Pizza in Kalamazoo is not just food—it’s practically a local obsession. There’s a distinct excitement in the air when that warm, cheesy box lands on your table, leaving you with the classic debate: who’s got the best slice in town? As someone who’s methodically tasted my way through Kalamazoo’s pizza landscape, I’ve experienced untold slices, tried mysterious house specials, and built up a list that brings both confidence and hunger pangs.
Whether you crave pillowy crusts, crave-worthy sauces, or inventive toppings, every spot on this list offers something memorable. With each visit, I talked to pizza makers about their craft, watched doughs hand-tossed before my eyes, and even debated fellow pizza fans at late-night haunts. So if you’ve ever found yourself paralyzed by choice or just want to find your new go-to pizzeria, you’re in the right place. Get ready to explore the best pizza in Kalamazoo—slice by slice.
Where to find the best pizza in Kalamazoo, MI
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Kalamazoo, MI:
- Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizza
- Bimbo’s Pizza
- Martini’s
- Bilbo’s Pizza
- Maestro’s Pizza
- Godfathers Pizza
- Blaze Pizza
- Kazoopy’s Pizza and Grinders
- Jet’s Pizza
- Jet’s Pizza
1. Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizza
Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizza sets itself apart from the start with an extensive menu that leans bold and creative. Walking through the doors, you’ll catch a waft of well-aged cheese and fresh dough, like a prelude to the meal. Servers don’t blink if you spend extra time debating your options; the possibilities are dizzying—in the best way.
One bite into the signature Erbelli’s Chicago Style Pizza convinced me I’d found a local legend. The crust is thick and perfectly balanced with just the right crunch, while the toppings are generous and meld into every bite. For lighter cravings, their gourmet thin crust pies—like the Mediterranean or Parmigiano Veggie—offer tons of flavor without heaviness.
The kitchen caters to nearly every diet, so nobody gets left out. Whether you go vegan, gluten-free, or classic, the attention to detail is clear. For anyone serious about good pizza in Kalamazoo, Erbelli’s always lands near the top of the list.
2. Bimbo’s Pizza
Bimbo’s Pizza is a downtown Kalamazoo staple, steeped in decades of local tradition. The charm begins at the entrance, with its retro neon sign promising the classics inside. The ambiance feels both homey and timeless, a perfect setting for old-school pizza lovers.
The crust here deserves its reputation—light, crisp, and slightly chewy, it stands up well to an array of toppings. I remember my first slice: mozzarella stretching for days, just enough sauce, and a satisfyingly thin base. Their veggie pizza balances fresh produce and cheese with remarkable ease.
Service is laid-back and friendly, making it easy to linger. While every pie hits the spot, the deluxe pizzas like the Veggie Deluxe capture Bimbo’s signature style: unfussy, generous, and reliably delicious.
3. Martini’s
Martini’s delivers more than just pizza—it feels like a spirited gathering spot, right on S Westnedge. With its lively dining room and gypsy jazz setting the mood, a meal here always feels like an experience. There’s a sense of comfort, whether you’re dining at the bar or unwinding on the patio.
What sets Martini’s pizza apart is their dedication to inventive toppings and balanced flavors. My go-to is the Classic Margherita: the herbs pop, the sauce is vivid, and the crust rides that fine line between crisp and chewy. Their Mediterranean Veggie pizza, loaded with artichokes and feta, is a strong contender for any veggie lover.
The menu caters to a range of diets without sacrificing creativity. Martini’s style blends cozy hospitality with a gourmet spin, making it a pizza must-stop on any Kalamazoo tour.
4. Bilbo’s Pizza
Bilbo’s Pizza brings a touch of whimsy to Kalamazoo, inspired by a love for Tolkien and true artisan pies. The atmosphere is cozy and laid-back, with quirky décor and the comforting scent of rising dough. It’s a place where laughter and shared slices come effortlessly.
The crust here is a standout: toothsome, slightly sweet, and able to hold even the heartiest toppings. My first choice is the Veggie Pie, layered with colorful peppers and earthy mushrooms. Each pizza feels crafted, not just assembled, with thoughtful combinations and fresh cheese in every bite.
Bilbo’s signature style shines in their sauce—rich, aromatic, and never overpowering. For anyone after pizza with a playful twist and solid roots, Bilbo’s deserves a seat at the table.
5. Maestro’s Pizza
Maestro’s Pizza combines the laid-back charm of a neighborhood hangout with the flair of an Italian bistro. Walking in, you’re welcomed by friendly faces and a lively bar—there’s an energy that invites you to stay awhile. This is a “pull-up-a-chair” kind of spot where regulars chat with staff like old friends.
The crust is Maestro’s signature move: just enough chew, with that golden oven kiss every good slice deserves. My pick is the Margherita, which nails balance with tangy sauce and creamy mozzarella. Adventurous eaters will find inventive options, especially on the gluten-free and keto-friendly menu.
The calzones shouldn’t be missed, either, stuffed full and baked beautifully. If you’re on the hunt for pizza with personality, Maestro’s makes every bite memorable and full of local warmth.
