There’s something about a slice of pizza that just feels right after a long day in the Florida sun. Maybe it’s the contrast—cheese melting over crisp dough, mingling with a breeze off the Gulf. Panama City Beach knows this well. From small sidewalk counters to lively family joints, there’s a pizza spot around every corner, each with its own character and devoted fans.
I still remember the first time I ordered pizza here, sand dusting my feet and a slice too hot to hold. The choices can feel endless, but over time, I’ve mapped out each spot, from classic New York style joints to inventive kitchens putting a spin on tradition. If you want to skip tourist traps and try something real, you’re in the right place. This guide will make sure your next pizza pick hits the spot.
Where to find the best pizza in Panama City Beach, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Panama City Beach, FL:
- Nick’s Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria & Bar
- Paparazzi Pizza
- Shore Shack Pizza
- Great White Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza
- Hungry Howies Pizza & Subs
- Hungry Howie’s Pizza
- Bricks & Barley Pizza
- Panama Pizzeria
- Bubbas Pizza
1. Nick’s Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria & Bar
+1 850-708-3177
See Menu
Nick’s Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria & Bar feels like a trip to New York, no plane ticket needed. Born and raised in Brooklyn, Nick brings decades of pizza wisdom right to the heart of Panama City Beach. The crust is thin but sturdy, the sauce has bite, and the mozzarella takes center stage.
Walk inside and you’ll find a friendly, no-nonsense atmosphere that feels straight out of Bensonhurst. On my last visit, I sat at the counter and watched fresh dough being tossed in the air—a sign you’re in the right place.
The classic cheese slice is a winner, but the white pizza and veggie pie deserve attention. Nick’s pies combine simplicity and top-notch ingredients, the way New York pizza should.
2. Paparazzi Pizza
Paparazzi Pizza brings old-school charm to Panama City Beach, built on three generations of family recipes. The stone-baked New York style pies here are crisp at the edges and just chewy enough in the center. You can taste the family touch in every bite, from sauce to dough.
My first time here, a generous slice arrived fresh out of the oven, the aroma filling the room. They offer more than just pizza, but the pies are the draw—especially after a day out nearby on Thomas Drive.
Try the Margherita or veggie pizza if you want a taste of their homemade sauce. For something heartier, the Supreme pulls together all the best toppings. If you want an authentic local pizza experience, Paparazzi delivers.
3. Shore Shack Pizza
Set just off the beach, Shore Shack Pizza delivers exactly what its name promises—a relaxed vibe and pizza worth lingering over. The dough is made fresh daily, resulting in pizzas that come out crisp and golden. It’s a spot that draws locals and visitors alike, thanks to friendly service and a genuine neighborhood feel.
I remember stopping in after a swim, ordering a classic cheese, and being surprised by the balance of flavors. The sauce is tangy, the crust holds its own, and every topping lands with purpose.
Order the veggie or the classic Margherita to taste what they do best. Each slice is light yet filling, perfectly suited for a meal after the waves. Shore Shack keeps things straightforward, making good pizza the main event.
4. Great White Pizza
Great White Pizza grabs your attention right in Pier Park with its stone-cooked pies and beach-casual energy. The dough is made fresh daily, giving every pizza that signature bite and a light, airy crust. Options are plenty, including gluten-free and vegan pizzas that don’t skimp on flavor.
On my last visit, I tried the veggie pizza right out of their stone conveyor oven. The edges were beautifully crisp, the flavors sharp without being overpowering, and the sauce was rich but mellow.
The Margherita shows off their homemade dough perfectly, while the build-your-own pizzas invite creativity. For those wanting something different, their flatbread sandwiches are no afterthought. Great White Pizza balances classic techniques with thoughtful options for everyone.
5. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Front Beach Road knows how to balance familiar flavors with a friendly touch. The dough is never frozen, so every pizza feels fresh and made just for you. This spot works well for an easy lunch or a takeout night that won’t disappoint.
I wandered in on a humid afternoon and ordered a garden pizza. The thin crust held a healthy layer of cheese, and the veggies kept their crunch. Friendly staff added to the neighborhood vibe, making it clear why Marco’s has regulars.
Try their garden or cheese pizza for classic flavor, or branch out with a custom order. Each pie reflects Marco’s promise: good ingredients, no fuss, and real comfort with every bite.
