Finding the best pizza in Valley Cottage, NY is part science, part obsession. Some folks search for that elusive cheese pull, others judge by the freshness of the sauce, and a surprising number get excited over a crust that walks the line between crackle and chew. I’ve spent more evenings here than I care to admit wandering from slice joint to sit-down, always chasing the next memorable bite. Over the years, a few spots have surprised me, whether with a garlic-kissed pie fresh from a family oven or a clever combination that tastes even better than it sounds on the menu.
Curiosity is the real engine behind Valley Cottage’s pizza scene. This stretch of Rockland County manages to balance classic New York slices with bold spins from local pizzaiolos, and not a single one disappoints. The following list goes beyond generic answers. These are real pizzerias worth your time, highlighted through personal stops and conversations with folks who know each oven and topping combo like the back of their hand. Ready for the lowdown on where to get truly great pizza in Valley Cottage? Read on.
Where to find the best pizza in Valley Cottage, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Valley Cottage, NY:
- Dee Marias
- The Pieman VC
- Valley Pizza
- Dee Marias Pizza & Pasta
- The Pieman VC & Italian Catering
- Franco’s Pizza
- A Slice of Sicily
- Calabria Restaurant
- Patricia Pizza
- Cacciatori Pizza
1. Dee Marias
Step inside Dee Marias and the first thing you’ll notice is the smell—the kind that tells you dough and sauce have been friends here for decades. This family-run spot feels both classic and comfortable, with service that never hurries you to finish up. On my last visit, I grabbed a table near the window and watched locals breeze in for their usual orders, which says a lot.
Dee Marias stands out for its crisp-yet-pillowy crust and a red sauce that leans sweet without overpowering the cheese. If you try just one pizza, make it the Margherita. The basil always tastes bright, and the cheese has that perfect melt every time. I’ve also shared a veggie pie with friends, and every bite felt like a small celebration.
For those who like to linger, there’s table service and a menu that makes nearly everyone happy. Ordering a pizza here isn’t just dinner—it’s a tradition.
2. The Pieman VC
The Pieman VC looks like your typical pizza spot from the outside, but step in and the vibe is upbeat and the ovens are always working overtime. I stopped by for a late lunch one weekday and watched a steady flow of regulars who clearly knew the staff by name. There’s no pretense here—just bold flavors and big slices.
This place sets itself apart with a crust that walks the perfect line between chewy and crisp. If you want something unique, try their signature White Pizza. The blend of creamy ricotta and fresh mozzarella really lets the dough shine. For those after a classic, their plain cheese slice is as New York as it gets—no shortcuts, just the right ratio of sauce to cheese.
Freshness is central to every pie, and it shows. The Pieman VC delivers the kind of pizza that makes even a quick meal feel special.
3. Valley Pizza
Valley Pizza is the kind of place that draws in both longtime locals and new faces, thanks to its relaxed setup and friendly energy. My first time here was on a rainy afternoon, and I found myself staying longer than planned, drawn in by the comfort food and the steady hum of conversation.
What sets Valley Pizza apart is its commitment to true Italian flavor without the fuss. The dough is proofed with patience, leading to a crust that’s satisfyingly crisp yet still tender. Their veggie pizza is a highlight for those looking for something both hearty and fresh. Layers of spinach, peppers, and onions work perfectly with the zesty sauce.
If you’re in the mood for the basics, the classic cheese or Margherita are executed with genuine attention. Valley Pizza’s pies have that simple, honest taste that keeps you coming back.
4. Dee Marias Pizza & Pasta
Dee Marias Pizza & Pasta takes comfort food seriously, with a menu that celebrates both Italian tradition and friendly, familiar service. My first meal here started with a simple slice, but soon turned into sharing a full pie with friends, drawn in by that classic blend of chewy, golden crust and tangy sauce.
What really makes Dee Marias Pizza & Pasta stand out is the attention they give to balance—never too cheesy, never too doughy. Their Sicilian pizza, square-cut and satisfying, is a standout. Each piece is thick, airy, and holds just the right amount of sauce and cheese. It’s the kind of dish that feels equally at home on a casual Tuesday or at a family celebration.
This spot captures the heart of Valley Cottage’s pizza scene—simple, genuine, and reliably good.
5. The Pieman VC & Italian Catering
The Pieman VC & Italian Catering manages to combine neighborhood pizzeria charm with the muscle of a full Italian kitchen. Walk in during the dinner rush and you’ll see families settling in for slices, while the kitchen hums with energy. My last visit was for a casual group dinner, and I left wishing I had room for more.