6. Godfathers Pizza
Godfathers Pizza is where simplicity meets crowd-pleasing comfort in Kalamazoo. The vibe is unfussy, with plenty of seating and a steady stream of regulars, making it perfect for a casual bite or a quick pick-up after a long day.
The crust—a signature feature—is thick and buttery, creating a solid base for layers of melted cheese and toppings. I remember my first slice of their classic Veggie Pizza: the peppers, onions, and olives were fresh and generous, piled on with purpose. Each bite delivered satisfying flavor in familiar, hearty proportions.
Godfathers’ approach favors timeless over trendy, and that’s its strength. For reliable pizza that’s big on comfort and always hits the spot, this spot delivers on its name.
7. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is for those who crave both choice and speed without sacrificing flavor. Your pizza journey here begins with an assembly line of fresh, colorful ingredients. The roster runs deep—more toppings than you could dream up—and every order is fired up in just three minutes.
I’ve built my own combos, but their Signature Red Vine pizza keeps calling me back: the mix of ripe tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil on a thin, crackly crust nails the basics with style. If you’re looking for something lighter, the gluten-free and vegan options hold their own, showing off Blaze’s quality across the board.
Blaze’s magic is customization with a touch of craftsmanship. Pick your favorites or let the pizzasmiths suggest; either way, the results stay crisp, fast, and full of Kalamazoo flavor.
8. Kazoopy’s Pizza and Grinders
Kazoopy’s Pizza and Grinders feels almost like a secret find in Kalamazoo—a spot where depth of flavor comes first. The pride in craft is clear, from freshly baked dough to house-made sauces. Walking in, the aroma is rich: a blend of tangy tomato, herbs, and melting cheese sets the scene for anticipation.
The standout? Their Kazoopysauce—zesty, fragrant, and unlike any other pizza sauce I’ve tried in town. My top pick is the Veggie Pizza, made with whole, real cheeses and crisp, colorful toppings. Each bite tastes vibrant and thoughtfully constructed.
For those in the mood for variety, the grinders crafted on Italian sourdough are another level altogether. At Kazoopy’s, it’s all about real ingredients and memorable flavor, making it a reliable spot for pizza lovers.
9. Jet’s Pizza
Jet’s Pizza makes its mark in Kalamazoo with thick, golden-edged Detroit-style pies that are addictive from the very first square. It’s the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back, thanks to its deep, crispy crust and edge-to-edge toppings.
The 8 Corner Pizza is Jet’s claim to fame—eight perfect pieces, each with plenty of caramelized cheese at the edge. I still remember biting into my first Jet’s slice: the soft, pillowy center and crunchy corners offered the best of both worlds. The veggie combo here showcases fresh peppers, mushrooms, and olives paired with generous cheese and sauce.
If you crave a pizza that balances texture and robust flavor, Jet’s easily lands among the local favorites. It’s comfort food, upgraded and ready every time you need a Detroit-style fix.
10. Jet’s Pizza
This Jet’s Pizza location on Gull Road delivers the same signature Detroit-style squares that made the brand famous, but with its own neighborhood vibe. The space is inviting—bright, clean, and perfect for a quick stop or a relaxed family meal.
The hallmark of Jet’s is its thick, airy crust, caramelized at the edges for irresistible crunch. I’ve yet to find a more satisfying square than their 8 Corner Pizza. The veggie version piles on crisp peppers and mushrooms for a colorful, hearty bite. Their breakfast pizzas add unexpected variety, a unique spin for morning pizza enthusiasts.
Whether you’re ordering lunch or dinner, Jet’s consistency never disappoints. It’s the kind of reliable, crave-worthy pizza that easily becomes a routine favorite in Kalamazoo.
More Things to Try in Kalamazoo, MI
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Kalamazoo for dine-in?
Martini’s, Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizza, and Bilbo’s Pizza offer inviting dine-in experiences, each with its own style and local favorites.
Where can I find vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Kalamazoo?
Erbelli’s Gourmet Pizza, Blaze Pizza, and Martini’s all provide a solid range of vegetarian and vegan pizzas, served with thoughtful toppings and lots of creativity.
Who has the best Detroit-style pizza in Kalamazoo?
Jet’s Pizza is widely known for its Detroit-style pies, especially the 8 Corner Pizza with a thick, crispy crust and generous edge-to-edge toppings.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Kalamazoo?
Many spots like Erbelli’s, Blaze Pizza, and Maestro’s Pizza offer gluten-free crusts, letting you enjoy quality pizza without compromise.
Which pizza spots deliver late at night in Kalamazoo?
Little Caesars, Domino’s, and Pizza Hut are reliable for late-night delivery. Some local shops, such as Erbelli’s, also offer extended hours on weekends.
What’s a must-try local specialty pizza in Kalamazoo?
Bilbo’s Pizza is known for its unique sauce and house-made crust, while Kazoopy’s is famous for its signature Kazoopysauce. Both are local legends worth trying.
Is there a family-friendly pizza restaurant in Kalamazoo?
Places like Maestro’s Pizza and Godfathers Pizza provide casual, welcoming atmospheres perfect for families and groups.
Can I find pizza places in Kalamazoo with outdoor seating?
Martini’s offers a vibrant patio, and several others provide outdoor seating when the weather cooperates, making it easy to enjoy your meal al fresco.