Few cities can spark a food debate quite as quickly as Jacksonville when it comes to pizza. From wood-fired pies with blistered crusts to classic foldable New York slices, the city’s pizza scene covers more ground than a map in an old-school pizzeria. Over the years, I’ve wandered into hole-in-the-wall joints and polished upmarket spots alike, sometimes on a whim, sometimes in search of comfort after a long day. Oddly enough, the most memorable slice I’ve eaten here wasn’t even planned—just a last-minute pick somewhere tucked between a comic shop and a laundromat, and somehow it hit every note; cheese pulling, sauce singing, and that perfect bite you chase with cold soda.
If you’re searching for the best pizza in Jacksonville, you’re in the right place. This guide is built on countless tastings, far too many napkins, and not an ounce of hyperbole. Each pizzeria has something unique to offer, and this list will point you to those that locals love, transplants rave about, and even chefs whisper about after closing time. Read on for an honest slice-by-slice tour that steers clear of the usual clichés and dives straight into what makes Jacksonville’s pizza so noteworthy.
Where to find the best pizza in Jacksonville, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Jacksonville, FL:
- Moon River Pizza
- Carmines Pie House
- V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco
- Milano’s Italian Restaurant pizza&bar
- Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Town Center
- Picasso’s
- Tony D’s New York Pizza
- Blaze Pizza
- Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Avondale
- V Pizza Mandarin
1. Moon River Pizza
Tucked into the heart of Riverside, Moon River Pizza isn’t your average neighborhood spot. Step inside and you’ll find a laid-back, high-energy space with quirky wall art and the hum of conversations. The first time I stopped in, their crust turned me into a repeat customer; it’s golden, chewy, and always carries just the right weight for toppings.
What sets Moon River apart is their loyal approach to quality. Fresh toppings, house-made sauces, and dough crafted daily fill each pie with character. The “Special” is a favorite—a medley of peppers, fresh veggies, and melty cheese that tastes as vibrant as it looks. For plant-based eaters, their customizable vegan and gluten-free options never feel like an afterthought.
If you love hearty, flavorful pizza, this is a must-visit.
2. Carmines Pie House
Carmines Pie House brings a blend of big-city flavor to Jacksonville’s historic Riverside neighborhood. From the moment you step inside, retro posters and the scent of fresh dough set the scene. My visit started with friendly banter at the counter and ended with a towering deep-dish I couldn’t stop thinking about for days.
Chicago deep-dish and New York-style pizzas share the spotlight here, a rare feat handled with equal skill. The “Windy City” deep-dish comes piled with mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce, delivering a fork-and-knife experience that leaves a lasting impression. If you’re after something classic, their hand-tossed New York pies offer giant, foldable slices brimming with fresh toppings.
Vegetarians and gluten-sensitive guests have solid options, too. This is the place to visit when you can’t choose between pizza traditions.
3. V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco
V Pizza & Sidecar – San Marco takes pizza back to its roots, embracing the traditions of Napoli with stone-fired ovens and a focus on simple ingredients. My first night here, the aroma of charred crust and fresh basil all but demanded that I try the classic Margherita. The result—pillowy dough, bright sauce, creamy mozzarella—set a benchmark I haven’t stopped comparing other pies against.
The heart of V Pizza is its commitment to traditional Napoletana craftsmanship. Here, each pizza feels made with care, from the slightly blistered edges to the balanced layers of flavor. For an upgrade, try the “Quattro Formaggi,” where four cheeses blend into a savory, bubbling masterpiece.
With vegan and gluten-free options available, there’s something for everyone. Grab a pie, visit Sidecar for a craft drink, and enjoy a slice of Italy in Jacksonville.
4. Milano’s Italian Restaurant pizza&bar
Milano’s Italian Restaurant pizza&bar is where comfort food and Italian classics come together without any pretense. I remember ducking in during a rainstorm and being greeted by a cozy atmosphere and the aroma of baking dough. The staff served up a smile along with piping-hot pizza, making me feel like a regular, even on my first visit.
What sets Milano’s apart is the attention to every detail. Pizzas here come out with crispy edges, chewy centers, and just the right balance of sauce and cheese. The “Milano’s Special”—topped with an array of fresh veggies and rich mozzarella—captures the essence of their style. Vegan pizza options are thoughtfully made and actually taste like a treat, never an afterthought.
If you crave unfussy, flavorful pies, this is a spot you’ll want to return to again and again.
5. Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Town Center
Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Town Center goes beyond the typical pizza joint. From the moment you walk in, the quirky art and friendly people set a relaxed, fun tone. My first visit here ended with a group of friends, a bright booth, and a table loaded with colorful, creative pies—everyone found a new favorite.
The big draw is their signature spring water crust, which is crisp yet pillowy, and topped with fresh, vibrant ingredients. If you’re not sure what to try, order the “Kosmic Karma”—it balances tangy sun-dried tomatoes and tender spinach with a creamy swirl of pesto, making each bite interesting and satisfying. Vegan and gluten-free diners find plenty of tasty choices that hold their own.
