Everyone knows the eternal debate: where do you find the best pizza in McHenry County, IL? I’ve taken on the delicious task of searching, slice by slice, through neighborhood pizzerias, big names, and secret gems. Along the way, I’ve found airy crusts, bubbly cheese, and sauce that tastes like a summer afternoon. The variety here is a pizza lover’s daydream. From classic pies to modern twists, this region knows how to do pizza right.
If you’re tired of sifting through so-so recommendations or scrolling endless reviews, you’re in the right spot. I’ve tasted my way through the options so you don’t have to. Whether you’re craving wood-fired classics or crave a simple pepperoni you’d swear was magic, the answers are here. This guide sorts out the standouts, so flip the napkin over, get ready to read, and maybe start thinking about dinner plans.
Where to find the best pizza in McHenry County, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in McHenry County, IL:
- Buddyz Pizzeria
- Fox Hole Tap And Pizzeria
- Little Caesars
- Salerno’s Pizzeria & R.Bar
- Jexal’s
- Little Caesars
- Snuggery Riverside Bar & Pizza
- Rosati’s Pizza
- Napoli Pizza Place
- Three Star Pizza
1. Buddyz Pizzeria
Buddyz Pizzeria takes deep dish seriously, and you’ll notice it from the very first bite. There’s a warmth to the bustling dining room and a comforting smell that always makes me pause at the door. The crust is thick, golden, and holds a mountain of gooey cheese and sauce you’ll want to savor.
It’s the Chicago-style pizza here that’s worth a road trip. The signature deep dish is a must. It’s layered with rich tomato sauce, silky cheese, and your favorite toppings—vegetarian options included.
Buddyz isn’t just about heavy pies, though. Their thin crust pizzas are crisp and full of flavor, perfect if you want something lighter.
Try the veggie supreme or build your own with fresh ingredients. Each pizza shows off why locals keep this spot high on their favorites list.
2. Fox Hole Tap And Pizzeria
Fox Hole Tap And Pizzeria is a true neighborhood favorite with a lively, down-to-earth atmosphere. The spot has been a McHenry staple since 1974, drawing locals for delicious pizza and friendly service. When I dropped in on a Friday night, the scent of baking crust, bubbling cheese, and oregano set the mood, and live music gave it extra charm.
Their pizza shines with a classic hand-tossed crust and fresh toppings. The veggie pizza is always crisp, packed with colorful produce, and never greasy. If you’re adventurous, their specialty pies go big on flavor without going overboard.
Order the Fox Hole Special for the full experience. It’s topped generously, and you can taste why regulars swear by it. This place is perfect for groups, so bring extra friends and a hearty appetite.
3. Little Caesars
+1 815-344-0821
Little Caesars is the definition of reliable pizza, always ready when you need it most. I’ve made more than one last-minute stop here after a busy day, and there’s comfort in grabbing a Hot-N-Ready and heading home.
The appeal is in the simplicity and speed. The crust holds up, the cheese stretches, and the sauce has a little zip. It’s a straightforward option that delivers every time.
Go for their classic cheese or veggie pizzas when you want something quick and consistent. The thin yet sturdy crust works especially well for a fast dinner or group movie night.
For people in McHenry County who need pizza on their time, Little Caesars delivers without fuss or fanfare—just good, honest pizza.
4. Salerno’s Pizzeria & R.Bar
Salerno’s Pizzeria & R.Bar feels like walking into a friend’s kitchen, where the focus is great Italian flavors and genuine hospitality. My last visit included warm greetings and the kind of welcoming vibe that makes lingering over dinner easy.
Their pizzas have a distinct homemade charm. Each crust is rolled just right, golden on the edges, and topped with rich tomato sauce that feels straight out of the garden. There’s no cut-corner here—just a love for detail and tradition.
The Margherita pizza is a standout, with fresh basil and melty cheese coming together in each satisfying slice. If you’re after something a little heartier, try their veggie or cheese pies for bold, classic flavor.
Salerno’s is what hand-crafted pizza should taste like in McHenry County: genuine, simple, and delicious.
5. Jexal’s
Jexal’s stands out with creativity and comfort, all wrapped in an inviting, modern setting. I found myself drawn in by the reclaimed wood décor and lively buzz—the kind of spot where you can relax after a day on the Fox River.
Here, the pizza dough is made fresh daily, and every slice tells the story. The cheese is always melty, the toppings are thoughtfully chosen, and you won’t find shortcuts in their kitchen. The dedication to homemade flavor shows up in every detail, down to the hand-shredded mozzarella.
Order their veggie-loaded pizza or classic cheese pie for a taste of Jexal’s signature freshness. The crust hits that sweet spot: crisp on the edge, tender in the center. You’ll taste the care in each bite.
If you’re looking for a spot in McHenry County that’s both stylish and laid-back, Jexal’s is the pizza stop you’ll want to show off to friends.
6. Little Caesars
Little Caesars on Elm St is all about no-frills convenience and a steady stream of hot, ready-to-go pies. On more rushed days than I care to admit, this spot has saved dinner with its quick grab-and-go setup and reliable flavors.
