Finding the best pizza in Urbana, OH feels a bit like searching for buried treasure—with far less digging and a lot more cheese. This town may not shout from the rooftops, but it has a knack for hiding exceptional pizza in places you’d stroll past on a typical day. My first bite of local pizza here was a happy accident: I ducked into a corner shop after a long walk, and the slice that appeared was proof that Urbana quietly holds its own on the map of Midwest pizza towns.
Over time, I discovered that every spot in Urbana takes a unique spin—some specialize in nostalgic, classic crusts while others are bold with their flavors and toppings. What ties them together is that unpretentious charm only small-town pizzerias seem to pull off. As someone who’s explored dough, sauce, and toppings in every corner of this city, this guide brings a taste of that journey. If you want a straight path to the most satisfying pie—without a side of hype or generic promises—you’re in the right place.
1. Jac-N-Do’s
(937) 653-6444Call
Jac-N-Do’s sits on Scioto Street like a true Urbana landmark, drawing in locals with the aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. Walking through the doors for the first time, the friendly crew set the tone before I’d even had a bite. The crowd here isn’t just loyal; they’re almost protective of their favorite spot.
What makes Jac-N-Do’s shine is the thin crust: light, crispy, and made for folding or devouring bite by bite. Taste the Classic Pepperoni or their Deluxe, loaded with fresh veggies and savory beef. Every slice holds its own, hot from the oven and never soggy.
Jac-N-Do’s wins hearts with consistency, quick service, and pizza that tastes just as good dining in or taking home.
2. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Scioto Street is where speed meets customization. I’ve found myself relying on them during late nights and quick lunches, and each order arrives impressively hot and accurate. This Domino’s team keeps their process quick, but the pies never feel rushed.
Here, the menu stretches far beyond expectations. Choose the thin crust for a classic fold or go for the Handmade Pan if you’re in a mood for something extra filling. My standout is their Parmesan Stuffed Crust—a gooey, golden option that always hits the spot.
Pair your pizza with a crisp salad or cheesy bread for a meal that covers all the bases. Domino’s makes it easy to tweak toppings or try something new every time, giving you control without ever overcomplicating dinner.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Scioto Street is a familiar beacon for comfort food fans. There’s a certain nostalgia here—mine is tied to childhood visits for Friday pizza nights, where the scent of fresh-baked crust made everything feel like a celebration. The staff keep things moving, yet manage that friendly, small-town vibe.
Their Original Stuffed Crust is famous for a reason, and never disappoints when you want a little extra with every bite. If you’re with a group, the Meat Lovers and Veggie Lover’s pizzas show off Pizza Hut’s generous approach to toppings and classic flavors.
Everything is comfortably consistent—from the cheese pull to the perfectly browned crust—making Pizza Hut a favorite for family meals or solo cravings in Urbana.
4. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Highway 36 brings a bit of old-world spirit to Urbana. The first time I tried their pizza, the difference was clear—a crust that tasted homemade, with a chewy bite and a hint of olive oil. The staff take pride in their craft, and you can taste the result in every slice.
Marco’s stands apart by making dough fresh daily and sticking to a tomato sauce recipe from 1978. Their blend of three cheeses melts into each corner, tying everything together for a full-flavored bite.
Order the classic Pepperoni Magnifico for a real taste of what Marco’s does best. If you want to shake things up, their White Cheezy brings out a creamy, garlic-rich side of pizza that’s hard to forget.
5. Tonya’s Main Street Deli & Pizza
(937) 653-8400Call
Tonya’s Main Street Deli & Pizza feels like Urbana’s best-kept secret. On my first visit, I found a welcoming spot where locals swap stories over slices stacked with cheese and fresh toppings. The deli vibe gives the place a cozy, down-to-earth charm that sets it apart from bigger chains.
What really makes Tonya’s stand out is their balance of deli craftsmanship and classic pizza making. The crust is crisp at the edge but soft underneath, and the toppings are always piled high without overwhelming the base.
The standout order here is the Supreme, packed with bell peppers and mushrooms. If you want something heartier, their signature Sicilian-style is a nod to tradition, with every bite offering layers of flavor and comfort.