It’s a spot that makes you want to linger, savor, and maybe get that extra slice for the ride home.
6. Picasso’s
Picasso’s stands out as a culinary canvas in the heart of Jacksonville. The first time I visited, I was struck by just how creative their menu could get. There’s an attention to detail here—each pie comes out looking as beautiful as it tastes, often with a vibrant touch of fresh herbs or unique toppings that feel curated.
The heart of Picasso’s appeal is their inventive approach to pizza. Artfully balanced flavors take center stage in options like the “Provençal”—a pie with roasted garlic, ripe tomatoes, and a bright finish of basil. For something extra special, ask about their rotating chef’s special, which always features fresh, seasonal ingredients.
Vegetarian and gluten-free pizzas are crafted with the same level of creativity, making Picasso’s a great match for adventurous appetites.
7. Tony D’s New York Pizza
Tony D’s New York Pizza transports you straight to a Brooklyn sidewalk, minus the hustle. On my first visit, I was greeted by the thwack of dough and the unmistakable scent of bubbling cheese. With its unfussy décor and real-deal ovens, Tony D’s sets the scene for classic New York slices done right.
Here, the hand-tossed crust steals the show—foldable, chewy, and able to handle a tower of toppings without buckling. The “Tony’s Special” is a crowd-pleaser: mushrooms, onions, peppers, and just the right hit of oregano, delivering old-school flavor in every bite. For something bold, the white pizza with ricotta and spinach turns a simple pie into comfort food heaven.
Whether you want a single slice or a whole pie, Tony D’s is spot-on for New York nostalgia.
8. Blaze Pizza
+1 904-757-2900
Blaze Pizza gives you creative control in a way few pizza shops do. The first time I went, I was amazed at the sheer number of toppings—over 30 choices lined up, inviting me to build a pie that felt personal. No waiters hovering, no pressure—just a clean, energetic space and the fun of designing your own meal.
The main draw is their fast-fired technique. In about three minutes, your pizza comes out of the oven perfectly crisp, with a charred crust and melty cheese. The “Build Your Own” option is a hit, letting you stack on fresh veggies, herbs, and sauces however you like. For a ready-made favorite, the “Veg Out” is loaded with roasted veggies and has real depth of flavor.
With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free pies, Blaze keeps everyone happy—every time, fast.
9. Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Avondale
Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville – Avondale sets itself apart with a mix of quirky décor and a laid-back, welcoming vibe. My last visit involved cozy window seating, street art on the walls, and pizza that showed real care in every bite. The staff here remembered regulars by name and made everyone feel like part of the neighborhood.
What keeps people coming back is the signature hand-tossed, stone-baked crust, made with spring water and topped with ultra-fresh ingredients. Try the “Holy Shiitake Pie”—roasted mushrooms, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a garlic aioli drizzle create layers of rich flavor that linger. There are strong choices for vegan and gluten-free diners, too, and every pie feels thoughtfully crafted.
If you’re after creative combinations in a spot that values its community, Avondale’s Mellow Mushroom will hit the mark.
10. V Pizza Mandarin
V Pizza Mandarin brings a slice of Italy to Jacksonville with its devotion to traditional Napoletana pizza making. Walking in, you’re met by the warm scent of wood-fired dough and a casual, lively crowd. My first visit ended with flour on my fingers and a smile, proof that their pies are best enjoyed straight from the oven—no waiting.
Their pizzas are all about authenticity, with thin, slightly charred crusts and a focus on simple, high-quality ingredients. The “Margherita” is the classic choice: tangy tomato, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, bright and balanced on every slice. Their menu also serves up vegan and gluten-free options without compromise.
With the TapGarden offering 50 draft brews, you can pair your pizza with something local. It’s a relaxed spot for serious pizza lovers.
More Things to Try in Jacksonville, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are popular in Jacksonville, FL?
Jacksonville offers a little bit of everything—classic New York slices, Chicago deep-dish, traditional Napoletana, and creative artisan pies. Local favorites often feature fresh, high-quality ingredients, hand-tossed crusts, and a mix of classic and inventive toppings.
Are there good vegan or gluten-free pizza options in Jacksonville?
Absolutely. Many spots, including Moon River Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Blaze Pizza, have vegan cheese and gluten-free crust options. These versions are just as carefully made as the traditional pies.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Jacksonville?
Carmines Pie House and Moon River Pizza are both known for serving late into the night, so you’re covered if a pizza craving hits after hours.
Is Jacksonville kid-friendly when it comes to pizza restaurants?
Most top pizza places, like Mellow Mushroom and Joseph’s Pizza, offer kid-friendly menus and a laid-back atmosphere that works for families.
What’s unique about pizza in Jacksonville compared to other cities?
Jacksonville’s pizza scene is impressively diverse, with a heavy focus on authenticity and quality. The city’s mix of Southern hospitality and global influences makes for creative menus and unique flavors not always found elsewhere.