Finding outstanding pizza in Odessa, FL used to feel like a quest for hidden treasure. I’ve tried just about every pizza spot tucked between busy highways and quiet neighborhoods, all in search of those slices that leave you thinking about them hours later. There’s something about the combination of crisp crust, gooey cheese, and inventive toppings that sparks friendly debates over dinner tables and brings people together faster than you can say “extra cheese, please.”
With so many options, knowing where to start can feel overwhelming. But after countless taste-tests, questionable shortcuts through GPS, and a few happy accidents, I’ve rounded up the best pizza places in Odessa for every mood and craving. Whether you’re chasing classic New York slices or craving a pie piled with fresh veggies, this guide lays out all the delicious stops you shouldn’t miss. Get ready to explore the flavors that make Odessa’s pizza scene worth the detour.
1. Angelina’s Pizza & Subs
(813) 792-2200Call
Angelina’s Pizza & Subs takes pizza night to another level. When I first walked in, that inviting aroma hit before the front door even closed—a sign of good things to come. The atmosphere is cozy, a local favorite for a reason, and busy enough to feel lively but never rushed.
The standout here is the hand-tossed pizza, which strikes a balance of crispy edges and satisfyingly chewy crust. I’ve never left disappointed, and every slice feels like it’s loaded with care, not just toppings.
If you only order once, go for the classic Margherita or the veggie pizza—both showcase fresh ingredients and skillful preparation. They don’t hold back on cheese or flavor, and that keeps the regulars coming back. This place raises the bar for pizza in Odessa, FL.
2. Godfather’s Pizza
(813) 920-0868Call
Godfather’s Pizza brings a bit of nostalgia and bold flavor to Odessa, FL. My first visit ended with a hands-down agreement at the table—these pies mean business. The crust is satisfyingly thick, with just enough crunch to keep you coming back for that next bite.
What really sets Godfather’s Pizza apart is the generous layering of toppings and a sauce that leans savory but never overpowers. Their pizzas arrive piping hot and loaded, just the way a classic pizza joint should serve them.
Don’t skip the Super Combo. It’s a local legend, piled high with veggies and pepperoni, a testament to why folks here stay loyal. For anyone in Odessa hunting for hearty, memorable slices, this spot won’t let you down.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Odessa, FL, always hits the spot when you want something reliable and quick. I remember grabbing a late-night pie here after a long day, and the fresh aroma from the box made the drive home feel shorter. Consistency is their charm, and every order proves it.
Their signature hand-tossed dough and tangy tomato sauce set a solid base for any topping combination. What stands out most is the Garlic Sauce—every crust deserves a dip.
If you’re ordering, try the The Works pizza. Loaded with layers of veggies and flavor, it’s a crowd-pleaser for any group. For those in Odessa craving dependable pizza, Papa Johns keeps it classic and satisfying every time.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Odessa, FL, delivers that familiar flavor many people grew up with. Sometimes nothing else quite matches the nostalgia of those red-roofed days and sharing a pie with friends. Their delivery is quick, but the flavors never feel rushed.
The real showstopper is the Original Stuffed Crust. I once made a meal of just the crust, saving it for last, because it’s the perfect bite: cheesy, warm, and never too doughy. Pizza Hut keeps their standards high, ensuring each pizza looks and tastes as expected.
Order the Meat Lovers® pizza or the Veggie Lover’s for crowd-pleasing options that reflect why Pizza Hut still holds a steady place in Odessa’s pizza lineup.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Odessa, FL, is the spot for anyone who loves customizing their pizza. I once ordered a thin-crust pie with every veggie on the menu and was genuinely surprised at how fast it landed on my doorstep—still piping hot. Their app makes the whole process almost too easy, which might explain my frequent orders.
What sets Domino’s apart is the range: classic hand-tossed, airy pan pizzas, and their cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust. Every time I’ve tried something new here, the flavors hold up, and they don’t skimp on toppings.
