Nutley holds a quiet claim to an impressive array of pizza joints. Within a few blocks, you can get everything from classic thin-crust to bubbling wood-fired masterpieces. Not long ago, I found myself on a rainy evening seeking comfort food and stumbled upon a local spot. The aroma of fresh basil and baking dough hit me before I even got to the counter. That night, I didn’t just eat pizza—I found a new Friday tradition.
Choosing the best pizza in Nutley isn’t simple, and that’s a good thing. This town’s pizzerias each have something distinctive, whether it’s a legendary family recipe, blistered Neapolitan edges, or creative combos you didn’t know belonged on a pie. In the following guide, you’ll find expert picks and honest insights into Nutley’s pizza scene, whether you want slices to go or a cozy spot to linger. Your next favorite is somewhere on this list.
Where to find the best pizza in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Nutley, NJ:
- Ralph’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
- Queen Margherita
- Rocky’s Pizza
- Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven
- Emilio’s Wood-Fired Pizza
- Luna Wood Fire Tavern
- Loue’s Place Pizza & Pasta
- Domino’s Pizza
- Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria
- Cucina 355
1. Ralph’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
Ralph’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant sits at the heart of Nutley’s pizza scene. The first time I visited, a table of locals was already deep into a debate about which pie was the best. The staff made me feel like I’d been a regular for years.
What really sets Ralph’s apart is its time-tested recipe and a crust that hits that sweet spot between chewy and crisp. If you’re staying classic, their Margherita is a standout—the kind of pie where fresh mozzarella and basil need nothing extra. For those who love a little bite, the White Pizza loaded with garlic is remarkably good.
Plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options mean everyone can join in. The portions are generous, so bring a friend—or a serious appetite.
2. Queen Margherita
Queen Margherita brings a slice of Italy to Washington Ave. Once, I wandered in for a quick lunch and found myself lingering, drawn in by the smell of wood-fired dough and bright tomatoes. Here, pizza is simple but never boring.
Their signature Margherita is a perfect introduction—soft, leopard-spotted crust, silky mozzarella, and just the right hit of fresh basil. This place takes Neapolitan seriously, yet isn’t afraid to get creative. Try their Verdura if you’re after a veggie twist, loaded with seasonal vegetables and just a touch of olive oil.
Queen Margherita’s menu keeps things flexible, with vegan and gluten-free pizzas that don’t skimp on taste. Cozy, relaxed, and always satisfying, it’s a spot that keeps calling you back.
3. Rocky’s Pizza
Rocky’s Pizza, tucked into a modest white building near Shop Rite, has a loyal following—and for good reason. The first time I tried a slice, I was surprised by how something so unassuming could pack so much flavor. There’s nothing fussy about this place, but the taste is anything but ordinary.
Rocky’s stands out for its classic, foldable slices that hit with just the right amount of cheese and tangy sauce. Their Sicilian pizza is a crowd favorite, square-cut with a golden, airy crust, and best shared with friends on a casual night out.
If you’re looking for a no-nonsense, flavorful pizza that feels straight out of an old-school Jersey pizzeria, Rocky’s is the spot. Simple, satisfying, always fresh out of the oven.
4. Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven
Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven delivers that golden, slightly charred crust only a brick oven can produce. My first visit was all about curiosity and, by the end, I was planning a return trip. The warm, inviting space feels perfect for gathering with friends over a hot, fragrant pie.
The signature brick oven Margherita is a must-try, with blistered edges, vibrant tomato sauce, and creamy mozzarella. If you’re craving something heartier, their veggie-topped pizzas come loaded and generously portioned.
It’s easy to see why locals champion Ritacco Brothers—the quality ingredients, rustic flavors, and friendly atmosphere set this place apart. Everything here tastes like it was made just for your table, straight from the oven.
5. Emilio’s Wood-Fired Pizza
Emilio’s Wood-Fired Pizza is the kind of place that feels instantly welcoming. I remember taking a seat outside on a summer evening, watching the flames inside the oven while my pizza baked. The smell alone could convert anyone into a regular.
What makes Emilio’s shine is that signature wood-fired flavor—smoky, slightly crisp crust, and toppings that never overpower the dough. Try the Classic Margherita for pure comfort, or go for their veggie-packed Garden Pie if you’re feeling adventurous.
Service is quick and friendly and, with digital payments and outdoor seating, it’s easy to relax while enjoying a hot pizza. Emilio’s is a jewel for anyone who values both tradition and a few thoughtful twists on the classic pie.
