Pizza cravings are universal, but real satisfaction is all about the spot you pick. In Johnstown, Ohio, the search for the best pizza isn’t just a question—it’s a delicious scavenger hunt. I’ve logged more hours debating which place has the flakiest crust, tastiest sauce, or boldest toppings than I’d care to admit. Each place here tells its own cheesy story, whether at a bright new shop or a family-owned staple that’s been slinging pies longer than many of us have been around.
What follows isn’t just a list. It’s a carefully assembled menu of Johnstown’s most-loved pizzerias, tested and tasted in person or by locals who know what matters—a perfect fold, melty cheese, crisp veggies, and just the right amount of bold flavor in every slice. Ready to discover where your next pizza obsession might come from? Let’s get into the doughy details.
1. Villa Pizza
Villa Pizza rests at the heart of Johnstown, serving **classic pies and genuine warmth** from its charming spot on W Coshocton Street. Walking in, you catch the aroma of dough rising and sauce simmering, which always sets the stage for good things ahead. The friendly staff greets regulars by name, but first-timers quickly feel right at home.
What really sticks with me is how every crust is golden without being greasy, and the cheese lands with a stretchy pull on each slice. The **signature Villa Special** deserves your attention—loaded with fresh vegetables and a generous helping of pepperoni. Their veggie pizzas are a highlight too, showing off the farm-fresh side of Johnstown.
**Villa Pizza’s menu** is broad, but if you’re unsure, stick with the traditional. Their style is pure midwestern comfort: sturdy base, bright sauce, and generous toppings. For a lunch break or a laid-back evening, this spot rarely disappoints.
2. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Main Street is where convenience meets craving. **Fast delivery and customizable options** make it a go-to for busy nights or last-minute group get-togethers. You can count on consistently hot pizzas with that familiar Domino’s flavor, and their quick service often saves the day when hunger hits hard.
I’ve often grabbed a late-night pie here and have never been let down by the classic **Hand Tossed Pizza**, which strikes the right balance between doughy and crisp. Their **Philly Cheese Steak Pizza** is always a conversation starter, loaded with peppers and melt-in-your-mouth steak—perfect for anyone seeking a little something different.
Domino’s stands out because you aren’t stuck with one style. Choose between crusts, sauces, and all sorts of veggie toppings. For lunch or dinner, it’s a spot that makes sure your preferences lead the way.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Johnstown Village Square channels family nostalgia and comfort right into your dinner plans. The red roof, friendly staff, and reliable flavors stay consistent visit after visit. **Thick, buttery pan crust** remains my top pick, crisp on the outside and perfectly soft in the middle—just the right canvas for the sauce and cheese to shine.
I have memories of lively team celebrations and laid-back weeknights, each time greeted with a piping hot pie that never disappoints. **The Supreme Pizza** here nails the balance of veggies and pepperoni without overwhelming the crust, reflecting Pizza Hut’s well-known style—hearty, approachable, and shareable.
Their breadsticks are another local favorite, especially as a side to the signature pan pizzas. For a table full of smiles, it’s tough to skip this spot.
4. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza brings a different vibe to the Johnstown pizza scene, combining convenience with satisfying flavor. Many locals know it as the top pick for a quick bite while running errands or filling up on a road trip. The pizza counter is integrated into a neighborhood shop—unexpected, but that’s part of its appeal.
Every time I stop by, I’m impressed with how the **original crust** holds up—chewy and sturdy, not lost under a mountain of cheese or sauce. Their **classic loaded pizza** is customizable; you pick the toppings, and every option is included, so no tough choices. It’s ideal for the indecisive or anyone eager to sample a bit of everything.
For a fast, tasty, and generous pizza in Johnstown, this spot stands out as an underrated gem.
5. Pizza Burg
(740) 967-3444Call
Pizza Burg on South Main Street is a local favorite for those who crave **no-fuss, hearty pizza**. It’s one of those spots where the classic neon signs and casual vibe set the tone for good, honest food. There’s something homey about picking up a piping hot pie here, especially after a day spent walking around downtown Johnstown.
The **deluxe pizza** always grabs my attention: a crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and a generous scatter of toppings that prove every bite matters. Their cheese blend is rich and always pulls just right, which speaks volumes to anyone obsessed with a perfect cheese stretch.
If you like things loaded and classic, Pizza Burg is for you. Grab a deluxe or try a veggie pizza—either choice fits the bill for true pizza comfort.
