If you ask around in Plattsburgh, you’ll notice a certain glint in people’s eyes when they talk about their favorite pizza spots. It’s not just about cheese, crust, or sauce—it’s the memories, the late-night slices with friends, or family dinners packed around checkered tables. Finding the best pizza here isn’t simply a search; it’s a rite of passage for anyone who loves a good pie.
Having tasted my way through Plattsburgh’s pizzerias, from classic neighborhood haunts to the modern take-out joints, I’ve learned that each place has its own story and style. Some go big on that chewy New York fold; others play up golden, crispy edges or a sauce that surprises you. If you’re seeking a pizza adventure that goes beyond the ordinary, you’re in the right place—and you might even discover your next go-to slice by the end of this guide.
Where to find the best pizza in Plattsburgh, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Plattsburgh, NY:
- Big Sal’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Pizza Palace
- Giuseppe’s Pizza Shop
- Pizza Bono
- Bazzano’s Pizza
- Arnie’s Restaurant
- Pizza Hut
- New York Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Little Caesars
1. Big Sal’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Big Sal’s Pizzeria & Restaurant finds its sweet spot between cozy neighborhood joint and culinary staple. Step inside and you’re greeted by the aroma of garlic and bubbly cheese—a signal that you’re in for something good. When I visited, the staff recommended their signature thin crust pizza. It arrived golden, crisp, and generously topped, making every bite worth savoring.
Big Sal’s is known for its chewy, foldable slices and a sauce that delivers both zing and depth. Anyone who’s serious about pizza tends to order the Big Sal’s Special; it’s a medley of fresh veggies and perfectly balanced cheese. For a lighter meal, the Margherita shows off the kitchen’s skill—the basil is always fragrant, and the crust never misses.
2. Pizza Palace
Pizza Palace takes its pizza seriously, but never loses the easygoing charm that makes locals drop by week after week. I remember ducking in on a rainy afternoon and being met by warm smiles and the sight of classic pies coming out of the oven. The crust here somehow manages to be both airy and satisfyingly chewy, making it a real contender for the top spot in town.
One standout is the Palace Veggie Pizza, a colorful celebration of fresh produce that proves vegetarian options can be every bit as crave-worthy. People talk about the Pepper and Onion Pizza, too—its blend of sweet peppers and sharp onions gives it a simple, honest flavor, letting the dough and sauce shine through.
If you want a shareable classic, the cheese pizza is a safe bet. Everything hits the right balance—nothing overpowers, and each slice is constructed with real care.
3. Giuseppe’s Pizza Shop
Giuseppe’s Pizza Shop hits the mark for anyone craving a classic pie but wanting something a little extra. The first time I stopped in, I watched the team stretch dough by hand, piling on fresh toppings. You feel the attention to detail in every slice. Their pizza has a crisp crust and a sauce that’s tangy without overpowering the other flavors.
Giuseppe’s is more than just pizza. Calzones and garlic knots arrive fresh and piping hot, each one evidence of the kitchen’s experience. Still, their Mediterranean Pizza stands out, loaded with tomatoes, spinach, olives, and feta—it’s light, savory, and packs a lot of character.
If you’re torn, try the cheese. It’s a safe bet, but far from ordinary, thanks to a careful balance of sauce and cheese that never disappoints.
4. Pizza Bono
Pizza Bono grabs your attention the moment you walk through the door. Slices are sliced big and bold, served by staff who know their regulars by name. The first time I tried their pizza, it was a busy night, yet the service was quick and friendly. Their dough is thick with a hearty chew, topped generously and cooked just right.
The veggie lovers’ pie is a local favorite, loaded with peppers, mushrooms, and plenty of cheese. There’s a subtle crunch in the crust that keeps every slice interesting. If you enjoy something classic, their plain cheese or Margherita hits that comfort-food note, blending fresh mozzarella and tangy sauce in perfect proportion.
This spot proves that a reliable slice can feel like something special.
5. Bazzano’s Pizza
Bazzano’s Pizza is one of those rare spots where the menu seems endless, yet the quality never slips. My first visit was late on a busy Friday, and the place was still buzzing with families and friends enjoying hearty slices. Their crust is thin but sturdy—never floppy—and always carries just the right amount of char.