The pizzas here have a familiar comfort: a chewy crust, zesty tomato sauce, and cheese that always stretches just enough. Consistency is their calling card, and you know exactly what you’re getting every time.
The veggie pizza and classic cheese are foolproof options for a satisfying meal, whether you’re feeding yourself or a group in a hurry. Slices hold up, travel well, and rarely disappoint.
For classic, unfussy pizza in McHenry County, this Little Caesars delivers exactly what you’d expect—fast, warm, and tasty.
7. Snuggery Riverside Bar & Pizza
Snuggery Riverside Bar & Pizza feels like a secret retreat on the Fox River, with friendly service and lively energy year-round. I remember grabbing a window seat and tucking into a pie while watching boats drift by, the aroma from the kitchen rivaled only by the view.
The thin-crust pizza here is award-winning for a reason. Each pie is loaded with bubbling cheese, a hearty sauce, and toppings that taste fresh and bright. The crust manages that balance—crispy at the edge and sturdy enough for a loaded slice.
The Moretti’s Special is an absolute crowd-pleaser, with a hearty mix of veggies and just the right amount of cheese. Their gluten-free option delivers the same bold flavor for everyone at the table.
If you love waterfront dining and crave a perfect slice, Snuggery Riverside is where comfort meets classic pizza in McHenry County.
8. Rosati’s Pizza
Rosati’s Pizza brings true Chicago flavor to McHenry County, combining heritage with quality you can taste in every bite. My recent visit left me impressed by the devotion to classic recipes and that unmistakable aroma of baking dough and herbs.
What sets Rosati’s apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients and authentic family recipes. The pizza has a golden crust, robust tomato sauce, and cheese that’s satisfyingly stretchy. You’ll notice the care and consistency in each slice.
Try their signature Chicago-style veggie or build your own from an array of toppings. The deep-dish is hearty and packed with flavor, perfect for sharing with friends or family after a long week.
If you want classic comfort done right, Rosati’s delivers a slice of Chicago heritage right in McHenry.
9. Napoli Pizza Place
(815) 338-2430Call
Napoli Pizza Place is the kind of unassuming spot you might drive past a dozen times until you hear a friend rave about it. That’s exactly how I discovered their pizza—by word of mouth, then a visit that proved the hype was real.
The crust here strikes the right balance: crisp at the edges, soft in the middle, with just enough chew. You can tell everything’s made with fresh ingredients, from the bright tomato sauce to the generous layer of cheese.
Order their veggie pizza or a simple cheese pie to get a real sense of Napoli’s style. Each slice is flavorful and satisfying, never weighed down by excess oil.
Napoli Pizza Place stands out in McHenry County as a go-to for straightforward, quality pizza at a friendly price.
10. Three Star Pizza
(815) 334-1313Call
Three Star Pizza is a true local staple in Woodstock, offering generous portions and the kind of comfort food you crave on a casual night in. I first tried their pizza after a long day, and it was just what I needed: hearty, hot, and loaded with flavor.
The appeal here is all about balance and quality ingredients. The crust is sturdy yet light, providing a good base for a sea of tangy sauce and stretchy cheese. It’s simple, satisfying, and never skimps on taste.
The veggie pizza is a standout, topped with fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms for a pop of color and crunch. Slices are generous, making it easy to feed a group or have leftovers for lunch.
If you’re looking for classic pizza with dependable flavor in McHenry County, Three Star Pizza delivers every time.
More Things to Try in McHenry County, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in McHenry County, IL?
You’ll find a wide range, including classic thin crust, deep dish, Chicago-style, hand-tossed, and even gluten-free options. Many places offer veggie and cheese-focused pies if you’re looking to keep things simple and delicious.
Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza spots in McHenry County?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, like Buddyz and Salerno’s, offer hearty vegetarian pies with fresh toppings. Just ask, and you’ll find plenty of veggie-friendly options.
Which pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Most pizza restaurants in McHenry County, from local favorites to chains like Little Caesars and Domino’s, offer both delivery and takeout. It’s best to check with each location for details and hours.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in McHenry County?
Yes. Several places, such as Snuggery Riverside Bar & Pizza and others, provide gluten-free crusts so everyone can enjoy a slice.
What’s the most popular type of pizza in the area?
Chicago-style deep dish and thin crust both have loyal followings here. You’ll see lots of locals ordering deep dish loaded with cheese and toppings, but the crispy thin crusts also have a big fan base.
Do any pizzerias have outdoor seating or a view?
Yes, spots like Snuggery Riverside Bar & Pizza feature riverside views and patios, making for a relaxing pizza experience.
Are there any late-night pizza options?
A handful of pizzerias and chains offer late hours, especially on weekends. Always check the latest opening times online or by calling ahead.
Can I build my own pizza at these restaurants?
Most local and chain spots in McHenry County let you pick your own toppings and crust, so you can customize your perfect pizza.