long Island pizza tradition in every visit.
5. La Capannina
(631) 569-4524Call
La Capannina in Holtsville is known for its warm atmosphere and authentic Italian cuisine. I visited recently and was impressed by how welcoming the staff was, making every guest feel like family. The restaurant’s spacious setting makes it perfect for both casual meals and special gatherings.
What makes La Capannina stand out is their commitment to quality and tradition. Their hand-tossed pizza features a perfect balance of crisp crust and flavorful toppings. I highly recommend trying their margherita pizza or their signature supreme pizza, which showcase their dedication to authentic Italian flavors. With a focus on fresh ingredients and craftsmanship, La Capannina offers a memorable pizza experience beyond the ordinary.
6. Pita & Pizza
Pita & Pizza in Central Islip offers a delightful mix of Mediterranean and Italian flavors. I once ordered their spinach and feta pizza, and the combination of fresh ingredients and well-balanced spices made it stand out. The welcoming vibe and prompt service make it a great spot for a casual dinner or takeout.
What sets Pita & Pizza apart is their ability to blend traditional pizza with Mediterranean influences. Their Greek-inspired pizza with toppings like olives, feta, and herbs showcases their creative approach. For a satisfying meal, I recommend trying their extra veggie pizza or their gyro platter. Every dish reflects their commitment to quality, offering a taste of diverse, authentic flavors in a cozy setting.
7. Mama Angelina’s Restaurant
Mama Angelina’s Restaurant in Hauppauge is a haven for traditional Italian and family-style dining. I visited recently and was greeted with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that felt like dining at a relative’s home. The menu features a variety of flavorful dishes, making it ideal for family dinners or casual gatherings.
What makes Mama Angelina’s stand out is their dedication to authentic flavors and generous portions. Their wood-fired pizza with a perfectly crispy crust and rich toppings is a highlight. I recommend trying their margherita pizza or the specialty pies that showcase true Italian craftsmanship. Every bite reflects their commitment to quality and creating a memorable dining experience.
8. Sal’s Pizzeria
(631) 467-2625Call
Sal’s Pizzeria in Ronkonkoma is a local favorite for its consistently delicious pizza and welcoming atmosphere. I once stopped by after a long day and was greeted with a friendly smile. The aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, promising a satisfying meal.
What makes Sal’s Pizzeria stand out is their commitment to quality ingredients and classic recipes. Their thin crust pizza topped with fresh cheese and flavorful toppings is simply exceptional. For a real treat, try the margherita or pepperoni pizza, which showcase their attention to detail and authentic style. Whether dine-in or takeout, Sal’s offers a dependable slice of Long Island’s pizza traditions.
9. LoPiccolo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
(631) 406-6281Call
LoPiccolo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante in Hauppauge offers a taste of Sicily right in Long Island. I once ordered their margherita pizza, and the balance of fresh basil, quality mozzarella, and perfectly baked crust left a lasting impression. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made my visit memorable.
What truly distinguishes LoPiccolo’s is its authentic approach to Italian cuisine combined with the convenience of free delivery. Their thin-crust pizza reflects traditional Sicilian techniques, emphasizing fresh ingredients and skillful preparation. I recommend trying their classic cheese pizza or the specialty pies to experience a true slice of Italy, crafted with care and passion.
10. Francesco’s
Francesco’s in Islip Terrace is a hidden gem for authentic Italian cuisine. I visited on a quiet evening and was greeted with warm hospitality and the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza. The cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for family dinners or a relaxed night out.
What makes Francesco’s stand out is its dedication to quality and traditional recipes. Their thin-crust pizza with fresh toppings captures the true essence of Italian pizza. I recommend trying their Margherita or pepperoni pizza for a classic experience, or their flavorful pasta dishes if you want to explore beyond pizza. Every dish reflects their commitment to craftsmanship and authentic flavors.
More Things to Try in Long Island, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some of the best pizza styles available in Long Island, NY?
A: Long Island offers a variety of pizza styles, including thin-crust, Sicilian, New York-style, and gourmet options. Each style provides a unique taste experience, from crispy and foldable slices to thick, cheesy squares.
Q: Are there family-friendly pizza restaurants in Long Island?
A: Yes, many pizza places like Mama Angelina’s and Francesco’s are family-friendly, offering casual atmospheres and menus suitable for all ages.
Q: Do Long Island pizzerias offer vegetarian or vegan options?
A: Increasingly, yes. Many restaurants now include vegetarian and vegan pizza options, with toppings like vegetables, plant-based cheeses, and specialty crusts.
Q: Can I get pizza delivered in Long Island?
A: Absolutely. Most pizzerias offer delivery services, often including online ordering through their websites or third-party apps.
Q: Are there gluten-free pizza options in Long Island?
A: Some restaurants provide gluten-free crusts for customers seeking gluten-free pizza, so it’s worth asking when ordering.