Looking for the best pizza in Springfield, MO is a bit like hunting for hidden treasure. The city’s pizza scene is full of surprises and local legends that keep both newcomers and regulars guessing about which slice will steal the show next. After spending countless evenings sampling pies across town, I quickly learned that there’s no single answer—Springfield truly serves up something for every craving.
Each pizzeria here has its own story, personality, and signature bite. Some are beloved for hand-tossed crusts, while others earn loyal followings for secret sauces or gooey cheese blends. Whether you want classic pepperoni, inventive toppings, or a taste of childhood nostalgia, this list will help you navigate the city’s best spots for pizza. Prepare for everything from cozy neighborhood haunts to local icons. Your next favorite slice could be closer than you think.
Where to find the best pizza in Springfield, MO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Springfield, MO:
- PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub Springfield Battlefield
- Pappo’s Pizzeria
- Pizza House
- Arris Pizza
- Neighborhood Pizza Cafe
- The Big Slice
- Springfield Incredible Pizza Company
- Rocco’s Pizza
- Bellacino’s Pizza and Grinders
- Garbo’s Pizzeria
1. PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub Springfield Battlefield
PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub Springfield Battlefield raises the local pizza game in style. The moment I first stepped inside, I noticed the laid-back vibe and friendly staff. The aroma from the stone hearth oven is enough to spark an appetite, no matter what time you arrive.
The star attraction is the handcrafted pizza, with a perfectly crisp crust and robust tomato sauce. PaPPo’s takes the extra step, making everything—from bread to dressings—from scratch. I always end up with the Margherita or the Italian, both loaded with fresh, vibrant toppings that tell you corners are never cut here.
If you like variety, the craft beer selection and homemade appetizers complement the pizza beautifully. No conveyor belts here, just careful craftsmanship and reliable flavor. For a real treat, don’t skip the oven-baked wings as a starter.
2. Pappo’s Pizzeria
Pappo’s Pizzeria on Walnut Street is the kind of place that turns a pizza craving into a mini event. Tucked into the vibrant heart of downtown, it draws a loyal crowd for good reason. When I dropped by for the first time, the aroma alone had me sold before I even made it to the counter.
The pizzas here come half-baked or hot out of the oven, each crust with that unbeatable homemade touch. Toppings are always vivid and generous, so you never feel shortchanged. The Mediterranean pizza in particular stands out—zippy with just the right blend of vegetables and cheese, which seems to capture what they do best: fresh, honest flavors.
Don’t miss their oven-baked jumbo wings or the hand-rolled breadsticks. If you’re watching for something lighter, a crisp, custom salad with standout homemade dressing will do the trick. It’s clear that Pappo’s Pizzeria crafts each dish with real care, making every visit feel special.
3. Pizza House
Pizza House on Commercial Street is one of those rare spots where the old-school charm feels just right. Step inside, and everything slows down—a welcome break from the bustle of the city. My first experience here reminded me why some places turn into local institutions.
What makes Pizza House unique is its cracker-thin crust, which strikes a crispy balance between light and flavorful. The classic cheese pizza is a must, and it always arrives cut into perfect party squares, adding a bit of nostalgia with each bite. Toppings are plentiful but never overwhelm the crisp base.
Vegetarian and vegan options are well thought out, so everyone finds something to savor. Table service is friendly and efficient, and the takeout travels well if you’re in a hurry. For those who enjoy a straightforward, timeless pizza, Pizza House always delivers.
4. Arris Pizza
Arris Pizza brings a touch of old-world flavor to Springfield. As soon as you walk in, the cozy setting and warm welcome set the tone for a relaxed meal. I first tried their pizza during a weekday lunch and quickly understood why so many call this spot a staple.
The standout here is their Greek-inspired approach, especially with the Athena pizza—fresh tomatoes, olives, and feta on a thin, crispy crust. You get a true sense of balance in each bite, with flavors that feel both classic and inventive.
Gluten-free and vegan options make sure every guest is covered, without ever compromising on quality. If you’re undecided, the build-your-own option lets you get creative. Arris Pizza consistently brings comfort and originality to the Springfield pizza scene.
5. Neighborhood Pizza Cafe
Neighborhood Pizza Cafe feels like the kind of place you stumble upon and wish you’d found years ago. On my first visit, the aroma of fresh dough and cheese made it clear this was no ordinary pizza stop. The genuine warmth and quick service are just a bonus.
The signature here is a five-cheese blend atop a house-made crust, with sauce crafted in-house daily. Toppings are always generous and the pizza strikes that irresistible balance between crispy and cheesy. I always recommend their veggie-loaded pizza for a burst of flavor in every slice.