6. Pizza King
(888) 294-5464Call
Pizza King on Jefferson Avenue is a name folks tend to remember. I stepped in once after a rainy afternoon, and the kitchen’s steady hum made it feel instantly inviting. There’s a sense of tradition here; it’s the kind of place where pizza is made old-school and the regulars know each other by name.
What gives Pizza King its edge is the hand-tossed crust—chewy in the middle, crunchy on the edge. Each pizza is baked to order, so nothing sits under a heat lamp.
Their signature Cheese Pizza is proof that simple can be best, but don’t overlook the Veggie Lovers for a colorful spread of fresh, local toppings that showcase what Pizza King does so well.
7. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza, found along Highway 36, may be tucked inside a convenience spot, but don’t underestimate it. My late-night pizza runs often end here, thanks to their surprisingly consistent pies and ready smile from the staff. It’s grab-and-go dining done right, without the wait or fuss.
The secret? Hunt Brothers offers a “choose your toppings” approach for no extra charge, making the whole pie feel personal. Everything comes out hot, and the crust stays thick and golden, just the way many love it.
Order the classic pepperoni or go for the Works if you want every topping in the house. Hunt Brothers is proof that you don’t have to dress up to get a piping hot, filling pizza in Urbana.
8. Sparky’s Pizzeria
Sparky’s Pizzeria, right on Scioto Street, has a welcoming, small-town energy that pulls you in. My first experience came on a cold evening, and within minutes their oven-warm pizza had melted away any chill. The team here bakes each pie with real attention, blending a bit of bakery expertise into the crust.
What sets Sparky’s apart is their fresh dough and a knack for golden, balanced bakes. The crust holds up, the cheese bubbles perfectly, and each topping feels refreshingly fresh. You can taste the care in every bite.
I always look forward to their Veggie Pizza or the classic cheese, both showing off that light, airy base. Sparky’s proves that a pizza made with heart always stands out in a crowd.
9. Cassano’s Pizza & Sub’s
(937) 294-5464Call
Cassano’s Pizza & Sub’s on Jefferson Avenue is one of those neighborhood places built on local tradition. My first order came from word of mouth—a friend swore by their crust, and after that first slice, I understood the hype. Everything here feels homegrown, from the recipes to the friendly way staff remember your usual order.
What makes Cassano’s stand out is the balance of flavor in their sauce and the crisp edges of their thin crust. Each pie is cut into perfect squares, so sharing is easy and every piece gets just the right amount of toppings.
The Deluxe Pizza is their claim to fame, loaded with fresh veggies, cheese, and tangy sauce. For a lighter bite, a plain cheese or veggie pizza lets that classic base shine.
10. Fusion 40.83
(937) 508-4145Call
Fusion 40.83 on Miami Street is anything but ordinary. The first time I visited, I was drawn in by a menu that reads like a passport, but it was their pizza that turned me into a regular. The kitchen layers global flavors onto classic pies, creating taste combinations you won’t find elsewhere in Urbana.
Fusion 40.83 stands out for its creativity. You can order a traditional pizza, but if you’re feeling adventurous, specials with fresh herbs and unexpected toppings take the experience further. Each crust is light, crisp, and acts as a perfect base for their unique sauces and fresh vegetables.
Try the Mediterranean-inspired veggie pizza for something refreshing, or their Margherita if you want simplicity done right. Fusion 40.83 proves that a good pizza can travel the world without leaving Main Street.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most popular pizza place in Urbana, OH?
Jac-N-Do’s and Marco’s Pizza usually get the most local love for their consistent quality and tasty crusts. If you prefer a chain, Pizza Hut and Domino’s are reliable options.
Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Urbana?
Yes, almost every pizzeria offers at least one veggie pizza. Sparky’s, Marco’s, and Fusion 40.83 take things up a notch with specialty vegetarian creations featuring fresh produce and herbs.
Who delivers pizza in Urbana, OH?
You can order delivery from Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Marco’s, Little Caesars, and several others. Many local spots also offer takeout or curbside pickup for convenience.
Where can I get pizza by the slice in Urbana?
Jac-N-Do’s and some places downtown will serve pizza by the slice, making them great for quick stops or sampling different flavors.
Does Urbana have any unique or specialty pizza styles?
Fusion 40.83 stands out for their global-inspired toppings, while spots like Tonya’s Main Street Deli & Pizza offer hearty Sicilian-style pies for something different than the standard round pizza.