6. Luna Wood Fire Tavern
Luna Wood Fire Tavern feels like the place you end up when you want more than just a quick slice. I still remember the first time I sat down here—the fire flickering in the oven, the lively chatter, and a pizza that set a new bar for wood-fired crusts.
Luna’s Margherita captures that delicate balance between smoky and soft, with just-charred bubbles along the edge and a fresh tomato kick. Their Rustic Veggie pie is another standout, loaded with seasonal produce and a hint of garlic.
The relaxed vibe, friendly service, and takeout option make Luna a strong contender for pizza lovers who want a little atmosphere along with their meal. This is the spot for a casual dinner that feels special.
7. Loue’s Place Pizza & Pasta
Loue’s Place Pizza & Pasta is a longtime neighborhood favorite, and walking in feels like being greeted by family. One afternoon, a friend insisted I try their pizza fresh from the oven instead of taking it to go. I’m glad I listened—the difference was clear from the first bite.
Loue’s brings big flavor with generous toppings on a perfectly balanced crust—neither too thick nor too thin. The Veggie Pizza stands out, loaded with crisp peppers and mushrooms, while their classic Margherita always comes out piping hot and satisfying.
This spot keeps things unfussy yet delicious, ideal for a simple lunch or an easygoing dinner. It’s the kind of old-school pizzeria where quality speaks for itself every single visit.
8. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Franklin Ave may be a national chain, but it’s often the first call for a last-minute pizza fix in Nutley. There’s an easy comfort in knowing exactly what to expect, whether you’re ordering late at night or for a quick lunch break. A pepperoni pie once turned my rushed weeknight into a cozy moment with friends.
What makes Domino’s stand out is the reliable crust, speedy service, and the ability to customize pizzas down to the smallest detail. Their Veggie Pizza is a dependable winner when you’re after something colorful and satisfying.
If you’re craving consistency, digital ordering, and lots of topping choices, Domino’s brings it all together, right on schedule every single time.
9. Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria
+1 973-667-8232
Bell Paese Deli Pizzeria and Trattoria feels like a secret spot you’re lucky to discover. On my first visit, I hesitated at the deli counter, eyeing the surprisingly big pizza menu before diving in. The staff suggested their Margherita, and I quickly understood why regulars swear by it.
Bell Paese’s pizza stands out with its golden crust and generous, fresh toppings that taste straight from the market. The Veggie Pie here is a real highlight—colorful, loaded, and perfectly baked with just the right touch of olive oil.
Whether you’re grabbing a slice for lunch or ordering a whole pie to bring home, Bell Paese nails that comfort-food balance of hearty and fresh. It’s one of those places you end up recommending to friends again and again.
10. Cucina 355
Cucina 355 offers that community feel you hope for in a local eatery. I stopped in one Sunday after hearing about their breakfast pizzas—yes, breakfast pizzas—and discovered a menu full of surprises. Warm light, friendly faces, and the scent of fresh dough make this place hard to leave.
Their Margherita is simple but superb, letting the ingredients speak for themselves. For a change, try the White Pizza, silky with ricotta and a hint of garlic. The crust is thin, crisp, and holds up well to any topping you choose.
Cucina 355 caters well to vegetarians and serves up pizza all day, so your cravings are covered no matter the hour. It’s the kind of spot that quietly becomes a favorite.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Nutley, NJ?
Nutley offers a great mix—classic Jersey-style thin crust, brick oven Neapolitan, Sicilian squares, and wood-fired pies. Whether you want a crispy slice or something with a bit more chew, you’ll find plenty of options.
Are there vegetarian and vegan pizza choices in Nutley?
Yes, many local pizzerias have vegetarian options and several, like Queen Margherita and Cucina 355, offer vegan cheese and gluten-free crusts. Most spots are happy to customize your order, too.
Which pizza places in Nutley have gluten-free options?
Queen Margherita, Ralph’s Pizzeria, and Cucina 355 all serve gluten-free pizzas. Call ahead to check availability, especially during peak times.
Do local pizza shops offer delivery or takeout?
Nearly every pizzeria in Nutley offers takeout, and most, including Domino’s and Emilio’s, deliver. Many also allow online ordering for convenience.
What’s the best pizza topping combo unique to Nutley?
While classics like Margherita and Veggie Pies are beloved, some pizzerias create seasonal specials using fresh, local ingredients. Ask about house favorites when you call or visit—the staff often has good recommendations.