The menu also features classics like the Neighborhood Casserole if you’re in the mood for something different. You can taste why this spot is an award winner—every bite feels like it was made just for you.
6. The Big Slice
The Big Slice keeps things simple but memorable, serving up exactly what its name promises—impressively large, foldable slices. Walking in for the first time, I was struck by the display of pizza bigger than my plate, topped with all sorts of vibrant, fresh ingredients. The laid-back vibe makes it perfect for a lunch break or casual dinner.
The classic New York-style crust is thin and crisp, perfect for holding up under generous toppings without sagging or getting soggy. If you want a taste of the city, grab a slice of their veggie or go bold with The Big Slice Special—layered flavors that showcase what they do best.
Flexible delivery and takeout options make this spot a go-to for hassle-free pizza cravings. It’s a must for anyone who wants a slice with real personality in Springfield.
7. Springfield Incredible Pizza Company
Springfield Incredible Pizza Company is the kind of place where pizza meets play, making it a go-to for families and groups. My first visit felt like stepping into a pizza wonderland, with arcade games and laughter around every corner. It’s more than a restaurant—it’s an experience.
The buffet features a wide range of pizzas, each with a fluffy crust and crowd-pleasing toppings. The veggie pizza gets high marks for freshness, and you can build your own to suit any craving. Options extend to salads and a dedicated section for vegan and vegetarian choices.
Digital payments make the process smooth, and the energetic setting keeps things lively. For a pizza spot that pairs solid pies with plenty of entertainment, this Springfield staple covers all the bases.
8. Rocco’s Pizza
Rocco’s Pizza has the cozy, neighborhood feel that instantly makes you want to become a regular. On my first visit, I was greeted with enthusiasm and a menu packed with tempting options. The warmth extends from the staff to every slice that leaves the oven.
What sets Rocco’s apart is the chewy, golden crust that serves as a sturdy base for their signature red sauce and layered toppings. I keep coming back for the Supreme, topped with crisp veggies and a perfect ratio of cheese, but the classic Margherita hits all the right notes too.
Delivery and takeout make Rocco’s an easy choice when the craving hits, and there are plenty of vegetarian options for variety. Whether it’s a casual dinner or a quick lunch, this place always delivers on flavor.
9. Bellacino’s Pizza and Grinders
Bellacino’s Pizza and Grinders feels like a cross between an old-school pizzeria and your favorite sandwich spot. My first taste was during a bustling lunch hour, and even with a full dining room, the service was quick and friendly. The space is inviting, setting the right notes for a casual meal.
Their pizza stands out with a golden, chewy crust and a blend of gooey cheese that’s easy to crave. Bellacino’s specialty pies, especially the classic Veggie or the customizable options, never disappoint. If you’re in the mood for something different, their grinders—fresh-baked sandwiches—make a hearty complement to your meal.
Gluten-free and vegetarian choices show care for every diner. For pizza with real comfort and solid flavor, Bellacino’s gets it right every time.
10. Garbo’s Pizzeria
Garbo’s Pizzeria is where Springfield’s love for pizza takes a flavorful turn. My first dinner here was a low-key weeknight that turned memorable, thanks to the welcoming team and the unmistakable scent of pizza fresh from the oven. The cozy atmosphere makes lingering over a slice almost inevitable.
Garbo’s thin, crispy crust creates the perfect canvas for their bold tomato sauce and well-balanced toppings. The Florentine pizza, with creamy ricotta and fresh spinach, has become my go-to when I want something a bit out of the ordinary and packed with character.
The menu is packed with vegetarian-friendly options, so everyone around the table is covered. Whether you dine in or take out, Garbo’s is an easy choice for pizza with personality and heart.
More Things to Try in Springfield, MO
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular style of pizza in Springfield, MO?
You’ll find a mix, but thin crust and New York-style pizzas tend to steal the spotlight. Many local favorites focus on a crispy base and generous toppings.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Springfield?
Definitely. Many pizzerias—like PaPPo’s and Pizza House—offer both vegetarian and vegan pizzas, plus gluten-free choices for those avoiding wheat.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Springfield?
Yes. Several places, including Arris Pizza and Bellacino’s, serve gluten-free crusts. Just ask for the options when you order, as some toppings may vary.
Which Springfield pizza spots deliver?
The Big Slice, Rocco’s Pizza, and many others offer delivery and takeout. Some third-party apps may make ordering even more convenient.
What’s a classic pizza to try in Springfield?
Many locals swear by cracker-thin cheese pizza at Pizza House or a custom pie from PaPPo’s. Both are classics that showcase Springfield’s unique pizza flavor.