6. Sub City Pizza & Family Restaurant
(740) 967-5454Call
Sub City Pizza & Family Restaurant is where pizzeria meets deli, tucked right into the heart of downtown Johnstown. The casual, welcoming feel makes it perfect for a laid-back lunch or big family gathering. You’ll find plenty of locals swapping stories while waiting for their orders, which says a lot about its loyal following.
What really stands out here is the **classic cheese pizza**—a perfect showcase for their soft, flavorful crust and slightly tangy sauce. If you like something extra, the **pepperoni pizza** lands on the table with crisp edges and no skimping on toppings. It’s straightforward and satisfying, which nails the spirit of their menu.
The mix of deli and pizza makes Sub City a reliable stop for any craving that comes your way.
7. Central City Pizza
(740) 788-8522Call
Central City Pizza is the kind of hidden spot you hear about from a friend who’s serious about their slices. Set on Meadow Lane, it’s a quick detour that pays off if you love **fresh, quality pizza without the frills**. The little shop gives off a welcoming, family-run vibe that makes grabbing a box feel like you’re in on a local secret.
I keep coming back for their **classic sausage pizza**. The crust is subtly chewy, the sauce hits that sweet-savory balance, and the toppings taste like they were sliced just minutes before you arrived.
If you’re after an unfussy, genuine pie that never skimps on quality, Central City Pizza holds its own in Johnstown’s busy pizza lineup.
8. Vick’s Pizza In Pataskala
(740) 927-8010Call
Vick’s Pizza In Pataskala takes an old-school approach, focusing on **crispy thin crusts and bold, familiar flavors**. Even though it’s just a short drive from Johnstown, it feels worth the trip—especially if you appreciate a pizza joint that keeps things classic.
I like their **veggie pizza**, which piles on fresh ingredients while letting the crust keep its snap. If you’re feeling traditional, their cheese pizza with extra sauce highlights the tangy, bright profile that regulars love.
Vick’s stands out by never complicating things. The menu sticks to the basics, but every pie feels like it’s been made with real care. It’s an easy spot to call your go-to if you crave dependability and that old-fashioned pizza experience.
9. Crenos Pizza
Crenos Pizza on W Coshocton St has developed a bit of a local following, and for good reason. This spot knows how to serve up pies that are **fresh, flavorful, and just a bit different** from your standard chain. The shop has a relaxed feel, perfect for a weeknight dinner that doesn’t require any fuss.
Their **white pizza** is a must for anyone open to something beyond traditional red sauce. Creamy, with a garlicky punch, it showcases just how versatile Crenos can be. For classic fans, their **deluxe pizza** comes loaded with a hearty mix of veggies and pepperoni that doesn’t drown out the crisp crust.
Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or want to try a unique specialty, Crenos delivers big on both choice and taste.
10. McCain’s Pizza
(740) 966-0199Call
McCain’s Pizza makes its mark in the Johnstown Village Square with a straightforward, no-nonsense approach. The vibe is friendly and easygoing, which pairs well with their **crispy, golden-edged pizzas** that keep you coming back. This is one of those places where a classic order really shines.
The **pepperoni pizza** is the go-to—never greasy, always balanced between a chewy base and bubbling cheese. I’ve grabbed a slice here after errands in the plaza and found it reliable every single time.
If you like your pizza classic but well-executed, McCain’s checks all the boxes. For anyone in search of a neighborhood spot that delivers exactly what you expect, this place is a solid choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best pizza places in Johnstown, OH?
A: Johnstown has a variety of pizza spots loved by locals. **Villa Pizza, Crenos Pizza**, and **McCain’s Pizza** stand out for their fresh ingredients and friendly service. There are also dependable chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut if you want familiar favorites.
Q: Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Johnstown?
A: Yes, most pizzerias, including **Villa Pizza** and **Crenos Pizza**, offer satisfying vegetarian pies loaded with fresh veggies and classic cheeses. Just ask for the veggie options on their menus.
Q: Can I order gluten-free pizza in Johnstown?
A: Some national chains such as **Domino’s Pizza** often carry gluten-free crusts. For local shops, it’s best to call ahead to check on current options.
Q: Which places offer pizza delivery in Johnstown, OH?
A: Delivery is available from most big chains like **Domino’s and Pizza Hut**. Several local favorites, such as **Crenos Pizza**, also provide delivery within the area.
Q: Are there late-night pizza spots in Johnstown?
A: Many spots, especially the chains, stay open relatively late for takeout or delivery. **Domino’s** and **Pizza Hut** are safe bets when you’re craving a pizza after standard dinner hours.