For pizza aficionados, the Veggie Deluxe earns high marks. It’s a medley of fresh mushrooms, colorful peppers, and sweet onions, brought together with Bazzano’s signature sauce. If you’re in the mood for something simple, the cheese pizza is a classic done right, with just enough sauce and a golden, bubbly finish.
Bazzano’s makes it easy to keep coming back, whether you’re after a solo slice or a family meal.
6. Arnie’s Restaurant
Arnie’s Restaurant feels like a slice of old Plattsburgh, where familiarity and good food go hand in hand. On my last visit, there was a gentle bustle of locals catching up over plates of pasta and slices of pizza, setting a warm, inviting mood. Their hand-tossed pizza stands out for its ultra-fresh ingredients and just-right ratio of sauce to cheese.
The standout pick is the Margherita Pizza, impressing with its fragrant basil, gooey mozzarella, and a bright tomato sauce that ties it all together. For those who favor something heartier, the Veggie Pizza brings together colorful toppings on a crisp, golden crust.
Arnie’s keeps the experience straightforward, flavor-packed, and satisfying, every single time.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Plattsburgh serves up nostalgia and comfort to anyone who grew up loving a pan pizza. My most recent visit brought back memories—sharing gooey, cheesy slices with family is a hard ritual to beat. The draw here is the signature pan crust: thick, buttery, with a satisfying crunch on the edges.
If you’re looking for a crowd-pleaser, the Veggie Lover’s Pizza is always popular. It’s loaded with veggies and plenty of cheese, staying true to what people expect from a solid chain favorite. The Original Stuffed Crust pizza stands out, each bite delivering that cheesy pull everyone craves.
Pizza Hut is all about quick service, classic options, and a reliably filling slice every time.
8. New York Pizza
New York Pizza brings a taste of the city to Plattsburgh with slices that are as big as your plate and always served piping hot. My first slice here was the classic cheese, pulled from the oven just moments before—its thin, crisp crust and robust tomato sauce immediately hit all the right notes.
Their Margherita pizza offers a perfect blend of fresh basil, creamy mozzarella, and tangy sauce, showing off a real respect for the simple things done well. For those who like a straight-up approach, the plain pie delivers everything you’d expect from a true New York-style spot.
Whether you’re grabbing one slice or a whole pie, the experience stays true to its roots: quick, flavorful, and always satisfying.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Cornelia Street is the answer for anyone needing quick, tasty pizza after a long day. I’ve ended plenty of busy evenings here with a box of their thin-crust pizza—it’s crisp, easy to fold, and hits the spot when you want that classic Domino’s comfort.
If you’re adventurous, their Parmesan Stuffed Crust is a top pick. Each bite comes packed with gooey cheese, with a toasted, savory finish that sets it apart from standard offerings. The Deluxe Veggie pizza stands out for its fresh toppings and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio.
Reliable delivery, plenty of crust choices, and consistently hot pies make Domino’s a favorite for families and students across Plattsburgh.
10. Little Caesars
Little Caesars on Smithfield Blvd knows how to cater to busy schedules and hungry crowds. On my last visit, the appeal was clear: you walk in, and most likely, your box is hot and ready. Speed is the name of the game here, but the pizza is always fresh out of the oven.
The classic choice is the Cheese or Veggie Pizza, which delivers on flavor without stretching your budget. Crust lovers will appreciate their signature Detroit-style deep dish, with its thick, fluffy interior and crispy edges. Each bite gives a satisfying crunch followed by a melt-in-your-mouth chew.
If you want a quick fix with no fuss, Little Caesars never lets you down.
More Things to Try in Plattsburgh, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Plattsburgh, NY?
You’ll find a range, from classic New York-style and thick pan pizzas to crisp thin crusts and Sicilian-style squares. Many local places put their own spin on traditional favorites, so variety is never in short supply.
Do any pizzerias in Plattsburgh offer vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Most of the top pizza spots offer vegetarian pizzas, like veggie lovers’ pies and cheese classics. Many even use fresh, locally sourced produce.
Which pizza places are open late in Plattsburgh?
Bazzano’s Pizza, Domino’s, and some chain locations often cater to late-night cravings, but hours can vary, so calling ahead is smart.
Can I get pizza delivered in Plattsburgh?
Yes, almost every pizzeria on this list offers delivery, along with takeout and dine-in for maximum convenience.
What’s a must-try local specialty?
Try regional spins like a Margherita with extra basil or a hearty veggie pie—local spots take pride in making the classics memorable with their unique touch.