Try the Pacific Veggie or the classic Handmade Pan pizza. Both are perfect examples of why Domino’s remains a go-to for pizza lovers in Odessa who appreciate value and speed. Consistent, convenient, and reliably delicious.
6. Three Brothers Pizza
Three Brothers Pizza serves up the kind of New York-style slices that make you pause mid-bite. The first time I stopped by, I was drawn in by the easygoing vibe and that unmistakable scent of fresh dough in the air. Locals talk about this spot for good reason—it delivers the real deal.
The secret is in the crust: thin, foldable, and just the right amount of char. If you’ve ever craved authentic New York pizza without the flight, this is your place. Slices come oversized and never short on cheese.
Order a classic Cheese or Margherita pizza to appreciate their craft, or try the White Pizza for something memorable and different. With friendly service and authentic style, Three Brothers sets the bar for pizza in Odessa, FL.
7. Angela’s Pizza
(813) 920-0007Call
Angela’s Pizza on Gunn Hwy feels like one of those local secrets you stumble on by luck. The day I found it, I was searching for something simple and satisfying, and Angela’s delivered from the very first bite. There’s a homey vibe, and the staff treat you like you’ve been stopping by for years.
Their pizza stands out for its light, airy crust and rich tomato sauce. Each pie arrives bubbling hot, the colors and aroma promising quality you can taste. Angela’s uses fresh ingredients and piles on the flavor.
Order their Veggie Pizza or the classic Cheese Pizza. Each slice delivers a comforting, straightforward take on a favorite, proving why Angela’s is a staple for pizza fans in Odessa, FL.
8. Santelli Pizza & Pasta
Santelli Pizza & Pasta captures the comfort of a family kitchen with every dish. My visit started with a warm greeting and ended with me reconsidering my pizza ranking for Odessa. The atmosphere feels relaxed, inviting you to slow down and savor every bite.
What sets Santelli apart is their dedication to fresh, homemade dough and vibrant sauces. Their pizzas emerge from the oven golden and piping hot, with just the right amount of char on the crust.
If you’re in a classic mood, the Margherita pizza perfectly showcases simple, quality ingredients. For something a bit different, try the Spinach White pizza—it’s creamy, satisfying, and definitely memorable. Santelli’s makes pizza that’s both comforting and crave-worthy, keeping locals loyal for good reason.
9. Keystone Corner Inc
Keystone Corner Inc may look like a classic local convenience stop, but their pizza is what keeps folks in Odessa talking. I stumbled in for a snack and was surprised to find hearty, handmade pizza being served alongside quick groceries. There’s a friendly, down-to-earth energy every time you walk through the door.
Their pies are generously topped, with a satisfyingly soft crust and just the right touch of cheese. It’s not fussy or fancy, but it’s flavorful and filling—perfect for a grab-and-go meal or a casual evening in.
Order the Supreme Pizza if you want to taste what Keystone does best. It’s loaded, balanced, and perfect for sharing, making it a genuine hidden gem for pizza in Odessa, FL.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Odessa, FL?
Some top picks include Angelina’s Pizza & Subs, Three Brothers Pizza, Santelli Pizza & Pasta, and Keystone Corner Inc. Each offers a unique style, from classic New York slices to extra cheesy oven-baked pies.
Do any Odessa pizza places offer delivery?
Yes, major chains like Domino’s Pizza, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut all offer delivery. Several local spots may also provide delivery or pickup options—check their websites or call to confirm.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options in Odessa?
Almost all of Odessa’s pizzerias have vegetarian-friendly pizzas. Three Brothers Pizza, Santelli Pizza & Pasta, and Papa Johns offer crowd-pleasing options loaded with fresh veggies and cheese.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Odessa, FL?
Chains like Domino’s Pizza and Papa Johns often have gluten-free crusts. Some local restaurants might offer their own versions—always call ahead to ask for details about cross-contamination and choices.
Which pizza spot is good for families?
Pizza Hut and Santelli Pizza & Pasta are both great for a family night out. They offer crowd-friendly menus, relaxed settings, and something for everyone to enjoy.