6. Hungry Howies Pizza & Subs
Hungry Howies Pizza & Subs on Front Beach Road stands out by keeping things bold and customizable. Their flavored crusts are a signature move, adding a surprise with every slice. It’s the kind of place you hit up when you want something familiar but with a twist.
I stopped in one evening craving something quick. The veggie pizza came out hot, each slice with a garlic-herb crust that really elevated the experience. It hit the mark for both taste and value, making it easy to see why this spot is always busy.
Don’t skip the veggie or cheese pizza on a flavored crust. If you’re in the mood for variety, their subs are fresh and satisfying too. Hungry Howies brings a bit of playful creativity to the classic pizza scene.
7. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
This Hungry Howie’s Pizza location keeps things simple, fast, and flavorful. The real draw is the huge variety of flavored crusts—from buttered to sesame seed—that turn every pizza into something a little different. It’s perfect when you want pizza your own way, without the wait.
I grabbed a quick bite here one weekend and was struck by how fresh the toppings tasted. The veggie pizza, in particular, came loaded and the crust had just enough crunch to seal the deal. Service was fast, which makes this spot an easy go-to for busy days.
Start with a cheese or veggie pizza and experiment with different crusts. For those who like to mix it up, every visit is a chance to try a new twist on an old favorite.
8. Bricks & Barley Pizza
+1 850-775-1677
See Menu
Bricks & Barley Pizza brings a bit of craft and comfort to the beach. The artisan crust is always crisp, and the toppings range from classic to creative without missing a beat. This spot is a solid choice whether you’re after a quick slice or a full sit-down meal.
My visit was marked by friendly faces and a buzz of people, from families to groups of friends. I grabbed a slice of veggie pizza and paired it with a craft soda—perfect balance of flavor and refreshment. The crust here stands out, with a satisfying chew and just enough char.
Order a Margherita or build your own for a true taste of what Bricks & Barley does best. Vegan and gluten-free options mean everyone can join in, making this pizzeria a real crowd-pleaser.
9. Panama Pizzeria
Panama Pizzeria serves up big flavors and a laid-back atmosphere just steps from the shore. Each pizza features a hand-stretched crust with a generous layer of gooey mozzarella, making every bite satisfying and memorable. This place works for families, late-night cravings, or those who just want a slice after sunset.
I remember dropping by after a sunset stroll and being won over by the classic veggie pizza. The veggies tasted fresh, the cheese was golden and bubbling, and the crust had that perfect chew. Service was genuine and quick, adding to the relaxed vibe.
Try their Margherita for a satisfying classic, or opt for a veggie or custom pie to suit your mood. Panama Pizzeria delivers on quality, no matter how late you order.
10. Bubbas Pizza
Bubbas Pizza nails that classic New York style with pies big enough to share and hand-tossed for the perfect bite. This spot is all about hearty portions, fresh ingredients, and a no-fuss approach that keeps the focus on the pizza. The atmosphere is casual, and service is quick, whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout.
The first time I tried Bubbas, the crust immediately got my attention—thin, a little chewy, and holding up under plenty of cheese and veggies. Their 18-inch pies are a hit for groups, but the smaller sizes pack the same punch.
Go for a classic cheese, veggie, or Margherita to enjoy their dough at its best. Bubbas’ pizzas have a homemade quality that gives each slice its own character.
More Things to Try in Panama City Beach, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza styles are popular in Panama City Beach?
You’ll find a range of classics, with New York style, stone-baked, and hand-tossed pies leading the way. Many pizzerias offer thin and crispy crusts, but there are thick and gluten-free options too.
Are there vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Panama City Beach?
Absolutely. Most local pizza spots offer vegetarian pizzas, and several have vegan cheese or plant-based toppings. You won’t have trouble finding veggie-friendly slices.
Which pizza place is best for families?
Many pizzerias are family-friendly, but Panama Pizzeria, Bricks & Barley, and Shore Shack Pizza are known for a relaxed atmosphere and big tables for groups.
Do any places deliver late at night?
Yes. Hungry Howie’s, Domino’s, and Panama Pizzeria all offer late-night delivery, making them good picks for midnight cravings.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Panama City Beach?
Yes, several spots—including Great White Pizza and Bricks & Barley—offer gluten-free crusts, so everyone can enjoy a good pie.
What’s the best pizza spot near the beach?
Nick’s Slice Of Brooklyn, Shore Shack Pizza, and Great White Pizza are all close to the water with a view or a short walk to the sand.