Finding great pizza in Homer Glen, IL isn’t about settling for the usual. This town delivers slices layered with decades of tradition and a few surprises along the way. Whether you swear by Chicago deep dish or hold thin crust close to your heart, Homer Glen has a spot that feels like it was built for your cravings. After sampling my way through every shop with a tempting aroma and a crowd out front, I found each pizzeria here brings a story to your table—and a pizza that lives up to it.
I still remember biting into a bubbling, oven-fresh pie at a neighborhood spot on my first visit. The crust was crisp, the toppings were rich, and the sauce tasted like a secret passed down with care. It was the kind of slice that makes you pause and just appreciate simple, good food. Whether you’re a local on the hunt for new favorites or passing through with an appetite, I’ve sorted out the best pizzerias in Homer Glen. You’ll find the standouts, the classics, and a few under-the-radar gems—each worth more than just one visit.
1. Chesdan’s Pizzeria and Grille
Chesdan’s Pizzeria and Grille stands as a local favorite tucked away on Bell Road. The moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked crust pulls you closer and the friendly staff makes it easy to settle in. It’s the kind of spot where both families and pizza fans lose track of time.
I once shared their classic cheese pizza with friends, and every slice boasted a golden, chewy base and a sauce that struck a perfect balance—never too sweet, never too rich. Their kitchen knows how to let quality ingredients shine.
Try the sausage and green pepper pizza for something that showcases their house-made sausage and expert layering. The veggie pizza also stands out, loaded with color and packed with flavor. Chesdan’s delivers every time, with crusts that hold up and toppings that impress.
2. Pizza Mia
Pizza Mia brings a little bit of Italy to Bell Road, serving pizzas that keep regulars coming back. The place has a low-key, unfussy vibe, which only makes the food shine brighter. With quick service and classic favorites, every visit feels familiar in the best way.
The first time I ordered their thin-crust pizza, I was hooked by the light, crispy edges and well-seasoned sauce. You can taste the care that goes into each pie, and there’s always someone picking up a box for the family at home.
The Margherita pizza is a top pick, with its fresh tomato slices and basil, making every bite pop. For something more indulgent, try the Meat Lovers. Whatever you choose, Pizza Mia nails comfort and quality with every order.
3. Enzo’s Pizzeria
Enzo’s Pizzeria pulls off the kind of neighborhood charm that keeps people talking. The cozy spot on 143rd Street has a warm, welcoming vibe, and it’s easy to see why families and friends gather here again and again.
One visit left me with a new favorite: the pizza. The crust at Enzo’s has that ideal balance between airy and crisp, always baked just right. Their sauce is lively but never overpowering, which lets the high-quality cheese shine through.
Order their classic Veggie Pizza for a burst of color and flavor, piled high with fresh vegetables. If you like to keep it traditional, their cheese or spinach pizza lets you savor the basics done well. Enzo’s captures what local pizza should be: simple, reliable, and seriously tasty.
4. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria – Carry Out
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria – Carry Out is where deep dish cravings instantly feel satisfied. While there’s no dine-in here, the food just begs to be enjoyed anywhere you please. Their team keeps the orders moving fast, so there’s no long wait between the urge and the first bite.
Each time I pick up a pie, I notice how perfectly the golden crust holds all those classic ingredients without getting soggy. You can taste that signature blend of tangy tomato sauce and melted cheese in every forkful.
The Deep Dish Cheese pizza is the undisputed favorite, with a thick, buttery base and hearty layers. For something a little more robust, try their spinach deep dish—it’s full of flavor and always comforting. Lou Malnati’s turns even a takeout night into something memorable.
5. Rosati’s Pizza
Rosati’s Pizza is a cornerstone for classic pies in Homer Glen, tucked right along Bell Road. It’s the kind of place everyone seems to know about—where the boxes fly out the door and the aroma makes you forget your plans.
On my last visit, Rosati’s thin crust left a mark. The base was crisp, yet strong enough to balance generous toppings and their signature sweet-savory sauce. Every bite felt balanced, with cheese stretching just the way you want it to.
Go for the Double Dough Pizza if you like a heartier bite. For pure comfort, order the Cheese Pizza—it’s a local favorite for a reason. Rosati’s keeps things uncomplicated and tasty, making it a solid pick every time.