It’s the type of place where both big trays and single slices get the same attention. Their Grandma pizza is a must—thin, square, with a subtle garlic note and a crisp bottom that holds up. Every bite tastes like it was made from scratch, with just enough richness to keep things interesting.
Freshness and consistency are the hallmarks here. Whether you need one pie or food for a crowd, The Pieman VC & Italian Catering delivers a slice of Valley Cottage tradition with every order.
6. Franco’s Pizza
Franco’s Pizza delivers real Italian flavor with a side of family warmth. On my first visit, I noticed how the team greets regulars by name and treats newcomers like old friends. The space has that classic, bustling pizzeria feel—plenty of laughter and the constant scent of baking dough in the air.
What sets Franco’s apart is their commitment to recipes passed down through generations. Every pizza is made fresh to order, and the difference is noticeable. The thin-crust Neapolitan is a standout, with bright tomato sauce, perfectly stretchy cheese, and a crust that crackles when you bite in.
Franco’s Pizza is best when shared. If you’re picking just one, go for a half veggie, half Margherita—you’ll taste why locals keep coming back.
7. A Slice of Sicily
(845) 589-0424Call
A Slice of Sicily is a little tucked-away spot that’s big on flavor. I first dropped by after hearing praise from a local foodie, and the visit turned into more than just a quick stop. There’s a comfortable, no-rush feeling in the air, and it’s easy to see why people are loyal.
The real draw here is the Sicilian pizza—thick, golden, and not weighed down by grease. You’ll find every square loaded with a zesty sauce that packs real depth and cheese that melts just right. This isn’t your average corner-slice experience. It’s more about savoring than speed.
If you’re after a slice that feels homemade yet refined, their namesake Sicilian is a must. Good ingredients, careful prep, and a taste that lingers.
8. Calabria Restaurant
Calabria Restaurant has the air of a neighborhood fixture—always busy, always filled with families and friends. My first dinner here was unplanned, but the inviting atmosphere and aroma of fresh-baked pizza made it a quick favorite. Their focus on classic Italian comfort and generous portions shines through in every dish.
The star of the menu is their thin-crust pizza. The balance between chewy and crisp is just right, making each bite satisfying without being heavy. Their Margherita is a personal highlight, as the basil and sauce keep things bright and fresh. If you’re craving something with a little more edge, try the veggie pie.
Calabria’s dedication to fresh ingredients and traditional prep stands out from the first bite. It’s a reliable stop for anyone searching for honest, hearty pizza near Valley Cottage.
9. Patricia Pizza
Patricia Pizza may look unassuming, but there’s a charm that keeps you coming back. My last stop involved grabbing a pie for a small get-together, and it quickly became the main topic of conversation. The staff is down-to-earth and service is fast, yet never rushed.
What makes Patricia Pizza memorable is their classic approach—no frills, just solid pizza, always fresh. The cheese pizza is the best way to see what they do: a crisp bottom, airy edges, and sauce with a little tang. For those after something different, their white pizza is rich but not heavy, and always popular with regulars.
Simple ingredients and careful attention define the Patricia Pizza experience. Sometimes, less is more.
10. Cacciatori Pizza
Cacciatori Pizza is the kind of neighborhood spot where regulars greet each other by name and newcomers don’t stay strangers for long. My visit started as a quick stop, but the inviting aroma and easy atmosphere convinced me to hang around. This place keeps it straightforward—good pizza, no fuss.
What separates Cacciatori from the crowd is how they handle their crust: thin, golden, and sturdy enough to hold a serious amount of toppings. Their veggie pizza steals the show, piled high but never soggy, with flavors that remain bright and distinct. If you like a crunch with each bite, you’ll find it here.
Cacciatori delivers quality and comfort in every pie. For those seeking reliable, no-nonsense pizza, this is a smart bet.
More Things to Try in Valley Cottage, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Valley Cottage, NY?
Local favorites include Dee Marias, The Pieman VC, and Valley Pizza. These spots are known for their fresh ingredients, friendly service, and classic pizza styles.
Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Valley Cottage?
Yes, most pizzerias offer vegetarian pies. Dee Marias, Valley Pizza, and Franco’s Pizza each have veggie options featuring fresh toppings and flavorful sauces.
Which pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
Many pizzerias in Valley Cottage provide both delivery and takeout, including Dee Marias, The Pieman VC, and Patricia Pizza. Ordering ahead is recommended during busy hours.
Where can I find New York-style pizza in Valley Cottage?
The Pieman VC, Valley Pizza, and Franco’s Pizza each excel at classic New York slices—thin and foldable with a crisp bite.
Is there a spot for a sit-down pizza dinner with family?
Several places like Dee Marias and Calabria Restaurant offer dine-in table service, making them great for a relaxed family meal.