6. Nancy’s Pizza
Nancy’s Pizza is a spot where comfort food feels extra comforting. Nestled on South Will Cook Road, it’s a go-to for both a quick bite and big family feasts. The space has a relaxed vibe and staff who treat regulars just like old friends.
When I first tried Nancy’s, I went all in for their stuffed pizza. Each slice was almost a meal in itself, with cheese stretching between layers of soft, buttery crust and tangy tomato sauce that makes you crave seconds. The hearty serving means leftovers, which taste just as good the next day.
The Spinach Stuffed Pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh spinach and gooey cheese in every bite. Their thin crust pizzas are another win, with edges that crunch and toppings spread right to the edge. Nancy’s knows how to keep pizza classic, bold, and satisfying.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Bell Road delivers the familiar comfort of classic chain pizza, and sometimes, that’s exactly what you need. Walk inside and the scent of melting cheese feels nostalgic, each pizza offering a reliable experience that never veers off course.
I remember sharing a pan pizza here with friends—the buttery crust and soft, hot center were spot-on. The service is fast, perfect for busy nights or family carryout.
The Veggie Lover’s Pizza is piled with crisp vegetables that stay fresh, even after delivery. Their Original Stuffed Crust® deserves some attention too, especially when you want something gooey and fun. When you’re looking for consistency and comfort, Pizza Hut keeps it simple and satisfying.
8. Bobalu’s Pizza
+1 708-737-7188
Bobalu’s Pizza might be easy to pass by on Bell Road, but pizza lovers know it’s a spot worth discovering. There’s a laid-back feel to the place, and the friendly staff always seems to have a recommendation ready.
On my first visit, I was won over by the perfectly balanced sauce and the crisp, oven-baked crust. Every pie feels like it was made to order, with edges that crunch and toppings that stay just right—not piled on, but thoughtfully layered for flavor.
Try the classic cheese pizza or veggie pizza to appreciate Bobalu’s dedication to fresh ingredients and mindful baking. Every slice feels honest, never trying too hard—just great pizza in its simplest form that hits the spot every time.
9. Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza on Bell Road knows how to deliver a reliable pie when cravings hit. It’s all about ease here—online orders, quick pickup, and hot pizza that makes it simple to gather everyone around the table.
Every time I order, the crust comes crisp but soft inside, and they never skimp on cheese. The pizza arrives with those signature pepperoncinis and a garlic sauce cup, which always feels like a little bonus at the end of a long day.
The Garden Fresh Pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh veggies that don’t wilt in delivery. Their Original Crust pizzas hold up well, staying flavorful and chewy. Papa John’s brings you pizza that’s both consistent and comforting, perfect for weeknights or spur-of-the-moment gatherings.
10. Great American Pizza
(708) 301-6669Call
Great American Pizza on 143rd Street lives up to its bold name. Step inside, and you’ll notice the local vibe—regulars talking with the staff, and the warm scent of dough filling the air. It’s nothing flashy, but reliability and good flavor go a long way here.
My first bite of their traditional thin crust left me impressed. The crust was crisp and light, letting the sauce and cheese get center stage. They aren’t afraid to keep things classic, and that’s where their strength lies.
Order the Veggie Pizza or classic Cheese Pizza if you want to taste what keeps people coming back. Both showcase simple, balanced flavors with the right amount of topping. Great American Pizza stands out by getting the basics right—every single time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most popular pizza style in Homer Glen?
Thin crust and deep dish pizzas both have a big following here. Places like Lou Malnati’s are known for their deep dish, while others such as Rosati’s and Pizza Mia shine with classic thin crust.
Are there any vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Homer Glen?
Yes, several pizzerias—including Chesdan’s, Nancy’s Pizza, and Pizza Hut—offer excellent veggie or cheese pizzas, plus a range of customizable toppings to suit plant-based diets.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Homer Glen?
Many major chains in the area, including Papa John’s and Domino’s, offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead at each location to confirm current options and kitchen practices.
Which pizzerias offer delivery in Homer Glen?
Nearly every major pizza spot in Homer Glen, including Bobalu’s, Nancy’s Pizza, Rosati’s, and all national chains, have delivery available. Just call or order online for quick service.
What’s the best place for a family pizza night?
Chesdan’s Pizzeria and Grille and Pizza Mia both have welcoming spaces ideal for groups. Lou Malnati’s is always a hit for takeout family feasts, too.